As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

May 1870

2 articles

The Evening Telegraph · Philadelphia, Pa.

A Cincinnati Gazette editorial criticizes the U.S. government's habit of trying to buy territory or independence, citing the Alaska purchase, the St. Thomas purchase, and Santo Domingo negotiations as examples of this 'dickering' tendency begun by Seward and Andrew Johnson. It argues this pattern embarrassed U.S. handling of the Cuban independence question by introducing a cash buyout proposal to Spain.

The Evening Telegraph · 12 May 1870 · page 6

THE CUBAN MUDDLE. From the Cincinnati Gazette. The Government of the United States in troduced into the question between Cuba and Spain the dickering feature. It gratuitously nung into ine an air me proposition tnat the Cubans should pay Spain one hundred mil lions for their independence. If the Cubans are enuuea 10 independence iney owe no money for it, not even for the publio pro peny; xor ims, so iar as 11 cose money, was paid for out of Cuban revenues. To propose to buy independence is to admit that the Cuban people have not the right to it.

See moreSee less

Our Government has a bad habit in this line of dicker. It was brought in by Democratic administrations, who were desirous to get Cuba in order to add two more States to the slave power, and who offered one hundred or two hundred millions for Cuba. It was expanded by Mr. Seward and Andy louuson in me Alaska purcnose, tne t

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The editorial criticizes a proposed government subsidy of ten million dollars for a private Pacific telegraph cable company, arguing the terms are preposterous and comparing it unfavorably to the $7.25 million Alaska purchase, which by contrast now looks like a great deal. It proposes alternative routes for a trans-Pacific telegraph line, including via Russia or the Aleutian Islands.

The New York Herald · 17 May 1870 · page 6

Alaska, it is but a short distance to the Japan islands, and thence from Jeddo another short bit of cable would conneot with Shanghae. Here, however, the objection may be interposed that the ohafing of the icebergs around

See the clipping