As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

February 1891

5 articles

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

A report on fur seal polygamy on the Pribilof Islands veers into the ongoing US-British diplomatic row over sealing rights in the Bering Sea, with Blaine citing the Alaska Purchase treaty's grant of 'waters thereof' as the basis for American claims. The piece recounts the verbal sparring between Salisbury and Blaine and notes the matter may go to the US Supreme Court.

The Helena Independent · 15 February 1891 · page 11

TWENTY WIVES APIECE

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash. · and 1 other paper

The article describes the Pribilof Islands seal rookeries and the Aleut natives' hunting practices, noting that government revenue from sealskins over two decades nearly equals what was paid to Russia for all of Alaska in 1867. It concludes that Seward's purchase, once mocked, has been economically vindicated by this single resource alone.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 15 February 1891 · page 10

THE NORTH ROOKKRV, ST. GEORGE ISLAND. off their clothes, night or day, gossiping, eating and getting drunk on quass. They eat ravenously, averaging two pounds of seal meat per day for every man. woman and child, in addition to vast quantities of other food. Up to last year they took about 100.000 skins a year, and the United States treas ury received $3 for each skin. The net result is that the government has received from the Commercial company during the last twenty years nearly as much as was paid to Russia for the whole of Alaska in IS6B. So Seward's purchase is vindicated. It was unquestionably a good bargain to

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont. · 15 February 1891

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The report describes the fur seal colonies on the Pribilof Islands and recounts the ongoing U.S.-British diplomatic dispute over sealing rights in the Bering Sea, framed as a consequence of America's 1867 purchase of Alaska 'with the waters thereof.' It presents an imagined dialogue between Blaine and Salisbury debating territorial claims over the sea.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 15 February 1891 · page 10

PUGNACITY OF THE BULLS.

WASHINGTON CITY, Feb. 9.— f Special Cor respondence.]— Our war with England is a war of words to date. Premier Salisbury and Premier Blaine are having it. "How dare you assault our vessels in Bering sea?" asks Salisbury. "We own that sea," replies Blaine, "and you folks must not fish there." "How do you "happen to own a sea that is a thousand miles square and a part of the Pacific ocean ?" asks Salisbury, "when you insist that wo own only three miles from shore in the Gulf of St.

See moreSee less

Lawrence?" "We bought it of Russia," says Blaine, "when we bought Alaska 'with the waters thereof.' " "Do 'the waters thereof cover the sea 200 miles from shore under any law or cus tom that nations have ever recognized?" asks Salisbury; "and did not the United States forty years ago send an ambassador to Russia to protest against the czar's claim that this very sea belonged exclus ively to him?" "I am not bound by the eccentricities of any predecessors," answers Blaine; "and if a nation can dominate the ocean only three miles from shore how does it happen that Great Britain commanded the sea for thirty

See the clipping

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A satirical dispatch frames the US-British Bering Sea sealing controversy as a dialogue between Secretary of State Blaine and Prime Minister Salisbury, debating whether the Alaska purchase included exclusive rights to the surrounding waters. It notes the Alaska Commercial Company's twenty-year monopoly on seal hunting and the unresolved question of whether the dispute will go to the US Supreme Court.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 15 February 1891 · page 6

THE PERCH OF PINNIPEDS ON PRIBYLOFF ISLANDS

Behring Sea?” asks Salisbury. •>VVe own that sea," replies Blaine, “and you fellows must uot fish there.’ “How do you happen to own a sea that is a thousand miles square and a part of the Pacific Ocean?" asks Salis bury. “when you insist that we own only three miles from the shore in the Gulf of St. Lawrence?” • We bought It from Russia." says Blaine, “when we bought Alaska, ’with the waters thereof.'" • Do 'the waters thereof’ cover the sea 200 milefrom shore under any law or custom that nations have ever recognized?” asks Salisbury: “and

See the clipping

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report describes the Pribyloff Islands' seal harvest and the Aleut natives' way of life, noting that government royalties from the Alaska Commercial Company over twenty years nearly equaled the purchase price paid to Russia. It concludes that Seward's purchase of Alaska has been vindicated as a shrewd bargain.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

Wheeling Sunday Register · 15 February 1891 · page 6

NORTH ROOKERY. PRIBYLOFF ISLANDS.

was paid to Russia for the whole ot Alaska in 1868. s>> Seward's purchase ivindicated: it was unqestionably a good bargain to pay -even million and two hundred thousand dollars for this va-t peninsula whose sources of wealth are not yet even guessed at. much loss developed. In the benilicent or malevolent, econo my ,.f nature and commerce there are iwi« e u> many females as males it. the -eal community: so polygamy flourishes If there ever could be an excuse for pi li ra; marriages in human society it would ; h*- in New England, where there ia j surplus t<f one hundred and eighty thousand women: there certainly Is j do.

See moreSee less

none in the middle of the Alkaline plains in I'tah, where there are two men to one woman everywhere. In the spring the adult seals come swimming hack from their mysterious tropical visit, accompanied by a million of the youug pups of the previous sum mer. and the Pribyloff islands are very lively once more—lively and reverber ant with roars of anger and of friendly greeting. Mostly roars of anger, for every male seal is the foreordained enemy of all other male seals, and must defend with his strength, and often with his life, the position he has assumed on the rocks as his particular seraglio. Tlp-re he gathers his harem, one by one, and here, in a few weeks, tipyoung anborn. Some of these bulls exhibit the same desper ate courage and insensibility to pain as is shown by the Indian brave who is hamstrung and hauled up to a tree top by the quivering sinews. One was pointed out to the Government agent who had survived forty or fifty pitched battles with as many antagonists and still held hiplace, covered with scars and firigktfully gashed, raw. festering and bloody, one eye gouged out and a fore flapper torn to ribbons, but yet lording it stubbornly over his harem of fifteen or twenty females, huddled ad miringly around him. The lighting is mostly done with the mouth. They seize each other with their canine teeth, always leaving ugly, and sometimes fa tal wounds. The male sealarrive from the South tirst, and are followed by the pretty lit tle females some weeks thereafter. Mon. George Wardman. the Treasury agent at the I'ribyloff Island, expresses no opinion about the question of mare clausum. I'-avlng that to be settled by the Secretary of State and the British Premier, but lie describes this polyg amy in a very lively manner: "The matured male seai, when lie draws tip out of the ocean after a six or eight months'cruise in waters to us unknown, is a magnificent animal. Bold, bad and beautiful, he taker, a position in May among the basaltic rocks which are washed by the surf in storms, braces his broad client upon his fori dippers, stretches his heavily-maned. glossy, un dulating neck, throws his tapering head aloft and roars forth a hoarse bellow of defiance to the world. He closes with a gutteral growl that sounds like two quarts of pebbles r.titling in his throat, while down the corners of his threat ening mouth, stockaded with ivory fangs, droop the long gray fangs of his aristocratic mustache. Here lie takes his stand, and here he will meet his ex pected family "r death. delightful.

See the clipping