As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

December 1912

12 articles

The Morris County Chronicle · Morristown, N.J.

A Minneapolis hunter reports seeing large numbers of wild pigeons along the White River in Arkansas, describing a tree full of birds and an old guide shooting ten with one blast. The account contradicts skepticism from others who doubted such sightings were still possible.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 23 days earlier.

Wrong

The Morris County Chronicle · 3 December 1912 · page 7

PUPPY’S BITE CAUSES DEATH Bride of Three Months 8uccumbs_ Two Dogs Also Die of Hydro phobia. Cleveland. Ohio.—Bitten on the arm three weeks ago by a puppy, Mrs. Florence, a bride of three months, died of hydrophobia In a hospital here. The bite was not thought to be of much consequence until the puppy bit anotner dog and both canines died with symptons of rabies. Four days ago Mrs. Dietz became seriously 111, and delirium and death followed. The puppy that bit Mrs. Dietz was a wed ding present from her husband.

See moreSee less

“None of us could guess what they were, but the old guide, who was sit ting in the stern guiding the boat. He dropped his paddle In surprise. ‘Gosh, fellers, them’s the first wild pigeons I’ve seen in twenty-five years!’ he yelled, and reached for the fowling piece. He brought down ten at a single shot.” Middies Lose Their Mascot. Annapolis.—Bill, for many years the goat mascot of the middles, is dead. An Angora cat will replace him. - FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE OF THE BALKANS stitute of Chicago.)

See the clipping

The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J.

A Minneapolis sportsman, Michael G. Burns, claims he saw huge numbers of wild pigeons along the White River in Arkansas, birds believed to have vanished decades earlier. His guide shot down ten with a single blast, though others who heard the story were skeptical.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

The Penn's Grove Record · 6 December 1912 · page 4

WILD PIGEONS OF ARKANSAS Reported Seen by A Hunting Party Along the White River—Ten Shot by Guns

ting in the stern guiding the boat. Ha dropped his paddle in surprise. “Gosh, fellers, them's the first wild pigeons

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A Toronto Globe piece reprinted in 1912 recalls the once-vast flocks of the passenger pigeon that darkened skies and nested by the millions, now virtually extinct. It laments wasteful slaughter—netting, shipping by the barrel, pinching breasts from squabs—and regrets that protective measures came too late.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 December 1912 · page 48

K. liuckro.se. George JI. Doran Co., New York. wood pigeon is done A Beautiful Bird, Once Present in Multitudes, Almost Extinct From the Toronto Cllobe. The wonderful flocks that darkened the sky, bent and broke tlie branches of trees

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The article recalls stories of wasteful slaughter of passenger pigeons and notes that protective measures came too late to save the species. It explains that modern claimed sightings in Ontario are consistently mourning doves, not the extinct wood pigeon, and that captive breeding is unlikely to save the species.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 December 1912 · page 48

“Does your wife make “Well, she doesn’t mince once—the first Christmas she was mar ried—and she was telling: me how lucky John (that was Hubby’s name) had been. 'Don't you know.’ she quer ried, 'he got a Mahogany Sewing Table from Mother and a set of hand-made doilies from Auntie, and a Dresden China Tea Set fsnm Cousin Minnie, and it was so hard for me to decide wheth er to give him Green Silk Portieres for the Hall or new Dace Curtains for the Drawing Room.’ Oh, John .was lucky, wasn’t lie?” 8111*1 giggled rather senselessly, the Mere Man thought.

See moreSee less

"So you see how easy It. Is,” she went on presently. "Do 1 make myself per fectly clear?** SI IK looked away with "welling eyes.” "You see," lie explained, to work it out by the pr< nation. When a. girl knot to give a man.” "Certally,” HUM ag cod simple hut there's Jnjt ftjj I want you to tell rfp hi tills conversation. Ijn &j to know a KKAh Smoking Jackets. t Hr* get them every Christmas "Ask a REAL mu : quickly, "about somfiHn^ the average Smoking average girl gives is*** usually a thing of velvet and embroid ery and—” It wasn't what he SAID but the WAV' he said It, that mtide the girl turn icy cold. "That’s what makes me advise every girl who asks me,” Hie Mere Man said presently, "not to EVER give a REAL man a—SMOKING JACKET.” abundance are remembered with stories of wanton destruction, of schooner loads wasted and of the tilling; of barrels with the breasts pinched from the squabs, th.* bodies bringthrown away. The wood pigeon could not now exist in old time abundance, for such flocks would clear away the crops which have supplanted the forest, but it is deeply to be regretted that protective measures were not adopted in time to avert extermination. There may yet be a few' specimens In captivity. Home ten years ago tlie owner of half a dozen birds in Chicago was seeking other owners willing to trade. His birds were descended from a single pair and were showing the degeneracy of in-breeding. It is not at ail likely that tlie birds In captivity will save the species from be coming extinct. Tim world now possesses only a. lew survivals from the countless forms of life that must have lived upon It ami the wild pigeon will bo the latest to go over to the majority. A slimmer seldom passes without the report of a wild pigeon being taken In some part of Ontario, tint these reports have* ceased to awaken any hope among those who have beep eagerly investigat ing them during the past two decades. In every case the bird described as a wood pigeon has proved to he a mourning dove. These birds are closely related to and closely resemble the wood pigeon. I hoy are considerably smaller, and their plumage i; b . s rich In color. A dark spot on either side of the neck is a distin guishing feature. The mourning dove sur vives because it lacks the gregarious nesting habits that made the wood pig eon an easy victim. In any extensive wood lot in southern Ontario a pair of mourning doves may spend the summer. A careless and strag gling nest of twigs Is made on the ground or on a Hat stump, and. If the two white eggs escape the crows. Jays, squirrels and other robbers, the twins, with the rapid growth peculiar to their race, are soon able to take wing. These birds are easily distinguished by their cooing notes, their long, pointed tails, and generally dull brownish colors. Naturally there Is an eager quest for wood pigeon skins and stuffed specimens. Anyone possessing even a fragment of a bird has a coveted treasure. Museums are paying fancy prices for the skins, but it Is not likely that there will be many additions to the specimens already recorded In ornitholo gical collections. "they’ll have - ; ufivUmt • 4 iutt !.nr ;! t * i i-i.'i u L l 4

See the clipping

Pioneer Press · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A local newspaper column discusses the killing of 210 wild geese by two hunters and argues for bird protection laws. It recalls that before the Civil War, millions of wild pigeons once filled the skies and broke tree limbs with their numbers, but notes they are now gone, used as a cautionary parallel for geese and ducks.

Pioneer Press · 14 December 1912 · page 2

?io of wild geeee and thousands in endlees processions were going to tbeir destination, Not so to-day, and the pie nre explains wby. Be fore tbe oivil war millions of wild pigeons Cf-me to ibis coontry yearly Tt>ere w^re so many tb-3 ridges and m<~?or!ains were lined with tbem and of evenings it was common to bear limba of trees breaking because of so many beinR on tbe.m. Are they breaking licoba now? Or do you know of any being cooped or ? fHpppd? *heee are gone and to will tbHg?ee< and ducks unleee protect ed.

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN

The report notes that a $400 reward offered a year earlier for discovering a single nesting pair of wild pigeons has gone unclaimed, prompting an increase to $1,500. It reflects on the once-vast flocks that darkened skies during migrations, now seemingly vanished more completely than the buffalo.

The Kanabec County Times · 19 December 1912 · page 8

WILD PIGEON HAS VANISHED. A year ago S4OO was offered by the national association of Audubon socie ties for the discovery of a single pair of nesting wild pigeons. Apparently none has been found thus far, and now the offer is increased to $1,500. That the wild pigeon has vanished from the United States seems almost unbelievable. Thousands of men still active remember when in the mi grations northward in April and southward in October, the air was sometimes darkened with the vast numbers of these birds which were seen. Often, for hours at a time, their flying squadrons were in sight This was true in states along the Atlantic seaboard as well as in the West.

See moreSee less

Branches of great trees were sometime|S broken down by the weight of these flocks as they alighted. And now they seem to have disappeared even more completely than the buffalo. —St. Louis Globe-Democrat.

See the clipping

The Ocala Banner · Ocala, Fla.

This editorial reflects on historical intolerance, citing atrocities against Native Americans and harsh colonial justice systems. It uses the extermination of billions of wild pigeons as a rhetorical comparison to the mass killing of indigenous peoples.

The Ocala Banner · 20 December 1912 · page 6

Millions upon millions, whole races and nations were remorselessly cut off the same as the billions of wild pigeons that formerly" darkened the earth have been in our day so ruth

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Ocala Banner · Ocala, Fla. · 23 September 1921

The Monett Times · Monett, Mo.

The article recalls the passenger pigeon's once-vast flocks, quoting Wilson's estimate of two billion birds in a single Kentucky flock, before describing how relentless shooting and netting wiped out the species by the early 1900s. It then pivots to argue that hawks, like the pigeon once was, are being needlessly persecuted through bounty programs despite being largely beneficial.

The Monett Times · 20 December 1912 · page 6

v ARE HAWKS HARMFUL? It is evident to the observer that the number of birds is de minishing rapidly. Only a lew years ago (up to 18S5)the passen ger pigeon was very abundant in this country. The stories that are told about the large llocks and their roosting places seem incredible. It is said that they traveled in such great numbers, that they actually darkened the sky, some times covering several square miles. Wilson, the great ornithologist, estimates that a flock seen by him near Frankfort Kentucky contained at least 2,000,000,000 individuals.

See moreSee less

What has become of these immense flocks of pigeons'? They were shot, netted, and cruelly slaughtered at their roosting places, and sent by the shipload to the markets and offered for sale at a penny apiece. This continued so long as there were birds enough to make it profit able. Major Bondine as late as 192 says: "It looks now as if their total extermination might be accomplished in this century." We must admit that his sad words are only too true. What is left of these large flocks? One or two reports that a passenger pigeon has been seen are receiv ed during the year and these are doubtful. The passenger pigeon has

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

A wild pigeon mailed from Odell Town, Quebec, to a Montreal newspaper was identified by SPCA officers as a nearly extinct passenger pigeon. The report recounts the species' history, its vast historical flocks, and attributes its decline to hunting, deforestation, and a series of cold winters between 1860 and 1870.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

East Oregonian : E.O · 25 December 1912 · page 7

RARE PASSENGER PIGEON A rather unusual ornithological specimen was received at Montreal recently, from Odell Town, Que., when a wild pigeon or dove carefully packed In a cardboard box was de posited in the city postoffice address ed to the "Witness. The bird was taken to J. B. Innes secretary of the Society for Preven tion of Cruelty to Animals, and also secretary of the Quebec Fish and Game Club. He definitely identified the bird as a wild pigeon or dove, a species now almost extinct. Officers connected with the sovie ty entered the office while Mr.

See moreSee less

In nes was Inspecting tho bird, and they each at once recognized it as a wild dove. . The sender of the little feathered creature was John Hough, of Odell Town, Que. He explained his reason for mailing it was to have it identified for he had heard queries had been made regarding wild pigeons. The wild, or passenger pigeon, so named from its habit of passing from one part of the country to another, was oncea resident of ouihern Can ada and the northern United States. One naturalist computed that there were more than a billion of these birds in continuous -fligh which he saw on one occasion. Incessant slaughter and the clear ing away of the .forests destroyed the pigeons, the dissappearance of which was hastened by a series of very cold winters between 1S60 and 1870. The male passenger pigeon is about 17 Inches long. Including the long narrow, gracefully pointed tail. The female is much smaller. The wings are long and pointed and ca pable of swift and powerful flight. The upper parts of the bird gener ally are of a variable blue, the neck glossed with a metallic golden vio let, the lower parts purplish or brownish, red fading behind into a velvet tint nearly white beneath the tail. The wing quills are blackish with a blueish border and the wing co verts are obsecurely spotted. The cen ter tail feathers are brown, the others pale blue on the outer and white on the Inner web. - Foils a Foul Plot. When a shameful plot exists be tween liver and bowels to cause dis tress by refusing to act. take Dr. King's New Life Pills, and end such abuse of your system. They gently compel right action of stomach, liv er and bowels, and restore your health and all good feelings. 25c at Koeppens. i Fines Roddy" Grirfin $100. St. Paul. W. H. (Reddy) Griffin of St. Paul and John Marks, alias Jake Sykes, who makes his home in both St. Paul and Minneapolis, were fined $100 each in a Minneapolis court for disorderly conduct. The men were found guilty but sentence was stayed to give the grand Jury time to act. The men also were ln-

See the clipping

Tensas Gazette · St. Joseph, La. · and 2 other papers

A Minneapolis report describes a hunting party along the White River claiming to have seen wild pigeons, species believed vanished for twenty-five years, with ten birds reportedly shot by a guide. The account questions whether the once-abundant wild pigeons have returned.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 21 days earlier.

Wrong

Tensas Gazette · 27 December 1912 · page 3

In actual cash and lands the 2,200 Osages are worth .""000oo0. 'ach WILD PIGEONS OF ARKANSAS Reported Seen by a Hunting Party Along the White River-Ten Shot by Guide.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Morris County Chronicle · Morristown, N.J. · 3 December 1912
  • The Commonwealth · Greenwood, Miss. · 6 December 1912

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · Lakeland, Fla.

A sermon-like editorial about historical cruelty and injustice references the passenger pigeon's extermination as a comparison point, noting that billions of wild pigeons that once darkened the sky have been ruthlessly wiped out in modern times. The piece uses this alongside colonial-era atrocities and brutal historical justice systems to criticize contemporary moral decay.

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · 27 December 1912 · page 6

(lefts of rocks, and the solitude of invisible caves; frcm the eternal snows of the Andes, where there were no witness but the all-seeing Sun, there went up to Cod a wail of des pair." Millions upon millions, whole races ; iul nations were remorselessly cut off the same as the billions of wild pigeons that formerly darkened the

See the clipping

Tensas Gazette · St. Joseph, La.

An old fishing/hunting guide reportedly spots a flock of birds he identifies as passenger pigeons, exclaiming he hasn't seen any in twenty-five years. He then shoots ten of them with a single blast from his fowling piece.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

Tensas Gazette · 27 December 1912 · page 3

PUPPY'S BITE CAUSES DEATH uride of Three Menthe Succumbs Two Dogs Also Die of Hydro. phobia. Cleveland, Ohio.-Bitten on the arm three weeks ago by a puppy, Mrs. Florence, a bride of three months. died of hydrophobia it a hospital here. The bite was not thought to be of much consequence until the puppy bit another dog and both canines died with symptons of rabies. Four days ago Mrs. Diets became seriously ill, and delirium and death followed. The puppy that bit Mrs. Diets was a wed ding present from er husband "None of us could guess what they were, but the old guide, who was sit ting in the stern guiding the boat He dropped his paddle in surprise.

See moreSee less

'Gosh. fellers, them's the first wild pigeons I've seen In twenty-five years!' he yelled, and reached for the fowling pieee. He brought down ten at a single shot." Middles Loes Their Mascot. Ansapells.-Bill, for many years the goat mascot of the middles, is deed. An Angora cat will repla~ hm. FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE OF THE BALKANS Mme. Ellka Perra N. TamborasktL a rich Servian lady, who gave her palatial home and all her money to the Red Cross. is shown in the pho tograph on her way to the front at Pogerizvots, where she organized the hospital cot pa tianity replaced the old belief in tribal orchids, where the streams are cano pled over with beautiful foliage. And gods and the veneration of ancestors. the ugly, leering faces of savages are In many of the islands there are mar painted and tattooed with hideous do riage laws, but mostly martriag con signs, their bodies cut with great scars sists only in the purchase of a wife, or of tribal wars or tribal dances. Here as many as a man can afford. with I am wearing trousers and shoes. cocoanuts. Money is practically un Why, out there where the sun always known-$50 will support a man a life shines, clothes are a thing apart from time. "And there are rare plants, mostly a man." ed what I bad In mind and we were still talking when the policeman came and seised him. I knew other wom en had been bothered and I Just de cided to have the fellow locked up." was given $5,000 in cash by the Unit

See the clipping