As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

January 1874

3 articles

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

A newspaper argues that Americans oppose further territorial annexation, citing the earlier 'national condemnation' of Seward's purchase of Alaska and Grant's Santo Domingo scheme as evidence. The piece claims the U.S. public, being commercially minded, would reject Hawaiian annexation absent clear financial benefit.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 17 January 1874 · page 4

New York Herald would thunder in its favor; but when it iconsidered that that paper would be in favor of annexing anything, from a stray ice-berg to the rent of the world, and that it generally is in the wrong, such support would not amount to much. And if it is not enough to state the public sentiment now, you have the na tional condemnation of Seward's purchase of Alaska, and of Grant's San Domingo scheme.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Gazette · Honolulu, Hawaii

A Hawaiian speaker argues against annexation to the United States, citing Seward's purchase of Alaska as an example that provoked public anger and discouraged further territorial acquisitions. The speech uses the Alaska purchase alongside the rejected annexation of San Domingo to argue that American public opinion, not treaties, determines whether annexation occurs.

The Hawaiian Gazette · 21 January 1874 · page 2

But when tho great question of annexation to the United States comes and the end of Hawaii an independence, then I stand firm and strong against annexation. I think lhat Hawaii's truest interest is to remain independent and govern it self. " Let ns see what the argument that reci procity means annexation amounts to. The United States and Canada for many years had such a treaty, and is Canada to-day annexed to tho United States ? Xo 1 It is to-day a free and independent nation and strong, because it had the great benefit of reciprocity so long.

See moreSee less

Has the United States annexed any country with which it has had treaties ? Xol and I defy any body to show that this connlry ever used a treaty to annex any other country. William 11. Seward, when Secretary of State, bought Alaska of Rus

See the clipping

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

A bill to extend U.S. land survey systems to Alaska has stalled due to opposition from the Interior Department. Speculators based in San Francisco had earlier secured provisions allowing them to claim valuable coal lands before surveys were completed, and now seek further legislation to extend their advantage.

National Republican (Washington City) · 22 January 1874 · page 1

ALASKA COAL LANDS WANTED. A bill to nrorlde fur tha avtsmalan nfthn TTnlti1 States system or land surveys over the Territory Of Alaska has tuNRn framail tvnt ti hMnnlnruhl lntne bad by oppesttlon rrom'the Interior De partment. Last winter a hill for the saloofeoal lands was passed, and prortslon was mado so that tracts or unsurreyed land could be ,held by per forming a certain ameunt or work and continuing tho same until tarreys were nude, when the holders would hsvo tho preferred right or entry. A nnmber-or speculators, srbeeaheadquarters nro In San Frandsoo, iueoeeded In getting the coal fields or Alaska Included within the provisions of the act.

See moreSee less

They hare formed companies and dis patched agents to take possession of large tracts orihe meet valuable el4aTHls In that Territory, tho exiuenee or which M-ealy known to a few men, and caw In order to perfect their grabs. tboy ask Congress to pass a bill to extend' the icja ever -tacsa.uommtssMneT-ijrammona . addressed a letter to Senator Mitchell In opposition to the scheme. There are rumors or other eomalnatlens to con trol and menopolUe the resources or that Terri tory, but there It a dlspeeitlea among members of wgrcza.io investigate tnem an, ana a movement wiU.be made tawaadg hajrax a oommlssion ap poaued to examine into tbe whole subject and at the same time to report anon tho manner in whleh the Alaska Fur Seal Company I falflllinrlU contract with the Government.

See the clipping