As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

August 1924

4 articles

The Omaha Morning Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This 1924 article reflects back on both the Louisiana Purchase and the Alaska Purchase, noting that both were initially mocked and doubted by contemporaries. It argues that just as the 'Great American Desert' of the Midwest later proved fertile and valuable, Alaska's purchase, once ridiculed as 'Seward's Folly,' was similarly vindicated by later discoveries of its resources.

The Omaha Morning Bee · 3 August 1924 · page 27

the territory under discussion as “the worthless west." deal was aonsummated Alaska was called “Seward's Folly. until the close of the civil war. most productive area in the known world. From Desert In Fertile Garden,

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

The review covers 'Seward's Folly' by Edison Marshall, a historical novel dramatizing the Alaska purchase involving Secretary Seward and agent Jefferson Sharp. The critic dismisses it as cheap melodrama with stilted, movie-title-style dialogue despite the promising historical theme.

South Bend News-Times · 16 August 1924 · page 13

“Seward's Polly” (Little, Brown) contains a theme from which an American epic might be made—the Alaska purchase romance. Edison Marshal}/ who wrote It, chooses to make it a cheap historical .novel,of little quality. Secretary Seward and Jefferson Sharp, his agent in the Alaska deal, converse In the fashion of movie titles, as witness: “His eyes looked straight into Jeff’s. 'I am a rebel. I cannot give my services to the enemy that conquered mK No, Mr. Seward, I would rather starve.' ” There Is plenty of this “you ain’t done right by our Nell” stuff in the book.

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A Milwaukee library's list of new book acquisitions includes a fiction title by E. Marshall called 'Seward's Folly,' alongside other new fiction, biography, and travel books. The listing is part of routine library announcements, not a historical account of the Alaska purchase itself.

The Milwaukee Leader · 16 August 1924 · page 3

Epochs in History. FICTION. Burroughs, E. R., The Land That Time Forgot: Kenney, R., A Pedlars Pack; Mac Gill. P.. Moleskin Joe; Marshall, E„ Seward’s Folly. YOUNG PEOPLE’S ROOM.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A review of Edison Marshall's novel 'Seward's Folly,' which imagines a British conspiracy to block renewal of an 1839 Russia-Britain treaty so Alaska would pass to Britain instead of America. The review notes the book's own foreword admits there is no historical evidence Seward blocked any such treaty, and criticizes the novel for reviving old Civil War-era anti-British sentiment under a thin guise of history.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 August 1924 · page 8

“Seward’s Folly,” Historical Ro mance by Edison Marshall Edison Mar-hall’s "Seward's Folly” (Little, Brown & Co., Boston, 82) is a lively yarn—perhaps ‘romanc •” should be the term used —of the block ing of the renewal of the treaty o' 1839 between Russia and Great Brit ain. Had the treaty in its revised form been renewed, Alaska would, ac cording to the story, have become a British Instead of an A meric in posse sion; but according to the Forewor ’ "the mysterious lapse of the treaty be tween the great Russian and English (fur) companies Is obscured In the shadows of the past.

See moreSee less

No historic?’ evidence exists that the Secretary of State, Seward, was instrumental in blocking the treaty, and parts of th-- narratlve dealing 'herewith must be regarded as purely fictitious. Considerable human nature and the great commercial importance of tin fur trade—the wealth drawn fr, m it by the trading companies for the'r owner—intrigue to retain these ad vantages would be very possible. Yet one must question the good taste if not the good judgement at this lav day of representing Britain as engag ing in a dishonorable conspiracy n.» merely with the purpose of acquiring Alaska, but of furthering *f possible the failure of popular government in the United States. In 1887 .he Nortl was still hotly hostile to England be cause of English sympathy with tlnSouth in the war between tile states but it is late now to rake ,ip the ac cusations and recriminations of thi. other quarrel, and to present them fo popular consumption in a guise likely to impress them on the casual read er as embodying historical 'act. As for the yarn, it is lively and In teresting in % superficial way, and will yield good light entertainment though its pervading tone >f spread eagleism belongs to 50 years ago rather than to 1924. By judicious sifting, one can even gather some sound background information cor.- erning Russian Alaska. Yet the sus picion insists on cropping up that even this may have been written in with an eye to ultimate utilization in a motion-picture film.

See the clipping