then separating from him, and not knowing who is Pope and thus acci dentally adhering to the wrong one. Accidental schism is deplorable, but it doesn ot carry the guilt of schism. When there have been two claimants of the Papal See, one of them has al ways been the right one, even if at the time it was hard to decide between them. It is well to look Into the mat ter, for the life of a body is shown by its successful struggle against disease as well as by its vigor in time of health.
See moreSee less
The Western schism is of special im portance, because there is no doubt that the unsettling it caused through out Europe directly paved the way for the great rebellions of Huss, Luther, Calvin and Henry VIII. It is instruc tive to note that it came about itself as a consequence and a punishment, of the Popes' long absence from their diocese in Avignon. The whole diffi culty arose from the condition that the conclave must be free from exterior pressure. Now after the Pope's re turn from Avignon, the Roman popu lace were exceedingly anxious for an Italian to be elected, lest the Avignon experiment should be repeated. Doubt less, also, they made their anxiety known. The historical question to be decided, therefore, is whether this cry of the people on the death of Gregory XI. amounted to such pressure on the Cardinals that they were terrorized. If so, the election was invalid if not, not. It is now more usually considered that the Cardinals who on this pretense proceeded to a new election, put them selves out of court by making no pro test for six months. If pressure in validated the election, the protest should have been made immediately the pressure was removed. Still, at the time the matter was doubtful enough and we can quite understand how St. Vincent Ferrer might be on one side and St Catherine of Siena on the other, without any derogation to tlieir sanctity. The real interest in the question lies in the manner in which the breach was healed. After thirty years of the two rival lines, the Cardinals of both obe diences (as they were called) united in summoning a council at Pisa. Both the claimants promised to resign in favor of the one who should be chosen by this council. Consequently Alex ander was elected, it was an unfortu nate choice, for both went back on their promises, apparently on personal grounds. Here then was a difficulty— the attempt at union resulted in three claimants Instead of two! Still, it was an honest attempt and actually be came the right way out of the diffi culty. It was a case of things having to get worse before they can be bet ter. Alexander's successor, John, called the council at Constance, pre sided over the first session of it, al lowed himself to be deposed, arranged for the other two to be excluded, and an American Why He Backed the United States. peror woyld remain, as they have to this day, secret. It: Is certain, how ever, that: when our (Jovernment and Union were imperiled by a formidable rebellion we should have found a powerful ally in Russia had an emer gency occurred." "The latter revelation." says the ed itor of these memoirs, "is corroborated by a well-known New York gentle man who was In St. Petersburg when the rebellion began, and who, during ail unotlieial call upon Prince Gortschiikoff, was shown by the chancellor an order written in Alex ander's own hand directing hi.s admiral to report to President Lincoln for or ders in case England or France sided with the Confederate's." The editor in question, Mr. Thurlow Weed Barnes, undoubtedly referred here to Mr. Itayard Taylor, who was Secretary of Legation at St. Peters burg at the lime of the incident here rwlated and who was on Intimate terms with Prince Gortschakoff. In the Nicolay nnad liny life of Lincoln a full account Is given of the effort of France to get England and Russia to Join In an Interference with the United States, it Is there said: "Many years elapsed before It be came generally known how near the British Government had come to ac cepting or even anticipating the over tures of tiie French for mediation." The Sun has the privilege of oflerlag now the testimony of one who was at the time Consul at Paris, and wke speaks with the highest personal authority, backed by documentary evidence never liefore publlshd: "To the Editor of The Sun: "Sir: Your representative has shewn me some letters to you question lag what the writers call the 'historical myth,' which credits Russia with hav ing attested her friendship for the United States in our Civil War by sending a squadron to our shores to be at the service of our government in case of need. He also asks me on your behalf if I can throw any light upon the subject. I think I can, though I do not know how conclusive It may appear to those who are pre disposed to doubt It. "In the summer of 1802 and before I had heard of the arrival of the Rus sian squadron in New York, I re ceived a letter from Mr. Seward, of which I inclose a copy. It was a re ply to rumors of coalitions and combi nations against the United States put in circulation by Confederate agencies In London and Paris, which I commun icated to the department. "I have marked the paragraph which I believed then to be, and still believe to have been, a sufflcent warrant for the Inference that the Secretary of State had an understand ing with the Russlnn Government. What he wrote certainly warrants more even than would be implied by a simple display of the flag of the Czar In the harbor of New York. "Shortly after my return from France In 1807, I spent a few days in Washington, during which time I had (frequent Interviews with Mr. Seward, and occasionally met at his house Mon sieur Bodlsco, the Russian Minister at Washington. The purchase of Alaska from Russia had just been con sumated. Of course neither Mr. Seward nor Monsieur Bodlsco said distinctly to me that that purchase was purely and simply as a gracious recognition on the part of the Washington Govern ment of the attitude of the Czar toward the United States in '62, but I doubt if there was any member of either house of Congress who supposed the government then had anyother motive in the purchase of Alaska than to recognize Its obligations to the Czar. "The fact stated by one of your cor respondents that 'there Is no record