As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

June 1913

12 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report discusses the house cat as a major destroyer of bird life, citing sportsmen's testimonials about cats killing game birds. It cites the passenger pigeon's extinction as a prime example, attributing it to cats stalking nests and killing fledglings and parent birds, while noting the Biological Survey's $1,500 reward for finding a wild pigeon nest has never been claimed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 1 June 1913 · page 18

V 1 publication, goes on record to the effect | that "the cat is the most deadly enemj ] of feathered game. These and similar commun:< atlons to ! periodical literature have been carefully preserved ;md indexed In the office of the biological purvey, where the house cat's depredations upon birds in general and game birds in particular has been made ! the subject of special studv. Both sport;-rmn and ornithologists re gard it as one of the tragedies of bird i life that tin wild pigeon, wb'rli on< e ) abounded in North America, ha> become i extinct.

See moreSee less

laterally by the million they | ??ircled over the continent, migrating from one feeding round to the other. They were as typical of the new world as the buffalo. It has become a com monplace to cite the fact that tiles? I pigeons have disappeared utterly and I completely. j "For many years there has been a I standing reward of $1,roo to l>e given any j one who would show where the nest of a| wild pigeon might b? found. The rej ward has never been claimed. It has ! become a sort of sea serpent canard that here and there a wild pigeon, or. perhaps, a small flock of them, has been seen Only a few days ago such a story apj p^ared In print. Pr. Fisher is author:ty ! for the statement that every such story upon Investigation has he. n found to l>e without foundation - * * i This most excellent of the grime birds ; which delighted our forefathers has un- ; douhted'y become extinct. The advance of : civilization car:cd the house cat i:i its ? train 'Vouching an 1 stalking in the : tub ble and the sagebrush, cunning Srimal kin. that noiseless and r*morse'#ss hrnNr. destroyed the : esJs. caught titc lied' lit p , j even captured and killed the parent bird-, I atid the passing of the wild pizeon i ihe sign and symbol of his feline skill. Experts have estimated that <::cii of the multitudinous cats, including .'like the fireside pets and the outcasts which revert to their primitive wildness. de stroy on an average at least fifty birds a year. There are few families in the I'nited States in which there are not front one to ha'f a dozen cats. It goes without savin* that the birds which tre fiuerit the towns and cities, and are more or less close in their fellowship with man, more readily fall a victim to the furry destroyer. It appears to he true, however, as the sportsmen contend, an l the biologists tes tify, that millions of game birds also are destroyed every year by that "sleek high wayman," the cat. and that his depreda tions are in a large measure responsible for the extermination of certain game birds and for the inroads which are made on other species to such an extent that the federal law. placing the protection of these birds under 1'nlted States control, has not come any too soon. In just what manner the law will be applied to Tom and Tabby has not yet

See the clipping

The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.

Tennessee state agriculture officials are launching a campaign through newspapers and schools to protect non-game birds like robins, which have been disappearing due to hunting. The article warns that these birds may share the fate of the extinct wild pigeon if not protected, while also touting their value in controlling crop pests like the boll weevil.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

The Columbia Herald · 6 June 1913 · page 10

NASHVILLE, May 30. The State of Tennessee, through its State De partments of Government, will launch this week a South-wide, if not nation-wlcifc, movement fo: the protection of non-game birds, look ing to the lesktratiou of the former flocks of bird j lor the protection of the vast, r.mxunt of crops now an nually desf.rovcd by the boll wevil, San Jose scale and other pest. A. L. Garrison of the State De partment of Agriculture, is now in augurating movement over ihe State to have the protection, of the bird3 stressed through the news papers and the public schools.

See moreSee less

Superintendent of Public Instruction Blister will probably assist him in the latter. It is a noticeable thing in many localities oi Tennesso this spring that the large flocks of robins, which annually made their return north ward about February, were almost entirely gone. Very few of the Northern songsters were seen in Davidson County this year. For years they have' been hunted merci lessly, and now appear well on their way to fellow the extinct wild pigeon. "It is the farmer boy we want to reach," said Mr. Garrison yesterday. "If they will care for the bin 3 at home on their farms and not perse cute them oy shooting and robbing their nests, we can bring the song birds back to Tennessee in as great numbers. 7e are going to p.j'peal to these beys through -JJie prblic

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The article surveys contradictory theories and unconfirmed sightings explaining the passenger pigeon's disappearance, including rumors they had migrated to Mexico or out to sea. It notes a reward once offered for proof of a nest, and claims a bird shot and mounted in Detroit is the only definite record of the species' last appearance, while the last captive bird lives at the Cincinnati Zoo.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1913 · page 67

MASSACHUSETTS IN 1848.

du ad The ?Ust living passenger pigeon i.? now ?'iii'lnnatl Zoological Oerdeng and i !want] -'-ti.- v. ara old l?r. i. aferrad to I ? , tlvorous and all other bird-? aliens from BOUth? as a "scourge to the bud Ufa .

See the clipping

Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D.

The article reports on new federal legislation protecting migratory birds, prompted by concerns over vanishing wild turkeys, geese, and ducks. It notes that wild pigeons have already disappeared from the wild, with the only known survivor housed in the Cincinnati Zoo.

Pierre Weekly Free Press · 19 June 1913 · page 1

htw been an agitation'' ih favor Of :iedei^%^f^^^ al legislation for the protection of game fowl to prevent their complete extern-1 ination. It has been said that wild tur-jf keys, wild geese and some of the other" Jjitm wild fowl have almost enUrely diaap-^ peered all over the country. Wild ducks have also Wn scarce and wild pigeohe have disappeared, the only wild pigeon known in" the country tcdajr being oils in the Zoo at Cincinnati, *!j So the government put I mjl Itirc^wh I congress, as a rider of 'the sundry dvils| appropriation bill to prohibit the kiUiiig of migratory birds and tory birds thoeo which do not spead the entire year in any one state, but which moves from 1 north in the fall to south, and from the south to the north in the spring,''.

See moreSee less

Since the federal law has beeir passed^ the states cannotdo any thing to chango the law. They cannot make duck shoot1 ing legal. From now on duck shoeting" in South Dakota will he a crime, even. I though one has invested, a dollar in a-* huaters' license.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

The article describes a $5,000 reward offered by bird lovers and wealthy patrons for anyone who can produce a genuine male and female passenger pigeon, noting the species' decline from billions to near extinction. It mentions the last known survivor, a lone female aged 21, living in the Cincinnati Zoo.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening Times · 25 June 1913 · page 6

FOUTI'NK EOR PATR PIGEONS. One Lone Female in Cincinnati Zoo All That Is I.cft of Mil lions of Famous Birds. (New York World.) Five thousand dollars for a pair of pigeons! es. and more than that. If any one can really deliver the goods. All that the bird lovers of the Unit ed States want to see is nvo genuine. simon-pure passenger pigeons, male and female, and the money's yours on a gold plate. Once millions upon millions of them I darkened our skies. Once their for est nesting places were so crowded I that 'ho noise of the blrrls was deaf ening.

See moreSee less

Thousands were shipped to •market every week one hunter could net or shoot or club to death hun dreds a day—fatigue or inability to see in the oncoming darkness was all that stopped the day's slaughter, And now there is none. Yes, there is one. She Is a poor, lone female. 21 years old. in the Cincinnati Zoo. Jealously guarded in her advancing age, cared for as tenderly as a prince Ming in swaddling clothes, her little day fast drawing to ita close. And then the race of passenger pigeons will have perished from the face of the earth, not tho first innocent vic tims nf the greed of man. But the Audubon societies of the country and bird lovers all still cher ish hope. Perhaps a pair Is still alive —snrn'-where. Perhaps some hidden nesting place may be found. Perhaps there is yet some solitary spot as vet untrodden bv man where they are dwelling In peace—perhaps. So the reward of $5,000. Several wealthy men have contributed to it. Chief among them are Colonel An N. thony R. Kuser of Bernardsviiie.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

The report describes the last known passenger pigeon, a female at the Cincinnati Zoo, and the $5,000 reward offered by wealthy bird lovers for proof of a surviving wild pair. It recounts a recent false sighting in Pennsylvania and gives background on the species' former abundance before its catastrophic decline.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Celina Democrat, 30 May 1913, The Columbia Herald, 6 June 1913.

Wrong

The Evening Times · 25 June 1913 · page 6

FORTUNE FOR PAIR PIGEONS

I one morning. "I saw them!" declared Mark Hau ler. resident of the Lehigh Motor club, and so did I!" reiterated Moses iNewhard. by way of emphasis. Scores immediately sought the woods near by. where once thousands upon thousands of the birds made their nesting places—everybody want ed to win that $5,000. Every tree big enough to hide a single nest was I anxiously scanned hut narv a pigeon. At night the search was given up in (despair. The $5,000 Is still awaiting a claimant. "We get on an average of two such reports a week from different parts of the country."

See moreSee less

said Dr. W. T. Horn aday. director of the New York Zoo logical Garden, "but they invariablv turn out to be incorrect." Just a brief history now of the passtng of this doomed bird. I A century ago the timid, gentle thing was among the most numerous of all our wild species. The vast for I est that covered Eastern North Ameri ca was its habitat. Breaking up Into I tremendous flocks in the autumn, it sought the more hospitable Southland [for the cold season, but with the ad vent of spring the birds assembled I again in several stupendous hosts to I return northward for the summer. So densely packed were the pigeons that they darkened the sky like a pall of thunder .clouds and the noises of their innumerable wings beating the air sounded like the onward roar of an advancing storm of wind and rain. Alexander Wilson, the great, ornith ologist. saw a flock near Frankfort, Ky., in 1808, in which he estimated there were at least 2,230,272,000 In dividual birds. As late as 1850 huge flocks made their vernal journeys right over New York City. But soon after they be gan to grow thinner and thinner. In July, 1881, 20.000 made a Roman holi day for trap shooters who held a week's butchery at Coney Island. No large flock ha3 been recorded since 1888. The last known great nesting place, four miles broad and twenty eight miles long, near Petoskey, Mich., was cleaned out In 1878, when a bil lion birds were slaughtered for mark et. Every living squab was shaken out of its nest and when the bird murder was complete and all the carcasses shipped that the market could ab sorb, droves of hogs were turned into the woods to feed on the dead and dying doves that remained on the ground. In 1893 a few hundred alone sur vived. In 1896 about 50 lingered in Missouri, a pitiful remnant. "Down in the pleasant valley of the Ohio," says Morltz Fischer, the na turalist, referring to the female in the Cincinnati Zoo, "amdist patriarchs of t'-'.e forest primeval, Uvea to this day a captive and a lonely daughter of her gentle tribe aad its sole relict, awaiting the final summons that to that breathe." ail

See the clipping

The Arvada Enterprise · Arvada, Colo.

A farmer writes to the editor defending pheasants and doves as beneficial rather than nuisances, arguing their insect and weed-seed destruction outweighs grain loss. He warns that doves could meet the same fate as the passenger pigeon, once abundant but now reduced to a single female at the Cincinnati Zoo.

The Arvada Enterprise · 26 June 1913 · page 1

Pheasant Blessing Says One.

iinestimable value to the farmer B 3 the dove—yet farmers let load "after lvad of city sports come and wantonly destroy them. The Dpen season on doves is a mis take. How long will it be before they too, will be extinct like the beautiful carrier or passenger pigeon that a few years ago was

See the clipping

The Leon Reporter · Leon, Iowa

A new federal statute classifies wild ducks and geese as migratory birds, making it a crime to shoot them anywhere in the U.S., with fines and imprisonment for violators. The report notes that wild turkeys and geese have nearly vanished and that wild pigeons have already disappeared entirely.

The Leon Reporter · 26 June 1913 · page 9

No More Duck Hunting.

United States. Wild ducks are now classified as migratory birds by the government, in a law just enacted, and a fine of $100 and ninety days' imprisonment are provided for a viotheir complete extermination. It has been said that wild turkeys, wild geese and some of the other wild fowls have almost entirely disap peared aid over the country. Wild ducks have also become scarce and wild pigeons have disappeared, the only wild pigeon known in the coun-

See the clipping

The Logan Republican · Logan, Utah

This 1913 piece recounts the destruction of Michigan's passenger pigeons, citing a $5,000 reward in 1903 that uncovered only one surviving bird by 1908. It uses the pigeon's extinction as a cautionary tale for protecting other native birds from overhunting and the plume trade.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Evening Times, 25 June 1913, The Evening Times, 25 June 1913.

Wrong

The Logan Republican · 26 June 1913 · page 6

m ' ( 'ACE SIX I iFdefensF I, OFTHE BIRDS H '' It Is Rooi to 8co this nation-wide B. i i luckllng ou of armor In behalf of our K; t little feathered friends. The wlso the H j iltrusltc. tlis poet-cal, liavo joined H 't lands In a common cause. Tlio wlao Hi S ucn realizes tho importance of proH H wiving .ho birds that our cro3 may H 'I lo; Urn altruist's heart swells with m j Rin'lcin at tho tales of cruelty and doB 1 lUacUou of the Innocent llttlo crcaB ' ' ' turca, will o the man with a strain of ' Erilcn.

See moreSee less

a wood, a field without tho all eery, merry songster. United, theso B Jirfcrent d.spos'tlons but with a com- -non cause, havo resulted In the Mc Mean Weeks bill for tho protection of ! I Kno migratory birds passed by conH (rcsu; bavo formed the Audubon so- ! ' defies In tho east. Many of tho states BB ! lave already sovcre ponhlltles attachBBl d to the needless slaughter of our HBb songsters and nscct vorous birds. And BIB most birds n o bat'J BBB Who tn l"il bus not awakened boH tides of nil c-'.y morn, and with heart I BBb filled with unu'.torablo Joy listened to BBBl tha carol of tho robin rod breast, BBB' matchless, liomollko songbird, or the BBB sweet llttlo wild canary, or If ho llvo BBBj m hamlet or outsklrt of city, heard BBH the round, melodious swing of the H meadow lark? There on May morning R they sit and Interpret for us tho gladBBY neis to be allvo as no numan-mado BBj joctry or music can over do !t, and at BBl cvcntldu from tho top of tho loft popBBl la.-, or hidden nway In tho cool re8 cesses of box elder, or locust, express BBBJ as naught olso can the full, out-pourBBBJ tng heart grateful for the perfect days H or spring and summer.. BBBJ Shall those doir llttlo creatures be BBBJ ruthlessly killed for sport, for to whnt tho Iloman appotlta which craves for j BBBJ dish of hummingbirds' tongues, or i to be shipped abroad that tho feathers B may bo returned to our shores to j BBbJ adorn tho head gear of our fair woVarious sections of thU broad land BBBJ Iinvo felt tho blighting Influences of ! B : wholesalo destruction of their native ' B birds, l.llto tho Judgement rod of God B havo quickly followed unpnrnlled rav H ages of ravenous Insects. B Now Vork and tho New England H states woro swept as If by nro In sue H ccsbIoii by tho brown toll and lllpiy H moth, while sectional portions of the H country havo been put under u blight H by tho codl'.n moth, green aphis and H otliors. It Is generally conceded that H a cultivation of tho native birds more B or less holds theso pests In cneck BBBB And Michigan mod tho day It miniBBBV hllated Its wild pigeons In 1SC0 to BBBB 1869. Ten years ago ii $5,000 reward H was offered for a nesting pair of theso H pigeons, which brought out tho aston-

See the clipping

The Keota News · Keota, Colo. · and 3 other papers

The report recounts how wild pigeons once filled the skies by the millions decades earlier, then vanished entirely within a year or two. It describes a recent rumor of a surviving pair near Ansonia, Pa., prompting a $5,000 reward and a fruitless weekend search by thousands of hopeful searchers.

The Keota News · 27 June 1913 · page 4

Slaty or more years ago the wild pigeons were here by the millions. They fairly covered the skies when they flew over In flocks. They sold In those days at five cents a dozen, and they were the best eating in the world; far superior to the tame pig eons we have now. Suddenly they disappeared, and in a year or two not a pigeon was to be seen anywhere.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 19 June 1913
  • The Odanah Star · Odanah, Wis. · 27 June 1913
  • The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La. · 5 July 1913

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

An editorial on a new game law argues that market or pot hunters were responsible for the practical extermination of the passenger pigeon and the buffalo, and are now destroying other game species. It calls for state-run breeding programs rather than mere sale restrictions to preserve wild game.

The San Francisco Call · 27 June 1913 · page 6

The New Game Law I The new game law prohibiting 1 the sale of 'wild game; except ducks, for; the month of November is in line with the game laws of most of the states of i the union. ,; If the state ? could, .[ or would, propagate ; wild game on the scale upon which it is done by private persons in England, for example, then the sale of wild game might be desirable. During the shooting season in Great Britain grouse and pheasants can be bought i it the market in London cheaper than similar birds can ever be bought here, yet the pot hunter ;in this country practically destroys the several species of wild I game and there is no serious effort made to re store it.

See moreSee less

■ ;■ ' '.=*.. ■_ \ - '" . ■ ' ■■' ■-. '"'_ ' The market hunter, or pot hunter, as he is gen \ crally called, is the man who is responsible for the practical extermination of the passenger pigeons land the buffalo, and for the rapidly disappearing grouse, woodcock, wild duck and other I game ani mals and birds in this country. Abolition of market hunting and restriction of the sportsman's bag may go some way toward preserving wild game life, but breeding by the state is the only way in which it can be kept at a maximum. - - -: r : ' ' '"■ " '.' ' " .' /,'•,"," : When deer can become, as they unquestionably are at times, a nuisance in the thickly settled manufacturing states of New England, under pro tection of the law, then the wild game life of such thinly settled i states as California may be restored to its normal condition. " "" Ice KingMorse is : one ex-convict with a good job,

See the clipping

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

A political article reports that the Progressive 'Bull Moose' party is fading away, with an editor predicting its extinction just like the wild pigeon and great auk. The passenger pigeon is invoked here merely as a byword for vanished species, not as news about the bird itself.

The Daily Gate City · 30 June 1913 · page 7

WILL SOON BE AN EXTINCT BIRD

AN EXTINCT BIRD The Bull Moose Is Passing Into Oblivion Like the Wild Pigeon and Great Auk. [Special to The Gate City.] WASHINGTON, D. C., June 30.—The

See the clipping