As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

January 1910

3 articles

The Daily Alaskan · Skagway, Alaska

The report criticizes President Taft's proposal to create an expensive governing commission for Alaska, arguing it would cost $46,000 annually versus a cheaper legislative alternative and insults self-governing Alaskans. It cites Alaska's vast economic contributions since the 1867 purchase, including $300 million in gold, fish, and furs, as proof the territory deserves self-rule rather than appointed oversight.

The Daily Alaskan · 5 January 1910 · page 2

ADDS INSULT TO INJURY. t There Is Just one thing more for President Taft to do in order to ?till further outrage the American principles and patriotism of the citi aens of Alaska and add insult to in jury, and that is to appoint either ex Oovernor Hoggatt or Lewis P. Shack leford a member of his pet com mission for making laws for this ter ritory, says the1 Cordova North Star. His commission will cost Alaska more than 146,000 per year. Accord ing to the press dispatches, four commissioners, to be appointed by himself , are to draw a salary or $7,500 per year.

See moreSee less

And for what? Just to sit in session sixty days each year with the governor and four elec tive representatives and pass laws which must afterwards be approved by* the governor and then by the pres ident. The elective representatives o the people, mind you, one to be cho sen from each Judicial district, are to receive pay only for the actual working time of the commission ? 60 days. They are to receive $23 per day. But the presidential appointees, on the other hand, are to sit around the rwt of the year, have their le gal residence In Alaska and spend the rest of the time outside, if they so desire, and draw salaries the en tire year. When the governor's salary is add td, $10,000 a year, a fraction over $-'5 per day for every day in the >e>ar including' Sundays, this proposed executive assembly means an annual expense of $46,000. This allows no thing for the traveling expenses of the elective representatives. The entire legislative session provided for by Delegate Wickersham in his bill for a 60 days" session every TWO YEARS would cost but little more than $12,000. What has Alaska done, we might ask, to merit such autocratic treat went at the hands of the executive head of one of the most intensely Republican forms of government? This territory has richly rewarded the government for every cent spent on public improvements, its cable ?ystem alone has realized it a pro fit of $530,000 in six years, after de ducting the cost of installation and maintenance. Alaska has been under the Stars and Stripes for over 40 years. Since the original purchase of $7,200,000 was made it has yielded approxi mately $300,000,000 in gold, fish, fur and other products. It has produc ed fully $150,000,000 in placer gold; its exports to the United States in 1908 were valued at $36,000,000 and its total trade with the states for that year amounted to $46,000,000. Alaska has been the only self-sup porting territory in the United States And yet President Taft tells the American citizens of the North land, the producers of all this an nual wealth and the ones who have made It a country for homes and educational and social ties, that they are not fit to govern themselves, that he will send a commission of his own choosing at a cost of $46,000 per year to show them how it is done. By virtue of his acts and proposed legislative commission, he repudiates the people's elected representative in Congress and giver, them four elective representatives and five ap pointive officials. The appointed officers, it will be ?een, outnumber the 'elective ones.

See the clipping

East St. Louis Daily Journal · East St. Louis, Ill.

The report notes that Alaska's estimated gold output this year totals $16,000,000. It states the territory continues to prove it was worth the $7,200,000 the United States paid for it.

East St. Louis Daily Journal · 11 January 1910 · page 4

The estimate of Alaska's gold out put this year puts the tdtal at $16,000, Ooo. The territory continues to fur nish proof that it is worth the $7,200,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A news commentary notes that the controversy over Alaska coal lands reveals the folly of those who once mocked the purchase of Alaska as 'Seward's Folly.' It observes that the so-called 'Arctic province' and 'iceberg' has proven to be a remarkably good investment.

New-York Tribune · 27 January 1910 · page 6

RE —_—— An interesting by-product of the con An interesting by-product of the con troversy over the Alaska coal lands is a troversy over the Alaska coal lands is a reflection upon the indiscretion of those reflection upon the indiscretion of those who too hastily denounced and ridiculed who too hastily denounced and ridiculed the purchase of that territory as “Sew the purchase of that territory as “Sew ard’s folly.” For an “Arctic province” ard’s folly.” For an “Arctic province” and an ‘iceberg’ Alaska has turned out and an ‘iceberg’ Alaska has turned out

See the clipping