As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

August 1923

4 articles

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A 1923 editor's book review of James Oliver Curwood's novel 'The Alaskan' references President Harding's trip to Alaska and recalls that critics once derisively called the territory 'Seward's icebox.' The piece uses the old nickname as color while praising the novel's romantic depiction of Alaska and its political conditions.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 August 1923 · page 6

Curwood’s Latest Here you see "Jim” Cur wood on the trail, in his new novel, "The Alaskan.” which has just been published, h'e l moves his characters up into America’s northern wonderland. "The Alaskan" represents the high-water mark of Curwood’s career, both ns a teller of robust and adventurous tales and as a best seller. Since President Hardin? steamed up the coast to take a look into "Seward’s icebox,” as Alaska was called by those who opposed its purchase, thousands of Americans are letting: Curwood carry them by the magic of "Tho Alaskan” away from midsummer heat to the ro mantic land of the last empire-builders.

See moreSee less

Woven into Curwood’s vivid romance is an exposition of tlie political condi tions in Alaska and an eloquent plea for the salvation of this northern wonderland front the Washington bu reaucrats and Wall street capitalists;1 and, strangely enough for fiction, one of the characters who plays a promi nent part in the story is Carl laimen of Nome, a real man, and the reindeer king of the Seward Peninsula. In "The Alaskan” Curwood portrays with all his old witchery and skill the outdoors he knows and loves. His pas sion for honor, fairness, square-shoul dered manliness, and for the beauty of fair women, makes his characters ever more memorable. Publishers, Cosmopolitan Cook Cor

See the clipping

The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.

Decades after Russia sold Alaska for $7,500,000 amid mockery that it was worthless, the territory has yielded hundreds of millions in gold, copper, fisheries and furs. The piece also praises the Panama Canal as another once-doubted investment now proving profitable.

The Chesterfield Advertiser · 2 August 1923 · page 2

UNCLE SAM’S TWO GOOD INVESTMENTS At the time negotiations were on for the purchase of Alaska front Rus sia for $7,50n,OUU objections were utgod on the ground that Alaska was not worth it, that it was a waste of money to buy a land covered most of the year with snow and ice. But it has turned out that, we got a bargain in that deal with Russia. A recent statement is to the effect that in thirty years Alaska has produced $250,000, 000 in gold. In the same 20 years the territory has produced $125,000, 0n0 in copper.

See moreSee less

Since its purchase by Uncle Sam Alaskan fisheries have pro duced an estimated $400,000,000 and also $100,000,01)0 in furs. These are | but the larger items in a productio I wide ;n scope, and take no account t . the vast potential wealth is lumln . and coal yet awaiting development. Government survey estimates avail able coal reserves in Alaska at 11. stupendous figure of 150,000,000,01m tons. This survey is but tentative, an ; those who made it say that develoi - nient may find coal deposits “vast!; more than that amount.”” So much for Alaska. When th Panama canal was under considera tion there was pronounced oppositio: upon the ground that it would net make any return of the investment or pay runningexpenses when complet ed. But after many unsuccessful a tempts President Roosevelt in 100. ordered the work continued that wa concluded under the direction of Gen eral Goethals and his corps of engi neers in 1915. The millions that were put into the building of the canal arc coming back. A recent settlement gives these facts as to what the can al is accomplishing: Ships using the canal have hcen paying nearly 2 million dollars a month in tolls. This is a gain of about two-thirds in a year. Oil tankers from

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A reader writes to correct a biographical column that omitted Seward's role in purchasing Alaska, comparing the ridiculed 'folly' to the earlier criticized Louisiana Purchase. The letter argues both purchases, though mocked at the time, proved to be among America's richest acquisitions.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 August 1923 · page 6

PEOPLE'S FORUM

To the Editor of The Age-Herald: Each morning I read “Mothers cf Famous Men” and “Poor Boys Who Became Fafhous." I enjoy both c lumns very much, but very often I find that the writers of these columns leave out very im portant historical facts. This morningunder the head of “Mothers of Famous Men” was an article in regard to the mother of William H. Seward, secretary of state under Abraham Linoln and Lincoln's right hand man. But this article failed to say anything about the Alaska purchase. Mr. Seward was the father of this deal and for years before he rose to the president’s cabinet he had been a champion of the purchase of Rus sian America.

See moreSee less

Like Jefferson, Monroe and Livingston, who were criticised severely for the pur chase in 1803 of Louisiana, known as the American Desert, also Se ward was severely criticised for his efforts to purchase the barren stretch of land known as Russian America. which today is known as Alaska, the richest American pos session. Seward's folly proved one of the wisest acts in our his tnrv There 1* a strange similarity in the purchases of Louisiana and Alaska. Jefferson, Monroe and Livingston did not believe that they had purchased an empire, but i their main object was to eliminate a foreign power from our door. Seward did not realize that he was purhasing an empire when he pur chased Alaska; his main object was the elimination of a dangerous foreign power from our doors. But instead both the Louisiana and Alaska purchases have proven to be America’s richest possessions, and eventually Alaska will bo thickly settled and will take its place with the other section of the country industrially, economi cally and politically. At present still little Is known of Alaska. Some writers and newspapers call it "America’s Wonderland,” also our late president’s visit to our Northern empire has revealed many valuable and almost un known things. But what a pity that today very few people ac tually know who was responsible for the United States of America possessing this invaluable terri tory.. Yours truly, T. C. McNEAL.

See the clipping

The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska

The Seattle Times criticizes the Boston Herald for repeating outdated 'Seward's Folly' and 'Seward's Icebox' characterizations of Alaska, calling it mischievous propaganda. It quotes the Herald's claims about Alaska's declining population and the costly, unprofitable federal railroad as examples of what it considers inaccurate reporting.

The Alaska Daily Empire · 11 August 1923 · page 4

Alaska’s Critics. ' (Seattle Times.) There are, apparently, a few newspapers in the country that still regard the phrases, "Seward’s Fol ly" and "Seward’s Icebox,” in use more than a half century ago, as descriptive of Alaska. Fortunately, they are not numerous, else there would be little progress in the republic, A fair sample of the miEchievotis propaganda dis seminated by the newspapers that adhere to the “Seward Folly" Idea of Alaska is found In the July lid issue of The Boston Herald. In a day when so much truthful information is available it is difficult to he patient with glaringly inaccurate statements.

See moreSee less

'1 he now. paper that deliberately ignores well substantiated fac^^nr trusts to a memory of Alaska a half century old, serves ils readers poorly. in discussing Alaska The Boston Herald says: We find a disposition on the part of para grapliers at the time of President Hardings visit to Alaska, to point to that acquisition as one of the triumphs of American policy. We wis!i we could share that view. * * * l P to date the situation is discouraging. The whole area, which wc were told in the geographies extends ns far west of San Fran cisco as we arc east of that city, contains only 60,000 Americans, and this number is decreasing at the rate of 10,000 a decade. Wo hear much about the railroad on which the President traveled. We ought to hear mucfi. The Federal Government has spent $200,000,000 on it. There are 3,000 miles of it, apporximately as much road us from here to San Francisco. Does it pay? Of course not. The losses which it incurs are prodigious. Congress did it at the bc iicrt of the Northwestern lawmakers, osten sibly to develop the Territory, but in reality to make business for Seattle, the long recognized ontreport of Alaska. The Seat tleans could not bear to ace Alaska go out of business, and eo they persuaded the Gov ernment to make this investment in order to keep Alaska moving. But. compared with this railroad, the new barge canal across New 1 ork State is a roaring success. It is doubtful is there is any transportation agency on earth in which the percentage of • revenue to the investment is so disparate as in the Alaska Railroad. The most striking thing about this acrimonious harangue is that tto material statement therein made Is true. I he Boston paper knows, or should know, that th Government did not spend $200,000,000 on the Alask Railroad. I p to date it has spent $56,000,000. The paper also knows, or should know, that th length et the railroad is not 3,000 miles, but approx! mutely 500 miles. v It was not built at the behest of Seattle for Seal ch benefit, although this city is rather proud c

See the clipping