As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

August 1916

3 articles

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

The report discusses ongoing negotiations for the U.S. to purchase the Danish West Indies, with commentators questioning the price and strategic value. It recalls the 1867 Alaska purchase for $7,200,000, noting it was once mocked as 'Seward's Folly' but ultimately proved enormously valuable.

The Barre Daily Times · 9 August 1916 · page 4

High Price for Islands. observe that editorial opinion throughout the country, concerning I n do Sam's prospective purchase of the the stated price. The negotiations have been carried on at a high rate ot speed, which leads some commentators to sus pect the presence of a "nigger in the woodpile." Others, while inclined to the opinion that we need the islands for na tional defense, hodl that we need ships guns, ammunition and men even more and that we might txtter put $20,000,- 000 into that form of defense than into the purchase of the three inlands in ques tion.

See moreSee less

Xearly all seem to think the L'nit ed States senate will be less easy to sat isfy than the Danish Parliament, in the matter of price. Ever since 167. when Secretary Se ward acquired for the I'nited States from Russia, the territory of Alaska for f7.2i0,OoO, this country has been looking for bargains whenever any real estate propositions rame it way. The finan cial alue of the IVnish AVest Indies, manifestly, is not to be compared with that of Alaska though our experience with Alaska make one hesitate to say even this, for $ 7.211 .W was regarded in manv quarters aa a tremendous price for Alaska, and the purchase, when it was finally made, was not uncommonly re ferred to as "s-eward's folly. Anyway, it is unhkelv that the islands wouid ever produoe anything Lke the wealth of gold. fish, furs and so on that Alaska has produced. When we consider $7. 2isi.sk as the price of Alaska, alongside of 2.i.(Vi.iHt i that of the Dam!) West Indies Well, it d-n't look like a real Yankee trade, now, doe it!

See the clipping

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Commentary on the proposed U.S. purchase of the Danish West Indies for $25,000,000 invokes the 1867 Alaska purchase as a historical comparison, noting that Alaska cost only $7,200,000 and was once mocked as 'Seward's folly.' The piece questions whether the new deal represents good value compared to the earlier, now-vindicated Alaska bargain.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 16 August 1916 · page 6

HIGH PRICE FOR ISLANDS.

Ever since 1867, when Secretary Seward acquired for the United States from Russia, the territory of Alaska for $7,200,000, this country has been looking for bargains whenever any real estate propositions came its way. The financial value of the Danish West Indias, manifestly, is not to be com pared with that of Alaska—through: our experience with Alaska makes one hesitate to say even this, for $7,200,- 000 was regarded in many quarters as a tremendous price for Alaska, and the purchase, when it was finally made, was not uncommonly referred to as “Seward’s folly.” Anyway, it is un likely that the islands would ever pro duce anything like the wealth of gold, fish, furs and so on that Alaska has produced.

See moreSee less

When we consider $7,200,- 000 as the price of Alaska, alongside of $25,000,000 as that of the Danish Went Indies—Well, it doesn't look like a real Yankee trade, now, does it? —_———————

See the clipping

News and Citizen · Morrisville, Vt.

The article recalls how critics derided Alaska as 'Seward's Folly' and claimed its only product was ice. It argues the purchase has been vindicated by valuable mineral, fur, and now coal exports benefiting Pacific Northwest consumers.

News and Citizen · 30 August 1916 · page 2

Appropiations of two billions is a pret ty fair record for a party which pledged itself to a policy of strict economy and which denounced all the evils of the land in the profligacy of the Republicans who had "wasted the substance of the peo ple." Seward's Folly Every time the United States has pre- ( posed to increase its territorial holdings loud objections have been made. Pro tests were made against the acquisition of Florida, of Texas, of Hawaii and of Alaska. It was charged that the chief product of Alaska was ice and the pur chase of this vast territory was de nounced as "Seward's Folly".

See moreSee less

But since this great tract of land was acquiied vast quantities of minerals, furs and so on have been sent from there to the United States and now the people of the northwest are rejoiced over the first train of coal out of Alaska. The supply of Coal there is practically inexhaustible and the coal fields are now being opened by gov ernment railroads. The result is that the cost of coal to the people of Oregon, Washington and California will be re duced. It will be hard to convince these people who are profiting by the foresight of Seward that his purchase of Alaska was folly.-'" ' ' A Farm Loan Frost

See the clipping