This is a tabulation of city election results from various wards, including council and clerk races, with raw vote totals for candidates. Among the Eighth Ward results is a listing for 'R. L. Earp' receiving 161 votes, unrelated to the Wyatt Earp story itself.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 1 January 1899 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
EIGHTH WARD
Talk of Sporting Men—How the Bolers Compare in Measurements.
(Copyright, 1898.)
See moreSee less
Public opinion has not been very favorable recently toward the boxing fraternity, especially the heavyweight class, on account of the talkative tactics employed by the principals. The recent fiasco in the Sharkey-Corbett affair in New York did not improve their standing with the sporting public. The agreement between Sharkey and McCoy, however, for a 20 round bout to take place on January 10, has been received better than might have been expected. The reason of this is that the preliminaries to the signing of the articles of agreement were managed in a businesslike way by the two men and without the tiresome discussions and holding out for special concessions by each such as have come of late to be looked upon as almost inevitable prior to a heavyweight encounter.
The belief prevails in sporting circles all over the country that the Lenox Atlethic club of New York, which is to pull off the match, was in no way implicated in the unfortunate Sharkey-Corbett affair. Consequently it is probable that another such crowd as congregated to witness that contest will assemble to see the coming one.
Both men have their admirers, and experts in such matters are divided in their opinion as to the probable outcome of the affair. The balance of favor seems to rest with Sharkey, however, though it is impossible to select a winner on the basis of their previous work. Besides, so called lines on prospective contests based on such data have many times been proved of little value.
Those who pin their faith on Sharkey point to their recent battles, which show that Sharkey defeated Ruhlin in less than one round, whereas McCoy required 20 rounds to defeat the same man and didn't knock him out at that. They also assert that in his recent bout with Corbett the ex-sailor showed decisively that he had gained a great deal in science and skill and proved that he is no longer to be feared as a foul fighter and is just as hard a hitter as ever. "Kid" McCoy's admirers, on the contrary, contend that the acknowledged skill and ring generalship of their favorite are sufficient to save him from defeat. They declare that the worst that can happen to him will be a draw. Such an outome will be regretted by the sporting fraternity, which always desires to have a win within the limit no matter who gets the decision.
A sports column debates the odds between Kid McCoy and Tom Sharkey, arguing McCoy's fans underestimate Sharkey's skill and speed. In passing, it references Wyatt Earp's infamous refereeing decision in a prior fight as 'an outrage' but notes the results stand regardless.
The Topeka State Journal · 3 January 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Friends of McCoy are Holding the Sailor Too Cheaply.
New York, Jan. 3.—Of late there has been a disposition on the part of the admirers of Kid McCoy to form a rather cheap estimate of Tom Sharkey. Ever since McCoy "flattened out" old Joe Goddard the most ardent of McCoy's followers have pooh-hooed Sharkey's chances.
See moreSee less
This is a mistake. In Sharkey the Kid will meet the toughest fighting proposition he ever faced. On form Sharkey should be the favorite. He has fought more good men than the Hoosier pugilist.
The same business methods should prevail in making an investment on a prize fight. Admirers of McCoy should not let sentiment interfere with their betting. Because they are friendly to McCoy is no reason why they should give odds that he will win, when the ring "dope" shows conclusively that the odds should be the other way.
If McCoy wins a decisive victory over Sharkey he will do what none of the other pugilists have ever been able to do. Even Fitzsimmons is on the winning side of Sharkey's tab. True, the pistol pocket decision of Wyatt Earp was an outrage, but on the principle that there is no going behind the re-
This sports column previews the upcoming McCoy-Sharkey fight, comparing the boxers' strengths, but in passing reaffirms that referee Wyatt Earp's controversial decision in the earlier Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout stands, calling it an outrage yet accepting Sharkey as the official victor. The bulk of the piece then shifts to an unrelated report on a 50-mile cycling race won by Harry Elkes over Frank Waller.
The Topeka State Journal · 3 January 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
was an outrage, but on the principle that there is no going behind the returns, Sharkey stands as the victor.
Because McCoy was able to elude and block Joe Goddard's bulldog rushes his friends at once jumped to the conclusion that he will do the same thing with Sharkey. There is where they may be wrong in their calculations. Sharkey is much faster than Goddard. Indeed, as far as foot movement is concerned, there are few faster men in the ring than the rough and ready marine. He is as nimble as a sprint runner on his feet, and the Kid will not find it as easy to get out of his road as he did in his engagement with the Barrier champion.
See moreSee less
The battle in the Lenox Athletic club on the 10th is going to be a "hot affair." The fighter who wins it will know he "has been to the races." McCoy has the advantage in height, reach and cleverness. To offset these advantages Sharkey has strength, endurance and experience. His last fight with Corbett also shows that he is a long ways from being a sucker at the game. In that contest he showed himself to be as good as Corbett. True, the Californian was slow and far from being in condition, but anybody who can make a head finish with Corbett in cleverness, no matter if the latter was off form, has to be fully up in the game. Under the circumstances it is folly for anybody to give odds on McCoy. The fight is a very even one.
A satirical newspaper column of short quips comments that Wyatt Earp's public esteem rises each time boxer Sharkey wins a fight. It's part of a miscellany of witty one-line observations on politics and culture of the day.
The Saint Paul Globe · 11 January 1899 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
It is perhaps in order for Mr. Rostand to give Mr. Gross a Bergerac nose.
Did Horton and Sheehan have to advertise themselves as 30-cent senators?
See moreSee less
Every time Sharkey wins Wyatt Earp stands a little higher in public esteem.
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
The article reports Tom Sharkey's win over 'Kid' McCoy, noting Sharkey previously won a controversial decision from Referee Wyatt Earp in a fight against Bob Fitzsimmons. This past ruling is cited as context for Sharkey's claim to heavyweight title contention.
Connecticut Western News · 12 January 1899 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
New York, Jan. 11.—Tom Sharkey, the American sailor, now stands the only heavyweight possibility for championship honors against the title held by Bob Fitzsimmons.
He whipped "Kid" McCoy good and hard in the tenth round of what was to have been a 20 round battle for heavyweight honors at the Lenox Athletic club last night, and by doing so forged his way so positively to the front rank that Fitzsimmons, with whom he fought in the west some time ago and obtained the favorable decision of Referee Wyatt Earp, must now consider the sailor pugilist's claim to championship honors without any delay.
See moreSee less
Sharkey last night was a revelation to those who saw him a couple of years ago. His ring work and generalship are so vastly superior to his exhibitions when he first came to the east as a fighter that the improvement is almost incredible.
McCoy is also worthy of unstinted praise. When he sent Sharkey twice to the floor in the third round last night, no one doubted the "Kid's" ability to hit hard, and many thought that he had Sharkey at his mercy.
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 12 January 1899
Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · and 1 other paper
This feature story recalls Doc Holliday, debunking a rumor that he, Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and Jim Corbett sailed to Havana for illicit business, noting Holliday actually died peacefully years earlier in Colorado Springs. It recounts his reputation as a deadly but honorable gunman in Tombstone and recalls his backstory as a Texas dentist turned killer after a jealous husband's death.
Kansas City Journal · 16 January 1899 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
reached. His Sad History. Halliday drifted into Tombstone from Texas with the first rush which took place within thirty days after the Schieffelin brothers and Dick Gird, now a millionaire of Southern California, located the famous Toughnut lode, and at once became prominent. Soon after his "story" followed him. He was a dentist and had practiced his profession for years in San Antonio, Tex. Among his patients was a beautiful but im-
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz. · 21 January 1899
Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.
A sensationalized biographical account describes Doc Holliday's wandering gambling life before Tombstone, then recounts the Earp brothers' roles as lawmen and gamblers and a stagecoach robbery pursuit involving Holliday and the Earps. The narrative is dramatized with flourishes about bravery and fearlessness.
Kansas City Journal · 16 January 1899 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
DOC HALLIDAY'S LAST SHOT
occurrence.
Always in Front.
See moreSee less
With the Earps "Doc" Halliday struck up a strong friendship and in every battle he was always well up in the front line.
A Topeka Journal dispatch denies reports that Doc Holliday sailed to Havana with Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and Jim Corbett for illicit business, noting Holliday died six years earlier in Colorado Springs. The piece recounts his character and reputation from his Tombstone days as a gambler and gunfighter credited with killing fourteen men.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 18 January 1899 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
WAS ONCE IN WICHITA
"Doc" Holliday Dies Peacefully at Colorado Springs.
A Topeka Journal dispatch says: The report that "Doc" Halliday, together with Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson and Jim Corbett have sailed from New York for Havana with the object of engaging in business there of a not strictly legitimate character, is a canard so far as "Doc" Halliday is concerned. "Doc" has been dead
A retrospective newspaper feature describes the Earp brothers' roles in Tombstone—Virgil as marshal, Wyatt and Jim as faro dealers, Morgan as a Wells Fargo messenger—and their deputy marshal duties chasing stage robbers. It recounts Doc Holliday's friendship with the Earps and a dramatic tale of a stagecoach being attacked by road agents near Bisbee.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 18 January 1899 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
stone.
The Earp boys were then the kings of the camp. All were gamblers, all brave and eager for a fray. Virgil was city marshall. Jim and Wyatt faro dealers, Morgan a Wells Fargo express messenger, and Warren, "the kid of the family," alternated behind a layout and on the boot of a stage coach. Virgil Wyatt and Morgan also held commissions as United States deputy marshals and were always among the men who took to the trail after a stage robbery, and they were of frequent occurrence.
See moreSee less
Wit hthe Earps "Doc" Halliday struck up a strong friendship and in every battle he was always well up in the front line. Although weak physically and the possessor of a hacking cough of a consumptive, Halliday never shirked in the performance of his self-imposed duties. No trail was too difficult for him to follow, no act of bravery he would not smilingly perform. He laughed at death, while courting its embrace.
The Bisbee stage, laden with treasure from the great copper camp in the Huachuca country, was attacked by road agents one day and after a running fight lasting for over three miles, in which many wounds, but none serions, were received by the attacking and repelling forces, the brave driver succeeded in outwitting them because of the superior speed of his six trained horses. When the stage arrived in Tombstone the time was only a few minutes short of midnight. The news soon spread and exactly on the hour of 12 Halliday, attired in a complete suit of buckskin and wearing a white felt sombrero, emerged from the Cosmopolitan hotel, where he roomed.
Wells Fargo's agent, Frank Marshall, who afterwards became an embezzler, organized a pursuing posse at once, and among his picked men were Wyatt, Morgan, Warren Earp and "Doc" Halliday. In less than an hour they were on their way to the scene of the attempted robbery. They suspected Tom and Frank McLowry, Ike Clanton and Billy Clanton, cattlemen and cowboys. They rode direct to their favorite range from the Bisbee road; made inquiries in pertinent language as to their whereabouts, and did not conceal their belief that th[e] cowmen were the men who tried to rob the stage. The sought-for men "were over the line," in Mexico, however, and the posse returned to Tombstone, disbanded and awaited developments.
This article corrects a false telegraphic report claiming Doc Holliday sailed to Havana with Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and Jim Corbett, noting Holliday had actually died six years earlier in Colorado Springs. It then recounts Holliday's reputation from the Tombstone era as a gambler and gunfighter credited with killing fourteen men, describing his character and demeanor.
Arizona Republican · 21 January 1899 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
FAMOUS GUN MAN
than fourteen human souls. Men who were in Tombstone, A. T., in the palmy days of that great chloride camp well remember "Doc" Halliday. He was a thorough gambler, rather temperate in his habits and was
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz. · and 1 other paper
This 1899 feature recounts Doc Halliday's violent past before arriving in Tombstone, where he allied with the Earp brothers who dominated the town as gamblers and lawmen. It describes a Bisbee stage robbery attempt that led to a posse, including Holliday and the Earps, riding out to confront the Clantons and McLaurys.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Arizona Republican · 21 January 1899 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
FAMOUS GUN MAN
horses. When the stage arrived in Tombstone the time was only a few minutes short of midnight. The news soon spread and exactly on the hour of 12 Halliday, attired in a complete suit of buckskin and wearing a white felt sombrero, emerged from the Cosmopolitan hotel, where he roomed.
Wells-Fargo's agent, Frank Marshall, who afterwards became an embezzler, organized a pursuing posse at once, and among his picked me[n] were Wyatt, Morgan, Warren Earp and "Doc" Halliday. In less than an hour they were on their way to the scene of the attempted robbery. They suspected Tom and Frank McLowry, Ike Clanton and Billy Clanton, cattlemen and cowboys. They rode direct to their favorite range from the Bisbee road; made inquiries in pertinent language as to their whereabouts, and did not conceal their belief that the cowmen were the men who tried to rob the stage. The sought-for men "were over the line," in Mexico, however, and the posse returned to Tombstone, disbanded and awaited developments.
See moreSee less
A month later the Clantons and the McLowrys arrived in Tombstone. All drank freely, and as the liquor robbed them of their reason their tongues became loosened and they openly voiced their contempt for the posse and insinuated that the Earps and Halliday were responsible for the numerous train robberies. As City Marshal Virgil Earp warned them to restrain their tongues and to keep the peace, they laughed at him. Later, while he was engaged in a game of poker, Tom McLowry insisted on playing. Virgil Earp met his bluff with an acquiescence.
For hours the game progressed, but beneath a silk handkerchief which lay on his lap Earp had a six-shooter ready for use. At dawn McLowry quit a loser. He became "grouchy" and boisterous. He cursed "the Earp gang," as he termed the posse, and invited a fight. Earp placed him under arrest. McLowry resisted and was felled to the ground by a blow from Earp's gun. He was dragged to jail, but at 10 o'clock was released on his promise to leave the camp. At 1 o'clock he and his crowd were still in evidence in the camp. Virgil Earp sent word that if they were not cut of the camp by 3 o'clock trouble would follow.
John Behan, then sheriff, knowing the temper of Earp, sought the cowboys and advised them to leave. At the appointed time the McLowrys and Clantons were bidding acquaintances goodby when Virgil, Wyatt and Morgan Earp and "Doc" Halliday approached them.
Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo. · 16 January 1899
The Worcester Spy · Worcester, Mass.
This sports feature profiles boxer Tom Sharkey's rise to wealth, noting his bout with Bob Fitzsimmons netted him $10,000 through what is called 'the Wyatt Earp business.' The reference recalls the controversial fight where Earp, as referee, disqualified Fitzsimmons for a low blow.
The Worcester Spy · 29 January 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
SHARKEY WORTH $70,000.
obtaining an easy living.
Today Tom is a wealthy man, as famous as Bill Bryan, and walks along Easy street's sunny side with the independence of Russell Sage and the dignity of a Richard Mansfield. He modestly asserts that he would not change bank accounts with some Wall street brokers, and people who should know take the sailor's word for it, and claim that he has a pile of cash as big as a sky scraping building. Sharkey's career as a pugilist has been one successful run. He crawled into luck when he first climbed into the ring, and he is still crawling.
See moreSee less
Sharkey's debut, or first bid for championship honors, was made in San Francisco. Noted fighters were convinced that Sharkey was a holy terror. He was not clever, they were told, but the navy used to use him to test the steel plates for battleships, and if the plates stood Sharkey's swings and uppercuts they were accepted; that is, the plates, not the punches and uppercuts. Sharkey got big purses from the time he entered for his maiden race, as 'Frisco sports call a man's first fight. He stood off Joe Choynski, and eventually met Bob Fitzsimmons, now an eminent actor, who is teaching a novice of the footlights—Ned Harrigan—how to draw big houses, and will testify to the effectiveness of the Wyatt Earp blow. Sharkey's bank account swelled $10,000 worth through the Earp business. Sharkey toured a little, not for his own health, but for the health of his pocketbook. He fell out with his manager, Lynch, and that settled him on the coast. He got a match with Jeffries, and the latter got the decision. Sharkey claimed there was a job, and that the worst he could have got was a draw. The best he got was the worse, he claimed, and, pained beyond expression, he decided to leave 'Frisco. It was mean to make him the victim of a job, and was degrading to say the least. Sharkey hated to see his beloved profession blemished—so came east.
Here luck and Sharkey renewed acquaintances. He hardly reached New York when he picked up $5000 in something like a minute, and all he had to do to earn it was to tap August Ruhlin of Akron, O., on the jaw, sending August into the land of Nod. Tom did other things to make him famous, and his latest achievement in the knocking out of one Norman Selby, who ran away from Rush county, Ind., to avoid doing duty as a scarecrow in his father's pea patch and adopted "Kid" McCoy as a disguise to be safe.
Thomas Sharkey is today worth something like $70,000, more or less. His manager, Tom O'Rourke, says he never spends a cent, and it is claimed that he still carries about his person the first dollar he ever made. Sharkey can get all the fight he wants, and victory in any one of them means a pile of money. Peter Maher would give a big bunch of genuine shamrocks, which he dearly cherishes, to get another fight with Tom. Peter says he is a "cinch."