As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

August 1911

5 articles

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The Fall River Herald recalls how Secretary Seward was mocked for buying Alaska in 1867, but notes the nation now recognizes its mineral wealth. The piece pivots to current debates over development, monopoly control, and President Taft's stance on granting franchises to encourage investment.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 August 1911 · page 6

When the Cnited States first ac quired Alaska by purchase from Rus sia in 1867, Secretary Seward, who en gineered the deal with the Czar, was round!) condemned by the majoritv of] his countrymen for his alleged folly in throwing away $7.-00,ikHI on a barren, ice-locked, worthless territory. Be cause of this popular feeling, Aluska was long neglected and its rich miner als, not then known to exist, were left untouched. Today the nation knows the value of this possession in the [northwest, but its development is be ing retarded for fear that some single person or corporation is about to put a chain and padlock on it and rob the sovereign people.

See moreSee less

Every safeguard should be obser\ ed to prevent mono polistic control of the mineral deposits there, but at the same time private en terprise should not be entirely dis couraged If Alaska is to grow and de velop and contribute its share to the wealth of tlie nation. After disposing of the famous "Dick to Dick" letter as a base fabrication, which the majority of thinking people are now ready to admit it is. President Taft, in his spe cial message to Congress dealing with tlie Alaskan situation, applies the light of reason to the case when lie says: ■ Tlie tiling which the Territory of Al aska needs is development, and where rights and franchises,can be proiierly granted to encourage investment and construct a railroad without conferring exclusive privileges. I believe it to be In accordance with good policy to grant them.” This is the only sensible view Common sense should not be blinded b\ hysteria. If the country waits un til the last probe has been asked for and settled, until tlie last suspicious person lias been satislied before open ing any land there to entry, this gen eration and others after it will have passed away without enjoying anv of tlie benefits which are properly theirs. It would seent practical and possible to develop Alaska without turning it over to the special interests, and it ought to be done. President Taft fol lowed this line of reasoning in the so ealied Controller bay district, when he said, regarding elimination of land from tlie reserve there: “I preferred to mak” a much larger elimination of a tract facing the entire channel, and with sufficient room for a terminal rail way town. I was willing to do this because 1 found the restrictions in the law sufficient to prevent the possibility of any monopoly of either the upland or the harbor or channel by the Con troller Railway H Navigation Co or any other persons or company." And the President I* sincere when he says it.

See the clipping

Valdez Daily Prospector · Valdez, Alaska

This editorial rebuts Scripps-McRae newspapers' claims that conservationists like Pinchot and Garfield are hurting Alaskans by blocking Guggenheim access to coal lands. It argues that federal law clearly prohibits the methods the Guggenheims used to gain control of Alaskan coal, and that conservationists are simply ensuring the law is enforced to prevent a natural monopoly.

Valdez Daily Prospector · 14 August 1911 · page 2

TEARS, IDLE TEARS.

OPEN UP ALASKA. Everywhere in the Northwest, the slogan is hoard, "Open Up Alaska." In as far as metal mines arc concerned, this is being done continually abreast of addition of transportation facilities, whose betterment is being retarded by the failure of a ."paternal" gov ernment, lo understand that the theories of "new nationalism" whieh were borrowed from a dead feudal system and seem so popu lar about the comfortable lobbies of fashionable hostelries of the national eapitoi, do not solve the problems of stupid laws that, em barrass intelligent development of Alaska.

See moreSee less

Reports of newer discoveries in Alaska are continued again and again in the great gold, copper i and coal lields tributary to Seward and Valdez. and the quartz and placer zones farther north. De velopment of these resources is discouraged by many obsolete laws and sonic stupid new ones that make investments unsafe in Alaska. Cheaper coal is needed for power for mines, mills, the more economical operation of Alaskan railroads and cheaper power for steamships. The most that Alaska needs is lo lie belter understood by the great majority of people who cast the votes that made the laws thai laid down the "feudal" rules of load ion now in "force." In the interest of general pub licity for Alaska, a stall' corres pondent for Power, Mine and Fac tory, will visit cities of southern and northwestern Alaska (hiring the months of August and Sep tember, calling further attention of all chapters of the American Alining Congress and the nation al press lo the needs of the north. —Power, Mine and Factory.

See the clipping

The Evening Standard · Ogden City, Utah

Senator LaFollette argues for government ownership of Alaska's transportation and utilities, warning that Morgan-Guggenheim syndicate control would impose exorbitant charges on resource development. He compares the situation to the Pennsylvania anthracite coal monopoly and cites the Panama Canal as proof government control can succeed.

The Evening Standard · 21 August 1911 · page 1

ALASKAN

;;r people were waging a losing light "against the corporations in Alaska. 1 Between tho great storehouse of natural resources and those who are i trying to develop It, he said, was to , fbe found "the enormous power of the greatest concentration of capital that the world has ever known. 5 : Mr. LaFollette found a parallel to 4, the present situation In Alaska in ;i the struggle In the anthracite coal i' : fields of Pennsylvania a quarter of

See the clipping

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

Senator La Follette criticizes the Morgan-Guggenheim syndicate's bid to control Alaska's resources, drawing parallels to the earlier anthracite coal monopoly. He argues the federal government should manage Alaska's transportation and resources for the public good, citing the Panama Canal Zone as a model.

Bisbee Daily Review · 22 August 1911 · page 1

itl mitlot tn tl.oso tt.nrVofo " Justifying his contention that tho government should engage In trans - Donation in Alaska, and the conserva - tiou of its resources, Mr. La Follette

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Representative William Sulzer outlined a plan to divide Alaska into three territories: Sumner, Seward, and Alaska, named to honor Senator Sumner and Secretary Seward for their roles in the 1867 purchase. Many Alaskans reportedly supported the plan following a related address by Secretary of the Interior Fisher.

Evening Star · 26 August 1911 · page 1

SULZER OUTLINES PLAN FOR DIVIDING ALASKA

Territory of Seward. "I would make southwestern Alaska, comprising all the district south of Yukon and west of the international boundary, another territory, and I would call it Seward in honor of the Secretary of State who initiated the purchase. Its capital would be the city of Seward, and within the lives of those before me tonight it will become as rich and as prosperous a country as Norway and Sweden com bined. "I would make all the district north of the Yukon to the frozen Arctic another territory,' and I would call it Alaska, be cause it will be always cold and sparsely settled, and its name would harmonize with the general conception of Alaska in the minds of most persons."

See the clipping