The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
A newspaper Q&A feature responds to a reader asking whether all wild pigeons in the United States have been killed. The answer explains that the passenger pigeon once inhabited the eastern United States and mountains, with scattered reports in other states, confirming its near-total disappearance.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 15 December 1920 · page 6
The fruit pies of English cooks srrVhat'different K 22i 18 B to which Americans are aenerallv accustomed. They are usually made a great deal thicker and have but one crust, which is spread over the top. This does away with a soggy bottom crust so frequent In juicy pies. Served with cream, these pies are a feast ia them selves. " ' Eill a baking dish with thinly! .It. S ...1 a.. ... . ' aiiccu appica. jhiu one-tniru cup sugar and one-quarter teaspoon ' feathers on the back ot its bead, cinnamon for each six apples (which Is supposed to resemble tbe Cover dish with pie crust 'cut la j P stack behind the ear ot a' Clerk, several places f to allow steam to1 Q.
See moreSee less
Ia It true that all the wild escape. Bake la moderate oven ' pigeons la the United States have about forty minutes or unttl apples i been Wiled? IL B. R. are tenner, .serve not wit cream A., The passenger pigeon which Q. When was the word brain storm first used? H.. N. A. This term was first employed at the second trial ot Harry K. Thaw in IMS, and was used to In dicate sudden, impulsive insanity. Q. What is the secretary bird and why is it so-called? F. H. A. The secretary bird is a soaks eating bird found la the tropics and eels its name from the crest of aunnarw sa
A California reader disputes claims that wild pigeons are extinct, noting many survive in northwestern California forests. The piece clarifies the extinction claim applies only to the passenger pigeon, not the common wild pigeon, and cites an earlier report of Massachusetts hunters positively identifying a pair of passenger pigeons.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The Hartford Republican · 17 December 1920 · page 3
WILD PIGEONS IN CALIFORNIA
&- KvX 1 property was steadily enlarged. The vacillation of the United States in creased the confidence of those Mexi cans who controlled the situation. It Is a familiar story, one that, is re pletewith humiliating episodes which all Americans would like to forget. Now Alvaro Obregon becomes pres ident of Mexico after a revolution in which President Carranza' was murdered. Obregon's election was as regular as any election could be in a country whero the bulk of the popula tion have not the slightest Idea of what an election means or how to mark a ballot.
See moreSee less
The country Is phy sically at peace for the timo being and there seems to be a general feel ing of good will toward the new ex ecutive. The Mexicans are hopeful of relief from the long series of out ages perpetrated upon them by graft ers constituting their government. Obregon's promises of better govern ment have a ring of sincerity to them, and his character gives some assur ance that he will try to preserve or dr. Obregon made his revolutionary campaign as a champion of the new constitution, which contains an ar ticle seemingly subversive of land titles. The foreign Investors In Mex ico, including Americans, havo been greatly concerned over this article, since Its strict executon would shake the integrity of their investments, if not sweep them away. Tho United States Government has clearly Inti mated that it would not recognize tho Mexican government If Article XXVII were enforced in such a man ner as to destroy titles honestly ac quired. Washington Post. WILD PIGEONS IX CALIFORNIA A California reader takes the Path finder to task for saying that hunters have exterminated the wild pigeon In the-United States. There are great numbers of them in northwstern Cal fornia, ho says, and great forests that aro almost impenetrable afford them safe retreats. We nqve'r said inten tionally -at least that the cpnimon wild pigeon had become extinct; it is the passenger pigeon which onco was found here In countless numbers but which was ruthlessly slaughtered by "game hogs" that has been mourn ed by bird-lovers as extinct. As re ported in these pages a few weeks ago, Massachusetts hunters reported finding and positively identifying, a pair of these birds. Pathfinder.
A 1920 conservation article cites William B. Mershon's unearthed 1878 Michigan Sportsman's Association records, which included an early plea for protecting the passenger pigeon from market hunters. The piece laments that this warning, like others for ducks and grouse, was not heeded by lawmakers, allowing the species to go extinct.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 19 December 1920 · page 33
170,000 Deer Killed In Michigan in 1878; California Is Assuring Her Citizens Perpetuation of Game by Its Three Million Acres of Game Refuges; Conservation Should Be Taught in Schools
Conservation Should Be Taught !Bj R. I'. HOl.l.AN I" William B. .Mershon. of Saginaw. Mich.. In a letter 10 the American (tame 1'rotectlve association, tell of unearthing onic vnlu.ible data In . connection with fnirr onservnlloii in the earlv days. vnicAig which wore the printed proceedings of th Michi gan sportsman's association or five consecutive years, beginning with 1878. In the oroceedingj of Tit It was ;d vocuti d that wilil ducks be pretectal! i law and that r. !..u hi pasted pro hibiting the shipment to foreign mar kets ni ruffed arouse and venison, i rain the records of the railroad coni pani of That year II was shown thai V seyanty thousand doer were killed nU shipped from 'he sta:e of Michigan.
See moreSee less
There it.i .1 iiea for the protection of th' oamenger pigeon, showing thai FDorinmn realized I hf htvo." o : ' i eated anion? lhes bird bj the Par ke : hooters. Among the proceeding wpa an article written on the gray Hup wiiii.ii had been discovered and Identi fied dnly a few years previously. s ii n experiment, hi-ook trout had been planted In southern Michigan and a leuueist was made fo their protec tion. Mr. Mershon states in hi let ter .hat hM father planted h. first trout frv that were ever put In a Mlch iKan stream. Thev were ilanted In the head waters of the Tohacco iivor( between Parwell and Clare. This data I all ii Interesting lo thiMiortsmen of toda: who cannot IipIj) lnt regret :hat the idea for tho protection of the passenger pigeon u..s not hei-ded. no( only by the .Michigan lawmakers, bul by other states as well, MO thai this valuable species of Amer ican game could have hern preserved ?OF l ho sportsmen of future genera-j '.I Oil!". California at 'he present time has. I ougniv peaking, the equivalent or' S per i ent of her total area set aside dt Came refuges, on which no hunt ing la allowed except that conducted by the state and federal ournmeni ... in an effort io exterminate' the ver- ' - nin. Including the National parks and monuments. California now has tort) -one distinct game ic'uges. The state is responsible for the erefollow sem Conservation.
A colony of 100 trumpeter swans, long believed extinct like the passenger pigeon, was discovered in British Columbia. Canadian authorities are now protecting the site and keeping its location secret to prevent hunting.
Capital Journal · 20 December 1920 · page 9
Believed Extinct, Found in Canada Edmonton, Alta., Dec. 20. Long supposed to have shared with the passenger pigeon the fate of utter extinction, a colony of one hund red trumpeter swans has been dis covered In British Columbia.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
A Washington correspondent explains that while many believe no wild pigeons exist in the U.S., three other wild pigeon species remain, though little known. He recounts the passenger pigeon's dramatic history of blackening skies and market slaughter, noting scientists believe an unexplained factor beyond hunting caused its sudden disappearance in the 1880s.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 27 December 1920 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Washington, D. C., Dec. 27.—That there is no such thing as a wild pigeon in the United States any more is an idea which seems to be widely entertained in this country, and which is wholly erroneous, according to the ornithologists.
The fact of the matter is that the passenger pigeon, which was once phenomenally abundant in the western United States, is extinct; but there are at least three species of wild pigeon found today within the United States. All three of them are little known, despite the fact that one of them is distributed, in a sparse and scattering manner, over a good part of the West.
See moreSee less
For some reason, the wild pigeon is an object of exceptional popular interest, if one may judge by the number of questions that come to an information bureau about it, and the number of newspaper and magazine articles that have been written on the subject.
Nearly every American now knows something of the tragic and mysterious history of the passenger pigeon, which 60 or 70 years ago darkened the sky with its vast flocks, killed whole forests by using them as roosting places, and glutted American markets with its flesh. It is believed by scientists that the slaughter of the pigeons did not alone account for their complete and sudden disappearance along in the eighties, but that some other factor, which has never been explained, must have had a part in it.
All of this has been often recited. The passenger pigeon has been given a great deal of publicity, while the other American wild pigeons are almost unknown to the general public.
ANOTHER WILD PIGEON.
The most important of these is the band-tailed pigeon, which occurs in a scattered and unaccountable way all over the Rocky Mountain country and west to the Pacific coast. The center of abundance
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
This 1920 article reflects on the passenger pigeon's extinction, describing its nesting habits and migratory behavior in search of acorns. It draws parallels to other extinct flightless or vulnerable island birds like the dodo and the solitaire, explaining how isolation from predators led to physical traits that made them easy prey for human hunters.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 27 December 1920 · page 4
f«M*r killed it with dure and ate .t «iown on L j The last of »he birds ws* with great gusto the 17th . enturv, but the« sre j killt'd in j ot i», and also saeieton*. written records of its near relative, to* The same is true l„vJG., which ws« much like it. though solitaire, wbic ««mailer and a trifle quicker on it* teet. sc« that it survived a few years longer. Pigeons live chieflv on «Lan as been use islands are generally'fw« of the predatory amauls which destroy auch ■ '«reit igec., i are eaady killed, wnue , stupid, a at «xe always po«irIy huiden.
See moreSee less
I their nests a . Austreii*, where | the tropical islands in '■ thev most abound, pi^eo i* nearly «.way* , S five in tree*, and their only enemies are ■ 1 hawks. It is interesting to note that taeae ; tropical pigeon» nearly always are green , j or greet ash m color above, so that the , not see them among »he .eevea. i h«W.. . . , . .. . , 1 On the other ;iaud, »hy Nona \mt. ca t 1 pgeons and dove*, whicn apena % In
This Washington report explains that the passenger pigeon is extinct, though other lesser-known wild pigeon species still exist in the U.S. It claims scientists believe slaughter alone cannot explain the pigeon's sudden disappearance in the 1880s, suggesting an unexplained mystery factor was involved.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Indiana Daily Times · 27 December 1920 · page 9
MILLIONS OF WILD PIGEONS DARKENED SKY
Famous Passenger Bird Unsolved Mystery. WASHINGTON, D. C.—That there la no such thing as a wild pigeon In the United States any more is an idea which seems to be widely entertained In this country, and which Is wholly erroneous, according to the ornithologists. The fact of the matter is that the pas senger pigeon, which was once phe nomenally abundant In the western United States, Is extinct; but there are at least three species of wild pigeon found today within tho United States. All three of them are little known, de spite the fact that one of them Is dis tributed, in a sparse and scattering man ner, over a good part of the West.
See moreSee less
For some reason, the w ild pigeon is an object of exceptional popular interest, if one may Judge by the number of ques tions that come to an Information bureau about it. and the number of newspaper and magazine articles that have been written on tlie subject. Nearly every American now knows something of tbe tragic and mysterious history of (he passenger pigion, which sixty or seventy years ago darkened the sky with Its vast flocks, killed whole forests by using them as roosting places, and glutted American markets with Its flesh. It Is believed by scientists that the slaughter of the pigeons did not alone account for their complete and sud deut disappearance along in the eighties, but that some other factor, which has never been explained, must have had a part In it. All of this has been often recited. The passenger pigeon has been given a great ileal of publicity, while the other Ameri can wild pigeons are almost unknown to the general public.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
A Washington letter disputes that the passenger pigeon is truly extinct, suggesting a rare, shy wild pigeon species persists in the Florida Keys. It frames the belief in total extinction as 'wholly erroneous.'
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 27 December 1920 · page 6
Washington D.C Dae. That there la no such thing as a wild pigeon ia the Catted States any more is an idea which seems to no aad which la wholly erroneous, cording . . . . . . . . 1. . , - M . W I A tklwl tell J i II. a,- J .k ht Ik. It.jtul S..4 over a good part of the west. is a tare For some reason, the wild pireon qualities. the number of newsoaner and mar aslne articles that hare been written of living creatures, on the subject Nearly every American now knows something of the tragic aad mysterious history of the passen ger pigeon, which60 or 70 years ago darkened the sky with its vast Bocks, killed whole forests by using them as roosting places, aad glutted American markets with its flesh.
See moreSee less
It is believed by scientists that tbe slaughter of the pigeons did not alone account for their com plete and sudden disappearance other factor, which baa never been explained, must have had a part; in it All of this has beea often recited. ' The passenger pigeon has been given a great deal of publicity, while the other American wild pigeons are almost unknown to the general public. The most Important of these is the band-failed pigeon, which oc curs in a scattered and unaccount able way all over the Rocky moun tain country and west to the Pacific coast The center of abundance is said to be at the mouth of the Col umbia river and people who live in that section are probably familiar with the birds, but . most persons, even in states where they are found, never saw one. The band-tailed nixeon is a true pigeon. It is a good deal more like the average man s idea of a pigeon than the passenger pigeon was, be cause n belongs to the same genus as the domestic pigeon. Wa have seen this bird and it looks exactly like a big blue domestic pigeon. It coos the same way,, and when it rises makes the same loud clapping sound with the wings, ; It has the very peculiar habit of carrying its light nest of twigs with it when frightened during the nesting sea son. This sounds fabulous, but is attested by government scientists. It grasps the nest and eggs between the legs. Sometimes merely a single egg is carried in this way. This pigeon has a way of Appear ing suddenly in large flocks where good crops o? acorns, ibs favorite WildPis a bird may appear. 1 1 onalitlea. longer. their environment
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The item answers public curiosity about the once-abundant passenger pigeon, noting it is now scarce and found scattered across the West. It describes related wild pigeon species and pigeons' adaptability to environment.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 27 December 1920 · page 6
Down in the Keys of Florida n more is an idea which seems to no have another wild pigeon WT? aad which la wholly erroneous, to the ornithologists. I rare, and extremely shy, u nl J. cording ict of the matter la that the being that it is one ot th ! too tact or tne manor is ins m.woi wai it is one or tt,. rou, aha will passenger pigeon, which was once ; toothsome of birds. A native hYZ to right the i nhnntnnlTv shnndant In the $ West told ns laat w- .
See moreSee less
-""; . - , , . 1 1 ' ' tnaiisr.1 . . . . . . . . 1. . , - M . W I A tklwl tell J i tne unitea duuct. aiiuuetoiuw"" uuiu wua pigeon cobub II. a,- J .k ht Ik. It.jtul S..4 mrm uiue uvwn, unpnv iu. i vu.vw awuv along' rs. j that f h (atrltwitMl in : Brands on tha i , a sparse and scattering manner,) is called the rtd-billed Birtm'J ls a large bird ot exceUehS over a good part of the west. is a tare For some reason, the wild pireon qualities. 1 1 onalitlea. is an object or exceptional popular; Pigeons are distributed all m Interest if one may Judge by the, the world, and they tut a Z number of questions that come to ! Interesting study, because thirl, aa information bureau about it and j lustrate so aptly the way inWuI environment affects the cereimL the number of newsoaner and mar the develops, aslne articles that hare been written of living creatures,
A syndicated Q&A column by Frederic J. Haskin explains that while the passenger pigeon is extinct, other wild pigeon species still exist in the US, contrary to popular belief. It recaps the passenger pigeon's history of once-vast flocks and notes scientists believe slaughter alone doesn't explain its sudden disappearance in the 1880s.
Hj f'mlortc J. Haskin. WASHINGTON. D. C., Dec. 24 ! That there Is no such thing as a wilt ] pigeon in the I’nited States any mori ' is an idea which seems to be widely entertained in this country, ant which is wholly erroneous, accordlnj to the ornithologists. The fact of>the matter is that thi passenger pigeon, which was onc< phenomenally abundant in th< western t’nited States, is extinct; bn: there are at least three species ol wild pigeons found today within the fnited States. All thrae of them are little known, despite the fact tiiai one of them is distributed, in a sparse and scattering manner, ovei a good part of the West.
See moreSee less
For some reason, the wild pigeon is an object of exceptional populai interest, if one may judge by the number of questions that come to an information bureau about it, me the number of newspaper and mag azine articles that have been written on the subject. Nearly every American now knows something of the tragic and myste rious history of the passenger pig eon, which 60 or 70 years ago dark ened the sky with its vast flocks, killed whole forests by using them as roosting places, and glutted American markets with its flesh. It is believed by scientists that the slaughter of the pigeons did not alone account for their complete and sudden disappearance along In the eighties, but that some other factor, which has never been explained, must have had a part in it. .an ot inis lias oeen orten recited. The passenger pigeon lias been given a great deal of publicity, w'hile the oth»r American wild pigeons are al most unknown to the general public. Another Wild Pigeon The most important of these is the band-tailed pigeon, which occurs In a scattered and unaccountable way all over the Rocky Mountain coun try and west to the Pacific Coast. The center of abundance Is said to be at the mouth of the Columbia River, and people who live in that section are probably familiar with the birds, but most persons, even in states where they are found, never saw one. The band-tailed pigeon is a true pigeon. It is a good deal more like the average man's idea of a pigeon than the passenger pigeon was, be cause. it belongs to the same genus as the domestic pigeon. We have seen this bird, and it looks exactly like a big blue domestic pigeon, it coos the same way, and when it rises makes the same loud rtapplng sound with the wings. It has the very pe culiar habit of carrying its light nest of twigs with it when frightened during the nesting season. This sounds fabulous, but is attested by Government scientists. It grasps the nest and eggs between the legs. Sometimes merely a single egg is carried in this way. This pigeon has a way of appear ing suddenly in large flocks where good crops of acorns, its favorite food, are found. For years after ward. if there are few acorns, not a bird may appear. Down in the Keys of Florida they have another wild pigeon known as the white-crowned pigeon. It is rare and extremely shy, the reason being that it is one of the most toothsome of birds. 'A native in Key West told us last winter that luring the tourist season as high as three dollars each is paid for the birds. It probably has n hard life. A third wild pigeon conies into the United States along the Rio Grande on the Mexican border. It is called the red-billed pigeon, and is a large bird of excellent table qualities. Pigeons are distributed all over the world, and they make a most in teresrting study, because they illus trate so aptly the way in which en vironment affects the development of living creatures. Thus, it is not generally known that the dodo was a great flightless pigeon. In fact, although the word dodo has become a part of our slang, very few people know what it means. Tlic Death of the Dodo The dodo was as big as a swan, and could no more fly than an os trich; yet it was a true pigeon. It developed its peculiar physical char acteristics because it lived in certain islands of the South Seas, where it had no natural enemies. It grew large, fat, clumsy and flightless, be cause it had no necessity for being otherwise. It suddenly acquired some enemies when the Dutch dis covered the island of Mauritius, which was its home. The Dutch sail ors ran It down on foot, killed it with clubs, and ate it with great gusto. The last of the birds was killed In the seventeenth century, but there are written records of it, and also skeletons. The same is true of its near relative, the solitaire, which was much like it, though smaller and a trifle quicker on its feet, so that It survived a few years longer. Figeons live chiefly on islands, because islands are generally free of the predatory animals which destroy such birds. Pigeons are stupid and are easily killed, while their nests are always ptforly hidden. In the tropical islands in Australia, where they most abound, pigeons nearly al. ways live in trees, and their only enemies are hawks. It is interesting to note that these tropical pigeons nearly always are green or greenish in color above, so that the hawks cannot see them among the leaves. On the other hand, the North Amer ican pigeons and doves, which spend