As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

October 1899

6 articles

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Judge Charles E. Flandrau recalls an 1860 speech by William H. Seward in St. Paul predicting the city's future importance, given years before the Alaska purchase. He frames this as proof Seward was already thinking about northern expansion and credits Minnesotans like James W. Taylor with influencing that vision.

The Saint Paul Globe · 8 October 1899 · page 14

A SHORT FRONTIER STORY

By Judge Charles E. Flandrau. The peopla of St. Paul have oft»n been proud of a remark which was made by Hon. Wm. H. Seward, in a speech de livered by him In 1860, at th« old capitol ou Wabasha street, whera he Bald he believed that tha centsr of power on the North American continent would be very near tha spot whera he then stcod. Ev erybody, while they liked tha prediction, looked upon it aa a pleasant way the speaker had of giving lila hosts and St. Paul a little "taffy," and nothing more.

See moreSee less

Such, however, wws not the case, and Mr. Seward, when he uttered the proph ecy, was thoroughly Impressed with (.he truth of what he said, as I will prove further on. This speech was delivered on the 18th of September, 1860. If I remember cor rectly, Mr. Seward was on an election eering tour in support of Lincoln's can didacy for the presidency, and that Gen. Jam«a W. Ney, of N«w York, afterwards governor of Nevada, wan of tha party, but I am not very sure of these facts, and they are not at all material to tha point I am about to make. 'Mr. Seward stayed at the Merchants' hotel, at the foot of Jackson street, kept by our well known host, Col. Allen, whle he remain ed In St. Paul.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The President, speaking in Minneapolis, noted that after the 1867 Alaska purchase, a House committee minority had called it 'inexpedient' to spend money on 'Russian America.' He contrasted this with current members of the same party criticizing the administration for not pursuing further territorial expansion.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 October 1899 · page 4

If the rumored massacre of two German officers in South Africa by an armed body of natives, who afterward escaped into Drltlsh territory, chould prove' true, the In cident may contribute to the rapidly grow ing complications In that country. Ger many will certainly try to punish the mur derers of her officers, and will be apt to pursue them regardless of boundary lines. In his speech at Minneapolis the Presi dent brought out a forgotten fact in that after the purchase of Alaska in 1S67 the minority of a House committee reported that "it Is Inexpedient to appropriate money for the purchase of Russian America."

See moreSee less

Now members of thesame party are de nouncing the administration because it is ot ready to go to war for an additional slice of the once despised territory. Unless the Council passes an ordinance to elevate the railroad tracks, nothing will be dene In that direction during the next two years. The mayor has approved one ordi nance, but it will be a dead letter. The Council can send him s genuine one. which -will not permit him to be on both sides. Meantime, the Republican Council should see. that tho railroads have proper gates and watchmen at all hours when trains are run, at every crossing used by any consid erable number of people.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

U.S. Senator Addison G. Foster's letter to the Alaska territorial convention is reprinted, arguing that Alaska is rich in resources and deserves more federal attention, including lighthouses and education. He notes that a single gold mine has already produced more wealth than the entire original purchase price of Alaska.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 16 October 1899 · page 12

HE WRITES CONCERNING ALASKA BOUNDARY QUESTION

Says It Is the Best Way la Which to Aroaee Pablio Sentiment. The text of the letter which United States Senator Addison GFoster ad dressed to the Alaska territorial conven tion, called for the purpose of recommend ing to congress suitable legislation for the trrrltory. h33 been received In this city. In his letter Senator Foster speaks from tn» standpoint of one who has bean over tn«» ground, and who bases hi* ©pinions and conclusions upon an actual and practical knowledge of the situation. He 6uii In part: "Commerce has grown and expanded in A!ai-ka In spit* of neglect and inattention on the part of the United S'.atei govern ment.

See moreSee less

"Hut the time has come when our gov ernment—sometimes a trifle slow, bu: al ways sure -should recognize more fully the needs and demands of Alaska Alaska Is no object of charity. To say nothing of gold, or sliver, or timber and the like, and only mentioning fish. Alaska Is rich And yet one mine has produced more gold than would pay for the original cost of the whole Alaska purchase. And yet we have neg lect ed to plant a few lighthouses there to protect hundreds of vessels that navigate the most remarkable stretch of coast line In the world. "The torch of education should and will corne with the beacon for the faithful nav igators of Alaskan waters. I have had the pleasure. I am glad to say to you, of hav irg indorsed and approved of several im portant educational matters on behalf of Southeastern Alaska since returning from my vistt there. The people should riot bs denied educational facilities and shcuia not be hampered by being forced to go to great expense and ths temporary less of their t hildren hy sending them away to school. Nowhere in the United States do we need parade educators as much as we do In Alaska. "During my recent visit to Washington city, 1 am glad to report that I found ev erybody, from President McKinley down, evincing much intercut in Alaska. Indeed, without fear of being the* first to tell it, I found eveiybody somewhat Interested, not so much in locating rich claims as in lo • aiing and nailing down the 'boundary.' "On this very important quest lon—all-im portant tjuestion, 1 may my -of the bound ary the Alaska people should not fail to take advantage of every favorable oppor tunity to express thi-ir views, in fact. i know of no better means of driving the im portance of this question home to the minds of the people of the United States than by a serif s of meetings called for the purpose of bringing out an expression of sentiment, starting in Alaska and ex tending down the Pacific coast and thus rea< b.ing the great body c-f the American people." PLAX ix THE nmrßßia.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A government official reports on his visit to Washington, where interest in Alaska's resources and the ongoing boundary dispute with Canada is high. He urges Alaskans to organize meetings along the Pacific coast to press public opinion on the boundary question, while also advocating for lighthouses and schools in the territory.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 16 October 1899 · page 12

BOUNDARY QUESTION

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The report recounts President McKinley's Minneapolis speech invoking past American territorial expansions, including Seward's 1867 Alaska purchase, to counter critics of Philippine annexation. It notes that past acquisitions like the Louisiana Purchase also faced harsh contemporary criticism, paralleling current anti-imperialist objections.

Kansas City Journal · 17 October 1899 · page 4

HOW THE COUNTRY HAS EXPANDED

From the Itorliesier Iiemorat and I'hroni. I.-. There may be some "glittering generali ties" In Pre,idcnt McKlniey's Minneapolis speech, a, there are. or ought to be. in all addresses on such occasions, but there is also an abundance of solid, concrete tacts about American expansion under former administrations, from Jeflerson's Ijiuisiana purchase In lG down to the acquisition of Alaska, through the statesmanlike fore sight of William S. Seward, in l"iil.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The piece criticizes a reported modus vivendi over the Alaskan boundary question, arguing Americans want firm action, not diplomatic compromise, with Britain/Canada. It argues that since the U.S. purchased Alaska outright including its seaports, no concessions should be made now that gold has made the region valuable.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 19 October 1899 · page 4

That Modus Vivendi.

!& the KloldDtAmerica lays no claim to that field, but havingbought Alaska outright, including Rs seaports. a purchase right undisputed bv England for n quarter of a ofeittury. there must not be no concessions to British greed. T0ie North American continent should be one, and that one the United States of America, and it-would be as wise andJ

See the clipping