Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
An up-town club conversation recalls a story about Wyatt Earp's reputation as a gunfighter during San Diego's boom years, where lesser toughs deferred to his authority in settling disputes. The tale describes a gambling confrontation between bank owner Bob Cahill and a player named Kelly that nearly erupted into violence.
Los Angeles Herald · 2 January 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE MAN KILLER
Among the "killers" at San Diego during the boom, was Wyatt Earp, of the notorious Earp brothers, known as "gun-fighters" and men slayers from "way back." So well established was his reputation as a quick pistol puller and a dead shot, that the minor toughs kotowed to him, and frequently allowed disputes to be settled by his arbitration. If a shooting match were on, both men to it were held off by their friends until Earp had investigated the matter, and his decision was final. Bob Cahill ran a "bank" at San Diego in those days.
See moreSee less
The limit was $25. A man named Kelly was a regular player. One night he was in good luck, and began forcing the game. Several times he placed $50 on a card, notwithstanding Cahill's protest. Finally Bob told him that he would have to stay with the limit or quit the game, as he did not intend to have any one come in his own bank and break him. Kelly bet $50 again, and his card won. "I told you not to top the limit," said