As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

October 1912

16 articles

Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me.

A Maine correspondent writes to the editor wondering why robins have vanished from his area in 1912, describing how he once fed fifty-two nesting pairs the previous year but now sees none. He compares the robins' plight to the passenger pigeon, noting the species was last seen locally in 1868 and that a reward offered by Prof. Hodge failed to turn up any living bird, nest, or egg.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Oxford Democrat · 1 October 1912 · page 2

within a foot of the spade. After the leaves had fallen I counted, in the shade trees touching the house an(T in the orchard near by, fifty-two nests made and oocupied during the sea son of 1911. This year, except a few that appeared to be journeying north ward in April, I have seen not one. Are tbey, like the passenger pigeons so nu merous aixty years ago, destined to ex

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

An article praising the rose-breasted grosbeak for eating destructive potato beetles and other pests mentions in passing that the passenger pigeon, once numbering in the millions, is now extinct. The piece contrasts the grosbeak's population increase with the pigeon's complete disappearance as an example of divergent species fortunes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.

Wrong

Yorkville Enquirer · 1 October 1912 · page 1

two decades. In this time most species have suffered a marked decrease in numbers. The passenger pigeon numbered millions when the grosbreak commenced to eat beetles. The pigeon

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Elmer Kimball thought he had captured a rare wild pigeon worth $1000, but ornithologist Frank T. Noble examined it and declared it was actually a mourning dove. The report notes the last confirmed wild pigeon shot in the U.S. was in 1894, and Noble had been unable to obtain a genuine specimen for five years.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 October 1912 · page 10

fhojiave been at their cottage for the wnifHjr.-'have returned to their home ^HhVson street. rifiiwd. Plates Senator Obadiah Gardner was in the city. Wednesday, registered at Hotel North. He was on his way to Freeport. Thomas Quinn, representative-elect from Miltinocket, was a business vis itor, Wednesday, in the city and was registered at Hotel North. Too much cannot be said of the ex hibit of fail millinery and garments at Whitman <v Adams Co. Ladies should not fail to visit the opening today, tomorrow and Saturday. • _____ Many are availing themselves of the delightful ride furnished by the Att gusta-to-Rockland auto service.

See moreSee less

The gorgeous hues of autumn in the fields and forests have added to the fascina tion of such a trip at this time. And the spicy atmosphere of October gives new life as well as enjoyment to the tourist. Edwin L. White of the Sidney road is suffering from a dislocated shoul der and fractured collar bone, which will keep bint front work for some time. The fting-bfiTf "of "inc ’ c^rl ' in which he was riding flew, out, as he was driving home from the city, and as a result he was thrown heavily to the ground, landing on his right shoul der. Elmer Kimball of Ward 8 succeed ed, a few#days ago, in securing what he believed to he a wild pigeon, a bird so rare Ithat a good specimen is worth at least $1000. He was about to have the bird sent to Winthrop for mounting when he decided to con sult Frank T. Noble of this city, who Is considered one of the best authori ties on ornithology In New England, as to its identity. Mr. Noble, upon seeing the specimen declared it to be a mourning dove instead of a wild pigeon, and Mr. Kimball, after seeing Mr. Noble’s specimen of the mourning dove became convinced that the lat ter was right. The mourning dove is not a common bird in this section but it is by no means extinct as is the wild pigeon. The last wild pigeon known to have been shot in the Unit ed States was killed in 1894, and for the post five years Mr. Noble has had a standing order with bird collectors for a specimen of a wild pigeon but out been able to secure one.

See the clipping

The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.

A conservation advocate in Arkansas argues that the state's birds are farmers' best friends and need legal protection, citing cold storage shipment data showing massive numbers of wild birds killed for food. He warns that the passenger pigeon has already gone extinct and that quail, turkey, woodcock, and deer could be next in Arkansas without stronger game laws.

The Prescott Daily News · 4 October 1912 · page 3

W. T. HART 3UBHED BY rs Printing Co. econd class mail matter 1905, at the postoffice rk., under the act of ch 3, 1879. )HNSON, Editor ,RT LECTUR- ' lL OVER STATE k, Oct. •!.—E. V. Vi/ iry of the Arkansas ish Protective Asso during throughout ihe interest of game laws. In discuss iportant subject be ipapers of this 'state i duty to perform n too long delayed, yJof the press to as l larger share of the vild life protection ifore It is in the press to save the of the wild life of " X — great many of these very birds were no doubt killed and shipped from Arkansas: 8,053] snow buntings, 7,607 sand-pipers,5,218 plovers, 7,003 snipe, 788 yellow legs, 7,560 grouse, 4,385 quail, 1,756 ducks, 288 bobolinks, and 06 wood cock.

See moreSee less

Will the farmers of Arkansas continue to stand for the sale of their best friend as ‘food’ for the hungry, no, for those who know not what hun ger is ? “August Silz of New York says he sells one million game birds per year. Thelpassenger pigeon has become] extinct, so has the prairie chicken so far as Arkansas is concerned, and the ng,xt candidates for|early extinc tion in ArkansasHare the quail, turkey, woodcock Jand’Jdeer. I appeal to the farmers ot] Arkan sas to insist upon theirjrepresen tatives and senators to support a general game bill that Swill pro tect. and I appeal to the press of the state]to keep these facts be fore the people continually, call ing attention to the great neces sity for the protection of wild life.”

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

An Arkansas wildlife official appeals to farmers and the press to support bird protection laws, citing cold storage trade data showing massive bird kills shipped to New York. He warns that the passenger pigeon is already extinct and the prairie chicken effectively gone from Arkansas, with quail, turkey, woodcock and deer next at risk.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 5 October 1912 · page 2

SAVE WILD LIFE

“August S lx of New York says he sells one million game birds per year. The passenger pigeon haa be er me extinct, so has the prairie chick en so far as Arkansas is concerned, and the next candidate for early ex t'nction in Arkansas are the quail, turkey, woodcock and deer. I appeal to the ffarmers of Arkansas to insist upon their representatives and Sena tors to support a general game h i! that will protect, and 1 appeal to the press r.f the state to keep these facts bet ere the people continually, calling attention to the great necessity for he protection of wild life.”

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

An Arkansas wildlife official urges farmers to support game laws, warning that the passenger pigeon has already gone extinct and that quail, turkey, woodcock, and deer could be next. The report frames bird protection as beneficial to crops and calls on the press to help educate farmers.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 9 October 1912 · page 6

i remainder of our wild life if it will ! I can go into the different countie: of the state and talk to the people, bu I cannot reach the great masses o the people whom the enactment o good game laws will most benefit, flu farmers. ‘'There are a great many farmers it . | Arkansas who do not understand tha , I the birds are their best friends, and t< ! protect the birds means to protect tin ! crops. The passenger pigeons ha: . ■ become extinct, and the next, candi

See the clipping

The Springdale News · Springdale, Ark.

An Arkansas wildlife official argues the state needs hunting and fishing licenses to prevent further loss of wildlife, noting the passenger pigeon has already gone extinct. He appeals to farmers and the press to support game laws before quail, turkey, woodcock, and deer suffer the same fate.

The Springdale News · 11 October 1912 · page 1

‘‘There are a great many farmers in Arkansas who do not understand that the birds are their best friends and to protect the birds means to protect the crops. The passenger pigeon has become extinct and the next candidates in Arkansas for early extinction are the quail, tur key, woodcock and deer. I appeal to the farmers of Arkansas to in sist upon their representatives vot ing for a game law.” KILLS FATHER-IN-LAW Arthur Webster I'ses Shot Gun

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The piece argues for bird protection legislation and refuges, referencing Mrs. Russell Sage's purchase of Marsh Island, Louisiana, as a migratory bird sanctuary. It mentions the passenger pigeon's flights once darkening the skies as a benchmark of former abundance, alongside other declining species like wood ducks and prairie chickens.

The Washington Herald · 11 October 1912 · page 4

Mrs. Russell Sage's Benefaction. It was time that something decisive should be done to protect the migratory feathered creatures. The beautiful wood duck is almost as nearly extinct as the wild pigeon, whose flights dark

See the clipping

The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.

A Minneapolis merchant, Michael G. Burns, claims to have seen vast flocks of wild pigeons along the White River in Arkansas, raising hope that the once-abundant species had returned after disappearing decades earlier. Other men who heard the claim were skeptical.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 17 days earlier.

Wrong

The Daily Ardmoreite · 18 October 1912 · page 1

Kansas City, Mo., Oct. 17. Have the wild pigeons which flew across the Mistlsslppi valley by the mil lions a quarter of a century ago, and then suddenly disappeared, re turned? If they have it Is the best news sportsmen have heard In many a day, and Miohael G. Burns of Minneapolis, merchant and sports man, declares that they have. Men who heard Mr. Burns' statement a' the Hotel White -were Inclined to discredit it, but the Minneapolis nlmrod declares he has seen within the last two weeks wild pigeons in great numbers along the White riv er in Arkansas.

See the clipping

Atlanta Georgian · Atlanta, Ga.

An Atlanta parks manager, responding to a Bronx Zoo survey on extinct game species, reports that passenger pigeons are gone from Georgia, with the last ones seen in 1886 near the North Carolina line. The report also catalogs other species considered extinct or rare in the state, including bison, elk, and mountain lions.

Atlanta Georgian · 21 October 1912 · page 6

GRESS ZOO GETS NEW BLACK BUCK

Passenger Pigeons Extinct. The passenger pigeon, the bison, the puna-mon mountain lion and elk are gone. Mr Carey said the Southeastern states were the original range of the American buffalo, but that they were driven West by the early settlers. The last passenger pigeons in Geor gia were observed in 1886 on Pigeon river, in Haywood county, near the North Carolina line. It was a large covey, but disappeared after the sum mer season of 1886. According to his information, the Carolina parakeet and the whooping crane are extinct, though they were seen a few years ago. Huffed grouse are found in the moun tains of northeast Georgia.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Atlanta Georgian · Atlanta, Ga. · 22 October 1912

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont.

Two Missoula men reported seeing a flock of 30-40 wild pigeons fly over a ranch, the first such sighting one of them had seen in his 30-40 years in Montana. They missed out on a magazine's prize for capturing a live pair, lacking only salt to lure the birds.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Missoulian · 22 October 1912 · page 10

WILD PIGEONS

Around the stove they gather now, when autumn winds blow raucous; they sit on boxes and FIXING on chairs and hold the THINGS evening caucus; the Balkan war calls forth a blast against the awful Turk; the caucus votes to pull for Greece in her avenging work; the baseball champs receive a dose of good old hot-stove roasting; Jake Stahl had such a nar row squeak that he should do no boasting; the man who shot at Roose velt, eternally is damned; his gtn, just as he used it, should down his throat be crammed; the argument is fierce and fast about the cost of liv ing; the price of turkey and of spuds forecasts a poor Thanksgiving; the mayor and the councilmen receive a torrid blast, because they let the autos run so gosh-almighty fast; the trusts are busted all to smash because of their great wrongs; each magnate is consigned to burn in the place where he belongs; the prospects of the win ter and the likely fall of snow, receive consideration, ere the hour comes to go; the enemies of the people receive an awful beating-then the order comes to douse the glim and ends the evening meeting.

See moreSee less

Contractor G. H. Nash, who is in charge of the work on Cedar street, yesterday received bills MORE of lading for two more BLOCKS cars of blocks. This makes four cars that are known to be on the road, and there will be no delay in their arrival here if the contractor can get them through. Agent Mason of the North ern Pacific is tracing the shipments and the first two cars should arrive in Missoula within a few days. As soon as the first cars get here, Mr. Nash will start his men back to work and will exert every endeavor to finish the street this fall. Now that he has re ceived the bills of lading, Mr. Nash feels more sure of the fact that the blocks are in transit. "I know now that blocks are coming," said Mr. Nash, "and we are going to get that street completed if there is any pos sible way of doing it. I don't think the company has given me a very square deal In regard to the blocks. They said in their telegrams that the blocks were not shipped on account of a lack of cars. As I understand it, the railroads have been sending emp ties west right along, and I don't think the company made any very great ex ertion or it could have gotten the blocks out here. The blocks should be here within a short tifne, however, and If the wet weather will only hold off, we will finish that street yet." Superintendent Wiltse is perfectly satisfied with the paving outlook at the present time. If LOOKS everything goes as he GOOD has it outlined, the work in Missoula will be complsted by the last of next week. The men practically finished the east end of Railroad street yesterday and there is only three days' work at the west end of the street. The east side of Higgins avenue at the north end of the bridge will be completed with in a few days and then nothing re mains to be done except Bank street. It was found necessary yesterday to take up the pavement on the east end of Railroad street in two places where it was low and allowed the water to gather. "We should have the forms off the bulkhead in Bank street by next Friday," said Superintendent Wiltse yesterday, "and I cannot see any reason why we shouldn't have that street finished by the last of next week. This will wind up our paving hero, for this season at least." Attorney J. E. Patterson was rather surprised yesterday when he received a letter from Helena WINS and noticed that it con PRIZES tained a check. Upon further investigation he found that he had taken three prizes on apples sent to the Helena State fair. As Mr. Patterson only sent six different varieties, he is some tickled at pulling down ribbons on three of them. Mr. Patterson was given prizes on his playts of fravenstein, Northern Spies and Wagenor apple. The (iravensteins took first place. The Northern Spies second and the Wag enors third. Mr. Patterson owns a 15-acre orchard west of Daly addition. "Recreation," a magazine devoted mostly to outdoor sports, has for the past few months been WILD carrying an an PIGEONS nouncement that it will give a large prize to anyone who captures a pair of wild pigeons alive. Only the absence of a little salt kept a couple of Missoula men from being enriched considerably by this offer. J. D. Rowland and 'Dr. \V. P. Mills were out at the Mills ranch Sunday, and during the after noon a flock of between 30 and 40 wild Pigeons passed directly over the house and flew south. "These are the first wild pigeons I have seen in Mon tana," said Dr. Mills, "and I have been a resident of this state between 30 and 40 years. I used to see them in Minnesota, but until Sunday I never saw a wild pigeon in this country." For some time political talk around Missoula was scarce. The world's series held everyone's TALK IS attention and after it REVIVED was over, several days' time was necessary to permit of a. full discussion of that tenth inning. Now that the New York fans have decided all about the way the blame should be divided, the po litical bee has commenced its bus xing--or rather resumed it. Election

See the clipping

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

At Phillips Exeter Academy, instructor Laurence Crosbie gave boys a talk on vanishing American game, citing the bison's near-destruction and the wild pigeon's total extinction as warnings. He urged stricter enforcement of game laws to protect quail, woodcock, and other declining species.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 23 October 1912 · page 4

buffalo, and told of how within a (}ua.r ter of a century the game hunters/ had 'practically wiped them out. - It was interesting to hear the in structor tell how thousands of them roamed the +western plains and how itodeay there is scarcely one of them to - be seen. He likewise referred to the ' game birds, which he sa:d, are becoming extinct in the same manner. The gun and the love of Killing has done the - work, was his inference. The instructor took, for example, the wild pigeon, show ing the fate of these birds, and said that if strict game laws were not enforced other birds would meet the fate of the pigeon.

See moreSee less

The wild pigeon was a game bird of much interest not more than

See the clipping

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont.

A farmer describes a sandy farm fifteen miles away that produces unusually heavy crops without added fertilizer. He was told this land was once a wild pigeon roost, and the rich droppings left by vast flocks still enrich the soil long after the pigeons disappeared.

The Poplar Standard · 24 October 1912 · page 7

LONG LASTING MANURE

«»r commercial fertilizer. I am told that this farm was a pigeon roost years ago, a place where the wild pigeons collected in vast numbers to roost overnight. They have disap peared from the country, but the soil j where they congregated siill shows the i effects of their presence. ,\ part of ! the plant food left by these birds ! seems to still be hold in the

See the clipping

Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis.

A farming column notes that a sandy farm long ago used as a mass pigeon roost still produces unusually heavy crops without manure or fertilizer. The writer attributes this lasting fertility to plant food left behind by the vast numbers of wild pigeons that once roosted there, though the birds have since disappeared.

Ladysmith News-Budget · 25 October 1912 · page 3

LONG LASTING MANURE

Heavy crops from year to year without either the application of stable manure or commercial fertilizer. I am told that this farm was a pigeon roost years ago, a place where the wild pigeons collected in vast numbers to roost overnight. They have disap peared from the country, but the soil where they congregated still shows the effects of their presence. A part of the plant food left by those birds seems to still be held in the soil.- farm ami Fireside.

See the clipping

The Bennington Evening Banner · Bennington, Vt. · and 1 other paper

A farm/poultry gossip column mentions a standing $500 Pennsylvania reward for anyone producing a live passenger pigeon. It states the last nesting site was in Michigan in 1878 and that the birds vanished forever by 1883.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Bennington Evening Banner · 26 October 1912 · page 5

Pennsylvania to the man who can pro duce a live passenger pigeon. It Is claimed the Inst nesting place of these wild pigeons was In Michigan hi 1S7S,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va. · 2 October 1912

Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va.

The report notes that the Cincinnati zoo is said to hold the only living wild passenger pigeon, a claim questioned by old Michigan hunters who once shipped the birds by the carload from famous roosts. It mentions a $1,000 reward for a real pair, while noting the forests needed for nesting had been destroyed.

Clarke Courier · 30 October 1912 · page 3

FEATHERS AND EGGSHELLS.

It Is claimed the zoo at Cincinnati has the only live ■wild passenger pigeon In existence. This is questioned by certain old Michigan hunters who used to ship them from the famous Michigan roosts by the carload. There is a $1,000 reward offered for a real pair of these pigeons. But if found,

See the clipping