As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1919

10 articles

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

A letter writer describes seeing a flock of birds in August 1919 that he and others identified as wild pigeons, triggering memories of massive passenger pigeon flocks from his childhood decades earlier. He recounts pioneer stories of pigeons destroying crops and being hunted with old flintlock guns.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Grant County Herald · 5 November 1919 · page 3

WILD PIGEON CONTROVERSY. To any Badger: I see that some people are stirred at a statement of Mr. Frank Tebo, who reports seeing a flock of wild pigeons. I. myself, was feeding a separator when Mr. Tebo said. “See that flock of birds.” Mr. J. L. Bishop said: They are wild pigeons!” The vision of my mind was brought back to over forty years ago as familiar as though it were yesterday. That same old ; flight, motion, and flip of the wings ' were again brought back to me on 'Aug.

See moreSee less

21st, 1919. I How well does it bring to my mem -1 ory. when a lad of but ten years of age, I sat by the fireside listening to old pioneers telling of the pigeons that fell upon their fair lands, telling how they dove down upon newly sown wheat and seemed to roll over the I ground in one direction. Telling how they got old Buck and Bright, the old yoke of cattle and replanted their grain. Then hitching on a brush and dragging it in again. The next day at daybreak they were on their ground with their old flintlock gun to meet the intruders and have a fat pie for breakfast, I. myself, have a gun, “Old Black Hawk,” which my grandfather bought from Daniel Boone’s nephew for a guinea. My grandfather brought it from Missouri to Galena and to the mines at Beetown. He told me that that gun had killed more pigeons than four yoke of oxen could pull. I, myself, could hardly believe my eyes when I saw that same old dark brown figure flipping their wings and flying as in days of yore.

See the clipping

Martinsburg W VA Evening Journal · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A Chillicothe, Ohio dispatch claims wild pigeons long believed extinct are being sighted in increasing numbers, suggesting the species may be recovering. Two local men are cited as having gone on a pigeon hunting trip to Michigan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Martinsburg W VA Evening Journal · 7 November 1919 · page 6

not une,j in coal trun'poriat'on In the past, the buu-au advises,,') advises, too may contracts have boon held until later in the year an material supplies have not been started moving during the 1"'“ ' when the car *upp‘> a' :ts a** mum. WILD PIGEONS INCREASING. rhillieothe, Ohio, Nov , -Tin* "poorman’s meat" a pioneer da> is coming back. V, il l pigpon^, eng believe ! extinct in Ohio, are report ed to be coming hack in good.y numbers if afforded pr - cet. n .or sufficient time to p-rnrit their nu'n be-s to increase they may again ..

See moreSee less

vc to Jolt thL -th cost of . ving. Mr Ear] J. Zimmerman. 'in - . u> and Mr. ' " Howard. Bed inuton motored to Honiney ur! 1 ■ t-r points where • v hav, .. a hunting tup M chigan .land, first r. ' e v 1 i;c of its lumber Alfri d the On • h : h id • :1 • " ; fir • tier' in '>

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This retrospective account traces the rise of American game conservation laws and societies from the late 1800s, crediting sportsmen and 'Forest and Stream' magazine for reforms. It notes that live passenger pigeons, now extinct, were once netted and used as targets in trap-shooting competitions before the practice was condemned in 1880.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 54 days earlier.

The Sun · 12 November 1919 · page 20

GUN NEWS ered to the claimant, who la allowed 10 daya in which to appeal; reducing from IS to 6 houra tha tlmo within which notice of the killing of a deer in defence of cropa muat bo given to the nearest flah and game warden; providing for the eatab. tlahment, around commercial orcharda hav ing an area of 10 acrea or more, of open jonea within which deer may be killed at any tlmo. but providing that no claim for damago by deer to orcharda within open aonea ahall be allowed, nnd requiring that the killing of a deer within an open ion ahall bo Immediately reported to the nwne.

See moreSee less

of tho orchard and to the neare.it llsh am, gamo wnrden; preacrlblng a 110 bounty on black beara killed within the State from Way 1 to November 1. formed. Pome famous sportsmen of the dv organized a society to advocate the pass lng of suitable gume laws, and the en forcement of such laws when pamed, an i to promote a healthy publlo opinion In relation to gnmo protection. "The names of these men should not he forgotten. Among them wore Henr' W Herbert, James Harper, Recorder Hackett Charles E. Whitehead. Ilnval 1'liAin. n.i,. Ltrt B. Roosevelt, Charlea Hanks and'uiany f others. Tho nsjoclatlon did a great pre paratory work. It Is still In existence. "Game laws then were few and were lightly regarded. Up to about 18S0, It was the practlco to shoot woodcock In the sum. mrr, the open aenson beginning July 4 when tho downy young were Just able to fly, ' "In thoso days annual conventions wer held by the New York State Asoclatlon at which the chief Attractions were the shooting of live pigeons from a trap. Fome times tho birds used In thewe competition" wero netted wild or passenger pigeon a species now extinct. "In 1880 the "Korest and ftream roi. demned this practice, and though tne at tack excited some Indlgatlon, the "Forei nnd Stream" carried Its point and put an end to the buslnm. This. I think, ws the first step taken -In this country M sportsmen to stop he practice of shoolni: released live pigeons as u test of tklil "'Forest and Stream' also attacked spring shooting and summer shooting, and In some States laws wero passed forbidding spring shooting. Yet some of lhe were afterward repealed, und there were (sit permanent laws forbidding this practice until somo years later. "A successful fight Tor conservation tlm was famous more than thirty years aro vas cnrrled on In 'Forest and Stream' in protect tho Yellowstone National ParU from being exploited for the prlvato profit of a small group of men. "In 1884 and 18SS the growing uv ot native birds In millinery decoration, anl their consequent wholesale d"struction, was combated by naturalists und sportf. men nllke. In 18S6 'Forest and Strr,m' founded the Audubon Society for the pro. tectlon of birds and supported it for som jears. The society, under the enfrr.ti, direction of William Dutcher, became am! (s now, a tremenodus forco for concern, tlon. "." 6ta,m,e ear the American Or. nlthologlsts Union drew up a model law for non-game birds, which was patted that

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

This is a satirical 1919 Thanksgiving column complaining about high turkey prices and post-war food costs. It briefly jokes that the passenger pigeon or the auk would have been easier birds to eat than turkey, using them as throwaway references rather than discussing their extinction.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Herald · 13 November 1919 · page 10

Drugs' ?ae?f WITH THE ACCENT ON THE GIVING Doth He who marl;? Ihe sparrow's fall al>o marl? the turkey's rise? Thanksgiving is pronounced with the oil on the last two syllables. After you get through giving the landlord, giving the coalman and giving the grocer, all you have left are mani?. And darned few of thctn. Twenty years ago you would have to pay $?0 freightage on the $i worth of turkey. Now, $io worth of turkey ran be mailed home for a ?-cent stamp. Two ?encrations ago, the old man could step forth and shoot a wild turkey.

See moreSee less

Now there arc no more wild turkeys. The sapps who buy 'em arc the babies who arc wild. Plentv. After you get a io-bill lurkry home you finti that it's all neck like a Greek vase, all feet like a centipede and all feathers like a duster. After you look at your minu? bankroll, you realize why they I call 'cm gobblers. Cooking turkey it50 cent-?Mi pound. Rating turkcj, is 60. Turkey ?for hashing purpose? only can be had for 40. It's so stringy that you 1 have to thread it through a needle and cal it thai way. Let us give ?thanks, brothers. Don't know why the turk was picked out as the bird of thank? Why not the auk, the passenger pigeon or sonic other bird that is easier to get? The profiteers arc taking a thick chance by leaving the wishbone in the turkey. If they don't break their legs it ain't the fault of the gent who gets the biggest half of the wishbone. Yea, bo. The old-fashioned turkey raffles are still with us, but they've changed like the map of Mitteleuropa. In order to get a gobbler, you raffle off your steam piano, twin beds, automobile and the baby's shoes. A $20 bird is too valuable to cat. It should be broken to harness and entered in the Grand Circuit Sweepstakes. Vou can't fall back on ganders, roosters or drakes. Duck is 40 a throw, goose is 45 a toss and chicken is 50. The only thing you have to fall back on is your shoulder blade. A body of men that has been guessing tor over a century is sure to guess right once. When Congress refuses to ratify the peace treaty, they're guessing right. The war ain't over yet. Not with turkey where it is. Which is where it shouldn't be. The rest of the Thanksgiving dinner is stringing right along with the turk. There is only one stalk of celery in a bunch. A pair of cranberries cost $8. Vou can get 10 cents worth of sugar on a Lincoln penny and .?-till recognize Abe by his warts. Mince pie. Even Conan Doyle can't claim there is a spirit mes sage in that. The 1010 mince pie is a strip of Sahara with a crust on it. Depriving a guy who pays for a Thanksgiving dinner of his mince julep is like making a bird undergo a major operation without an anaesthetic. Unless the food yeggs relent it looks as if any bird who forgets to bait the mouse trap ain't going to have any dinner on November 27. Which is the date set for Thanksgiving, but many only turn out to be November 27.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A satirical 1919 Thanksgiving column complains about rising turkey prices and food costs, joking that birds like the auk or passenger pigeon might be easier to obtain than turkey. The passenger pigeon is mentioned only in passing as a comic aside, implicitly acknowledging its extinction.

Omaha Daily Bee · 16 November 1919 · page 27

WITH THE ACCENT ON THE GIVING

who buy 'era are the babies who "are wild. ' Plenty. After you get a ten bill turkey home vou find that It's all neck like a Greek vase, all feet like a centipede and all feathers like a duster. After you look at your minus bankroll, you realize why they call 'era gobblers. mm , Cooking turkey is fifty cents a pound. Eating turkey is sixty. Turkey for hashing purposes only, can be had for forty. It's so stringy that you have to thread it through a needle and eat it that way. Let us give thanks, brothers. . . Don't why the turk was picked out as the bird of thanks. Why not the auk, the passenger pigeon or some other bird that is easier to get?

See the clipping

The Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.

A brief dispatch claims wild pigeons have gained a foothold near Chillicothe, Ohio, and are rapidly increasing in number. The item notes that only a few years earlier, the last known passenger pigeon died unmated in the Cincinnati zoo despite a $500 offer for a mate.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 49 days earlier.

The Kentuckian · 20 November 1919 · page 1

EDITORIAL PERISCOPE

A dispatch from Chillicothe, Ohio, reports that' wild pigeons have got ten a gtart 'in that vicinity and are increasing rapidly.' Only a few years ago, the last known specimen was in the Cincinnati zoo and $500 was of fered fora mate, but the 'bird died unmated.. ' ' :-':.- '" ''" ; ! The Prince of Wales was shown all ,' the sights in New York Tuesday, and given a brilliant. Reception. A .booK '.-J.of newspaper ' clippings , -and "-other, gifts were Prented to" hirti,-irtclttdIng'.a. silkeritais;ahd StripW Bi ; ble given '-by' the .New .York Bible V Society, a replicator the one present-1 ed to his grandfather.

See moreSee less

King Edward VIIr when hey a irr PrineeTof WalfcV 'Srisited'this .co.wiB&tyyefWjlo,: "and 'gold1 medt donated' by the : repteaentatiwii , of 1 thirty., racesyrho have contributed t the building of - America. The ?oung"British heir had Bcareely; a moment to call his pwn. ; Iri warmth' and enthusiasm,

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

The report reflects on how passenger pigeons, once abundant fifty years earlier, were slaughtered indiscriminately and fed to hogs due to lack of protection. It expresses skepticism about a claimed sighting of the birds in Ohio, noting that no scientist has claimed the $1,000 reward for a specimen in twenty years.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Grant County Herald, 5 November 1919, Martinsburg W VA Evening Journal, 7 November 1919, The Washington Herald, 13 November 1919.

Mineral Point Tribune · 20 November 1919 · page 5

—John Unger, Jr., left Friday to transact business in Milwaukee. Miss Irene Mitchell, who was here to spend a short time with her mother, has returned to Beloit. —Raymond Moreland and wife of Argyle were guests of her mother, Mrs. John Stephenson, a part of the i past week. —An automobile will never wholly rej place the buggy in the country districts until it can be successfully driven with out the use of hands. —What is funnier than a group of prominent citizens who imagine they j are the most prominent of all?

See moreSee less

, —There is a good deal of talk in all circles about “women's wear" and some of them do wear pretty well while others are just bores. Had the wild pigeons, more abun dant fifty years ago than any migra tory birds, been properly protected, they would today mean much as a check to the economic problem of get ting meat to eat. But (hey were slaugh tered indiscriminately and fed to five I dollar hogs. Ohio reports the return of a few of these birds but since no scien tist in twenty years has been able to win the standing reward of a thousand dollars for a single specimen, it is hard ly likely that any escaped to return to Ohio as reported.

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A 1919 review of Gene Stratton-Porter's bird book 'Homing with the Birds' mentions it contains an account of one of the last passenger pigeons among its nature stories. The review focuses mainly on other birds and anecdotes, giving only brief mention to the pigeon.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 November 1919 · page 56

the moving train. The intimate family life of the birds is told In the text and the pictures in such detail as can seldom be found In a book of this kind. Among these Inci dents is the story of one of the last passenger pigeons. * Like all of Mrs. Porter’s nature books tt Is Illustrated with photographs taken

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This reminiscence piece describes a travel journey by rail and steamboat in earlier days, then shifts to profile an elderly riverboat captain known as 'Bill.' Among his childhood memories in a once rural village is his grandfather catching wild pigeons with a net, alongside details of his career on Hudson River sloops and schooners.

The Sun · 23 November 1919 · page 94

'Academy," where Pedagogue Loomls taught him to use, in tho Captain's words, "hooks and trammels." Re calling these primitive times tho Cap tain tnlrl linn. t,n ,,.nnt in I rled to church for his mother. In thoso days tho present vlllago was nil green fields, in which he recalls his grandfather catching wild pigeons with a net. School days over nt tho ago of 15 tho Captain began his career on the water with tho late Capt. Levi De Noyclles of tho celebrated family of that name, shipping on the sloop John De Noyclles as cabin boy and cook In tho Albany-Havcrstraw lumber trade. After a couplo of years ho was ap prenticed to tho wheelwright trade, but tho lure of tho river called him

See the clipping

The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.

A garbled newspaper fragment, embedded amid patent medicine advertisements, recalls a time when wild pigeons were abundant alongside deer, which were the primary target of hunters. It suggests pigeons were so plentiful they were almost incidental to hunting trips focused on deer.

The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 26 November 1919 · page 7

phosphate on an empty stomach is wonderfully invigorating. It cleans out all the sour fermentations, gases and acidity and gives one a fine appej tite for breakfast. I A quarter pound of limestone phos- ! abundance as well as wild pigeons, phate will cost very little at the drug "But it was the deer they were af they needed for a few coppers a day. The first shot they fired brought down a bustard, which weiarhed 25 pounds and was as good eating as a turkey. Pheasants were found in

See the clipping