As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

November 1898

2 articles

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A review describes Mr. Keim's book as the work of a historical enthusiast who personally observed Seward's handling of the Alaska purchase and long awaited its vindication as wise statesmanship. The review praises the book's exhaustive coverage of Alaska's history, resources, and people, contrasting it with a more practical guide to the Yukon goldfields.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1898 · page 8

— w— — gold fields. Contrasted with thig is Mr. Keim's book: the work of an historical enthusiast, whose whole mind {8s absorbed in the triumph of an idea once treated with contempt by mankind in general. Mr. Keim in his younger days was in almost constant contact with Secretary Seward. He watched all the steps taken in the purchase of Alaska, and he has watched ever since for the moment when that purchase, so much decried at the time, would be vindicated as an act of the highest political wisdom.

See moreSee less

Hia book contains a mass of information. If there is anything | omitted which would serve to cast a light on | the history, the resources, the extent, the peo. ple or the wonders of Alaska, {t must have been very elusive to escape his scrutiny. He writes, | however, almost exclusively as a historian and not as a tourist or adventurer.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This editorial argues that the U.S. government has an inherent sovereign right to acquire and govern new territory, citing the Louisiana Purchase, Texas annexation, and the Alaska purchase as precedents despite constitutional objections at the time. It uses the once-mocked Alaska purchase to rebut claims that colonial governance of the Philippines would be unconstitutional.

The Indianapolis Journal · 28 November 1898 · page 4

Constitution or not. The right to acquire territory is us plainly an attribute of sovereignty as is the right of self-preserva tion. Thomas Jefferson, himself a strict constructionist, could not find any consti tutional authority to purchase the Louis iana territory, but he made the purchase and no person has ever disputed our titlu to the property. The annexation of Texas was denounced as unconstitutional, but it was annexed. The acquisition of New Mex ico and California at the close of the Mexi can war was opposed on constitutional grounds, but they were acquired.

See moreSee less

The anti expansionists of Mr. Seward’s time de nounced I lie purchase of Alaska as uncon stitutional, but the purchase was made and the Constitution did not suffer any harm, in fact, it is a very elastic and expansive instrument when national growth is con cerned. A Paris cablegram in the Sunday Journal indicates a befogged state of mind on this question. In trying to define the views of our peace commissioners the dispatch says: The Philippine islands will be adminis tered as a colony and the opposing argu ment against colonial government stands in Alaska, if the United States, it is pointed out, has no right to hold colonial posses sions then the United States’ title in Alas ka is vitiated. The United States appoints a. Governor and a judge in Alaska, but it has not legislative power. Somewhere in

See the clipping