As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

July 1888

5 articles

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

A Denver reporter interviews former Wells Fargo messenger C. A. Bartholomew about road agent troubles near Tombstone, including a stage robbery and posse action against outlaws. Bartholomew recounts the Earp brothers' 1881 gunfight with the Clanton gang, describing how Marshal Virgil Earp deputized his brothers and Doc Holliday after the gang refused to surrender their weapons.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Reporter and Farmer · 12 July 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

organized road agent gangs.

AN OLD-TIME EXPRESS AGENT.

See moreSee less

A Denver Republican reporter met Mr. C. A. Bartholomew, the man who was in command of the posse of men here referred to.

The reporter approached him with a desire to learn something of the capture of the road agents and the robbery which lead to it.

"Well, this was one time, at least, that I was licked," said Mr. Bartholomew, refering to the hold-up, "but I got even finally. It was the only battle I had to fight during the five years I was in the employ of the Wells, Fargo company, but it was battle enough. This was on the 6th of January, 1881, and some three months previous to that time there had been a hold-up on the Hubbard stage-line, running from Tombstone to Bisbee copper mines, in which a driver and a passenger were killed. I was at that time a messenger for the Wells, Fargo Company on the Kerns & Griffith line running from Yuma to Tuscon. The company ordered me to the Tombstone-Bisbee line, and during the three months our stage had run along without any attempt being made to hold us up. We usually had a large treasure, but we had exceedingly good luck, and I had begun to think I should escape the road agents.

"In December, 1880, however, there occurred a little trouble in Tombstone which gave me some fears that it might be my turn next. The three Clanton boys and two MacElroys, whom I believed to be of this gang of eighty road agents, came into town armed. There was a town ordinance forbidding the carrying of firearms, and when any of this gang of outlaws came into town they were quickly disarmed. Upon this occasion the Sheriff told these fellows not to give up their arms. Virg Earp--one of the Earp brothers--was Town Marshal, and when he needed deputies would call upon one or more of his brothers or Doc Holladay. The Marshal knew that if he demanded the guns of these men he would have to stand a fight. He deputized his brothers, Wyatt and Morg, and Doc Holladay to assist him. The Clanton gang refused to surrender and a battle resulted, in which the three Earp brothers were wounded and Billy Clanton and the two MacElroy boys and Ike Clanton were killed.

"This band of road agents and all of the rough gambling and thieving element in Tombstone were enemies of the Earp brothers for the reason that they stood in with and assisted the law-and-order people of the town.

"The town was divided in the way that frontier towns usually were in those days, and still are at present, except that in Tombstone this division was probably more marked than elsewhere. One side of the main street was occupied by rough saloons, gambling-houses and their accompaniments, while on the other side the stores and better class of people carried on their business. The Earp brothers and Holladay, and many of that class of men who were well behaved sporting men, boarded at the Cosmopolitan hotel, while the thieves and thugs made their rendezvous at the Grand."

"What had this fight and the enmity between the toughs and the better class of men to do with the holding-up of your stage?" asked the reporter.

"Well, it had this to do with it: The action of these boys indicated that they were opposed to the thieves and hold-ups, and their talk was proof enough that they were friends of the Wells-Fargo company. These outlaws were determined to exterminate Holladay and the Earps if possible. A few weeks after this fight they again shot and wounded Virg Earp while he was passing along the street.

See the clipping

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

An old express agent recounts in an interview the 1881 gunfight between the Earp brothers and the Clanton gang, framing it as part of an ongoing war between law-and-order men and outlaws in Tombstone. He also describes being ambushed while riding shotgun on a stagecoach near Bisbee.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Fremont Clipper, 19 April 1888, The Fremont Clipper, 19 April 1888.

Reporter and Farmer · 12 July 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

organized road agent gangs.

AN OLD-TIME EXPRESS AGENT.

See moreSee less

A Denver Republican reporter met Mr. C. A. Bartholomew, the man who was in command of the posse of men here referred to.

The reporter approached him with a desire to learn something of the capture of the road agents and the robbery which lead to it.

"Well, this was one time, at least, that I was licked," said Mr. Bartholomew, refering to the hold-up, "but I got even finally. It was the only battle I had to fight during the five years I was in the employ of the Wells, Fargo company, but it was battle enough. This was on the 6th of January, 1881, and some three months previous to that time there had been a hold-up on the Hubbard stage-line, running from Tombstone to Bisbee copper mines, in which a driver and a passenger were killed. I was at that time a messenger for the Wells, Fargo Company on the Kerns & Griffith line running from Yuma to Tuscon. The company ordered me to the Tombstone-Bisbee line, and during the three months our stage had run along without any attempt being made to hold us up. We usually had a large treasure, but we had exceedingly good luck, and I had begun to think I should escape the road agents.

"In December, 1880, however, there occurred a little trouble in Tombstone which gave me some fears that it might be my turn next. The three Clanton boys and two MacElroys, whom I believed to be of this gang of eighty road agents, came into town armed. There was a town ordinance forbidding the carrying of firearms, and when any of this gang of outlaws came into town they were quickly disarmed. Upon this occasion the Sheriff told these fellows not to give up their arms. Virg Earp--one of the Earp brothers--was Town Marshal, and when he needed deputies would call upon one or more of his brothers or Doc Holladay. The Marshal knew that if he demanded the guns of these men he would have to stand a fight. He deputized his brothers, Wyatt and Morg, and Doc Holladay to assist him. The Clanton gang refused to surrender and a battle resulted, in which the three Earp brothers were wounded and Billy Clanton and the two MacElroy boys and Ike Clanton were killed.

"This band of road agents and all of the rough gambling and thieving element in Tombstone were enemies of the Earp brothers for the reason that they stood in with and assisted the law-and-order people of the town.

"The town was divided in the way that frontier towns usually were in those days, and still are at present, except that in Tombstone this division was probably more marked than elsewhere. One side of the main street was occupied by rough saloons, gambling-houses and their accompaniments, while on the other side the stores and better class of people carried on their business. The Earp brothers and Holladay, and many of that class of men who were well behaved sporting men, boarded at the Cosmopolitan hotel, while the thieves and thugs made their rendezvous at the Grand."

"What had this fight and the enmity between the toughs and the better class of men to do with the holding-up of your stage?" asked the reporter.

"Well, it had this to do with it: The action of these boys indicated that they were opposed to the thieves and hold-ups, and their talk was proof enough that they were friends of the Wells-Fargo company. These outlaws were determined to exterminate Holladay and the Earps if possible. A few weeks after this fight they again shot and wounded Virg Earp while he was passing along the street.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

A stagecoach messenger recounts years later how he surrendered a gold shipment to road agents near Tombstone, then helped organize a posse that gave Wyatt Earp command of part of the force. He praises Earp's bravery and principles, while being asked whether Morgan Earp's death spurred his zeal, despite the posse action described predating that killing.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

Reporter and Farmer · 12 July 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

"There was but one move to make then. That was to move on into town on foot, for our horses were dead. When I told the story the business men and mining superintendents started in to raise a posse of men to capture the road agents, in which they were endorsed by the United States district attorney, and I was given command. I gave Wyatt Earp charge of ten of the forty men and I took the others. He acted under my orders. I never saw a braver nor a more efficient man than Wyatt Earp. He was gentlemanly and kind in his conduct toward his men and rendered me very valuable service."

"Is it not probable that Wyatt Earp was urged to his good work by a spirit of revenge, or is it a fact that his brother Morg was killed before this posse started out?"

See moreSee less

"It is probable that the death of his brother was an incentive to harder work, but Wyatt Earp is a man who believes in right and justice, and he was ready at any time to render his assistance in a warfare upon thieves and hold-ups. Now, I want to say to you that Wyatt Earp and all of his four brothers were men of principle, and they were fighters who were not afraid of man or devil. They were all valuable men upon occasions of this kind, and their unwillingness to associate with the tough element of Tombstone was a sufficient guarantee to me that they did their work because they believed in the right and were anxious to see the right on top. I know some people have a different view but I know what I am talking about and shall never have anything but the truth to tell of them."

"You captured this band of road agents, did you not?"

"We captured about thirty-five of them and killed those to whom I was compelled to deliver the treasure-box, and we ran the balance of them out of the country. On the first night out, the 15 of January, we captured seventeen of them at Charleston. Then our work was harder, as this fact embittered them and they were hard fighters. But in forty days we finished the job."

"Can you give me the facts as to the killing of Morg Earp and also of the killing of Stillwell? Did Wyatt Earp or Doc Holladay kill the latter?"

"Morg Earp and Doc Holladay were playing billiards one day while we were getting ready to start on this raid. Some of this road agent gang went to the rear of the billiard hall; climbed up on some of the beer-kegs and shot through the transom of the door at Holladay and killed Earp.

"As to the killing of Stillwell; that was done by Holladay. The boys had gone over to the railroad station to take the train for the East for the purpose of carrying the body of Morg Earp back to his home. I gave them orders that if any of the gang should board the train after it started to kill them if they could. Stillwell was on the platform and had made threats that he would kill Virg Earp. The train started and he boarded it and made a break for Virg Earp. Doc Holladay knocked him off with his gun and his dead body was afterwards picked up."

Mr. Bartholomew came to Denver in April, 1859, but returned to Iowa before the breaking out of the war and was in the first regiment and first company organized in that

Battling Road Agents.

Eighty of the Gentry Routed by Forty Deputy Marshals.

Road agents in the border States are becoming extinct. It seems like a long time ago that the daily press gave almost daily accounts of the depredations of this class of outlaws. But in reality it has been but a very few years since some great battles were fought between armed officers and the desperadoes whose sole aim was robbery, and principally the robbery of express and mail on the stage lines of the Western States from Colorado to California. Stage robberies ten years ago were of daily occurence throughout the States and Territories of that section, and many an express agent and driver met death while doing his duty to the company he represented.

It required courage, bravery and a thorough knowledge of the use of firearms by the agents of the express companies to stand off a squad of road-agents, and there were brave men needed when an effort was made to capture a band of outlaws. One of the latest and probably the most notable capture made was that in Arizona in 1881. In that raid a band of eighty hard men was thoroughly broken up by an armed posse of forty Deputy United States Marshals formed in Tombstone. The speedy and fatal work done by the law and order men in that attack struck terror to the hearts of the robber element and since that time there has been but little holding up of stages by large and thoroughly organized road agent gangs.

AN OLD-TIME EXPRESS AGENT.

See the clipping

Emmons County Record · Williamsport, N.D. · and 2 other papers

An old-time Wells-Fargo express agent recounts the Earp-Clanton gunfight in Tombstone, describing the town's factions and the feud between the Earps and outlaws. He then describes being ambushed by five armed men while riding the Bisbee stage on January 6th.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Emmons County Record · 20 July 1888 · page 3

AN OLD-TIME EXPRESS AGENT. A Denver Republican reporter met Mr. C. A. Bartholomew, the man who was in command of the posse of men here referred to. The reporter approached him with a desire to learn something of the capture of the road agents and the robbery which lead to it. "Well, this was one time, at least, that I was licked," said Mr. Bartholomew, refering to the hold-up, "but I got even finally. It was the only battle I had to fight during the five years I was in the employ of the Wells, Fargo company, but it was battle enough.

See moreSee less

This was on the 6th of January, 1881, and some three months previous to that time there had been a hold-up on the Hubbard stage-line, running from Tombstone to Bis bee copper mines, in which a driver and a passenger were killed. I was at that time a messenger for the Wells, Fargo Company on tho Kerns & Griffith line running from Yuma to Tuscon. The company ordered me to the Tombstone-Bisbee line, and during the three months our stage had run along without any attempt being made to hold us up. We usually had a large treasure, but we had ex ceedingly good luck, and I had begun to think 1 should escape the road agents. "In December, 1880, however, there oc curred a little trouble in Tombstone which gave me some fears that it might be my turn next. The three Clanton boys and two MacElrojw, whom I believed to be of this gang of eighty road agents, came into town armed. There was a town ordinance forbid ding the carrying of firearms, and when any of this gang of outlaws came into town they were quickly disarmed. Upon this occasion the Sheriff told these fellows not to give up their arms. Virg Earp—one of the Earp brothers—was Town Marshal, and when he needed deputies would call upon one or more of his brothers or Doc Holladay. The Mar shal knew that if he demanded tho guns of these men he would have to stand a fight. He deputized his brothers, Wyatt and Morg, and Doc Holladay to assist him. The Clan ton gang refused to surrender and a battle resulted, in which the three Earp brothers were wounded and Billy Clanton and the two MacElroy boys and Ike Clanton were killed. "This band of road agents and all of the rough gambling and thieving element in Tombstone were enemies of the Earp brothers for the reason that they stood in with and assisted the law-and-order people of the town. "The town was divided in the way that frontier towns usually were in those days, and still are at present, except that in Tomb stone this division was probably more marked than elsewhere. One side of the main street was occupied by rough saloons, gam bling-houses and their accompaniments, while on the other side the stores and better class of people carried on their business. The Earp brothers and Holladay, and many that class of men who were well behaved sporting men, boarded at the Cosmopolitan hotel, while the thieves and thugs made their rendezvous at the Grand." "What had this fight: and the enmity be tween tho toughs and the better class of men to do with the holding-up of your stage?" asked the reporter. "Well, it had this to do with it: The ac tion of boys indicated that they were theBe opposed to the thieves and hold-ups, and their talk was proof enough that they were friends of the Wells-Fargo company. These outlaws were determined to exterminate Hol laday and the Earps if possible. A few weeks after this fight they again shot and wounded Virg Earp while he was passing along the street.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Warner Sun · Warner, S.D. · 13 July 1888
  • Phillipsburg Herald · Phillipsburg, Kan. · 3 August 1888

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Arizona Territory Ariz.

An opinion piece argues that Tombstone's citizens deliberately provoked a fight between the Earp and Clanton gangs to eliminate both as a public menace. The author compares this to other Arizona Territory incidents involving former lawmen turned outlaws, framing it as part of a broader pattern of frontier justice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The St. Johns Herald · 26 July 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Desperadoes as Peace Officers. Written for the St. Johns Herald. The article which appeared in your issue of June 7th, has received the unqualified approbation of the entire territorial press; at least, of all those papers whose editors are intelligently posted on the territory and its political history; the exceptions, are those ignorant of, or who purposely misconstrue the intent and meaning thereof. To further illustrate my position: Take Tombstone under the regime of desperadoes—the Earp-Clanton gangs—all

See the clipping