As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

October 1871

2 articles

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

A Democratic speaker opposing Grant's San Domingo annexation recalls his earlier opposition to the 'worthless acquisition' of Alaska, describing how Seward secretly negotiated the treaty after Congress adjourned and surprised the country with its $7.2 million price tag. The speech misdates the episode to 1870 and the 40th Congress.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kenosha Telegraph · 19 October 1871 · page 2

The Democrats, in their state platform, having denounced the attempt of Presi dent Grant to acquire that island, I feel that I may speak with propriety upon the subject. Having, as a member of con gress, opposed the best of my ability the worthless acquisition of Alaska aud St. Thomas, I fee) tint I have the right to speak of San Domingo. On the 4tli of March, 1870, the 40th congress assembled at Washington. It remained in session only three or four days and then adjourned. The senate was immediately reassembled for an ex ecutive session.

See moreSee less

No sooner had the mem bers of the popular branch of congress left Washington, as they did, without any suspicion that mischief was brewing, than Mr. Seward sent to the Senate a treaty which he had secretly negotiated for the purchase of the territory of Alaska. The country was taken entirely by surprise. There was no public senti ment demanding its purchase, the Presi dent had not recommended it in any mes sage, no one had advocated it, and even the negotiator had no knowledge in re gard to the country he was buying, or if he had any knowledge, it was that the. country was the most inhospitable and repulsive on the face of the earth. But the treaty was made and sent to the Sen ate. By its terms we agreed to pay within, a certain time after it should be ratified, $7,200,000 in gold. It first struck the country as one of Seward jokes,and they hardly dreamed the Senate would ratify it. But in this they were mistaken. It was hurriedly taken up, and Mr. Sumner, Chairman of the Com (Concluded on third page.)

See the clipping

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

A former House committee member recounts his 1867 report and speeches opposing the Alaska Treaty as wasteful and the land worthless, and claims Seward used a troop deployment to coerce House approval of funding. He asserts later events proved him right, calling Alaska a costly, revenue-less burden on the nation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 237 days later.

Wrong

The Kenosha Telegraph · 19 October 1871 · page 3

Sto getuvta Sekgwfli. KENOSHA, WIS., OCTOBER 19, 1871 (Concluded from second page.) uittee on Foreign Relations, became its great champion and carried it through so quick that the country had no time to think before it was announced that it was confirmed Mr. Sumner made a very long speech in favor of the acquisition, which speech showed conclusively that his knowledge *>f the country was of the most meagre and unreliable character, and such es to put any reasonable man on hi» guard. Among the who joined in confirming this treaty was my honorable friend.

See moreSee less

On the assembling of Congress iu December, it became neces sary to obtain an appropriation to pay for this purchase, and a failure to appro priate the money would have rendered the treaty null and void. A bill making the appropriation was early introduced, and referred to the Committee on Foreigu Affairs. Gen. Banks was chairman of the committee, and I had the fortune to be a member of it. General Banks was strongly in favor of the tieaty, and of the appropriation, and 1 as strongly agaiiist it. I opposed the committee to the best of my ability, taking the ground that the Senate had no right to control the action of the Hous in any case requiring an ap propriation of money. I made a lengthy report against the acquisition. I showed conclusively, and from a thorough exam ination of authorities, that the country ■was wholly without resources, barren,dis mal, worthless, and instead of its posses sions being a source of strength, it would be a source of weakness, a source of pov erty instead <f wealth. When the bill was reported and brought before the House for discussion, I made two speeches, each more than one hour in length, pro testing against any more robbery of the people as an appropriation to pay fur that job would be. I failed in my effort in defence of the people, and I can tell you why I failed. No sooner had the Senate confirmed the treaty, and before the House had sane tioned it by appropriating the money, than Seward sent Geu. Rousseau up to Alaska with a body of soldiers to take posession, and the Russian authorities retired from the countrj. This was a trick to place the House in a false posi tion, and coerce its action. It had the desired effect. Members who agreed with me, that the treaty was a fraud and the country utterly worthless, said “we are now placed in that position where we must either vote the money or offend our friend the Czar of Russia,” and upon that constraint they voted for the appropriation. Suosequent events have demonstrated the truth of all I said against the acquisition. The country is a source of no revenue, but on the con tra:y it costs us about $1,000,000 a year to keep it. In a word, it is one of the biggest elephants that ever any nation had on its hands, and if Russia would take it back on the payment of $7,000, 000 more, it would be wise to give it. Mr. Seward haviug met with such ex cellent success in buying A.aska and bringing the Senate to his support, cast around iu search of fresh fields and pas tures new, and his eyes fell upon the small and insignificant island of St. Thomas, in the (Jarribean sea, an island about the size of a township of land be longing to the Kingdom of Denmark. To make the negotiation go easy, it is said that he sent my friend out to Copenhagen, in the summer of 1867, to aid iu making the acquisition. Certain it istbat he was in Copenhagen in the summer of 1867, and if he was not there in behalf ot the State Department, he can easily say so. At any rate a treaty was negotiated about that time, agree ing to pay $7,500,000 for St. Thomas. This the public were in profound ig norance of. On the assembling of Congress in November 1867, in advance of the reg ular time, there was a rumor floating about, that such a treaty had been ne gotiated. Acting on that rumor, and btaring in mind the embarrassing posi tion we had been placed in regard to Russia, I lost no time in submitting tbe following resolution, which was adopted by a vote ot 93 to 43, and effectually gave a quietus to the purchase of that bit of real estate (which has since been swal lowed up by an earthquake), and saved to the people $7,500,000 in gold. I will take the liberty of quoting the resolution from the Congressional Globe of Novem ber 25, 1867, as well as what was said in explanation of it.

See the clipping