As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

December 1925

10 articles

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A personal memoir recounts how the author secured President Theodore Roosevelt's approval to name a new Alaskan town 'Seward' after William H. Seward, who negotiated the Alaska Purchase. The account details the postoffice approval process and briefly touches on the subsequent railroad construction history connected to the town.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 December 1925 · page 38

“T. R.” The Mr. Bristow he addressed was the then Fourth Assistant Postmaster General, and was aft erward United States Senator from Kansas. As President Roosevelt handed me the two letters he said,' with a twinkle of a smile: “I think these indorsements will bring the results you are after.” And they certainly did. In ten minutes after I had presented the letter to Mr. Bristow, an order was issued establishing a new postoffice on Resurrection Bay, Alaska, un der the name of “Seward,” and Mr. Bristow expressed his emphat ic approval of the patriotic senti ments, in agreement with the Pres ident. At 4 o’clock the same day ap proval was given by the Commis sioner of the General Land Office

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

The Seattle Daily Times declares Alaska a treasure house with growing trade, citing $61 million in products last year and over $1.2 billion since the 1867 purchase. It highlights revived mining, new industrial investments, record tourist travel, and government railroad development as signs of Alaska's expanding prosperity.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 December 1925 · page 48

Alaska is the Treasure House of the World Announces Seattle Times in Recent Issue

United States in Seattle, announces the Seattle Daily Times. This year with the revival of mining noticed some months ago, with plans for the expenditure of approximately $9,000,000 in Fairbanks by a new gold dredging company and of $10,000,000 for a paper mill at Seward, with the outlook for fisheries improved and increasing timber business, is expect ed to set a record in Alaska trade. The bulk of it will move through Se attle. Since Alaska was purchased in 1867 up to January 1, 1925, the Territory has exported products valued at $1,236,469,345.

See moreSee less

Last year its products were valued at $61,317,370, a slight decrease of the total of 1923. Tourist travel through Seattle to Alaska this year reached into 20,000 persons, eclipsing all records. The expenditure of $11,000,000 by the government for the development of the Alaska Railroad during the next six or seven years is the program advo cated by Noel W. Smith, new general manager, The first million is now be ing spent for steel bridges for the en tire system.

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A magazine writer recounts a secondhand tale told to President Harding, claiming the real purchase price of Alaska was only $1,400,000 despite a warrant for $7,200,000. The story traces through a chain of oral retellings from a bank clerk to a general to a senator decades after the 1867 purchase.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 35 days earlier.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 December 1925 · page 49

STORY RETOLD TO PRESIDENT HARDING BEFORE HIS ALASKAN TOUR REGARDING PURCHASE PRICE OF TERRITORY INTERESTED THE CHIEF IMMENSELY

_4_ By JOE MITCHELL CHAPPLE, In National Magazine WHEN Mr. Charles C. Glover of the Riggs National Bank re told me a story that very much interested the late Presi dent Harding just before his Alaskan trip, I was all eyes and ears. It conveys a new light upon an incident in United States history concerning which there has always been a great deal of com ment, but nothing definitely declared. When a young clerk in the Riggs National Bank, C. C. Glover was accosted by General Simpson who was then living in Philadelphia and kept his bank account in Washington and came to pay his life insurance.

See moreSee less

The latter told him an enlightening story concerning the purchase of Alaska, which now, for the first time, is available for publication. “According to the story told me,” said Mr. Glover, “the truth of which has been vouched for, the United States did not, as the his torians tell us, pay $7,200,000 for Alaska. The actual purchase price was $1,400,000, although the warrant turned over to Russia, which was handled by me, called for $7,200,000.” General Simpson, from whom Glover, then a young bank clerk, got the tale, was later Governor of Montana. After his term of of fice lie was sent to Alaska, and while on the train going West he met Senator Dawes of Massachusetts, who had something to do with the negotiations, and who told him the anecdote which thus bears the stamp of Senatorial authority. Prior to the war, negotiations had been started by Russia to sell Alaska for $1,400,000. It was decided to conclude the sale before England annexed the territory in extending her northwest boundary, at the time a land of icebergs. The war interfered with the nego tiations. In the darkest days of the struggle, when England was about to break the blockade and declare her sympathy for the Southern Confederacy, Secretary William Henry Seward was looking about for some way of checkmating the move which he was informed had been definitely decided upon. Soon after he called in the Russian Minister, Stoehl, for a con ference and arranged to have a Russian fleet come to New York and a small fleet was sent to San Francisco as a warning to England to keep off the American coast. This little demonstration had much to do with turning the tide and was an emphatic notice to Great Britain that Russia was friendly to the Union. The cost of this little dem onstration was about five million dollars, which England added to the costs of the war to the U. S. A. After the war, the deficiency fund was exhausted and the treas ury was so depleted that there was no possible way of passing a bill to pay Russia for its services without giving offense to England. It was decided, when the final arrangements were made, that the price paid for the territory purchased should be made to cover the full cost of obtaining Alaska, at $7,200,000. This sum, of course, included the original purchase price of $1,400,000 and the cost of sending the Rus sian fleet to safeguard the Union. Five million dollars and more wms the sum paid for the services of the Russian naval vessels. Thus in what purported to be only the price paid for Alaska was payment also, for Russia’s friendly demonstration at a most critical time. briefly some of the more important

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A banker recounts a secondhand tale from a Montana governor claiming the true purchase price of Alaska was only $1,400,000, with the rest of the $7,200,000 warrant actually covering Russia's naval demonstration against England during the Civil War. The story is presented as having 'Senatorial authority' via a chain of retellings decades after the 1867 purchase.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 December 1925 · page 49 · transcribed from the page image

By JOE MITCHELL CHAPPLE, In National Magazine

WHEN Mr. Charles C. Glover of the Riggs National Bank retold me a story that very much interested the late President Harding just before his Alaskan trip, I was all eyes and ears. It conveys a new light upon an incident in United States history concerning which there has always been a great deal of comment, but nothing definitely declared. When a young clerk in the Riggs National Bank, C. C. Glover was accosted by General Simpson who was then living in Philadelphia and kept his bank account in Washington and came to pay his life insurance. The latter told him an enlightening story concerning the purchase of Alaska, which now, for the first time, is available for publication.

See moreSee less

"According to the story told me," said Mr. Glover, "the truth of which has been vouched for, the United States did not, as the historians tell us, pay $7,200,000 for Alaska. The actual purchase price was $1,400,000, although the warrant turned over to Russia, which was handled by me, called for $7,200,000."

General Simpson, from whom Glover, then a young bank clerk, got the tale, was later Governor of Montana. After his term of office he was sent to Alaska, and while on the train going West he met Senator Dawes of Massachusetts, who had something to do with the negotiations, and who told him the anecdote which thus bears the stamp of Senatorial authority.

Prior to the war, negotiations had been started by Russia to sell Alaska for $1,400,000. It was decided to conclude the sale before England annexed the territory in extending her northwest boundary, at the time a land of icebergs. The war interfered with the negotiations. In the darkest days of the struggle, when England was about to break the blockade and declare her sympathy for the Southern Confederacy, Secretary William Henry Seward was looking about for some way of checkmating the move which he was informed had been definitely decided upon.

Soon after he called in the Russian Minister, Stoehl, for a conference and arranged to have a Russian fleet come to New York and a small fleet was sent to San Francisco as a warning to England to keep off the American coast. This little demonstration had much to do with turning the tide and was an emphatic notice to Great Britain that Russia was friendly to the Union. The cost of this little demonstration was about five million dollars, which England added to the costs of the war to the U. S. A.

After the war, the deficiency fund was exhausted and the treasury was so depleted that there was no possible way of passing a bill to pay Russia for its services without giving offense to England. It was decided, when the final arrangements were made, that the price paid for the territory purchased should be made to cover the full cost of obtaining Alaska, at $7,200,000. This sum, of course, included the original purchase price of $1,400,000 and the cost of sending the Russian fleet to safeguard the Union. Five million dollars and more was the sum paid for the services of the Russian naval vessels. Thus in what purported to be only the price paid for Alaska was payment also, for Russia's friendly demonstration at a most critical time.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

This retrospective piece describes how Alaska Day (Oct. 18) and Seward Day (March 30) became legal but not school holidays in the Territory, and reviews the history of the 1867 purchase. It repeats a claim that the $7.2 million price secretly included $5 million paid to Russia for sending its fleet to support the Union during the Civil War.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 December 1925 · page 49

TRANSFERED OCT 18, '67

_4_ By JOE MITCHELL CHAPPLE, In National Magazine WHEN Mr. Charles C. Glover of the Riggs National Bank re told me a story that very much interested the late Presi dent Harding just before his Alaskan trip, I was all eyes and ears. It conveys a new light upon an incident in United States history concerning which there has always been a great deal of com ment, but nothing definitely declared. When a young clerk in the Riggs National Bank, C. C. Glover was accosted by General Simpson who was then living in Philadelphia and kept his bank account in Washington and came to pay his life insurance.

See moreSee less

The latter told him an enlightening story concerning the purchase of Alaska, which now, for the first time, is available for publication. “According to the story told me,” said Mr. Glover, “the truth of which has been vouched for, the United States did not, as the his torians tell us, pay $7,200,000 for Alaska. The actual purchase price was $1,400,000, although the warrant turned over to Russia, which was handled by me, called for $7,200,000.” General Simpson, from whom Glover, then a young bank clerk, got the tale, was later Governor of Montana. After his term of of fice lie was sent to Alaska, and while on the train going West he met Senator Dawes of Massachusetts, who had something to do with the negotiations, and who told him the anecdote which thus bears the stamp of Senatorial authority. Prior to the war, negotiations had been started by Russia to sell Alaska for $1,400,000. It was decided to conclude the sale before England annexed the territory in extending her northwest boundary, at the time a land of icebergs. The war interfered with the nego tiations. In the darkest days of the struggle, when England was about to break the blockade and declare her sympathy for the Southern Confederacy, Secretary William Henry Seward was looking about for some way of checkmating the move which he was informed had been definitely decided upon. Soon after he called in the Russian Minister, Stoehl, for a con ference and arranged to have a Russian fleet come to New York and a small fleet was sent to San Francisco as a warning to England to keep off the American coast. This little demonstration had much to do with turning the tide and was an emphatic notice to Great Britain that Russia was friendly to the Union. The cost of this little dem onstration was about five million dollars, which England added to the costs of the war to the U. S. A. After the war, the deficiency fund was exhausted and the treas ury was so depleted that there was no possible way of passing a bill to pay Russia for its services without giving offense to England. It was decided, when the final arrangements were made, that the price paid for the territory purchased should be made to cover the full cost of obtaining Alaska, at $7,200,000. This sum, of course, included the original purchase price of $1,400,000 and the cost of sending the Rus sian fleet to safeguard the Union. Five million dollars and more wms the sum paid for the services of the Russian naval vessels. Thus in what purported to be only the price paid for Alaska was payment also, for Russia’s friendly demonstration at a most critical time. briefly some of the more important

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A long-distance telephone exchange has a Seward booster answering skeptical questions about the Alaska Railroad, which a U.S. senator had dismissed as worthless. The booster counters by describing the railroad's 500-mile route through resource-rich territory, defending it as proof of Alaska's value.

Seward Daily Gateway · 23 December 1925 · page 4

COMMUNICATION “Central, give me long distance ” Long Distance: “Hello, this is long distance. Give you Seward; you bet and very long, too. Can you locate James McConnell, formerly of Pitts ville, Wis.?” “Yes, sir; he is right here.” “Hello, Mr. McConnell; I want to ask you a few questions in regard to that railroad that runs out of Sew —ard that road that you boosted for. uln our last conversation you said that this road you Alaskans boosted for so much runs out of Seward. Now, if it runs of of Seward where does it run to?

See moreSee less

Out in the woods and stop, or out in the Bay? What are the re sources in the country it runs thru? I have just read a letter from a U. S. senator, I have forgotten his name, saying that your railroad will not amount to anything. He advocates pulling up the rails and making a wagon road out of it. Now how about that. I want to know the truth.” “Well, now, do not hang up disgust ed. If I must tell the whole truth it will take some time. You see, we

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A longtime Alaska resident recounts placer mining stories along the Kenai River and argues that the Alaska Railroad, if properly supported, will prove as good an investment as the original purchase of Alaska from Russia. He criticizes senators who judge the territory without leaving their train cars.

Seward Daily Gateway · 23 December 1925 · page 4

Alaska will make of it as good an investment as the purchase of Alaska with the Matanuska Valley and Tan ana Valley. The latter valley lies

See the clipping

The Kusko Times · McGrath, Alaska

A 1925 rebuttal to a Mr. Free's criticism of the Alaska Railroad argues the line benefits thousands of residents, citing the delivery of diphtheria antitoxin to Nome as proof of its value. The writer invokes the historical mockery of the Alaska purchase as 'Seward's Folly,' noting no one today regrets the $7,200,000 cost, and defends railroad spending as similarly visionary.

The Kusko Times · 26 December 1925 · page 2

TREE'S ATTACK ON ALASKA ((Engineering and Mining Journal Press, New York.) Representative Arthur M. Free, of California, ranking member of the •committee on merchant marine and ifisheries in the House of Representa tives, has just returned from Alaska, where he inspected the government railroad. He has issued a statement that the railroad should be aban doned. on the grounds that it serves «a population of only 5,000 at a cost •of $400 per capita per pear, and at a lloss to the government. While it may be true that there are only 5,000 peo ple “on or near" the railroad, yet a .g!: \ at the atlas shows that the to; i extends to the very heart of the great Territory, and that tributary •to the road (excluding the Copper River valley and Southeastern Alas ,ka) there are villages as far west as Nome, with a total population of 15,000.

See moreSee less

that receive a direct benefit from this road in the matter of mail, passenngenr service and freight. Mr. Free should not forget the service rendered and tihie saved in trans porting antitoxin to stricken Nome Jast winter from the railroad at Ne nana, 450 miles inland—a saving of •eight to ten days and undoubtedly the ifives of many people at the isolated sand frantic city. Every prospector, ^fisherman, woodchopper, and Indian in the great Yukon valley, and as far morth as the reindeer fields of the .Arctic, is benefited directly or indi rectly by this road. The census takes cognizance of only the permanent population. During •every summer season there is usually 1 :a transient population of two or even ifhree times the local citizenry that :must be taken into consideration 'when reckoning in terms of abandon iment. The purchase of Alaska was •characterized as “Seward’s Folly,” yet 'who is there today that begrudges (the original cost of §7,200,000? As Jbusiness is organized at present, the ertn finn nnn l.,_1., iupon the recommendation of the late ’Franklin K. Lane, Secretary of the interior, is not excessively large in (comparison with the cost of “Sew ard's Folly.” Apparently Mr. Free implies that this venture is “Lane'sj iFolly,” but, as a matter of fait, as in the case of Seward, Lane had the wision of a future empire north of! ‘“54-40.” Alaska has coal, ocpper, gold and '

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1925 Associated Press piece quotes 85-year-old Bruce W. Stone, who claims to be among the last living Americans present at the 1867 ceremony transferring Alaska from Russia to the United States. He describes the formal exchange of flags at Sitka, with American and Russian soldiers facing each other as the Stars and Stripes replaced the Russian standard.

Evening Star · 27 December 1925 · page 26

RECALLS DAY U. S. FLAG WAS RAISED IN ALASKA

B.v tinAe'O.-iated Press. OAKLAND, Calif.. Decembei 2th Bruce \\\ Stone, who soldiered for l nc!e Sam GO years ago, is one of the few. if not the only American, still living who witnessed the flag ceremony inaugurating American do minion over Alaska. I I his military rite took place on the ! Sitka parade ground on . plateau reached by a flight of ;itio steps cut ! into a rough cliff overlooking the Pa cific (>ce an. “I remember (be occasion dearly." ' said the v* teran. now S 5 years old.

See moreSee less

“I was it member of the Army ymu termaster Department and was lin«-d up with the other soldiers for the r-ere i mony. \V»- mimbered about 250 arid in rigid, formal lire faced an equal i number of Russian soldiers. Between us was the flagpole atop of which flew the Russian standard. "In silence the czars banner was lowered and ours quickly run tip. As the Stars and Stripes took the breeze the gunboats in the harbor began to boom the salute to the flag and the transfer of this great northern em pire's political allegiance front St. Petersburg to Washington was ac complished."

See the clipping

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

An 85-year-old Oakland man, Bruce W. Stone, who served in the U.S. Army decades earlier, recalls witnessing the military ceremony at Sitka that inaugurated American rule over Alaska. He describes the flag ceremony taking place on a parade ground reached by 300 steps cut into a cliff overlooking the Pacific.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 28 December 1925 · page 1

Soldier of 1867 Saw U. S. I Flag Raised Over Alaska OAKLAND, Cal., Dec. 28.—Bruce W. Stone, who soldiered for Uncle | ermaster s department and was lined ip with the other soldiers for tlie

See the clipping