As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

May 1912

8 articles

The Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis.

A bulletin from the American Game Protective and Propagation Association warns readers about birds at risk of extinction, including the snipe and passenger pigeon. It urges wider public awareness and concern for protecting such species.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

The Watertown Weekly Leader · 3 May 1912 · page 4

Game Birds. The bulletin just issued by the American Game Protective and Propa gation association should be read wide ly. Facts about the danger of extinc tion for such familiar sounding crea tures as the snipe and the passenger pigeon will make many a man thought ful about protecting them who wouldn’t know T one from another.

See the clipping

Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.

A Reedsburg newspaper reported that about 100 wild pigeons were seen flying over the city on May 1st, noting the species was believed nearly or wholly extinct. The article also mentions Clark University's ongoing $1,000 reward for finding undisturbed passenger pigeon nests, unclaimed for two years.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 28 days earlier.

Wrong

Baraboo Weekly News · 16 May 1912 · page 7

TO BE CURED oi meumatism ing at 38 to 40 cents a pound and even with all its lameness, aches and at that price the growers are reluctant pains, take Hood’s Sarsaparilla. You to sell.” #uust be sure to GET HOOD’S* mi phi t! mil On May Ist at about 2p. m. a flock of about 100 wild pigeons was seen by competent observers, flying in a south westerly direction over the city limits. The pigeons were not flying very high but their line of flight was quite di rect. This is interesting from the fact that our wild pigeons, which were once so numerous, have almost wholly disappeared, and by many are re garded as having become wholly extinct.

See moreSee less

—Reedsburg Free Press. Years ago millions of wild pigeons roosted in Sauk om;y and mmy were killed. The bird is be lieved to be extinct. Clark univer sity of Worcester, Massachusetts offers a reward of one thousand dol lars for the discovery of the undis turbed nests of passenger pigeons. For two years the offer has been made but without avail. Reports of band tailed viosea, red-billed or white winged pigeons from the western part of United States or mourning doves from eastern states have been re ceived but the rare bird is yet to be found. If there are any wild pigeons their nesting place must be difficult to find. All information should be sent to Charles K. Reed, Worcester, Mass.

See the clipping

Bryan Daily Eagle and Pilot · Bryan, Tex.

William T. Hornaday writes in Leslie's that forces destroying wildlife are increasing, noting the passenger pigeon, great auk, and other species are already completely exterminated. He warns at least fourteen more species face extinction soon without a shift in public sentiment to stop the slaughter.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

Bryan Daily Eagle and Pilot · 23 May 1912 · page 4

New York Times. Exterminating Our Wild Life. The forces that are actively seeking to destroy nil our best wild life are overwhelmingly numerous and very aggressive. Unfortunately each one of these forces of destruction Is stead ily becoming more deadly. I assert, without feHr of contradiction, that to day every valuable wild species in our country Is being killed faster than it is breeding. In our own tiroes the great auk. passenger pigeon. Labrador duck, Eskimo curlew. Carolina parrakeet, flamingo (in the United States). Pallao'8 cormorant and the whooping crane have been completely extermi nated.

See moreSee less

There are at least fourteen more species of birds that will be ren dered extinct in the near future un less a revolution in public sentiment quickly and sternly tops the universal slaughter. William T. Hornaday tn Leslie's.

See the clipping

Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.

A resident named Henry Erswell reports seeing two flocks of passenger pigeons flying northward, recalling how plentiful the birds once were in the area. The article notes naturalists believe the species may be extinct and that a $1,000 reward is offered for proof of surviving wild pigeons.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Baraboo Weekly News · 23 May 1912 · page 1

PASSENGER PIGEONS SEEN BY RESIDENT Henry Erswell Claims to Have Seen Flocks Northward Bound. BIG REWARD IS OFFERED Birds Once Numerous Believed by Some to be Now Extinct.

stand us. “home paper”! i City. lieved by Some to be Now Extinct. Henry Erswell, who resides near town, says that be has recently seen two flocks of passenger pigeons. In the one case there were probably 60 and in the next flock 40 or 50, he savs the two flocks were seen in the evening and were flying northward. Mr. Erswell says he well remembers when they were numerous in this country and has often visited their roosting places. He recalls going to the jack oak timber north of Kilbourn where he saw them nesting years ago.

See moreSee less

B tore he left Ohio he once went to a place in the Ashtabula sw 7 ara[.s where there were birds in abundance. While hunting for bees he has often seen the pigeons and feels well aquainted with them. He is sure the birds he saw some nights ago were wild or passenger pig eons. It is believed by naturalists that there are no more birds living and a reward of SI,OOO is ottered for proof that there are wild pigeons in this country. Years ago thousands and thousands were killed in Sauk county and there may be a few yet on the con tinent. In order to secure an intelligent search for the practically extinct pas senger pigeon, in the hope that the species may be saved from extermination, the awards offered by eastern ornithologists for the last two seasons will again be offered this year. (Continued on Last Page.)

See the clipping

Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.

Henry Erswell reportedly claims to have seen flocks of passenger pigeons heading northward, prompting mention of a $1,000 reward for verified nesting sites organized by naturalist C.F. Hodge. The report notes that in two years of searching, every previous sighting claim has proven false, usually misidentified mourning doves.

Baraboo Weekly News · 23 May 1912 · page 12

PASSENGER PIGEONS SEEN BY RESIDENT

E Thayer. Especial emphasis is laid by C f Hodge of Clarke university, Worces ter, Mass , by whom the search is be ing conducted, upon the fact tha* awards are offered solely for the infor mation of undisturbed nesting*. Th possession of any birds, alive or dead, is not desired. The effort is directed solely to save the free, wild pigeon. During the two years that the search has been conducted, several report have been received from diffeieot pan.- < f the country of the birds’ observa tion. These, however, without excep lion, have proven without cmfirma tion.

See moreSee less

All were of other species of pigeon or dove and not so much as a feather of tangible evidence has been found that the passenger pigeon stib exists in the wild state. The bird is sixteen inches in length, ruddy buff breasted, with red feet. It is often confused with the morning dove, which, however, is smaller ane may be distinguished by a olack spot on the side of the n< ck.

See the clipping

The Glenwood Post · Glenwood Springs, Colo. · and 8 other papers

A notice reports that the American Game Protective and Propagation Association has issued a bulletin warning about species facing extinction, including the snipe and passenger pigeon. It urges wide public readership to raise awareness about protecting these birds.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Glenwood Post · 25 May 1912 · page 3

{ the rows of plants in the same man: & ner as an ordinary cultivator, [ Game Birds. The bulletin just issued by the American Game Protective and Propa gation association should be read wide ly. Facts about the danger of extinc tion for such familiar sounding crea tures as the snipe and the passenger pigeon will jnake many a man thought ful about protecting them who wouldn't { know one from another.

See the clipping

Also printed in 8 papers
  • The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J. · 29 March 1912
  • Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 29 March 1912
  • The Spanish American · Roy, N.M. · 30 March 1912
  • The Mingo Republican · Williamson, W. Va. · 2 April 1912
  • Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 2 April 1912
  • The Oakley Herald · Oakley, Idaho · 26 April 1912
  • The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss. · 27 April 1912
  • Big Arm Graphic · Big Arm, Mont. · 1 May 1912

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A short item reports that Dr. M. Crown went into Paradise Valley and killed numerous 'White Winged' birds he called wild pigeons, craving their flavor. The writer jokingly likens it to the biblical Slaughter of the Innocents.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Republican · 26 May 1912 · page 6

A TERRIBLE SLAUGHTER. The "Slaughter of the Innocents" was nothing compared to the irreparable damage done yesterday by Dr. M. Crown, who went into Paradise and killed any number of White Winged creatures. The fact that it was Par adise Valley and the doctor hungry for the Tlavor of wild pigeon, only partially mitigates the offense.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report lists species already completely exterminated, including the great auk, passenger pigeon, Labrador duck, and others, and warns that at least fourteen more bird species face extinction soon. It calls for a revolution in public sentiment to stop the ongoing slaughter of wildlife.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Glenwood Post, 25 May 1912, Arizona Republican, 26 May 1912.

Evening Journal · 30 May 1912 · page 6

EXTERMINATING OUR WILD LIFE

country Is being killed faster than it la breeding. In our own times the j j great auk, passenger pigeon, Labrador . .

See the clipping