As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

February 1904

3 articles

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The article recounts that Russian warships anchored in New York during the Civil War to deter France and England from aiding the Confederacy, implying a secret alliance with the Union. It then claims Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska for $7,200,000 was actually a covert repayment to Russia for this support, a motive it insists is historically undisputed even though never officially admitted.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 February 1904 · page 14

the isolated government fell. - l^ese facts have never been dis puted, nor can the second chapter of the story be successfully questioned. When the civil war was ended Russia needed money—she always does—and she asked reimbursement. Secretary Seward gave her $7,200,000, taking over as an excuse for the payment of the sum Alaska, then considered worthless, absolutely worthless. Like Thomas Jefferson in the Louisiana purchase, Mr. Seward bought better than he knew, but when the purchase was made Alaska was considered an incumbrance rather than a valuable asset. The purchase of Alaska squared the account; the Confederacy had been outwtted by its wiley adversary, and a big sum was thrown into the hol low Russian treasury.

See moreSee less

All this Is real ly history, although the motive of the Alaska business has never been ad mitted, and probably never will be. That motive is not, however, doubted or denied by those who have studied the subject. Insuring Women’s Lives. The Montreal Chronicle discusses at length the insuring of women's lives. In former days few women were insured. Few desired to be insured. In those days women were not wage earners. They were not self-support ing, and they had none of the respon sibilities of the breadwinner in the family. This condition is greatly changed today, and all towns are full of women workers, and the spirit of the new movement extends to the re motest hamlets. An ambition to be in dependent and self-supporting, and to enjoy some at least of the fine things of this life induces a host of women to seek employment, or to enter into business avocations, and this tendency will be Increased in the future rather than decreased. Insurance companies see the situa tion, and they are preparing to con form to it. They see that there will soon be many applications from wo men for policies, and that rates will have to be extended to young women employed in gainful occupations. Such risks are not quite so desirable as risks upon men’s lives, but the differ ence is not great enough to justify a company In demanding extra pre miums from young women. The writer in the Montreal Chroni cle advises young women to put their surplus earnings in savings banks, but if sufficient self-restraint be lacking, then he advisc3 a resort to the endow ment policies running through a term of years. When the policy matures a change to an annuity plan could read ily oe negotiated, anu this, says the Chronicle writer, would be better suit ed to the average woman than a straight life policy. The subject is receiving no little at tention among actuaries, and no doubt it will soon be worked out on a satis factory basis. All that can be said now Is taat many women will soon want life insurance in some form, whereas In the days before the war they never thought of such a thing. ' Low Estate of the Stage. William Winter of the New York Tribune has a wonderful command of invective, and he does not hesitate to pour it out against the stage as it ex ists at present. In a recent article he said in conclusion: There has not been a time In fifty years when the theatre was at so low a level as it has reached today—when the Impulse is vanity, the motive Is greed, the method Is sordid engrossment, the aim Is exclusive ly "business.” and the result Is a barren traffic and an arid waste. Voices, In deed. are faintly cryingf In the wilderness to signify that somebody beneath theun derbrush wants to “elevate the drama;” but these. In every case, art found to be the voices of visionary zanies, like the sentimental W. B. Yeats, whose actual purpose Is only to elevate themselves. Some do not agree with Mr. Winter when he talks about the "veterans who totter and mumble;” "the supers of yesterday who are stars of today;” "the three-cornered girls who rasp the welkin with voices that rival the screech of the peacock,” or the dram atists “who manifest the brain of the rabbit and the dignity of the wet hen.” But however much Mr. Winter exag gerates the situation in the fluency of his rhetoric, yet it is conceded by all intelligent observers that his criti cisms rest largely on the truth. Tho stage is simply in a deplorable condi tion. And yet neither actors nor managers are lo be chiefly blamed. The demand «■ is for something showy, novel and trivial. The supply simply compiles with the demand. It Is the old law of trade applied to art, and the old law is as effective in the one instance as in the other. What the patrons of the theatre want Ujey are sure to get, and the blame should not be laid at the doors of actors and managers. It rests where it belongs, upon the man who buys tickets at he box office. 'Until the play-goer asks for some thing better than the froth and foam which crowd the modern stage, we will get nothing that calls for imlglna tlon, or thought, or study of character, or anything else that is uplifting and inspiring. The flutter of the plays that the public affects at present are indictlve of the social condition of the people—a condition that calls for yel low Journalism, historical novels and ragtime music. The stage cannot be changed by even Mr. Winter’s raillery, effective and telling though it be, and largely truthful, but it must wait upon the intellectual and social conditions of the American people, and when these are changed we will have a bet ter stage. In the meanwhile we must accept .the frivolous, or else go stage hungry, and it is difficult to say which is the better choice. When Uncle Sam’s cruiser arrives at Santo Domingo to reinforce the gun boat Yankee the Dominicans may not think the shooting game is so funny after all. Senator Platt has transferred the Amen corner to the Waldorf Astoria, but the corner is no longer itself, and Governor Odell presides in the old place. A man went to a show in Connecti cut the other day and yawned so hard that he dislocated his jaw. The show must have been highly soporific. Just as Baltimore got the center of the stage, says the Baltimore News, little Japan had to sneak to the foot lights and fire o(T a hoss pistol. The cry will never be "On to Peters burg” until things change a bit. What was impossible for Napoleon will be impossible for lesser generals. Shanghai will now try to outshine Mole St. Nicholas. It will probably be able to give it twenty In the score and then discount It. Formal declarations of war are not needed after the trigger gets In its ! work. The latter is more significant than mere words. Mr. Bryan has ofTered $100 for a new democratic platform, and the wise poli ticians ought to wake up and make some money. The government is thinking of send ing out an exploring expedition to dis cover what has become of the Panama canal treaty. A torpedo boat Is sometimes an over-match for a battleship. It is the man behind the gun after all that does the work. Miss Morgan’s little bull terrier is about six inches high and cost the neat sum of $1000. Ho Is small in nothing but size. The mission of the modern woman is to see how many trunks of clothes she can carry along when she travels. While the czar appeals to the God of Battles, the Japanese get out their torpedo boats and begin the shooting. Philander Knox displays fine ring generalship In fighting the trusts all the time and never landing a blow. Brooklyn will have a little Wall street of Its own, and the iambs will be plentiful enough to go arounu. In order to show how progressive it can be a New York daily now pub lishes "Japanese literary notes.” Some millionaires don't mind water ing their stocks, but they strongly ob ject to watering their drinks. The czar says the Japs were inso lent. From the looks of things they went further than insolence. Appedicitis has been made still more vulgar by the discovery that It is due to a germ and Is contagious. John W. Gates is wielding the flail on unwary speculators for the benefit of the Rockefeller combine. The fireproof safety vaults In Balti more stood the test nobly. They came out of It fully vindicated. “Rooseveltophobia” Is quite preva lent now along Wall street, according to the latest reports. Mr. Schwab hopes to find that rest in Europe wyhich is denied him on this side of the water. Selma does not take any stock in the masculine women or In chorus girls who ride astride. America is trying to claim the credit of having made Admiral Uriu of the Japanese navy. There is a town in Alabama called Dime, and therefore it cannot look like thirty cents. The Balkans are determined that Russia and Japan shall not monopolize the stage. Russia stands badly in need of some non-sinkable ship preservers. Japanese and Russian literature is very much In demand. The European concert has ceased to be a concert.

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The article recounts financier Henry Clews's claim that Seward invited a Russian fleet to New York during the Civil War to deter British and French recognition of the Confederacy, and that the Alaska purchase was partly meant to repay Russia for this service. Clews says Grand Duke Alexis confirmed the story in 1871, though the writer notes Alaska also proved a sound purchase on its own merits.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 24 days later.

Wrong

The Savannah Morning News · 21 February 1904 · page 4

Its departure, Mr. Seward being satis fied that ha had accomplished hls purpose. If this Is the true story of the visit of the Russian fleet to New York dur ing the Civil War It shows that Mr. Seward was a very shrewd roan. That It is the true one, Mr. Clews asserts most positively. He says he not only had it from Mr. Seward, but that it was verified by Duke Alexis In IsTl, ma’ams? In times past they were* abundant. For every vacancy there were several applicants. Are there fewer educated and trained women now than heretofore?

See moreSee less

That sugges tion is not reasonable, with colleges all over the country opening their door? to women. Asa matter of fact, there are more institutions of higher learning open to women than to men. A considerable majority of the so called men’s colleges admit women stu dents, while the women have a large number of ’'female colleges” devoted to thir education exclusively, and into which no male student dare poke his nose. There can, therefore, be no shortage of educated women, since all of these advanced schools are full season after season. In all probability women do not make teaching a life work now in nnmbers as large as formerly because there are so many more avenues of employment open to them. In which they can make better salaries. Not only the professions but the highly skilled trades are being invaded by women. And then again, possibly, schoolma'ams are more sought in mat rimony these days. There was a time when "schoolma’am” was regarded as being practically synonymous with "old maid.” That Is not so any longer. Men have learned better how to ap preciate the teachers. They have dis covered that these trained, educated, patient, refined women make highly desirable life companions. The teach er must necessarily be a student of human nature, of domestic affairs and of literature, and thus her mind Is broadened and deepened by her occu pation. When she becomes a wife she takes into the household and makes practical use of the knowledge she has acquired In the school room and at the normal lectures. It is a pleasure to note that the schoolm&'am is having her innings, even at the expense of a shortage of her in parts of the coun try.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A writer recalls 1867 conversations with Seward and the Russian minister, suggesting the Alaska purchase was a gesture of gratitude for Russia's friendly stance toward the Union during the Civil War. He implies Congress saw little real value in the territory itself, citing an 1861 letter from Charles Francis Adams about Russian diplomatic support against British and French sympathy for the Confederacy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 31 days earlier.

Wrong

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 28 February 1904 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

United

standing with the Russian government implying much more than could be inferred from a simple display of the flag of the czar in the harbor of New York. This impression was confirmed by observations made in Washington shortly after my return from France in 1867, at which time I had frequent interviews with Mr. Seward and several times met at his house Mr. Bodisco, the Russian minister at Washington.

See moreSee less

"The purchase of Alaska from Russia had then just been consummated. Of course neither Mr. Seward nor Mr. Bodisco said distinctly to me that that purchase was made as a gracious recognition on the part of the United States of the czar's attitude toward us in 1862, but I doubt if there was any member of either house of congress who supposed that our government had any other motive for the purchase of that as territory of Alaska had any substantial value except as ridding us of an alient neighbor.

"A single paragraph from a letter written by Charles Francis Adams, the American ambassador to London, to Mr. Seward as early as November, 1861, and immediately after a conference with Earl Russell, minister of foreign affairs of England, helps to justify the interpretation I have put on Mr. Seward's letter to me, if it needs any justification. Mr. Adams wrote:

" 'I ought to add that in going into the ante-room, previous to the conference, I met there Baron Brunnow, the Russian ambassador, who siezed the occasion to express his great regret as the misunderstanding which is taking place, and his earnest offer of any services on the part of himself or his government that might have the effect to restore friendly relations between the two countries.' "

"Parenthetically it may be explained that at his early date both France and England gave signs of friendliness towards the confederacy, which led to some ill-feeling toward these two countries and the United States.

"These words from an ambassador under any circumstances," continued Dr. Bigelow, "could hardly be regarded as a commonplace assurance, but illumined by the light of what followed, leaves no doubt in my mind that they were the shadows of coming events."

"Do you think that the ships sent to the United States by Russia were intended, in case of necessity, to be used for the assistance of the United States?"

"I think they may have been intended to give notice to the world, and especially to France and England, that the czar was not to be an indifferent spectator of this attempt to break up our union, for in the first place he sent no ship of war into southern waters, and when J. Q. C. La Mar was sent abroad by Jefferson Davis with a commission as minister plenipotentiary to the Russian government, he received notice before entering Russia that he would not be received."

See the clipping