As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

January 1892

2 articles

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

An up-town club conversation recalls a story about Wyatt Earp's reputation as a gunfighter during San Diego's boom years, where lesser toughs deferred to his authority in settling disputes. The tale describes a gambling confrontation between bank owner Bob Cahill and a player named Kelly that nearly erupted into violence.

Los Angeles Herald · 2 January 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE MAN KILLER

Among the "killers" at San Diego during the boom, was Wyatt Earp, of the notorious Earp brothers, known as "gun-fighters" and men slayers from "way back." So well established was his reputation as a quick pistol puller and a dead shot, that the minor toughs kotowed to him, and frequently allowed disputes to be settled by his arbitration. If a shooting match were on, both men to it were held off by their friends until Earp had investigated the matter, and his decision was final. Bob Cahill ran a "bank" at San Diego in those days.

See moreSee less

The limit was $25. A man named Kelly was a regular player. One night he was in good luck, and began forcing the game. Several times he placed $50 on a card, notwithstanding Cahill's protest. Finally Bob told him that he would have to stay with the limit or quit the game, as he did not intend to have any one come in his own bank and break him. Kelly bet $50 again, and his card won. "I told you not to top the limit," said

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The report recounts a faro game confrontation between dealer Bob Cahill and gambler Kelly that nearly turned violent. Instead of calling police, both sides deferred to Wyatt Earp, whose reputation as an expert on 'man killing' let him mediate and defuse the standoff.

Los Angeles Herald · 2 January 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE MAN KILLER.

hand for his gun.

"Well, I guess not," said Cahill, who also reached for his revolver. Immediately the other players fled, and in a minute there would have been a fusillade, if Joe Bell, a friend of Kelly, had not caught him by the arms and hustled him into another room. Cahill was also taken away. Then the friends of both men, instead of summoning the police or the sheriff, sent for Wyatt Earp to get the benefit of his experience in the matter. Earp, it was conceded, knew more about the ethics of man killing than any other man in San Diego.

See moreSee less

He came and listened to explanations. Then he saw Kelly and said, "You want to kill Bob, eh?"

"That's right, Wyatt," said the gambler.

Cahill was next interviewed by the boss manslayer.

"You want to kill Kelly, do you?" said Earp.

"Well, I want to prevent him killing me, Wyatt," said the dealer.

Earp then returned to the gambling room and weighed the testimony, the gamblers waiting in respectful silence for his decision. Both disputants were summoned by his orders, and then stepping over to Kelly, Earp said: "Kelly, I've heard all the testimony in this case, and from all the evidence, I don't think you've got no kill a-coming."

"All right, Wyatt, that settles it; let's all take a drink," said Kelly. He and Cahill shook hands, and everybody drank; then there was a round on the house, and Kelly and Cahill resuming their seats at the faro table, the game went on.

See the clipping