As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

April 1891

7 articles

In the story →

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

The article recalls that Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska for $7.2 million was widely mocked as a bad bargain, with critics viewing the territory as worthless ice and rock. It then cites a recent census bulletin showing $63,000,000 in furs, fisheries, and gold produced over 23 years, with future returns expected to grow further.

Gloucester County Democrat · 9 April 1891 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

When Secretary Seward negotiated the treaty with Russia by which we acquired Alaska, there were many who believed the United States were throwing away $7,200,000 of good money for which no fair equivalent would ever be realized. Alaska was regarded as a region of glaciers and inaccessible mountain ranges, with some fish not worth catching, and a little timber that would not pay the cost of marketing. That its possession carried with it some strategic value was deemed probable, but there were few who believed that the bargain was a good one from a pecuniary point of view.

A recent census bulletin, however, dispels this illusion completely. The shipment of fur seal-skins since 1867, the year in which Alaska was acquired, has reached $33,000,000, and of other furs, $16,000,000; a total fur output of $49,000,000. The salmon and cod fisheries have netted $10,000,000, and the gold mines $4,000,000, making the total product of tho Territory in the twenty-three years $63,000,000, not a bad return on the original investment.

See moreSee less

Whatever may befall the seal fisheries, the income from the salmon and cod fisheries is certain to be much greater in the future than in the past. The rivers fairly swarm with salmon, and now that the Columbia river and its tributaries are becoming depleted, the canneries are removing to Alaska. The cod fisheries of the Pacific coast are only in their infancy, but they are known to be very valuable. About $700,000 annually is taken from the gold mines' an output that is certain to increase with the decline of the gold deposits in California. There is a vast extent of gold producing territory in Alaska awaiting development. If Secretary Seward were alive now he would not be called upon to apologize for the purchase of Alaska.

[Phila. Times.

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

A census bulletin reports that since the 1867 purchase, Alaska has produced $49 million in furs, $10 million in fisheries, and $4 million in gold, totaling $63 million. The article argues this proves Seward need not apologize for buying Alaska, debunking the 'Seward's Folly' label.

Gloucester County Democrat · 9 April 1891 · page 2

When Secretary Seward negotiated the treaty with Russia by which we acquired Alaska,there were many who believed the United States were tbrowiug away $7,200, 000 of good money for which no fair equiv alent would ever be realized. Alaska was regarded as a region of glaciers and inac cessible mountain ranges, with some fish not worth catching, and a little timber that would not pay the cost of marketing. That its possession carried with it some strategic value was deemed probable, but there were few who believed that the bar gain was a good oue from a pecuniary point ot view.

See moreSee less

A recent census bulletin, however, dis oels this illusion completely. The ship ment of fur seal-skins since 1867, the year in which Alaska was acquiied, has reached $33,000,000, and of other furs, $16,000,000 ; a total fur output of $49,000,000. The sal mon and cod fisheries have netted $10,000, 000, and the gold mines $4,000,000, making the total product of tho Territory in the twenty-three years $63,000,000, not a had return on the original investment. Whatever may befall the seal fisheries, the income from the salmon and cod fishe ries is certain to Ire ranch greater in the future than in the past. The rivers fairly swarm with salmon, and now that the Co lumbia river and ils tributaries are becom ing depleted, the canneries are removing to Alaska. The cod fisheries of the Pacific coast are only in their infancy, but they are known to be very valuable. About $700, 000 annually is taken from the gold mines’ an output that is certain to increase with the decline ot the gold deposits in Califor nia. There is a vast extent ol gold produc ing territory in Alaska awaiting develop ment. It Secretary Seward were alive now he would not be called upon to apolo gize for the purchase of Alaska. [I’hila. Times. Wonder Iwhy so many persons suffer from ca tarrh when ywith Old Saul’s Catarrh Curetthey would be cured at once. We all have our preferences ; but who prefers to hear a crying baby when the fact Is so well known, that I)r. Bull's Baby Syrup would at once quiet it.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.

The report describes Alaska's mineral resources, noting that gold and silver rank next to furs and fish in value, with the first productive gold mines located near Juneau in 1890. It details the famous Treadwell mine's uncertain output figures and confirms that Yukon region surface mines are within Alaska's boundaries, not British Columbia as sometimes reported, having produced gold for six or seven years.

The L'anse Sentinel · 18 April 1891 · page 4

jbulliou, among them tho famous Tread well or Taris mine, said to be the larg est now iu existence, which supplies a mill with a capacity of 240stn)!ipK. The output of this mine has been variously j and vaguely atated at figures ranging i from ftU,lHH) to more than s1()0,(m0 per ! tons bus lwu worked down to three "month, but as it has leeu possible to thousand tons of what ia known ns the ascertain the total shipment of dust and j"Seligmanu c pper." The stocks at bullion from Alaska, wliich docs not , the mines are light, having nccumnlat indnstiial purposes, the effect on prices will be veiy much sharper.

See moreSee less

The rea son begins' on a better footing altogeth er. Stocks on hand are fur liirlitithan they were a your ago. The Synd icate's legacy of tweiity-llvo thousand

See the clipping

The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.

The article reviews Alaska's mineral production since purchase, noting exaggerated claims about a major copper mine's output and clarifying that Yukon surface gold mines are within Alaska's boundaries, not British Columbia. It details modest silver output, untapped copper and cinnabar deposits due to transportation difficulties, and a failed silver-galena mining venture on the Tih river.

The L'anse Sentinel · 18 April 1891 · page 4

jbulliou, among them tho famous Tread well or Taris mine, said to be the larg est now iu existence, which supplies a mill with a capacity of 240stn)!ipK. The output of this mine has been variously j and vaguely atated at figures ranging i if; evident that the yield of this mine must Lave leen great! exaggerated. The surface mines of the Yukon , region, though frequently reported as y being located withiu DritisU Columbia Lave been definitely ascertained to b.i within the boundaries of Alankn. Those I ii" mines have produced gold dut for t period oi six or seven years, ana aver t , aged betweeu $ 10,000 aud ."0,000 per annum until the teason of 18D0.

See moreSee less

In that year tho output wag nearly I0,000, V the gold lteing found in rather coarse dust aud Tnuggeis. The total value it thus far exported from Alaska since its purchase approaches $1,000,000, but it t '' safe to oay that this sum does not t apectmg aud in (lie purchase or mining - and . milling plants iu southeastern jUaska a state of affairs experienced '' in all miiieral countries in tho early atagea of development. The output of r , ailver in Alaska has been quite insigni ') '. ficant not exceeding $3,000 per annum. y Large deposits of copper, said to le , ' of great richness, are known to, exist in r the interior of Alaska, but their loca tion is such that tho difllonlties of tran sportation are' almost insurmountable. This wea"t'i will not probably be utiliz ed nntil the far distant future. Several deposits of cinnabar are also known to exist in Kuskokowin region ; , but, though located ou the banks of a river navigable by light-draught steam ers, mining men have thus iar declined to in tea; money in their development. ' A mining enterprise was inaugurated five or six yoirs ago on the banks of Tih river, wh.ch empties into Norton Csar.d, for tho development of a deposit o - (First publication Mar. .) ,.; r

See the clipping

Fairhaven Herald · Fairhaven, Wash.

A Herald correspondent in St. Petersburg reports Russian government views ahead of Bering Sea arbitration with the U.S. The dispatch states Russia never intended to convey special rights in the open waters of Bering Sea, noting the Alaska purchase stemmed from private talks between Baron Edouard de Stoeckl and Secretary Seward that deliberately left maritime jurisdiction unresolved.

Fairhaven Herald · 23 April 1891 · page 1

Blaine should make no mistake about the position of Russia in the coming arbitra tion of the Bering sea question. [ know the views of the goyernment, although it would not be fair to hold it responsible for my words. In the first place, there is nothing on record to show that Russia intended to convey to the United States any special rl,hu In the open waters of Bering sea. The Alaska purchase was the result of private negotiations between Baron Edward De Stocki and Secretary

See the clipping

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

The article defends the 1867 Alaska purchase, noting Secretary Seward paid $7,200,000 for the territory. It cites census data showing nearly $50 million from furs and over $10 million from salmon and cod fisheries since the purchase, far exceeding the original cost.

The Corvallis Gazette · 24 April 1891 · page 2

ALASKA NOT A SUCKED ORANGE

ALASKA HOT A "SUCKEDORAXGE: It is no wonder that New York capitalists were willing to back Captain Carroll, for the purchase of Alaska, with twice the sum paid for that territory by the United States through Secretary Seward, nor is it surprising that the old "shellback" announces that the offer still holds good. What may be the settlement of the seal difficulty, it is certain that the discussion of the question will give our Alaskan possessions a wider advertising than they would otherwise have received in many years. Facts are coming to light that show the industry of catch ing fur-bearing animals to have been of greater value than was suspected.

See moreSee less

As everybody knows, Secretary Seward bought Alaska from Rus sia, paying therefor $7,200,000. Since that purchase in 1867, ac cording to a census bulletin con taining an abstract of the report of Ivan PetrofF, the special agent of the bureau, sealskins to the value of $33,000,000 have been shipped from Alaska and sold in the London markets, and other furs to the amount $16,000,000 have been sold. Nearly fifty mil lion dollars have been collected from furs alone. But this is not all that has to go to the credit of Alaska. The sal

See the clipping

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

A 1891 report cites a U.S. census bulletin on Alaska showing that fur, salmon, fish, whale, and gold production since the 1867 purchase have far exceeded the $7,200,000 price paid. The article credits Secretary Seward with having 'builded better than he knew' in buying the territory.

The Redwood Gazette · 30 April 1891 · page 2

The CJoited States paid $7,200,000 for the territory of Alaska, says the Winona Republican. Since the pur chase in 1867, according to a census bulletin containing an abstract of the report of Ivan Petroff, the special ag ent of the bureau, fur sealskins to the value of $33,000,000 have been shipped from Alaska and sold in the London markets, and other furs to the amount of $16,000,000 have been sold. The salmon fisheries alone since 1884 have yielded $7,500,000, or more than the cost of the territory* In 1890, 3,000, 000 salmon were taken at Karluk, where the largest cannery in the world is located, and 200,000 cases canned— 1,100 men being employed at the work.

See moreSee less

The herring fish at Killissnoo yields annually 150,000 gallons of oil and nearly 100 tons of fertilizing material The codfish catch in Alaskan waters sinco 1868 amount to about $3,000,000 The whale fisheries of the Arctic ocean in 1890 yielded 226,402 pounds of whalebone worth from $2.50 to $3.50 a pound. $3,980 pounds of ivory and 14,557 barrels of oil. The annual pro duction of gold in Alaska is now about $700,000. Thus it appears that eyen the far-seeing .Mr. Seward in his pur chase of Alaska "builded better than he knew."

See the clipping