As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

July 1907

19 articles

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J. · and 1 other paper

On the 40th anniversary of the Alaska treaty, the article recounts how Seward predicted Americans would not appreciate Alaska's value for a third of a century, and notes that his critics, who derided the purchase as 'Seward's Folly,' have since been proven wrong. It draws a parallel to premature political predictions about William Jennings Bryan's fading relevance.

Gloucester County Democrat · 4 July 1907 · page 2

and True—Nicholas and the Douma. a great work. Seward went to his grave hearing “roasts” on his Alaska policy—roasts that were simply false prophecies. He could do nothing to defend himself. At that time Alaska was an unknown quantity, an inchoate wilderness, as it still is to a large ex tent. The following from Leslie’s Weekly is quite apropos: June 20, 1907, the fortieth anniversary of the day on which the Alaska annexation treats' went into operation, is a date mark of great importance to the United States. When shortly before his death, in 1S72, William H.

See moreSee less

Seward was asked what he believed to be the greatest achievement of bis public career, he an swered, "The annexation of Alaska.” He added, however, “But the American peo ple will not grasp the value of that ac quisition for a third of a century yet.” This shows that Seward, the empire builder, was also a prophet. Seward has been dead for thirty-five years, and it is only in recent times that his countrymen have appreciated the importance cf Alas ka as a possession. Strong opposition was ottered in the house of representatives in 1867 to making the appropriation of $7, 200,000, the price which Seward paid to Russia for the province. Said one of an nexation's opponents in that chamber, “All that Alaska will ever be able to pro duce are polar bears and icebergs.” For several years a nickname for the region was "Seward's Folly.” But time has vin dicated Seward.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D. · 4 July 1907

Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · Cresco, Iowa

This piece, prompted by a Leslie's Weekly item on the 40th anniversary of the Alaska annexation treaty, recalls how Seward was mocked for the $7,200,000 purchase and quotes his 1872 prediction that Americans would need a third of a century to appreciate its value. It frames 'Seward's Folly' as a case of false political prophecy now vindicated by time.

Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · 5 July 1907 · page 2

Other Prophets, True and Falqe, Prophesying is easy and cheap to him who would deride a gre.it man or a great work. Seward went to his grave hearing "roasts" on his Alaska policy—roasts thai were simply false prophecies. He coyltl do nothing to defend himself. At Unit time Alaska was an unknown (juantity, an luchoate wilderness, as It still is^to a lurge ex tent. 'The following from Leslie's Weekly Is quite apropos June pi, 3007, the fortieth anniversary of tho lay oh wulcli the Ala»ka annexation treaty went Into operation [9: a data mark of pivat Importance to Jie United States.

See moreSee less

.When shortly before his death,. In 1872, William H." Sowftril was uslccd' What he foeli'cYed lo be thegreatest achievement of his public career, he an •w^reOt "The onewxiutoo «f. Alaska J.'., Be

See the clipping

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

This 1907 piece marks the fortieth anniversary of the Alaska annexation treaty, recalling how Seward was mocked with 'Seward's Folly' and his purchase ridiculed by critics in Congress who predicted only polar bears and icebergs. It notes that Seward predicted his countrymen would not appreciate Alaska's value for a third of a century, and argues history has now proven him right.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 6 July 1907 · page 10

and True Nkholai and the Douma. -: n grnt work. Seward went to his grave hearing "ronstV on his Alaska policy roasts that were simply fnlso prophecies. Ho could do nothing to defend himself. At thnt time Alaska win an unknown quantity, nn Inchoate wilderness, as It still Is to n large ex tent. Tho following from Leslie's Weekly Is quite apropos: June 10. 1M7, tho fortieth nnnUersnry of the day on which the Alaska annexation treaty went Into operation, Is a date mark of great Importance to the United States.

See moreSee less

When shortly before his deAth, In 1872. William II. Seward vvns asked what ho believed to be tho greatest achievement of his public carrer. ho an swered. "The annexation of Alaska " lie added, however, "Ilut the American peo ple will not grnsp the value of that ac quisition for a. third of a century yet." This shows that Seward, tho empire builder was also a prophet. Seward has been dad for thlrt-Iho ears. and It Is only In recent times that his countrjmen have appreciated the Importance of Alas ka as n possession Strong opposition was offcicd In tho house of representatives lu 18G7 to making the appropriation of 17. aw.OOO, the price which SowHrd paid lo Ilnssla for tho province Said one of an nexatlon's opponents in that chamber, "All that Alaska will ever be able to pro duce are polar bears and Icebergs." For several years a nickname for the region was "Seward's Folly." Uut lime has vin dicated Seward.

See the clipping

The Caucasian · Shreveport, La.

The piece marks the 40th anniversary of the Alaska annexation treaty, recalling that Seward considered it his greatest achievement despite being ridiculed as 'Seward's Folly' and facing opposition in Congress over the $7,200,000 price. It notes that Seward predicted Americans would not appreciate the purchase's value for a third of a century, a prophecy later proven true.

The Caucasian · 7 July 1907 · page 2

Tlhe Dingley Law and Tramps -Jap La bor in Texas - Political Prophets, False and True Nicholas and Ine Douma. -: a great work. Seward went to his grave hearing "roasts" on this Alaska policy--roasts that were simply false prophieles. 1le coitl do nothing to defi'eid himself. At that time Alaska (stas an unknown citiiitfly. an inchoite wilderness. as It still Is to a iarge ex tent. The following fronm Leslie's Weekly is ijilite did'ip 'ot: June :tI. 1107. the forth th anniversary of the day on which the Aaiskz antexation treuty went into optratioi.

See moreSee less

is a date mark of cr.tt hOportance to thr f'nitetl States. When shortly before his death. In 1572. Williant It. Seward was iaked what hi believed to hie the grea tiit achievement of his public career. he an swered. "The annexation of Alaska.' lie added. however. "lttt the American pee pie will not grasp the value of that ne quisition for a third of a century yet. This shows that Seward. the empire builder. was also a prophet. Seward has been dead for thirty-five years. and it Is only in recent timos that his countrymen have appreciated the importance of Alas ka an a possession. Strong opposition was offered in the house of representatives in 1567 to making the appropriation of $7. 2110,000. the price which Seward pall fo Russia for the province. Said one of an nexation's opponents in that chamber. "All that Alaska will ever he able to pro duce are polar bears and icebergs." For several years a nickname for the r'tlon was "Seward's Folly." But time has vin dicated Seward.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Decades after the Alaska purchase, three different flags are each claimed by their owners to be the original U.S. flag raised during the 1867 transfer ceremony. The article recounts the story of Edward Leudecke of Wrangell, who reportedly hoisted the American flag there when purchase troops passed through en route to Sitka, as organizers seek the authentic flag for the 1909 Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition.

Arizona Republican · 14 July 1907 · page 10

IOne flag, the property or Leudecke of Wiangell, has a strong claim to he j ing the original. It now reposes in the vaults or tne i-x(er-iiorion hank in Seattle. The story Is that e body of American troops that left San Fran cisco in the autumn of lStiT for Sitka to take possession of the country pro ceeded by the Inside channel and" touched first at Wrengell. At that point there were living a few Americans engage in pioneer week. One of these was Edward Leu decke. who, after forty years is still a resident of Wrengell.

See moreSee less

Leudecke, when the troops touched at that point, heard for the first time of the Ameri can purchase. Although the country was not then formally taken over by the United States he ran to the flag pole and hoisted the American flag, anil there it flew for many months. In the meantime the troops proceeded to Sitka, then the capital, and on Oc

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The article, written decades after the 1867 Alaska purchase, recounts stories of various American flags associated with the transfer ceremony, including one raised by Leudecke in Wrangell and others documented through government records. It discusses the provenance of these flags as potential candidates for display at an exposition, noting the famous flag-raising at Sitka on October 18, 1867.

Arizona Republican · 14 July 1907 · page 10

Nebraska to the Union was announced and theflag with thirty-six stars was j'Ulle.l down and another one with thirty-seven stars, was raised in its place. Lrt-udecke. however, clung care fully to his flag and in lirt". turned the banner over to ;. K. Rodman, an at torney of Wrangell. who sent it on to its present destination for safe keep ing. Ieudecke Is now seventy-two years of age and is strong and hearty. " He remembers perfectly the first arrival of Anieriian troops in the north and the amazement and joy of the few Americans there on being told that Alaska had been purchased from the Russians.

See moreSee less

Of course, this flag of I.eudecke's cannot -be the official one as it was flown at Wrangell. Nevertheless, it would seem as if it has a strong claim to be the first American flag over flown in the Northland. Another fl.-ijj is told about by Major A. N. Rrown, private secretary to Governor Albert K. M.-e. of the state or Washington. Mr. Brown in this connection writes as follows the story of this flag: "In making some researches among the government documetts and reports on the acquisition of Alaska, I have found thatwhen Secretary Seward General Rousseau as Ited States Commissioner to Sitka receive the territory of Alaska from

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This article recounts historical trivia about how various U.S. states and territories received their names, including proposed alternatives rejected by Congress. It notes that after the Alaska purchase, names like Walrussia, American Siberia, and Polario were considered before Charles Sumner's suggestion of "Alaska," said to mean "The Great Land" in the language of Indians who gave the name to Captain Cook.

Evening Star · 14 July 1907 · page 37

American Siberia, Zero Islands, and Polario. The name now used was proposed by Charles Sumner, who stated it to be that bestowed bv the Indians that it signified "The Great Land.'* Objections to Walrussia yjTT'ALRUSSIA was rejected on account of the disinclination among our people to adopt any name recalling a despotic Empire, although a hint was given at the time that this name was intended to commemorate, not the Russian Empire, but the walrus, then abundant on the shores of Bering Sea. Siberia was instantlv vetoed, from the fact that it was best known in this country as a place of exile, horrible pictures being drawn of the sufferings en dured by political prisoners m the Siberian mines.

See moreSee less

Zero Islands and Polario were deemed unfit; as <>ne member of Congress intimated. "The territory is probably worthless: but no one knows what it may be in the future, and there is no use in saddling it with a title in itself offensive and repellent." The original name of Arizona was Arizuma, a

See the clipping

The San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A Seattle report describes efforts by the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific exposition to locate the first American flag raised over Sitka in 1867, questioning where it now rests and how it was preserved. It recounts the dramatic transfer ceremony, including the Russian flag being torn as it was lowered and a weeping Russian princess lamenting the sale.

The San Antonio Light · 14 July 1907 · page 20

FIRST U.S. FLAG WHICH FLOATED OVER ALASKA

Hunter. Sherman Democrat. Special to The Light. Baxter." Seattle, Wash., July 13.—In what place is the American banner that first fluttered over Alaska now rest ing? In what manner has the flag been preserved to the present time? And finally, what is the real story of that stirring October day art Sitka when the American warship arrived to take possession of the country, and when the Russian flag was rent in two pieces as they pulled it down from the flag pole for the last time in the western hemisphere, while the beau tiful Russian Princess Maksoatoff wept at the shortsightedness of her country at selling a land with so much potential greatness.

See moreSee less

A few months ago the management issue. of the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific exposition started to solve these questions, espe cially the first one, as to the where abouts of the flag. The result was curious, and indeed reminds so forci bly of a famous incident of the eighteenth century, that perhaps the Story may be told. John Baxter, in his day a famous livine, died with so many pious ex pressions of hope and belief, that his jelrs determined to issue the story. The book, "The Last Words of RichJrd Baxter,” was issued, and was an inmediate success. Money rolled in. The heirs became greedy, and hoping b duplicate the success issued another

See the clipping

The San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

This 1907 article examines three flags, each claimed by its owner to be the original raised during the 1867 Alaska transfer. It recounts Edward Leudecke's story of hoisting the American flag at Wrangell before the official ceremony at Sitka, and notes the flag was later replaced when a new star was added for Nebraska's statehood.

The San Antonio Light · 14 July 1907 · page 20

1867 for Sitka to take possession of the country proceeded by the inside channel and touched first at Wrangell. At that point there were living a few Americans engaged in pioneer work. One of these was Edward ecke who after forty years is still a resident of Wrangell. Leudecke. when the troops touched at that point, heard for the first time of the American purchase. Although the country was not then formally taken over by the United States be ran to the flagpole and hoisted the American flag, and there it flew for many months. In the meantime the troops proceeded to Sitka, then the capital, and on Oc tober 18. 1867. the Russian flag was

See the clipping

Douglas Island News · Douglas City, Alaska

Forty years after the 1867 transfer, three different flags are each claimed by their owners to be the original American flag raised in Alaska. The article recounts the story behind one flag kept by Edward Leudecke of Wrangell, who raised a flag there upon hearing of the purchase, distinct from the official flag raised at Sitka, and introduces a second claim involving General Rousseau's flag.

Douglas Island News · 17 July 1907 · page 4

San Francisco in the autumn of 1807 for Sitka to take possession of thecoun- ! try proceeded by the inside channel . and touched first at Wrangell. At that point there were living a few Americans engaged in pioneer work. One of these was Edward Leudecke who after forty years is still a resident of Wrangell. Leudecke, when the troops touchcd at that point, heard for the first time of the American pur chase. Although the country was not theu formally taken over by the United States, he ran to the flagpole and hoist ed the Americau flag, and there it flew for many months. In the meantime the troops proceeded to Sitka, then the cap

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition inquiry tries to trace the actual American flag raised at Sitka in 1867, prompting a flood of rival claims as many owners insist their old flag is the 'real' one. The writer compares this to a historical hoax, noting the many inconsistent and self-interested stories now circulating about the flag's fate.

Evening Star · 20 July 1907 · page 23

In what manner has the flag been pre, I'-rvi! to the present time? And finally 1 what is the real story of that stirring . October t\Ay at Sitka when the Am.Ticar warship arrived to take possession of the country, and when the Russian flag was i rent In two pieces as they pulled It dowr J from the flag pole for the last time in th< f western hemisphere, while the beautifu i Russian Princess Makso&tofF wept at th> shortsightedness of her country at selling

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An exposition planning committee investigates competing claims to the original 36-star flag raised at Sitka during the 1867 transfer of Alaska, finding three candidate flags held in different parts of the US. One claimant, owned by Edward Leudecke of Wrangell and kept in a Seattle bank vault, is tied to a story about American troops passing through Wrangell en route to Sitka.

Evening Star · 20 July 1907 · page 23

WHERE IS THE FIRST FLAG

obtained by the exposition to be used at ? } the opening ceremonies. It Is the plan of I the management that when on June 1, 1900 - t' gates of the exposition swing open to ) the world the banner on the topmost ' pinnacle of the ten-million eKfcosltlon of e Alaska. Yukon and the Pacific countries c will be the same one that waved farewell tc the Russians two generations ago. K The writer, while In Grand Pre in the Acadian valley, some yearB ago. was shown s. n.r.e different sites where once stood the

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article recounts how a man named Leudecke raised an American flag at Wrangell upon hearing of the Alaska purchase, before the official transfer ceremony at Sitka on October 18, 1867. It notes the flag was later replaced with a 37-star version and eventually donated for preservation, while acknowledging it was not the official transfer flag.

Evening Star · 20 July 1907 · page 23

I?eudecke is now seventy-two years of age and la strong and hearty. He remembers perfectly the first arrival of American troops In the north and the amazement and joy of the few Americans there on being told that Alaska had been purchased from the Russians. Of course, this flag of Leudecke's cannot be the offlclST one as It was flown at Wrangell. Nevertheless, it would seem as If it has a strong claim to be the first American flag ever flown in the northland. Another flag Is told about by Maj. A. N. Brown, private secretary to Gov. Albert E. Mead of the state of Washington. Mr.

See the clipping

Daily Press · Newport News, Va.

This 1907 article recounts various proposed and rejected names for American states and territories, including Acadia for Louisiana and Deseret for Utah. It details how Alaska was nearly named Walrussia, American Siberia, Zero Islands, or Polario before Charles Sumner's suggested name, said to be an Indian term meaning 'The Great Land,' was adopted.

Daily Press · 21 July 1907 · page 10

through Andalusia south of (Iranada. After the purchase of Alaska, sever-j al names were suggested for the new possession, among them WnlriiSHlii. 'American Siberia. Zero Islands, and Polarlo, The name now used was proposed by Charles Sunnier, who stated It to be that bestowed by the Indians themselves ami given to Cap lain Cool; with tlm Information that It signified '.'Tho Croat Land." Objections to Walrussia. Walrussia was rejected on account of the disinclination among our pen

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The report describes competing claims by various individuals to have been first to plant the American flag on Alaskan soil after the 1867 purchase. It states that Joseph Keefer, who accompanied Captain Ketchum as part of the 'Secretary Seward Alaskan Expedition,' holds the only officially recognized claim, having helped raise the flag over the state house in Sitka.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Times · 24 July 1907 · page 12

FIRST FLAG UNFURLED IN ALASKA TERRITORY

in eompany with Captain Ketchum, was Seputized by the State Department in to officially take possission of the newly acquired territory. This they did by unfurling the American flag from the dome of the state house at Sitka. The party, known as the Secretary Seward Alaskan Ex ition, consisted of thirty members, although but three, Captain Ketchum, Mr. Keefer, and aa aide-de-camp were authorized by the Government.

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

A 1907 newspaper article, prompted by interest in the upcoming Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition, retells an old sailor's secret history claiming the 1867 Alaska purchase was partly payment for Russia secretly lending warships and sailors to the Union during the Civil War. The story, sourced from the Portland Oregonian, presents itself explicitly as 'alleged' unwritten history.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Gloucester County Democrat · 25 July 1907 · page 6

WHAT RUSSIA DID FOR US. An Alleged Authentic Bit of Unwritten History. interest in the Alaska-i'ukou-Paeifie exposition, which will be held at Seat tle in 1909 to exploit the territory, has brought to light an old bit of secret history of the times of the civil war. It now appears from the story of an old sailor who fought under Admiral Farragut that the purchase of Alaska from Russian in 1SC7 for $7,200,000 by William H. Seward, secretary of state, was not only made to please Russia and to express the thanks of the Unit ed States for Russia's friendship for the north by taking from the czar at a high figure what he thought was a bit of useless property, but was also part of a deeply laid bit of the diplo macy of those stirring times.

See moreSee less

In fact, it would look now as if the purchase of Alaska were a portion of the price that the United States paid Russia for keep ing 150,000 men at Cronstadt during the latter years of the war in order to have them available for America’s use and for embarkation on active service as an ally of the north did Great Brit ain openly espouse the cause of the Confederacy. And another portion of the service rendered by Russia for the Alaskan purchase price was the lending of 500 of her best sailors for service in the American fleet, with Russian officers to translate the orders of the Ameri can commanders. These men, accord ing to the story of the old sailor, fought for some months under Farra gut, made a brilliant showing and final ly were shipped back to their native shore In the same surreptitious manner that marked their arrival. The story is given In the Portland Oregonian of Jan. 13 last. The writer, Gabriel Justus Dahlgren, relates that he got the story from a resident of Salem, Ore., one Thomas Thompson, a well known sailor of that place. If the spare hours during March were properly employed, some of the farm vehicles and machinery were given a coat of paint. It Is more often lack of paint than wear that causes the wood en portions of vehicles and machinery Gas Water Heaters n

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

The item notes that Jack London, Rex Beach, Warren Chaney and others have turned Alaska's history into profitable literary material, an outcome Secretary Seward never anticipated when urging the purchase. It highlights Chaney's novels on Baranoff and the Russian occupation as blending literary quality with historical truth.

East Oregonian : E.O · 25 July 1907 · page 4

THE DAYS OK BARANOFF. Jack London, Rex Beach, Bailey Millard and other writers have found In Alaska a mine as rich as any that underlies the tundra at Nome. The literary output of the past few years, of which Alaska has been the theme, Is an asset that Secretary Seward reckoned not with when he recom mended the purchase of the territory from the Russians. Mrs. Atherton went to Sitka not long ago In order to find lflaterlal for a novel relating to the Russian occu pation of Alaska and the Pacific coast, but another writer, Just as re sourceful, had been there before her, and his books bear promise of main taining a sure standard of fiction re lating to Baranoff and his times.

See moreSee less

In the "Challenge," and In "The Way of the North." Warren Chaney, California poet, editor and man of affairs, struck an extremely high aver age of literary quality, combined with historic truth. The books have at tracted many readers, nnd his pub lishers have requested another volume on the same general theme. Sunset.

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

The item recounts that shortly before his death in 1872, William H. Seward was asked what he considered the greatest achievement of his public career. He answered that it was the annexation (of Alaska), though the text is cut off before completing the quote.

The Mitchell Capital · 26 July 1907 · page 12

Seward's Prophecy Realized. When, shortly before his death In 1872, William II. Seward was asked •what he believed to be the greatest achievement of his public career, he an swered, "The annexation of Alaska." He added, however, "But the American people will not grasp the value of that acquisition for a third of a century yet." This shows that Seward, the em pire builder, was also a prophet. Sew ard has been dead for thirty-five years, and It is only in recent times that his countrymen have appreciated the im portance of Alaska as a possession.

See moreSee less

Strong .opposition was offered in the house of representatives in 18G7 to making the appropriation of $7,200,000, the price which Seward paid to Russia for the province. Said one of annexa tion's opponents it, that chamber, "All that Alaska will ever he able to pro duce are polar bears and icebergs." For several years a nickname for the region was "Seward's Folly." lint time has fully vindicated Seward.—Leslie's Weekly.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article describes how Alaska, once mocked as 'Seward's Icebox,' has become a national treasure house, adding $600,000,000 to national wealth through gold, furs, and fisheries. It details growing investment in copper mining, railroads, and other resources by major interests like Guggenheim and Morgan.

Evening Star · 27 July 1907 · page 26

"SEWARD'S ICEBOX" ALASKA BECOMING A NATIONAL TREASURE HOUSE.

petroleum and timber lands, practically unexploited, still await capital and better transportation facilities before they can begin to supply us and other nations with heat, light and building material. Copper mining in Alaska has just begun. Men competent to judge claim that Alaska is destined to control the copper markets <>t . the wcrld. The Gugg-nheim interests hav ,? recently paid J5.000.000 for a single i A la ska. mine In southern Alaska. Seeing the im- | portance and need of transportation facili- (

See the clipping