As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

November 1920

4 articles

The Cordova Daily Times · Cordova, Alaska

An article citing historian Frank A. Holder in the American History Review discusses lingering mysteries about why Russia sold Alaska and why the U.S. bought it. It concludes Russia sold the territory because it had become valueless and burdensome, while Secretary Seward's own motives for pursuing the purchase remain unclear.

The Cordova Daily Times · 4 November 1920 · page 4

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 1920. OUR PURCHASE OF ALASKA Alter the lapse of more than half a century there is still not a little mystery surrounding the purchase of the territory of Alaska by the United States from Russia. In the current number of the American History Re view Mr. Frank A. Holder tells the story of the transaction, not hesi tating to disclose some discreditable conduct on the part of members of the American congress, and conclud ing that “Russia sold Alaska not out of enmity to England, not out of the friendship for the United States, but out of the desire to get j rid of a territory which had become valueless and burdensome."

See moreSee less

On the other hand, just why the United States bought Alaska is not quite so clear to Mr. Holder. It was not done, he thinks, with the object of catering to the Pacific coast states or of pleasing Russia. Mr. Holder maintains That in reality no one but Secretary Seward was deep ly interested in the purchase of Alaska and the question is, why was he eager to buy? Stoeckel, the Rus sian agent in the transaction, did not think that Seward's object was mere ly that of a far-sighted statesman who saw the political and economic importance of the territory. It seemed to Stoeckel that Seward was interested in the purchase because of hope that it would bring him once more into popular favor. Some of the correspondence of Stoeckel with his government thrpws

See the clipping

The Cordova Daily Times · Cordova, Alaska

An American History Review article by Frank A. Holder re-examines the 1867 Alaska purchase, arguing Russia sold the territory because it had become burdensome rather than from friendship with the U.S. The piece also suggests Secretary Seward alone truly championed the deal, possibly to regain political popularity, citing Russian diplomat Stoeckel's private correspondence.

The Cordova Daily Times · 4 November 1920 · page 4

OUR PURCHASE OF ALASKA

Russia. At one stage in the nego tiations for the sale in the spring of 1868 Stoeckel thought that the case was almost hopeless and asked j « for additional instructions from his j government. As far as he could see there were only two dignified courses to pursue: (1) To tell the United States that Russia had done her part, and that if the United States were unwilling to pay for Alaska, they could have it without paying; (2) To send a strong but a courteous note which would touch the American pride.

See moreSee less

The Russian minister of foreign affairs wrote a reply which was approved by the czar favoring the second of these courses but not the first for fear that the offer would be taken up! He $aid: “But you shoi^ld not say a word about the cession without compensation. I consider it impru dent to expose American cupidity to this temptation.”

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

The report describes a 1920 Soviet concession granting American oil magnates (Vanderlip, Doheny, Lane) rights to a vast Siberian territory, including fisheries, oil, and coal resources. It explicitly frames this development as likely to follow the earlier pattern established by Alaska's development, invoking the 1867 purchase as precedent.

The Milwaukee Leader · 22 November 1920 · page 12

Seattle. The development of this new empire is likely to follow that of Alaska. The main features of the Alaskan devel opment are: 4. The sealing industry on the Pribilof isNinepin Sociology bowlers who have been using the “unfit” as ninepins? The fact

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

This editorial discusses the controversial Vanderlip-Soviet lease deal for Siberian resources, drawing a parallel to the 1867 Alaska purchase. It notes that Czarist Russia sold Alaska partly out of fear that Britain might seize it, questioning whether Soviet Russia has similar fears about Japan today.

The Milwaukee Leader · 22 November 1920 · page 12

PRICE THREE CENTS. THE VANDERLIP EL DORADO Do you realize the big "world’problems” (both of labor and ot imperialism) that are opened up by this deal between the Vanderlip-Doheny-Lane outfit and the Russian Soviet government? It looks like the biggest El Dorado scheme of this century. An area larger than our three Pacific, coast states combined has been turned over, on a 60-year lease, to a syndicate of Pacific coast gentlemen. This area is shown on the adjoining map. It includes Kamchatka and the rest of Siberia east of the 160th parallel.

See moreSee less

The lease includes “rights to exploit coal, oil and fisheries,” Chicherin informs us. "The syndicate expects to take pos session and commence operations in the spring of 1921.” What does it all mean? Is Harding going to recognize Soviet Russia? He savs he never heard of Washington D. Vanderlip; that he knows nothing about the matter and has "no interest in it what ever.” Of course, that’s his business—to know nothing whatever about anything, especially plans being hatched around him. Is the history of Alaska (which was once Russian k e re P eate d in this territory (which we might call Amencan-Russia”) ? The old Czarist Russian govern ment, back in the 1860’s, had a hunch, you remember, that Great Britain might grab off "Russian America.” And so for a song they sold the whole territory to the United States government. Has the present Soviet Russian government a similar hunch today about Japan? With the present temper of imperialist Japan about “American spheres in the Pacific,” and with Mr. Harding promising to protect all American “citizens” on lawful mis sions ‘‘anywhere under the shining sun,” what effect is this deal likely to have on the imperial relations of the two countries ? So much for imperialism; now for labor. How about the “exploitation of natural resources” (which always boil down to "human resources”) ? Is the exploitation of this new “American Russia” to follow that of “Russian America” ? The American people had jn Alaska (and might have

See the clipping