The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
This 1891 report describes Senator Carlisle's Socratic cross-examination of Farmers' Alliance delegates over railroad nationalization costs. In rebutting the comparison of railroad purchase costs to Civil War spending, the writer invokes the Alaska purchase price as an example of a sound investment, alongside the Louisiana and Gadsden purchases.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 4 June 1891 · page 4
CARLISLE AND THE SOCRATIC
Alaska. It may cost more to open and work a valuable gold mine than to pay for "a fight to a finish" between Bullivan and
The article recalls that critics once derided Seward's 1867 Alaska purchase as a waste of $7.2 million, but a new census bulletin shows the territory's fur, fishery, and gold output since then has totaled about $63,000,000. It argues the investment has proven highly profitable and predicts continued growth in salmon, cod, and gold production.
Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 6 June 1891 · page 2
Whatever may befall the teal fisher ; ies, the income from the salmon and cod I fisheries is certain to be mnoh greater in the futare than in the past. The risers fairly swarm with salmon, and now that the Colombia river and it* tributaries are becoming depleted, the canneries are moving to Alaska. The cod fisheries of the Pacific ooast are only in their infancy, but they are known to be very valuable. About (700,000 annually is taken from the gold mines, an output that is certain to icoreaae with the decline of the gold deposits in California. Thar* Is a vast extent of gold-producing territory in Alaska awaiting development. If Secre tary Seward wm alive now he wonld not
The report recalls that Secretary Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska for $7.2 million was widely mocked as a waste of money. A new census bulletin shows the territory's furs, fisheries, and gold have since yielded over $63,000,000, vindicating the purchase.
The Central Nevadan · 11 June 1891 · page 2
FRANK FRANCIS - - EDITOR. When Secretary Seward negotiated the treaty with Russia by which we acquired Alaska there were many who believed the United States were throwing away $7,200,000 of good money for which no proper equivalent would be realized. Alaska was regarded as a region of glaciers and inaccessible mountain ranges, with some fish not wor.h catching and a little timber that would not pay the cost of marketing. That i a possession carried with it some strategic value was deemed probable, but there were few who believed that the bargain was a good one from a pecuniary point of view.
See moreSee less
A recent census bulletin, how ever dispels this illusion completely. The shipment of-fur seal skins since 1867, the year in which Alaska was acquired, has reached $33,000,000, and of other furs, $16,000,000; a total fur output of $49,000,000. The salmon aad codfisheries have netted $10,000,000, and the gold mines, $4,000,000; making the total product of the Territory in the twenty-three years, $63,000,000, not a bad return on tbe original invest ment, Whatever may befall the seal fisheries, the income from the sal mon and cod fisheries is certain to be much greater in the future than in the past. The rivers fairly swarm with salman, and now that the Columbia River and its tributaries are becoming depicted, the can neries are moving te Alaska. The co4 fisheries of the Pacific Coast are only in their infancy, but they are known to be very valuable. About $700,000 annually is taken from the gold mines, an output that is certain to increase with the decline of the gold deposits in California. There is a vast extent of gold-producing territory in Alaska awaiting develop ment. If Secretary Seward was alive now he would not be called upon to apologise for the purchase
The report cites a recent census bulletin showing Alaska has generated over $57 million in furs, fisheries, and gold since its 1867 purchase, far exceeding the original cost. It notes that salmon, cod, and gold mining are still in early development and expected to grow, vindicating Seward's much-mocked deal.
The Somerset Herald · 17 June 1891 · page 4
H. L. . effected a cure in my case, ver, Waverly, X. Y. Alaska a Good Bargain. When Secretary Seward negotiated Mi-eaty with Kuwia by which we ac red Alaska, there were many who bew l the I uited states were throwing kv JTifioxl of good money for which i roiwr equivalent would ever be real d. Alaska was rvpirded as r. region of triers and inacces-ible mountain .iges. with some fish not worth catchand a little timber that would not y the cost of marketing. That its pos ion earned with it some strategic valdeemed probable, but there were w who believed that the bargain was a ...1 one from a cuniary point of view.
See moreSee less
A recent census bulletin, tiowever, dis is this illusion completely. Tne sbip ent of fur seal skins since lGT.Ue year hi. h Alaska was acquired, ha&reach 1 i:;n,mH),iHiO and other furs, rlO,0K),CKK) t..ul fur output of f4",0ti,000. The sal ,on and cod fisheries have urtted $4,000, t ; making the total prodtut of the ei ritory in the Zi years .Y;,tH,0ti0 ; not had return on the original investment. Whatever may befall the seal fisheries le income from the saiuion and cod hheries is certaia to be more in tbe fu ":re than in the past. The rivers fairly warm with salmon, and now that tbe ilunhia river and its attributaries are eeoiuing depleted the canneries areinov ug to Alaska. The cod fisheries of the av i lie coast are only in their infaa-y n 1 they are known to I very valuable .bout t700,0W annually is taken frojn lie gold mines, an output that is certain increase with the decline of the gold 'eponit in California, There is a vast xtent of gold producing territory in Alas- ; awaiting develojmenL If Secretary -ward ere alive now he Would not be tiled upon to apologize for the purchase
Idaho News · Blackfoot, Idaho · and 4 other papers
This 1891 editorial paragraph dismisses the old notion that developing Alaska would impoverish the territory, noting that fish, gold, and furs will enrich other parts of the country for years to come. It wryly suggests Alaska could eventually profit further through tourism once other resources are depleted.
Idaho News · 27 June 1891 · page 6
The idea that the development of Alaska wt!l tmpovensh that country would have been queer doctrine in the ears of Secretary Seward. Still the fish and the gold and the furs and the — <-» a— sr years to come will enrich people in other territories of Uncle Sam. and when her own resources are exhausted Alaska may get rich herself by a ju dicioas series of summer hotels.