As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

January 1925

6 articles

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A fishing column warns that overfishing could cause Potomac black bass to vanish just as the passenger pigeon did, quoting an 1857 Ohio Senate committee report that dismissed the need to protect the pigeon. It urges a multi-year closed season to prevent bass from suffering the pigeon's fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Times · 3 January 1925 · page 19 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

By R. A. ANGLER.

The gamest of the game are making a last and d[esperate stand.] "Sounds sensational," you will say. Well, that's ex[actly my inten]tion, to excite local anglers to a pitch whereby they [will realize] it will only be a question of time before the finest sp[ort of the finny] tribes will have entirely disappeared from our waters[. So great is] the want of food that the small-mouthed black bas[s of the] Potomac are gradually, but surely, being defeated, f[or no nat]ural feeding grounds can be found in our whole Uni[on than] the broken water of the historic river.

See moreSee less

"Then what is the reason for such an alarming [condition, and] what can be done to save the brave clan," you ask[.] The foremost cause is the ever-increasing number [of followers of the] rod and reel. A few years back, before the adven[t of] good roads, only a handful of anglers trailed the gam[e and their] catches had little effect upon the vast quantity of f[ish. Today] it is an entirely different story. Every inch of th[e river is fished] for the "King of Kings" by a big army of Walto[nians from the] District as well as from nearby and outlying States.

If allowed to continue on it[s course, it] will follow in the wake of the passenger pigeon of a decade ago. Using the feathery tribe as an illustration, it was thought that, regardless of the number of hunters, the birds could never be killed off and the sport would continue on indefinitely.

In an interesting report of a select committee of the senate of Ohio, in 1857, on a bill proposed to protect the passenger pigeon, we read:

"The passenger pigeon needs no protection. Wonderfully prolific, having the vast forests of the North as its breeding grounds, traveling hundreds of miles in search of food, it is here today and elsewhere tomorrow, and no ordinary destruction can lessen them, or be missed from the myriads that are yearly produced.

"The snipe (Scalopex Wilsonii) needs no protection. * * * The snipe, too, like the pigeon, will take care of itself, and its yearly numbers can not be materially lessened by the gun."

As Ed Hawk would say, "What's the answer?" The last passenger pigeon died September 1, 1914, and Wilson snipe is a bird almost un[heard of.]

Max Carey Place On Base Th[...]

During the 19[24 season] Carey, of the Pi[rates, won] the base stealing [crown of the] National League[, having] fered forty-nine [stolen bases, and] received the [award] from Hazen Cu[ming, his team]mate, who stole th[e next highest number.] As a team the Pi[rates account]ed for more stolen b[ases than any] other club. They [stole] 181 bags. The Cu[bs stole ? ] bases and the R[eds ? ] Cards stole 86 [bases,] Giants 82.

[illegible] can be easily notic[ed by its con]stant motion.

The Small-Mouth[ Bass] The little mouth b[ass] There's red in hi[s eye] The scales extend on And his forehead i[s]

His forehead is rou[gh,] boys, And he sleeps th[e] He likes the rocks[...]

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A University of Minnesota geologist, discussing the mysterious extinction of mammoths and other Ice Age animals, cites the passenger pigeon as the only modern parallel to such disappearances. He notes that although humans slaughtered passenger pigeons by the millions, it has never been proven that this hunting alone caused their extinction.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 11 January 1925 · page 39

a disappearance In North America is that of the passenger pigeons. Man slaughtered these by the millions, but It has never been established that this carnage alone caused their final ex tinction." Dr. Stauffer Inclines to the belief that a pestilence caused the disap pearance of the mammoth, tiger and horse, although he sees no reason why all should have succumbed to the same disease, nor does he think they all passed at the same time. But they did all live at the same time, and all vanished, possibly 100.000 years ago.

See moreSee less

The horse alone repopu lated part of North America after es caping from Spanish Invaders In the sixteenth century. He then pro ceeded to flourish greatly. , Since last summer when the dis covery of several Jeffersonian ele phants In Minnesota was reported by geologists, the number has Increased to JO. Formerly only about half that number had been known In Minnesota. American elephants were visitors from far away Egypt In the first In stance, Dr. Stauffer says. From Egypt they spread to France and through out Europe and Asia, finally cross ing Behring Straits to Alaska. Thence they wandered over North America. North American types Included the mastodon and two mammoths, ele phaa, **|effersoniensls and olephas boreus. Still another type was found in South America, to which it had wandered from theNorthern contt nent. Dr. Stauffer asserts.

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

Dr. Stauffer argues climate, food loss, and even human slaughter cannot fully explain the extinction of mammoths, tigers, and horses. He compares this to the passenger pigeon, noting that although hunters killed them by the millions, this carnage alone was never proven to be the sole cause of their final extinction.

New Britain Herald · 12 January 1925 · page 14

America Is that of the passenger pigeons. Man slaughtered these by the million, but It has never been established that this carnago alone caused their llnal extinction." Pr. StaufTer Inclines to the be. lief that a pestilence caused the

See the clipping

The Omaha Morning Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A daily crossword puzzle by Richard H. Tingley includes clue 30 Down: 'An extinct pigeon,' with the answer presumably being a word for the passenger pigeon. This casual reference shows the bird's extinction had become common cultural knowledge by 1925.

The Omaha Morning Bee · 18 January 1925 · page 9

H> [<H IIARI) II. TINULEY. 29. Expire. 20. An extinct pigeon. 32. Church of England (abbr). 33. Hindu god of rain. 35. Species of willow. 37. Busy insect. 3S. So be it. 40. Mother. 41. Inclines (O one side. 43. Pertaining to one of the con tinents. 45. Fasten. 46. Musical composition. 48. No good (slang). 49. Lawful. 51. Absorb.

See the clipping

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Prof. Clinton Stauffer of the University of Minnesota discusses the mysterious extinction of mammoths, horses, and saber-toothed tigers, favoring a pestilence theory over climate or human predation. He cites the passenger pigeon as the only modern parallel, noting humans killed them by the millions though this alone may not explain their total extinction.

Brownsville Herald · 28 January 1925 · page 8

KILLED BEASTS

“The only modern parallel for such a disappearance in North America is that of the passenger pigeons. Man iiiiaugt'herfd these by the million, but it has ncv< r been established that this

See the clipping

The Anderson News · Lawrenceburg, Ky.

C.J. Meredith, speaking on game protection, recalled that an 1857 Ohio bill to protect passenger pigeons failed because legislators insisted they needed no protection. He noted the last passenger pigeon died as a result, using this alongside the destruction of buffalo, beaver, and antelope to argue for game conservation laws.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Grand Rapids Herald-Review, 31 December 1924, Grand Rapids Herald-Review, 31 December 1924, The Washington Times, 3 January 1925, The Montgomery Advertiser, 11 January 1925.

The Anderson News · 29 January 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Recalls Fate of Pigeons

NAME RICE CLUB PRESIDENT

An Anderson county sportsmen's club was organized here Thursday night with an initial membership of 50 as a result of the visit of George C. Waggoner, executive agent of the Kentucky Game and Fish Commission, and C. J. Meredith, superintendent of game wardens.

See moreSee less

Carlton Rice was elected president of the club. Walter Bond was chosen vice president and Dr. G. B. Claxon was named secretary of the organization. An effort will be made to enroll all sportsmen of the county in the club. Similar organizations have been effected in many counties of the state, 65 clubs having already been organized.

The purpose of sportsmen's clubs is to aid in the protection and distribution of game, help in securing needed legislation, create game preserves, promote more congenial relation between landlords and sportsmen Mr. Waggoner explained.

It will be the policy of the Commission to help those counties which seek through organization to help themselves. Game and fish will be distributed in counties where there is reasonable surety of its being protected, it was said.

Recalls Fate of Pigeons

C. J. Meredith, calling attention to the need for protection of game said that in 1857 a measure introduced into the Ohio legislature providing for protection of passenger pigeons was hooted at with the declaration that they needed no protection. The bill failed of passage. The last passenger pigeon died in 1894, as a result of failure to protect.

The destruction of buffalo, beaver and antelope were cited as illustrating the point that without protection such game could not survive. Fish no longer breed in streams to any considerable extent, Mr. Meredith said, due to the destruction of timber which permits freshets, high and muddy water at the spawning season, resulting in eggs being washed away. This necessitates restocking of streams from the state hatcheries he said.

Comparative figures were quoted to show how much larger the expenditure for game conservation is in other states than in Kentucky. Despite limited funds, 194,000 fish were distrib[uted]

See the clipping