The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A San Francisco dispatch recounts Wyatt Earp's involvement in a San Diego gambling legal dispute, then flashes back to his Tombstone days, describing the O.K. Corral fight and the killing of Frank Stilwell in Tucson after Morgan Earp's assassination. It claims an inquest jury was persuaded by Wyatt's argument about frontier horsemanship and ruled the killing justifiable homicide.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 123 days later.
The Sun · 6 January 1889 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image
WYATT EARP AND HIS PISTOLS.
He is a Law-abiding Man Now, but He was a Terror Some Years Ago.
See moreSee less
SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 29.βIn a legal contest between the gambling fraternity and the authorities of San Diego, Cal., which is now in progress, Wyatt Earp figures as a common, every-day sort of a sport, who will obey the law if he must, but who will resist it to the extent of contributing to the fund which the boys have raised for the pay of their lawyers. Some years ago Wyatt was a law unto himself, and his revolvers were his executioners. When his brother was City Marshal of Tombstone, Arizona, Wyatt kept him company, partly for fun and partly for profit and glory. After the big battle with the McClowrys, in which the Earps killed seven or eight men, the latter spent most of their time dodging bullets. Friends of the dead men had sworn vengeance, and it was not long before they had it.
One night Morgan Earp, still another brother, was assassinated in a saloon in Tombstone. No one saw the murderer, the bullet coming through a window, but Wyatt made up his mind that the culprit was Frank Stillman. The next morning Stillman took breakfast at 9 o'clock in Tucson, some ninety miles away. The second morning after the tragedy Wyatt Earp, Doc Halliday, Texas Jack, and two or three