A reader asks what became of the once-abundant North American wild pigeons. The answer explains they were hunted to extinction due to being easy prey and valued as food.
The Topeka State Journal · 1 March 1920 · page 4
the reception In her home, which foliowsT W. A. ti. A. If she goes direct to the reception and does not change her dress she should still wear th veil. It. of course, would not be worn with any other dres. Q. What became of the North American wild pigeons that used to be so numerous? K. K.
This sports column about overfishing of big-mouth bass in Virginia warns that the species is being driven to extinction through illegal netting and trapping. It invokes the passenger pigeon, wild turkey, and brook trout as prior examples of species lost to similar negligence.
The Richmond Virginian · 3 March 1920 · page 4
EXTERMINATING THE BASS
ually, but surely, being exterminated What a pity to see this real game, fish, who furnishes so many happyl days to the angler of the fly rod, the casting rod. and the cane pole with its lively smelt, going the wav of lb passenger pigeon, the wild turkey sad
A reader asks what became of the North American wild pigeons that used to be so numerous, and the answer begins by noting they once existed in such numbers that their combined weight was remarkable, though the text cuts off before completing the explanation. This is a brief entry within a general newspaper 'question and answer' advice column covering many unrelated topics.
Rock Island Argus · 10 March 1920 · page 6
Cuba? R. T. A. It is about ninety miles and the trip is made by boat in from six to seven hours. The fare is about $20, which on some boats in cludes one meal. Q. What is meant when It is said that gold is cheap? H. C A. Gold is exactly the same price an ounce that it was before the war. Its price was set decades ago by international agreement at $20.67 an ounce. It is still at that price. It la therefore cheap . as compared with silver, copper, lead and other metals that have in creased in value gTeatly under the influence of war.
See moreSee less
Q. What became of the North American wild pigeons that used to be so numerous? R. E. A. These pigeons, which used to be so numerous that the weight of forests where they rooated. are now extinct. They were such easy prey to the hunter and so attractive from food standpoint that they have How many otPreauUnt JrTU-Help,"
This is an obituary for an early Wisconsin settler who arrived in 1836, recounting his life, family, and pioneer-era memories. Among his recollections of frontier wildlife, he remembered flights of wild pigeons so vast they darkened the sun.
Grant County Herald · 10 March 1920 · page 1
Bear, deer and wolves abounded and when going home from mill late at night he w’as often followed by wolves. The flight of wild pigeons which darkened the sun were one of the wonders of nature which he could recall. He resided on the farm near Jamestown until fifty-two years ago when he moved to Lancaster to the home near the southern limits of the city where he lived for more than forty years. He had married March 3, 1863, Miss Emily E. Cook of Ba tavia, New York. She died in Sep tember. 1868, leaving him with two little daughters, Emma (Mrs. Harry
An editorial argues Alaska needs stronger game law enforcement to prevent extermination of moose, sheep, and caribou. It invokes the extinction of the American bison, fur seal, and passenger pigeon as historical warnings of what unchecked hunting can do.
Douglas Island News · 12 March 1920 · page 4
LAWS FOR ALASKA
not strange? "When the laat mooae. the la*' iheep and the laat caribou falla tt> wasteful hunters, what will feed the hungry white man muahing over the long trails of the Interior? There may be those In Alaska and Canada who scoff at the Idea that all the caribou may be killed, but we ask them to remember the millions ot the American bison, the fur seal, and the billions of passenger pigeon."
Greenbrier Independent · Lewisburg, Va. W. Va. · and 1 other paper
Canadian conservationists are pushing for a large wild-bird preserve along Lake Erie's north shore to protect wild fowl and insectivorous birds. They warn that without action these species could become as extinct as the wild pigeon.
Greenbrier Independent · 12 March 1920 · page 6
Bird Preserve Planned. The proposal to establish an exten sive wild-bird preserve on the north ern shore of Lake Erie is gaining wide favor in Canada. Something must be done at once, it is urged by bird lov ers, to preserve the wild fowl and in sectivorous birds, or they will be come as extinct a? the wild pigeon. There are strict game regulations in the province, but the establishment of a largo preserve would assist the leg islation. There is already a nucleus of the proposed area In Rondean park, and It is planned to extend this along the lake shore west for 30 miles.
The Ocala Evening Star · Ocala, Fla. · 20 March 1920
The News Scimitar · Memphis, Tenn.
A reader asks what became of the once-numerous North American wild pigeons, and the column answers that they have been entirely exterminated. It attributes their extinction to being easy prey for hunters and valuable as food.
The News Scimitar · 16 March 1920 · page 6
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
(J. Who WM Hoy let M A. D. A You probably refer to Kdmond Hoyle. tinKnglishmun, who in 171J published "A Short Treatise on the .,,,,. i,Rin, iii,i , in, M saliva been the recognized authority on that game, ne wrote other hooks on nth games, and 'according to Hoyle" is still a laminar pnrase around the world. Q. When a marriage lakes place In a i hurcli should the bride wear her veil at the reception m her home winch loo low? VV. A. U A. If she goes direct to the recaption and does not change her dre-A she should still wear the veil.
See moreSee less
It, of course, would not be worn with any other dregs. IJ. What became of the North Amer ican wild pigeons that used to be so numerous? r. k a. Those pigeons which usetl to be so numerous that the weight of them broke down the trees of Iho forests where they roosted are now extinct. They were such easy prey to the burner end io attractive ir.uu a ind standpoint that they have been entirely extermi
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
A report on the American eagle's decline recalls that the passenger pigeon, once found in incredible numbers, was utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and destruction of its nests. The museum uses this precedent to argue for federal protection of the eagle before it meets the same fate.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 27 March 1920 · page 7
Recalling the fact that the wild pigeon, formerly found in incredible numbers in certain parts of the United States, had been "utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the destruction of its nests" the museum says that only the prompt passage of a Federal law will save the American eagle from the same fate. Carolina assembly called for Judy. But Delaware remains their major hope for effecting ratification of the amendment in time to insure nation wide suffrage in the coming primaries. BUILDING PERMITS. Building permits aggregating $20 6, 783 were granted at last night's meet
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
This Arizona hunting report describes quail and dove shooting near the Gila River, mentioning that Sonora pigeons or White-Winged Doves are 'direct descendants' of the extinct passenger pigeon. The bulk of the piece details a quail hunt with a skilled setter named Ben in the Salt River Valley's maize fields.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 27 March 1920 · page 15
BY V TftM MARSHALL the ordinance should be repealed obviating the possibility of some visiting women being incarcerated in the bastile should she overplay her hand in dress extremes. A timely warning. Indians have donned wearing ap parel and become the "hewexs of wood and carriers of water." -They are the cotton pickers of the Salt River Valley, annually delivering over 50.000 bales of Americau Long staple cotton formerly grown only iu the valley of the Nile, Egypt, to American markets. Gov ernment construction of Roosevelt Dam made this production possible.
See moreSee less
Milo-maize, plumed corn of Ari zona, bearing a kernel about the size of a small pea, is bountifully produced in that section. Sonora pigeons or White "Winged Doves, di rect descendants of our extinct passenger pigeons, pre-empt the maize fields as feeding grounds, as sisted by the valley and mountain quail, fields are frequently de vastated. The Valley quail with his colorings of blue, white and brown, is a voracious little plumed knight. His selected foods make his flesh a culinary delicacy. As shooting guest of w. B. Twitchell and M. P. De Mund of Phoenix, I visited and shot in the maize fields near the Gila River, about 50 miles south west of Phoenix between Buckeye and Gila Bend, where little shoot ing had been done. Valley quail were abundant On the side hills ithey could be seen dancing. Jump ing, playing and chanting their plaintive little past'me call. Twitchell owned an English setter Ben who was an acknowl edged expert on valley quail hunt ing. He knew their habits, pecul iarities and haunts. Entering a maize field he would jump, bark and run in every direction, flush ing and putting the birds awing, Alighting, they would road a short distance, hide beneath a brush, where they would lay to the dog. It was at this stage of the hunt that "Ben" got in his artistic work, making some beautiful points, then flushing and retrieving at com mand. Ouessing distance and ac curately reading the flight velocity of a valley quail is a work cut out for real scatter gun artists only. Liberal allowance of daylight must
A sporting article about quail and dove hunting in the Gila River valley near Phoenix mentions in passing that Sonora pigeons or white-winged doves are 'direct descendants' of the extinct passenger pigeon. The piece is primarily about a hunting excursion with English setters and valley quail, with the passenger pigeon reference being incidental.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
El Paso Herald · 27 March 1920 · page 16
BY valley, an anally deliver! ns: o.soo bales or American long cotton formerly grown only in .Hey of the Nile. Egypt, to :an markets. Government eon- : structlon of Roosevelt dam made this production possible. MHo-maize, plumed earn of Ari zona, bearing a kernel abottt the size ofa small pea. is bountifully pro duced in that section. Sonera pigeons or white winged doves, direct de scendants of our extinct passenger, pigeons, pre-empt the maize, fields as feeding grounds, assisted by the val ley and mountain cualL fields are frequently devastated. The valley Quail with his colorings of bine, white and brown, is a voracious little plumed knight.
See moreSee less
His selected foods make bis flesh a culinary delicacy. Aa shooting guest of W. B. Twitchell and X. P. De Mund. of Phoenix. I visited and shot in the maize fields near the Gila river, about M miles southwest of Pboealx. between Back eye and Gila Bend, where little shoot ing had been done. Valley quail were abundant. On the aide hills they could be seen dandnc lumslne. playing and chanting their plaintive little pastime can. Twitch ell owned an English setter "Bee" who was an acknowledged expert on vauey quzll hunting. He knew their habits, peculiarities and haunts. Bntertes a stage of the hunt that "Ben" got in his artistic work, making some beau tifuj points, then flashing and re trie vin at command. Guessing dis tance and accurately reading the flight velocity of a valley quail Is a work cut out for real scatter gun artists only. Liberal allowance of daylight must be Injected ahead of a cross flight hard Or resells are very nn satisfactory. Nature has ed ucated the valley quail as expert surgeons for personal and team work. It wounded by shot driving the feathers Into a flesh wound, their flock mates take the ease, extracting the Imbedded feathers and relieving the pain. Valley quail .are credited annually with three broods of ap proximately 14 birds each nesting Arizona weather conditions govern the amount of birds to be found. One objectionable feature occasionally experienced In quail hunting is .the eastlnet solo, or warning of the ranch despised rattler. When heard. th seasoned hunter refuses to move un til the cause Is located and removed A rattlesnake will commit harl-kar by biting and Injecting the poison
A 1920 American Museum of Natural History statement warns that the bald eagle faces extinction from unregulated hunting in Alaska, unless federal protection is enacted. It invokes the passenger pigeon, noting the once-abundant bird was 'utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the destruction of its nest' as a cautionary precedent.
The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 27 March 1920 · page 7
Recalling the fact that the wild pigeon. formerly found in incredible numbers m certain parts of the United States, had been "utterly wired out by unrestricted shooting and the destruction of its nest the museum savs that only the pr.Mnnt iasace of a federal law will save the American eagle from the same fate.
A museum report on eagle hunting in Alaska for bounty payments cites the passenger pigeon as a precedent, noting the once-abundant bird was 'utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the destruction of its nests.' The museum argues swift federal protection is needed to prevent eagles from suffering the same fate.
The Wheeling Intelligencer · 27 March 1920 · page 2
I eagle pre} s> chiefly . ? . : lar-e rodents I harmful to farm crops, for t in: control j Iff which the governni' nt annually e\- ( Tends l.irg-' sum.-., tlo museum d.- iares . i that "tales of the Ann rn-.n, . age's dci Ft mot i veneps to game or d'Oiiesii*: ant-; ma Is are fur the greater part pure fiei tion." The bird, it says. i.? migratory : i nnd therefore no stal" or territory can > claim the right to destroy it. Miat rig'.U being \estej in tinI-Ydera!
See moreSee less
government. He. ailing thfact tM.it t wild pigeon, formerty found !n inr.'dibl.- ! ! numbers in certain parts of the r ni<d (Slates, had be. n "utterly wiped out by I unrestricted shooting and th? d?-stru>;- | ! tion of its n.-sts " the niUF' iini says tliai j only t lie prompt pas-ag. of (?"??d-rtii [law will siO'' the Ann rican < agb. front I (!i< sa infat ? .
The American Museum of Natural History invoked the passenger pigeon's extinction by unrestricted shooting and nest destruction as a cautionary precedent while urging federal protection for the American eagle. The pigeon reference serves as historical proof that unregulated hunting can wipe out even once-abundant species.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 28 March 1920 · page 5
the federal government. Recalling the fact that the wild pigeon, formerly found in incredible numbers in certain parts of the Up'ited States, had been “utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the destruction of its nests,” the museum says that only the prompt passage of a federal law will save tbe American eagle from xne same fate. ,
A 1920 hunting report from Arizona describes white-winged doves (Sonora pigeons) as 'direct descendants of our extinct passenger pigeons' while recounting a quail-shooting expedition near the Gila River. The piece focuses mainly on valley quail hunting with a skilled setter, cotton production, and local tourism scenes in Phoenix.
jid h -T HERE.-I'LL - 1 HERE WWN Lo the poor Idian! The progressive and cosmopolitan city of Phoenix, Ari zona, located in the Salt River valley, has been called home by the nomadic tribes of Indians from time immemo rial. , Remnants of once powerful na tionS"are now found Apaches, Nava jos, sPimas, Maricopas and Sacatons are 4H in evidence, originally attracted by equitable climatic conditions which enabled them to dispense with outer garments. Buckskin was worn as a base",upon which beads and gaudy or naments were attached. At times those decorations became burdensome and.
See moreSee less
'they appeared upon the Phoenix streets on ponies or following drag cart3 with insufficient clothing to flag a. bread wagon. The paleface arose in righteous indignation legislating agaiijst their copper colored visitors. Cityj-solons passed an ordinance pro hibiting visiting bucks from appearing en deshbille on the streets, requiring then? to wear shirts and trousers. Squaws must be gowned with a front -ut of the dress not lower than the arm pits above -or higher than the knees below. Public appearance in war : paint was not permitted. The passing of this penalty bearing ordin ance necessitated a stop at the city limits by all Indians with an exhibi tion of lightning clothing change work. There has never been a test case under this ordinance. It is certainly uncon stitutional as it carries no reservations being emphatically class legislation. On a recent visit to Phoenix women tourists) were conspicuous . in hotels and cafes decorated in war paint of modern manufacture - and wearing rcwits abbreviated at both top and bottom, leaving little for the imagina tion.;: The police wickedly winked at this flagrant transgression of their original . ordinance which modern gowns and artistic hand painting have relegated to the discard against the t'jotost of squawdom. If obsolete 'the ordinance should be repealed obviat 'ng Jhe possibility pf some visiting tveman being incarcerated In the ba nile should she overplay her hand In iressSextremes. . A timely warning. Indians have' donned ' wearing ap f arel and become the "hewers of wood and Carriers of water." They are the cotton pickers of the Salt River valley, annually delivering over 50.000 bales of American long staple cotton former ly grown only in the valley of the Nile; KgypL to American markets. Government-construction of Roosevelt dam made'this production possible. Milo maize, plumed corn of Arizona, bearing a kernel about the size of a small, pea. is bountifully produced in that section. - Sonora pigeons or white winged doves, direct descend unts bf our extinct passenger pigeons, pre-empt the maize fields as feeding mingham. Ala.- ' '
An article advocating federal protection for the bald eagle in Alaska references the passenger pigeon's extinction as a cautionary precedent. It notes the pigeon was wiped out by unrestricted shooting and nest destruction before the public recognized the need for protection.
Evening Star · 28 March 1920 · page 9
PLEA FOR FEDERAL LAW TO PROTECT AMERICAN EAGLE
Much has beta written In deprecation of the permitted extermination of the wild pigeon. Formerly found Inal most Incredible number* In some parts of the United States, the species was utterly wiped out. It Is asserted, by unrestricted tkMtlnc and the de struction of its nests. And to rapid was the prooess of Its extinction that the bird had vanished before the pub lic realised its need Of protection. A similar fate, it Is claimed, now threatens the "American." or bald, eagle, our national emblem and one of the most beautiful and magnificent Of ?\ir native birds. And, by a curious irony, the destruction Is being: ac complished at public expense, as pro vided In the bounty law passed by
The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla. · and 1 other paper
A museum report warns the American eagle faces extinction from unregulated hunting and bounty killing in Alaska. It invokes the passenger pigeon's historical fate—wiped out by unrestricted shooting and nest destruction—as a warning of what could happen without federal protection.
The Pensacola Journal · 28 March 1920 · page 7
IS FAST PASSING
Recalling the fact that the wild pigeon, formerly found in incrcdiable numbers in certain parts of the Unit ed States, had been "utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the de struction of its nests" the museum says that only the prompt passage ot a le eral law; will save the American eagle from the same fate.
The Ocala Evening Star · Ocala, Fla. · 3 April 1920
Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
The report recalls that the wild passenger pigeon, once found in immense numbers across the United States, was completely wiped out by indiscriminate hunting and destruction of its nests. It uses this precedent to argue for a federal law to prevent the American eagle from suffering the same fate.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 28 March 1920 · page 41
vrn men ? IteeailiuK lipfact that .lie wild pigeon. formerly I-hjiiiI :n im edible "timbers in ? rtt::i naris of t!??- I niteil St lies, has been "utter.v wiped out by iiMe.-tri I ? ooling ana the destruc tion ot ts -..-I? " f S, n I 11M-1M11 fit.. S tiiat only protiipl |i>ia'.,- of a I'ederal :a\V will >a\i tile \ liie.' l -IUl little I'rolH the .same fate.
A museum report warns that unregulated bounty hunting in Alaska is decimating the American eagle population, with over 5,600 killed in months. It cites the passenger pigeon's total extermination through unrestricted shooting and nest destruction as a cautionary precedent, urging federal protection law.
The Barre Daily Times · 29 March 1920 · page 6
ment Recalling the fact that the wild pigeon, formerly found in incredible numbers in certain parts of the United States, had been ''utterly wiped out by unrestricted shooting and the destruc tion of its nests" the mqxeum says that only the prompt passage of a federal law wil save the American eagle from the same fate,
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
The report describes Alaska's bounty law that paid fifty cents per eagle, noting museum experts say five thousand have already been killed and the species is nearing extinction. It draws a moral parallel to the passenger pigeon, lamenting that the wild pigeon was killed off foolishly before anyone acted to save it.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 30 March 1920 · page 4
SAVE THE EAGLE. From the public information bureau of the We killed off otir wild pigeons foolishly and! OUR DAMAGED RAILWAYS. The iystam of the country adequate to its needs. .f
A 1920 hunting feature describes bird hunting near Phoenix, Arizona, including white-winged doves that the writer claims are direct descendants of the extinct passenger pigeon. The piece focuses mainly on valley quail hunting with a skilled setter named Ben.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.
Wrong
The News Scimitar · 30 March 1920 · page 16
On a recent visit to Phoenix women OnnrlalKl were ccliMlit UOUS 111 hotels and cats decorated m war paint of apjern manufactun and wearing gown abbreviated ni both t ind bottom, leaving little for the Imagination The po.ice wickedly winked nt this flagrant ion 01 llieir original oruuiuu the hastile should she overplay hei hand In dress extremes. A timely warning Indians vmuzoa. InOlrar.s 'njr.e rtrTtert i-e.iT.:g alparel and become the ' hewers ot wood and carriers of water" They are the , i ton pickers of the Silt river valley, annually delivering v.r rei.cna hai.s American long staple .
See moreSee less
..Men, f..nt'v grown only In th" valley of tie i! Egypt, to American markets, liuvern ment construction of 11 velt dam made this produc'imi possible. sQlo-malxe, pltmiei! corn of Arizona, bearing a kernel about tin slxe of a small pea, is botmtlfur.y produced in that section. Honora pigeons or whit, winged do'e. direct dcsccin! int.- of tm extinct passenger pigeons, pre-empt the matea fields as feeding grounds, assist