As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

December 1913

16 articles

The Punta Gorda Herald · Punta Gorda, Fla.

The piece recalls how passenger pigeons once darkened the sky but were wastefully killed for sport, paralleling the destruction of buffalo. It urges sportsmen and legislatures to protect remaining game species like turkey, grouse, and wood duck before they meet the same fate.

The Punta Gorda Herald · 4 December 1913 · page 1

SOME PERTINENT FACTS On Hunting Timely Words tor the True Sportsman When the white people came to this country, they found it overflowing with wild life. Flocks of wild pigeons were so great that they obscured the sun; they were hours passing a given point, anil one could not see either edze o the flock. Buffalo roamed nearly the entire country. : r Today the wild pigeon and the buffalo are gone. " A large share of the pigeons were killed in the name of sport, and many were fed to hogs.

See moreSee less

Buffalo were killed for their skins, and their meat left to rot on the prairie. Today, the wild turkey, the sandhill crane, the wild goose the ruffled grouse, the woodcock. the wood duck, and . the canvas back are on their way to extmc tion. 4- . . A

See the clipping

University Missourian · Columbia, Mo.

A Missouri newspaper editorial on protecting wild game birds notes that the wild pigeon is almost extinct, using it as a cautionary example alongside declining wild turkey, goose, and wood duck populations. It calls for game refuges and better-qualified wardens to prevent further losses of quail, mallard, teal, and prairie chicken.

University Missourian · 8 December 1913 · page 2

PROTECTION OF WILD LIFE

Seteral thousand Missouri sports men are cleaning their firearms this week because of the beginning of the open season for quail hunting last week. The game birds in this state are growning each year less numer ous and unless some radical measures are adopted for their protection the few species which still remain are soon to become extinct. Or the millions of game birds that once frequented our forests and streams the wild pigeon is almost ex tinct. We may as well abandon all hope of saving the wild turkey, the wild goose, pheasant and wood duck, for they are so nearly gone that it is impossible to save them. Only the quail, mallard, teal and prairie chick en remain and the deadly pump and

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

The article recounts rumors of passenger pigeon survivors, including an unconfirmed Pennsylvania pair and Professor Hodge's claimed discovery of a small nesting colony in Oregon. It reviews the species' dramatic decline from billions in Wilson's famous sighting to near-total extinction through market netting.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Evening Times-Republican, 28 November 1913, The Clio Messenger, 28 November 1913.

Wrong

The Mirror and Farmer · 11 December 1913 · page 6

In this connection - the latest report of the discovery of a few passenger pigeons attracts more than passing interest. Sev eral months ago it was reported that a pair had been found in Pennsylvania,

See the clipping

Yerington Times · Yerington, Nev.

The article claims naturalists offered a $1,000 reward for the first discovered nest of the North American passenger pigeon, won by a man in Ontario, and that scientists hoped to revive the species. It notes the bird, once abundant in the early 1880s, was now nearly extinct.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Yerington Times · 13 December 1913 · page 2

SHEEPMEN HARD HIT BY UN DERWOOD TARIFF. From present indications the sheep men of Nevada have been hard hit by the free wool schedule of the new tariff bill. Wool is now selling at 14 cents, but as Nevada wool is subject to heavy shrinkage the price for the Nevada product is much lower; in fact the owners of Nevada wool will do well if they get 10 cents a pound for it. Last year wethers sold for $4.50, while this year the best price obtainable is $3. Recently the offers have been re duced to $2.65 which is a tremendous shrinkage and one wh'ch will prove a hard blow to the sheep industry.

See moreSee less

The high price of beef and pork is about the only hope of the sheepmen at the present time, as it will prove a resisting order against the decline of mutton in lower levels. Few people even in Ely realize the importance of the sheep industry to White Pine county. Instead of being owned by foreigners, a sstated by Senator Pitt man, they are owned entirely by American ciizens. who are largely the bone and sinew of the ranching inter ests. And then the sheep are taxed at $2.50 per head, which is very nearly their cash value at the present time and this is also considered as a hard ship by the growers. They are also annoyed and their ranges eaten out by the nomadic bands of sheep from Utah and Idaho, which winter here, and escape in many instances without paying a just proportion of taxes to the State or county. There should be some law passed by the next legisla ture to prevent this and protect the resident sheep grower who is a tax payer and large producer of the wealth of the State.—Ely Record. Costs Increased One Cent Per Pound. The Lake Superior Copper Com panies have granted heir employes an 8 hour day at a $3 wage. The com panies refuse any Union recognition, but the increase in wages and reduc tion in hours will undoubtedly end the 5 months’ strike We understand, however, tha the reduction in hours and increase in wages will increase Lake Superior Copper costs about one cent per pound.—Thompson, Towle & Co. -x Finds Pigeon's Nest. The naturalists of the United States and Canada offered a reward of $1,000 for the discovery of the first nest of North American or passenger pigeons. This prize was won by a man in On tario. This breed of pigeons was very numerous in the early eighties, but re now about extinct, and natural s are going to try to revive the <es in America. the ind •ir, *e e e <1 a 1

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A conservationist recalls witnessing massive market-hunting slaughter of ducks and geese in Arkansas, which spurred him to advocate for game bird protection laws. He cites the passenger pigeon's disappearance as proof that unchecked commercial hunting can drive a species to extinction, while discussing the broader need for bird protection against market hunters.

The Washington Herald · 14 December 1913 · page 20

use. . . w m '7""" "v" should not be killed It is only when kllllng Is likely to exterminate a species that It should be prohibited. Song birds i and certain msectiv orous birds, however, f ., ,., .......... ... i.ttt.i .. BUUU1U UCIC1 UTS JV1I1CU. A11U gpnng SuOOtIngof game birds ought to be stopped entirely," "What birds," I asked, 'have become inexistent' "The wild pigeon, as all of us know, has disappeared. Any one with a gun could kill wild pigeons by the hundred Fired Into once, they would fly a short distance ana men return to give the hunter another chance.

See moreSee less

Maity lnsect-eatlngbirds were fast being entirely kin ed off by commercial hunters, who sold the feathers of such birds to manufac turing milliners. Fortunately, publlo sentiment, going forward b) leaps and bounds on the subject of wild life preser vation, has compelled the enactment of protective laws in most of the States. Forty-foUr States have game comm's doners or wardens. New Tfork has 1C3 salaried game protectors. Georgia has IIS county wardens and 2,200 deputy war dens. The slaughter of our birds has been checked, but it has not been stop

See the clipping

The Ocala Evening Star · Ocala, Fla.

A newspaper report on a Dr. Swope lantern-slide lecture for the Audubon Society describes efforts to protect declining bird species, using the wild pigeon's disappearance as a cautionary example. It notes that doves, once as plentiful as the passenger pigeon, are now being killed in huge numbers despite their value in eating weed seeds and insects that damage crops.

The Ocala Evening Star · 16 December 1913 · page 5

The dove is another Dird that a few years ago was almost as plenti ful as the wild pigeon, but when par ties go out from this city to a near by plantation and when night comes they have a pile of dead doves 800 i i number to their credit, the craws o each one containing from IS to 11200 seeds of noxious weeds, it is

See the clipping

The Ocala Evening Star · Ocala, Fla.

A speaker addressing bird conservation told how insect damage costs the U.S. over a billion dollars yearly, worsened by bird destruction, citing the passenger pigeon as an already-extinct species. He recounted that despite an 1860s Ohio law declaring pigeons too numerous to exterminate, a reward of $3000 was later offered by Roosevelt, Sage and others for anyone who could find a single nest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Ocala Evening Star · 16 December 1913 · page 5

Speaking of bird destruction he said that in quite recent years three different species had been entirely exterminated and that at least ten others were on the verge of annihil ation unless some stop, was put to their wanton destruction. Among those already gone he mentioned the passenger pigeon,, a beautiful but i

See the clipping

The Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis. · and 3 other papers

A doctor recounts a humorous anecdote from the early 1870s about encountering a massive passenger pigeon roost so dense it bent a tree to the ground. He describes how his hitched horse was lifted into the air when the birds flew off and the tree sprang upright, and how he cleverly lured the pigeons back to free his horse.

The Watertown Weekly Leader · 19 December 1913 · page 8

Doctor Tells This. Dr. Blevins sat quietly, listening to the yarns of a party seated at the fire side of the hospitable host M., occa sionally sniffling the air, and impa tiently awaiting his turn. At length, the stock of yarns of his voluble com panions seemed to have become ex hausted. "Away back In an autumn of the earlyseventies,” began the doctor, "the wild pigeons came in great num bers after the mast. I was riding along a country road, one late after noon, w-hen 1 came to a pigeon roost.

See moreSee less

There were so many of these birds that their weight had bent the tree in which they were roosting to the ground, I thought I would stop and * a few of the birds. I bitched my rse to the branches of the treetop, but when I attempted to catch the birds they all flewaway, letting the tree spring back into an upright po sition, and to my discomfiture, carry ing my horse up, too. There he hung by the bridle in the treetop. I was puzzled. Presently an idea occurred to me. The pigeons had lighted on a tree that stood on the next hillside. I ran around to the far side of the tree and ‘shooed’ the birds. They flew back to the first tree, where my horse bung, and lighting on it again, bent it to f he ground as before. I ran back, loosened the bridle, and got my horse. "Since that experience, I tell you I am always careful as to where I hitch ray horse.”

See the clipping

Also printed 7 more times, in 3 papers
  • Daily Independent · Elko, Nev. · 26 December 1913
  • Daily Independent · Elko, Nev. · 27 December 1913
  • Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · Annapolis, Md. · 24 January 1914
  • Daily Independent · Elko, Nev. · 10 February 1914
  • Daily Independent · Elko, Nev. · 11 February 1914
  • Philip Weekly Review and Bad River News · Philip, S.D. · 11 June 1914
  • Philip Weekly Review and Bad River News · Philip, S.D. · 19 August 1915

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A Pendleton, Oregon report states that Professor Hodge of the University of Oregon announced finding a nesting site of passenger pigeons, a species long thought extinct by ornithologists. He planned to visit the site in spring and sought federal aid to help revive the species.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Mirror and Farmer, 11 December 1913, The Ocala Evening Star, 16 December 1913.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 21 December 1913 · page 52

Found Passenger Pigeon

E A. SCHILLER Presents Southland’s Favorite ' UTTLE Philadelphia, December 20.—(Special.I—.« father prosecuted, convicted and sen fenced his son before Magistrate Brlgg! In the Seventeenth district police coar today and gave him a year In the housi of correction. The young man had broker the furniture and tried to drive his mothe; and sister from the house. Michael .T. Ryan, 3013 South Opal street teas the plaintiff, and Michael Ryan, 24 tvas the defendant. The father eald hli son wouldn't work and drank almos constantly. H* was out of Jail on parole but seemed determined to get back.

See moreSee less

Tin magistrate asked how lung the sentenc< should be and the father said a year, r was so ordered. Found Passenger Pigeon Pendleton, Ore., December 20.—(Special Belief that after years of seeking am the offer of large rewards he has fount the nesting place of some American pas senger pigeons, thought by ornithologist; to be extinct, was announced here to night In a lecture by Prof. Hodge of tin University of Oregon. As late as 1878. said Professor Hodge flights of passenger pigeons at times iit erally darkened the skies of Michigan but the species rapidly disappeared. Professor Hodge announced Ills Inten tlon of visiting the nesting place nexl spring and said that with federal aid he would try to revive the species becaus. of their Immense value to farmers as Insect destroyers. Extra Matinee Friday

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A Wisconsin old-timer recalls when passenger pigeons darkened the sky in flocks of millions near Neenah and Chilton in the 1850s-60s, now completely gone from the state. He argues the shotgun theory for their disappearance is untenable, comparing their vanishing to an unexplainable mystery like migrating locusts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later.

Wrong

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 22 December 1913 · page 8

PiON MYSTERY Neenah, Wia., Dec. 22.—Fifty years ago any Neenah man who owned a gun and could hit a barn door at fifty feet and who had a hunger on for a wild pigeon pot pie could go out into the woods nearby, and even right in this, then village, and couldn't miss the birds should he try, they were so num erous, says Capt. J. N. Stone of The TimesToday there is not. a live wild pigeon in the state of Wisconsin. In the falls of 1859 and 1860, the ed itor of The Times saw in the woods near Chilton flocks of millions of these birds, so many in fact, that when in flight they would darken the day at noon time.

See moreSee less

The great mystery *s, what has become of them? The wild pigeon was always a (bird of mystery. Where it came from and whither bound no one efver knew. It used to pass over this vicinity in I flocks going east that darkened the skies. There were not only millions but billions in' the flocks. The theory that the breed fell a sac ri.fice of the shotgun is untenable. Their migration was like unto that of the locusts. Their numbers were not to be estimated. A bos' with an old muzzle-loader could bag them by the hundreds. It was no fun to shoot the birds it was ibutchery. Pigeon pot pie was too easy to ibe rated a delica cy. But today a mess of wild pigeons would prove a luxury and flavored with cherished memories of the past, long gone, but not forgotten. The wild pigeon will probably never ths bte&a

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

The report offers several unconfirmed theories for the vanishing of passenger pigeons, including an epidemic, a change in migration route, or relocation to South America. It concludes the true cause will likely never be known by the old-time hunters.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 22 December 1913 · page 8

nome this evening, 424 Fourth street 'orl^T,!in 's Ella Hanson one of the brides to be January. Mr Garrlty of the 'office Atty. E. r*t»r««£.wa8 Passenger to Ulen this a afternoon on a business mission. Mr. and Mrs. S. G. Comstock and Miss Jessie Comstock left over the Northern 1 acific this afternoon for Northampton, Mass., to be the Christ mas guests of Miss Ada Comstock, dean of women at Smith college. Miss Jessie Comstock will remain there indefinitely but Mr. and Mrs. Comstock, after a few days stay with their daughter will proceed to Ashvllle, N.

See moreSee less

C., where they will sojourn for a few weeks and then they will proceed to New Orleans where a stay will be made before proceeding to some point in Florida, to be selected according to circumstances. There was no lack of activity on the site of the new Comstock garage to day, operations along all lines being in progress. There were brickmasons at work and carpenters and structural Ironworkers, besides a number of un skilled laborers and helpers. The erec tion of the iron work for the roof is expected to be in place by tomorrow night. An interesting center today was the corridor of the postoffice from which there was a continual stream of young men and maidens, old men and children who had been mailing that letter or that parcel to the dear ones somewhere. All of the time of Postmaster Flaten and Miss Fay was occupied receiving and weighing parcels to be sent by par cel post and placing the postage and testing the parcels as to their right to parcel post rates. Chrlatmas Tree at St. Jolm'a. The children's Christmas tree and service at St. John's Episcopal church will be held tomorrow evening at 7:30 o'clock and it is the earnest wish of the rector that the parents as far as poss ible attend the service which will pre cede the distribution of the gifts to the little ones. fel victim to an cpidemic or they changed the direction of their migra tion. It is said that pigeons are plen tiful in South America, That may ex plain the mystery of their disappear ance. But the real cause for the pass ins: of the pigeon will probably remain unsolved to the hunters of the olden days until they get together in "the happy hunting grounds".

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A newspaper captain recalls seeing passenger pigeons darken the sky near Chilton in the 1850s, calling their vanishing a great mystery. The report dismisses shotgun hunting as the cause, comparing their disappearance instead to the unexplained migration of locusts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

Evening Times-Republican · 23 December 1913 · page 2

the stato of Wisconsin. ISM In the falls of and 1550, the edi­ tor of the Times saw In the woods near Chilton flocks of millions of these birds, so many In fact, that when In flight they would darken the day at noon time. The great mystery Is, what has become of them? The wild pigeon was always a bird of mystery. Where it oame from and whither bound no one ever knew. It used to pass over this vicinity In flock* going east that darksned the Mai Train In skies.

See moreSee less

There were not only atflUions but billions ia ths flocks. The theory that ths breed fell a sacrifice of the shotgun is untenable. Their migration was like unto that ot the locusts. Their numbers wars not to be estimated. A boy with aa old One eent a weed eaeh laesrtlea—Ne ad teeeived far four hens al8o sorne Barred Rock, ud ei8" Mou*nton. 1 UWBte. Rapids. For 8sl®—Two No. 1 milch cows For Sale One yearling Ch« O W. flhephard, Iowa have White boar. to do at home.: Falls, Iowa. For Aplington, Iowa. hogs. M. B. Ca pron, R. It bourne, Iowa. flr"t For Sale—Five good registered Duroc Jersey male hogs. J. H. Belckley, Glad brook. Iowa. R. F. D. No. I. For 8sU Poland China male hogs, ,c®un*Jr' H1"*-1 wr lo w,_„ seIL Shorthorn bulls, one straight Scotch IS Iowa. months old twenty-five Barred Rock cockerels $2 each. J. C. Bally, Marwith «rrnrt length an h»ainr bonoalso (or bulls, sired by a eon of the Chicago in­ for service. O. E. Paul, Haverhill, Iowa. "v* navy For Sale—Choice Poland China male h°ust^£inr anJ hog, cholera immune, eligible, $20. Also red' 102 For Sale—Duroc males, 120 each. If •old soon barred Rock cockerels, Blus Rod. Andalusian cockerels and pullets. J.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

The report reflects on the passenger pigeon as a cherished memory, now long gone from local skies. It offers competing theories for the disappearance—an epidemic, a change in migration route, or relocation to South America—concluding the true cause may never be known.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 30 days later.

Wrong

Evening Times-Republican · 23 December 1913 · page 2

lshed msmories of ths past, loag gons, but not forgottsa. The wild pigeon will probably neve* be seen here again. Either ths trM fell victim to an epidemic or they changed the direction of their migra tion. It Is said that pigeons are plen tiful la South America. That may ex plala the myaeery of their disappear* ance. But the real cause for ths pass* Ins of the pigeon will probably remain unsolved to the hunters of the olden days uatll they gat: togethir .ia "the happy hunting grounds." Mai Train In A B*n beat a trata ia a roMfct raoa bOtwaea the two fromdroom to Kur* eOottg, India—* distance ot mil**.

See moreSee less

if 1ft Ilia victor, a private named Graham, ot tfca Argyll* boat tho train by two mlaatas. Tha dtstaacewas la wnM oat bear and thlrtyminutss by ct» tiauoai running. Graham walked two days betora froai Obboa to Kaneont and back, Si miles la sly sad odo 2 0%

See the clipping

The Lancaster Gazette · Lancaster, N.H.

The Observer column reports that Stephen Eames of Upton, Mass. saw birds he believed were passenger pigeons twice in two weeks, correcting earlier belief the species was extinct since the 1870s. A Massachusetts Fish and Game official confirms receiving similar reports from other parts of the state.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Lancaster Gazette · 31 December 1913 · page 2

litI it has been thought the species wasj 'practically exterminated. There is good authority now for believing that the birds are returning, though not in such numbers as formerly. ;Stephen H. Eames of Upton, Mass., says that he saw them recently in Upton Woods where they formerlyl were very plentiful. Mr. Eames says:l "I have seen what I am confident are passenger pigeons twice within Ithe past two weeks. The first time !I was auto riding with my son, Atty. :Burton Eames, Boston. We were going along the Westboro road and were near the Bradish place when a !

See moreSee less

pigeon flew out from a clump of oaks at the side of the road and then straight up the road and into another grove of white oaks Although I had not seen a passenger pigeon since ! the early 70's, I at once recognized Ithe bird and spoke of it to my son. I also spoke of it to Deputy State Fish and Game Commissioner Charles lAdams when he visited Upton a couple lof days after. He stated that the commission had received three retorts from various parts of the state that 'the passenger, or wild pigeon, had 1 been seen."

See the clipping

The Lancaster Gazette · Lancaster, N.H.

Residents of Upton, Massachusetts describe sightings of birds they believe are passenger pigeons, extinct in the wild for decades. Witnesses recount multiple encounters and speculate the birds returned due to an abundant acorn crop, with a report sent to sporting magazines for investigation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Lancaster Gazette · 31 December 1913 · page 2

after him. lAldrichI Aldrich says: "1 told Mr. Eames that I believed that I had started up wild pigeons from what I had read of them and the pictures I had seen. He said that he believed that he had seen one himself in the north part a week before and that he would go ; with me and see if we could start any ' more. We left the town farm bridge and, cut up through the woods onto what is known as the plains. We started; through the corn field and started six' :pigeons out of there, both of us getting a good view of them.

See moreSee less

After this „ separated. I went over to the edge I l of the woods. Soon I started one fromj an oak tree and it flew onto an oldl idead limb of a tree within five rods of' where Mr. Eames was standing. In all we started nine and got a good chance to study the one that flew ionto the dead limb." Mr. Eames said: "I hunted wild pigeons when I was a young man in ,the late 60's and the early 70's and I ,am firmly convinced that birds I have

See the clipping

The Lancaster Gazette · Lancaster, N.H.

A local man named Eames claims birds seen recently in town are passenger pigeons, recalling that he last shot one in 1872 and attributing their supposed return to an abundance of white oak acorns. He also describes old pot-hunting methods used to capture pigeons in nets before the species vanished.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Lancaster Gazette · 31 December 1913 · page 2

,am firmly convinced that birds I have I seen recently in town are passenger ipigeons. The last one I shot was in 11872, when I was one of a party that [brought in a bag of 72." Mr Eames has communicated with I the Field and Stream and other sport ling magazines and it is expected that I they will send a man to Upton to investigate. Mr. Eames states that the only explanation of the rare birds' return to New England after so many years is the great amount of white oak acorns this year, which always were the passenger pigeons' chief article of food.

See moreSee less

When these birds disappeared there were no game laws worth mentioning and pot hunting was the rule. The birds flocked to the grain fields where snares were set and the ground covered with grain. When hundreds of the birds had collected the snare, which was nothing more or less than an immense het, was sprung and the

See the clipping