This editorial supports a new conservation law regulating hunting, arguing that unchecked slaughter leads to extinction as happened with the passenger pigeon and American bison. It urges citizens to support enforcement of the law to preserve game birds for future generations.
The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · 6 September 1916 · page 7
COUNTRY'S GAME
slaughter was allowed to go on un. checked we would awake some day to find many of our present game birds extinct. This has been proven in the extinction of the wild passenger pigeon, the American bison and a great number of other' animals and birds
The article quotes an 1857 Ohio Senate report dismissing the need to protect the passenger pigeon as inexhaustible, then notes that by 1916 the species is completely extinct. It reflects on the lesson for conservation, warning that other species like game birds face similar extermination from overhunting.
The States-Graphic · 8 September 1916 · page 6
THE LESSON OF 1S16 The report of a select committee of the senate of Ohio in 1857 on a bill proposed to prtect the passenger pigeon follows: s l "The passenger pigeon needs no pro tection. Wonderfully prolific, havimr vast forests of the north as its breed mg grounds, travelling hundreds of miles in search of food, it is here to day and elsewhere tomorrow and no ordinary destruction can lessen them, or be missed from the myriads that are yearly produced." The quest is closed, hope abandoned. The passenger pigeon is absolutely exterminated.
See moreSee less
Not one individual of it remains alive. How many there are in Haywood county at the present time who can remember the myriads of pigeons that semi-annually visited here. You have seen the heavens black with them for hours. As one flock followed another, oftimes the sun was obscured, while farmers were in dark ness and in shadow. We have no way of ujdging of the future but by the past. Lift the veil now, and look at the stories of the bison, the passenger pigeon, the wild duck, etc. As reason
A report on the Berlin, Connecticut fair describes midway attractions and a wild animal show featuring various creatures, including 'American wild pigeons, now practically extinct.' The bulk of the article covers livestock exhibits, carnival attractions, and fair activities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.
Wrong
New Britain Herald · 11 September 1916 · page 1
Wild Animal Show. The wild animal show is a feature of the midway this year. This con cession is located southeast of the grandstand just below the lunch tent of the East Berlin M. E. tent. Queer animals such as the South American agota, which is a combination of the kangaroo and rat and lives on roots; the South African mangabe, resemb ling in many ways the North Ameri can ground hog, Irish hares, the odor less skunk, New. England raccoon, American wild pigeons, now practic ally extinct, and last but not least the great American diamond-back rattler, the most poisonous snake in the west ern hemisphere.
The article discusses the constitutionality of a federal law protecting migratory game birds, comparing it to the Mann Act and predicting it will be upheld in court. It invokes the passenger pigeon's extinction as a warning of what happens to species without hunting protections.
Yerington Times · 16 September 1916 · page 2
PHONE 31. The federal game agent for the District of Nevada, in a letter to the Reno Gazette which is reprinted in this paper, announces that under the act he will vigorously prosecute all persons who shoot wild ducks prior to the 1st day of October. Under the State law it is per missable to kill them on the 15th of this monthHis letter is clear and frank. In it attention is called to the fact that the Judge of the United States District Court of the District of Kansas has held the law to be unconstitutional, while the Judge of the same court for the District of South Dakota has held it to be constitutional.
See moreSee less
If it is correct that the Kansas judge, two or three years ago wink the Caminetti and Diggs cases in California were pending on appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals, decided that the Mann Act relating to white slavery was unconstitutional in a case similar to that of t ie California cases, his decision will have no weight in this State for the reason that Nevada is in the Ninth Circuit. As the Court which decided the Caminetti and Diggs cases has jurisdiction over Ne vada the federal judge of Nevada will follow that decision which has weight while the decision of the Kansas judge has none here. 1 lie question in the Caminetti case was whether Congress invaded what is known as the police power of the states when it passed the Mann act. The same question will probably decide the constitutionality of the federal act protecting wild migratory gameIf the case goes to the Circuit Court of Appeals it will in all probabilty sustain the game law as it did the Mann act, and for the same reasons. Whether or not Congress has the right to protect ducks and other migratory game the true sportsman will restrain his desire to slaughter for the short period of two weeks and enable the young ducks, many of which are barely able to fly on the opening of the season under the State law, to have a slightly greater chance to escape. Every one knows that unless they are protected until they have a chance to increase, the wild duck will become extinct as did the passenger pigeon. Many who kill ducks before the date fixed by Congress will be ar rested and prosecuted. The Nevada Court will not be influenced by the decision of the Kansas judge and it will be necessary to clear ly show that the law is unconstitutional in order for those who may be prosecuted to avoid the penalty prescribedIt will be an expen sive proceeding should a defense be established. In case the law should be sustained the punishment will be severe as well as costly in money. The offender may be both fined and imprisoned. The taking of animal life for the pleasure of killing is becoming more and more questionable. Many, both young and old, w'ho dearly love to shoot, prefer inanimate targets, movable and fixed, to living animals Among many ilevotes to the pleasure of hunting the camera has supplanted the gunTo those who have used both, the camera ap peals more strongly because it records the narrative that the one who kills much less impressively relates. Fifteen days is not long to wait, and the short period gives thousands of birds a greater chance to escape that would be killed at the earlier date because of their lack of strength and ability to avoid the most cruel enemy of animal life—man. Don’t break the federal law. Even though you feel that it cannot enforced, it is a good one. It is reported that a syndicate is being organized to install a reservoir for the conservation of water at Alkali Lake. Attempts have previously been made to accomplish this but so far have not been successful. It is well known that the site is one of the most available in the United States and that sufficient water could be stored to insure the irrigation of from 40,000 to 50,000 acres of land in Antelope and Smith Valleys which could later be doubled with com paratively small expense by increasing the height of the retaining damIt is said that there has been more or less opposition to the project among the settlers of Antelope Valley but surely with the ad vantage they would receive from the reclamation of land that is now lying idle this opposition could be easily overcome. If in no other way, the sharing in the burden of taxation, of which the ranchers complain, by the lands thus reclaimed would more than compensate any cost it would be to themAgain the addition to the population of the district would result in doubling the values of all their hold ings.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
This 1916 article warns that the prairie chicken faces extinction from overhunting, much as the passenger pigeon did. It cites experts debating causes of decline and difficulties breeding the birds in captivity, urging protective legislation.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 20 September 1916 · page 4
IS THE PRAIRIE CHICKEN DOOMED? The Forum has been urging a closed season or at least closer restrictions to protect the prairie chickens. The Minneapolis Journal has the following editorial, showing that something must be done if the prairie chickens are to be saved from extinction: Ducks are very plentiful this season, andvthere is nn abundance of other birds, except prairie chickens. The chicken reports are not very encouraging, many birds hav ing been killed by spring storms.—Interview with Carlos Avery, state game and fish commissioner. The scarcity of prairie chickens is becoming an oft-told tale.
See moreSee less
Last season hunters complained that these highly esteemed game birds were unusually rare in the stubble. Bird experts then asserted that the species was in dire danger of extinction. When Dr. William T. Hornaday, the well known game conser vationist, was here late in the fall to help organize a state association, he declared that the danger of extinction for the prairie chicken was fa very real and menacing one. He doubted, indeed, whether it was not even then too late to save the species by declaring a closed season for the next five or ten years, though immediate resort should be had to that expedient. Many hunters who have shot prairie chicken in the stubble fields of the northwest for years, have pooh-poohed such statements. They have had various explanations for the marked diminution in numbers. Mr. Avery holds the spring storms at least partly responsible. But everyone knows that the chief factor in the steady wiping out of the pinnated grouse is the popping automatics. According to Dr. Horanady, the greatest obstacle to perpetuat ing the species, after it has been so decimated by shotguns, lies in the fact that it has been found almost impossible to raise the pinnated grouse in captivity. On the other hand, the ruffled grouse or partridge, the quail, and most of the wild duck species can be so raised under favorable conditions. Once a bird species is worn down to small numbers by the gun ners, it finds increasing difficulty in resisting the inroads of its nat ural enemies, and tends to disappear altogether, as did the passenger pigeon. The seeming impossibility of hatching and raising prairie
The piece reminisces about hunters decades earlier reporting pigeons as abundant, then notes that the last wild pigeon died in the Cincinnati Zoo a few years prior. It laments that other bird species may soon follow passenger pigeons into extinction despite game laws.
Connecticut Western News · 28 September 1916 · page 4
NEVER AGAIN. In our reminiscence column this week we note that "Fred Miles and Ernest Pease of Twin Lakes were doing good shooting on pigeons" thirty-eight years ago, and that they reported the birds "quite abundant." No doubt the hunters of today who helped to ex terminate these birds, regret that never again will there be good pigeon shoot ing, as the last wild pigeon on earth died in the Cincinnati Zoo a few years ago. Other beautiful and valuable birds are rapidly following the passenger pigeon, and, unless saved by the adop tion of heroic measures, will soon be no more. And yet many a hunter will run the risk of prosecution by violating the game laws to slaughter the few birds left to perpetuate the race.