As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

January 1876

2 articles

In the story →

The New Orleans Bulletin · New Orleans, La.

The report alleges that the lease granting the Alaska Commercial Company exclusive rights to hunt fur-seals in Alaska was a massive swindle of the government, implicating officials including Boutwell, Richardson, Dent, and Babcock. It details a congressional resolution, introduced by Mr. Wood of New York and agreed to, directing the Committee on Ways and Means to investigate whether the lease was lawfully executed and advantageous to the United States.

The New Orleans Bulletin · 28 January 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A BIG STEAL UNEARTHED.

How the Government was Swindled in the Lease of the Alaska Commercial Company.

See moreSee less

Boutwell, Richardson, Dent and Babcock Have a Finger in the Pie.

An Investigation That Will Make the "Fur Fly."

Next to the great whisky frauds upon the general government, there has been no other swindle, probably, of such great magnitude as that which is covered up by the lease of the "Alaska Commercial Company," whereby that company obtained the exclusive right to take fur-seals in the recently acquired Territory of Alaska.

The manner in which the fraud was consummated has been known to us for some time, and steps had been taken to have a full investigation of the matter had on motion of one of the Conservative members of the House from Louisiana. By the congressional record of the 18th inst., however, we see that Mr. Wood, of New York, by unanimous consent, submitted the following resolution, which was read, considered and agreed to:

Resolved, That the Committee on Ways and Means be requested to examine into and to report whether the lease from the United States to the Alaska Commercial Company of the right to take fur-seals in Alaska, signed and executed by William A. Richardson, acting Secretary of the Treasury, in behalf of the United States, and John F. Miller in behalf of said company, was made and executed in pursuance of law, and whether said lease was made to the best advantage of the United States according to the offers of other bidders; and also whether the interests of the United States were properly protected by the stipulations of said lease; and whether the Alaska Commercial Company have complied with its terms and conditions, and with the provisions, requirements and limitations of the act of Congress, approved July 1, 1870; with power to send for persons and papers, administer oaths, and to report at any time.

The taking of fur-seals in Alaska is an immensely profitable business, and shortly after the purchase of the Territory from Russia, a bill was passed through Congress by the expenditure of a vast sum of money, nearly $300,000, authorizing the Secretary of the Treasury to sell to the highest and best bidder the exclusive privilege of taking fur-seals in the Territory, for the term of twenty years. The manner in which the bids were opened and the award made, is very truthfully and graphically described by Gen. O. O. Howard, in a letter written by him to the Secretary of War, under date of June 30, 1875, when he was on an official tour of inspection in Alaska Territory. The following is

GEN. HOWARD'S STORY,

which we may state can be corroborated in every particular by unimpeachable witnesses:

The Secretary then proceeded to open the bids, of which there were fourteen.

The lowest bid was that of the Alaska Commercial Commercial Company, amounting to $65,000 rental a year, and the highest bid that of Louis Goldstone, for a combination of various San Francisco firms, amounting to a yearly rental of $227,500.

The principal parties in the combination of firms for whom Goldstone had made the bids were the firm of Taylor & Bendel, one of the most respectable and prominent houses of San Francisco, that had been engaged in the Alaska trade from its opening, and having the additional advantage over the Alaska Commercial Company of prior occupation. The inquiries immediately instituted by the government in Washington, through the agency of Custom-House Collector Phelps, of San Francisco, as to their standing and responsibility, were of a character in every way satisfactory.

Notwithstanding this and the great discrepancy in the bids, the Alaska Commercial Company entered various protests, which were referred by Mr. Boutwell to the Attorney General, then Mr. A. T. Akerman, who heard arguments on both sides, and under date of July 29 decided in favor of Goldstone and associates.

After the delivery of Mr. Akerman's opinion it was everywhere taken for granted the lease would be awarded to Goldstone. Nobody had any doubt of it. All obstacles had been removed, and all protests done away with.

On July 30 Mr. Goldstone consequently called at the Treasury office for the lease, but to his utter astonishment and consternation he was informed that the lease had been awarded to the Alaska Commercial Company on the terms of his own (Goldstone's) bid. The communication was made by Acting Secretary William A. Richardson, whose face in giving the information was crimsoned with shame. Mr. Boutwell had secretly left for Massachusetts.

Thus it came to pass that the scheme succeeded; that slavery and bondage, for the abolishment of which a few years before the best blood in America had been sacrificed, was here restored and was openly sanctioned by Congress; that free and liberal America had openly granted a monopoly of trade and was placed on a footing with the most despotic of the powers of Europe, Russia, and that Christian communities, together with the two islands, were leased to the Alaska Commercial Company for twenty years. Alas! Alaska was then, indeed, an appropriate term.

ACCUSED OF BRIBERY.

If the prize that the Alaska Commercial Company had thus gained was enormous, it can be imagined that a tremendous sum had to be sacrificed to satisfy the political cormorants, and the press in those days made the most sweeping charges against members of Congress and members of the Administration, and there was an ugly rumor that the brother-in-law of the President, Mr. Dent, had been made a partner to the concern at the eleventh hour.

Here are charges serious enough to warrant criminal proceedings against every public officer implicated, and an investigation will prove that the President himself used his influence in favor of the company that was permitted to defraud the Treasury of the United States.

THE BID OF GOLDSTONE

was so largely in excess of that made by the successful company, was made by such responsible parties, that upon the very ay on which the contract was adjudicated, a prominent Washington capitalist approached Goldstone and made him a bona fide offer of $500,000 for his bid; but having been informed by Mr. Boutwell that the matter was all right and that he, Goldstone, must go to the Treasurer's office at 1 o'clock, to sign the necessary documents, the offer was rejected.

Imagine the surprise of Goldstone upon visiting the office as directed, to find that Boutwell had suddenly left Washington on the 12:45 train, and to see Gen. Miller, the representative of the $65,000 bid, with his arm familiarly

AROUND THE NECK OF RICHARDSON,

laughing and chatting about the matter. Imagine his consternation upon Richardson's informing him that the Secretary had determined to award the lease to Gen. Miller—he, Miller, agreeing to bid as high as Goldstone.

To kick against such official bricks as Boutwell, Richardson, Dent & Co., was of course worse than useless. The Congress was all one way, and expostulations and protests were idle. The resolution of Mr. Wood was a mistake in not calling for a special committee. The subject is of sufficient importance to warrant the expense, and the House should probe it to the very bottom. Some idea of the money involved may be had when it is known that the Company has never paid less than $1,500,000 net profit per annum, and the customary sum pocketed by the Company every year is $1,800,000. Let us have a special committee on this important matter, Mr. Kerr, by all means.

See the clipping

The New Orleans Bulletin · New Orleans, La.

A House resolution directs the Committee on Ways and Means to investigate whether the lucrative Alaska fur-seal lease to the Alaska Commercial Company was legally and fairly awarded, despite a much higher bid from a rival San Francisco combination. The report includes Gen. O.O. Howard's account of the bidding process as evidence of possible wrongdoing.

The New Orleans Bulletin · 28 January 1876 · page 1

A BIG STEAL UNEARTHED.

Next to the great whisky frauds upon the t t general government, there has been no other ; ; swindle, probably, of such great magnitude as that which is covered np by the lease of the ! ! "Alaska Commercial Company," whereby that company obtained the exclusive right to take fur-seals in the recently acquired Terrii i tory of Alaska. The manner in which the fraud was con summated h-s been known to us for some j j time, and steps had been taken to have a full investigation of the matter had on motion of ^ ^ one of the Conservative members of the H inse from Louisiana.

See moreSee less

By the congressional record of the 18th ins*., however, we see that Mr. of Wood, of New York, by unanimous consent, submitted the following resolution, which was read, considered aud agreed to : Iiesolved, That the Committee on Ways and Means be requested to examine iuto and to report whether the lease lrom the Uni- ; ; ted StatEs to the Alaska Commercial i i Company of the right to take fur-seals in ' ' Aliska, signed and executed by William A. j j Richardson, acting Secretary of the Treasury, 1 1 m behalf of the United States, and John F. | | Miller in behalf of said company, was made j j and executed ia pursuance of law, and whether said lease was made to the best ad vantage of the United States according to the offers of other bidders; and also whether the interests of the Uui'ei States were properly protected by the stipulations of said lease; aud whether the Alaska Commercial Company have complied with its terms and conditions, and with the provisions, requirements and ; ; limitations of tho act of Congress, approved \ \ •July 1, 1870; with power to send for persons . . und papers, administer oaths, and to report at i i any time. The taking of fur-seals in Alaska is an im m nseiy profitable business, aud shortly after , , the purchase of the Territory from Russia, a bill was passed through Congress by the ex' : : penditure of a vast sum of money, nearly j j $300,000, authorizing the Secretary of the ! ! Treasury to sell to the highest and best bidder the exclusive privilege of taking fnr-seals in j j the Territory, for the term of twenty years. ! ! The manner in whi^ the bids were opened and the award made, is very truthfully and j j graphically described by Gen. O. O. Howard, in a letter written by him to the Secretary of i i War, under date of June 30, 1875, when he ; ; was on an oflisial tour of inspection in Alaska Territory. The following is gen. Howard's story, which we may state can be corroborated 1 1 in every particular by unimpeachable wit- ! ! nesses ;

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page