As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1909

9 articles

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A review of Rudolf Cronau's book on American wastefulness discusses the destruction of forests, water, soil, and wildlife, naming the passenger pigeon alongside bison, elk, and seals as species decimated by overexploitation. The review focuses mainly on the bison's extermination, citing conflicting population estimates and describing Hornaday's 1886 expedition to collect buffalo specimens for the Smithsonian.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 2 February 1909 · page 6

URAL WEALTH. — _ _Tells INIT •* De struction *1 Forest*, Salto, Min erals aa4 Ailsilii America, "the land of Inexhaustible resources," Is nearing a time when, through the prodigality of theyresent and past generations, It will be stripped of Its natural wealth and 1U people will be compelled to face an era of desti tution more widespread and hopeless than has been experienced by any other nation of the world. The prediction la appalling; but It summarises more or less accurately the conclusion reached by a German-Ameri can writer In a little volume which has lust appeared under the title, ‘Our Wasteful Nation; the Story of Prodigal ity and the Abuse of Our National Resources.

See moreSee less

Of count), there Is an “1*“ In the pre diction. The author ot the book In auestlon, Rudolf Crons*, does not be lieve that the Impending calamity, or series of calamities, Indicated Is Inev itable. His savin* clause Is somethin* to this effect: We will soon reach the end of our national resources If some thin* Is not done, by legislation and through other means, tp curb the exist ing extravagance of the American people in the use of many ot the ne cessities of human life which hereto fore, unfortunately, have been supposed to exist on this continent In practical ly Inexhaustible quantities. Bvea Human Mves. Many writers have taken up this matter of national wastefulness, espe cially during the present year, when the subject has been brought promi nently before the public through the conference of Governors at Washing ton. Usually. howevOr, It Is some par ticular kind of national wasftefulness— the destruction of the forests, for in stance—which has attracted the atten tion of the student. Mr. Crouan goes further than this and collects In one volume the details of various kinds of wastefulness, not confining himself to any particular branch of the subject. He thus gives “the story," not only of the destruction or dur forests, but of the waste of water, of soil, of minerals, of animals of all kinds, of public lands and privileges, public money and prop erty. and finally of the waste of human lives. His book Is thus Impressive from the wide array of facts which It marshals before the reader, and IS of special value and Interest when nation al wastefulness has become so fre quently a matter of public dlscussslon. Robbed of its rich fauna, which once supported millions of people and was the source of fabulous wealth, America !s fast becoming the continent poorest In animal life. The enormous destruc tion wrought to the fauna of North America became most apparent with creatures which kept together In large herds or flocks, like the bison or buffalo, the elk. the seal, the passenger pigeon, the heron, and the salmon. In detailing the story of the loss of America’s game, Mr. Cronau naturally dwells on the amaslngly short time In which was exterminated that king of American wild animals, the buffalo. He estimates that at the time of the dis covery of America by Columbus the number of bison roaming the Western plains, and. In fact, to be found In al most every part of the country, was 150,000,000 head. This estimate, he ad mits. Is difficult to authenticate; but he states as a positive fact that the blsoo "up to the beginning of the nine teenth century had decreased to about T 10 000.000. At that time the buffalo was still hunted In Kentucky and Illinois" From this section they rapidly, "melted away like snow until the last buffalo hunt occurred in the United States," in 188*. when William T. Hornaday, chief at that time of the taxldermlcal de partment of the Smithsonian Institu tion, Washington. D. C-, started an ex pedition to collect In Montana some robes and skeletons of buffalo which might be used for arranging a group of buffalo to be exhibited at the National T Museum. Only after very tedious move ments of several months Mr. Hornaday succeeded In bringing together twenty four hides and sixteen skeleton* which be brought to our Capital. Only a Few Left. “Of the 40,000,000 buffalo which at he beginning of the nineteenth cen

See the clipping

The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.

A report on Oklahoma's new game laws details hunting seasons and restrictions for various species, including deer, quail, turkeys, and waterfowl. Among the provisions, it states that passenger pigeons may not be killed at any time, reflecting the species' precarious status.

The Chickasha Daily Express · 4 February 1909 · page 1

Kaihoads may be fined $1(K and allowed ten days after the close of an open season are for propagation or ex change purposes. Possession of game birds during the closed season is made proof of violation of law. No antelope may be killed in Okla homa for five years, while the limit Tor deer Is one buck with horns each year. Quail may be shot from Nov. IS to Jan. 15, six weeks less than tha present season; wild turkeys from Nov. 15 to April 1; prairie chickens from Sept. 1 to Oct.

See moreSee less

1; doves from Sept. 1 to Oct. 1; snipes, plovers, cur lews, short birds, ducks, geese, brants, cranes, swans, Aug. to May 7; Mon golian, Chinese English ring neck or other pheasants may not be killed be fore Nov. 1 to Dec 1 of each year. Passenger pigeons may not be killed at any time.

See the clipping

The Tacoma Times · Tacoma, Wash.

The Pierce County Game and Fish Protective Association asked the state legislature for a raft of wildlife protections, including bag limits, bounties on predators, and licensing requirements. Among the many proposed rules was a restriction limiting the wild pigeon hunting season to October through December 31st.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Tacoma Times · 6 February 1909 · page 2

URGES MANY CHANGES If the legislature enacts bills as asked for by the Pierce County Game and flame Fish Protective Association, there ought to be plenty of birds and wild game In I a few years. It wants all killing of deer without horns prohibited and the present open season short ened. Included in the demands made at a meeting last night at the court house are: A game .pre serve on the Narrows; bounties of $25 for cougars, $10 for coyotes, $& for bobcat or lynx; no shoot ing of Hungarian phesant for 10 years; no shooting of hen pheas ants any time; no one allowed to shoot more than 10 quail, 5 paeas ants or 15 water fowl; all squirrel shooting prohibited; selling of trout prohibited, and number and size limited to fishermen; size and quantity limit placed on bass; wild pigeon season shall be only from October to December 31; all fishermen and hunters must have licenses.

See moreSee less

Arrangements will be made to send a lobby to Olympia to boost these propositions.

See the clipping

The San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

This editorial calls for a 10-year closed season and strict penalties to protect the wood duck from extinction, urging state legislation and captive breeding by clubs and estate owners. It warns that without action, the wood duck will vanish like the bison and passenger pigeon already have.

The San Antonio Light · 7 February 1909 · page 4

SAVE THE WOOD-DUCK.

1907. In addition to such a law, which is imperatively necessary at this time, it is recommended that all the clubs of ths country which control large pre serves, and individuals owning estates where suitable breeding places are found, should engage in the experiment of raising wood ducks, which at the end of the breeding season could be liberated. With a 10 years’ close sea son and breeding by public-spirited cit izens, the beautiful species of Ameri can wild fowl may be prevented from following in the steps of the bison, the passenger pigeon and others of the

See the clipping

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

The Nebraska senate amended King's game law, setting seasons for various game while removing wild pigeons from the list of protected species. The bill covered ducks, geese, quail, squirrels, bass, and other wildlife, but passenger pigeons were explicitly excluded from protection.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Valentine Democrat · 11 February 1909 · page 3

closes the snipe season May ] ; tae ! wild pigeons out of the protected list , and protects doves the entire year : make an open season for squirrel" from October 1 to November 30 ; black bass , from June 1 to November 15 : prohibits the taking or pursuing of

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

The article describes the passenger pigeon, now 'practically extinct,' as having been the most rapid continuous flyer among game birds despite unfavorable wing proportions. It cites claims of speeds exceeding a mile a minute, with some authorities estimating up to 120 miles per hour, supported by anecdotal evidence of rice from the Carolinas found in birds shot in Canada.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 23 days earlier.

Wrong

The Manitowoc Pilot · 11 February 1909 · page 5

Speed of Flight of Pigeons. Of our game birds the most gre garious and most beautiful passenger pigeon, now unhappily practically e\ tihet, Is or was doubtless the most

See the clipping

Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb.

The article recalls ornithologist Wilson's estimate of a flock exceeding two billion birds and Audubon's 1813 Kentucky account of pigeons so numerous they blotted out the sun for hours. It frames these as evidence of how abundant the species once was, now that it has been nearly wiped out.

Dakota County Herald · 12 February 1909 · page 6

Haa Been Almost Wiped Out. The ornithologist, Wilson, estimated a flock of passenger pigeons which lie once observed to contain over 2,000,000,- 000 of birds. But the great Audubon's graphic account of the Incredible num bers, flight and volant methods of flocks he noted In 1813 in Kentucky Is one of the most striking pictures of bird liter ature. Outing says. After counting 10:1 different' flocks In something less than one and ahalf hours and noting their increase In density and number, lie gave up any thought of even a wild approximation.

See moreSee less

"I traveled on," he says, "and still met more the further I proceeded. Tho air was literally filled with pigeons. The light of noondny was obscured ns by an eclipse nnd the dung fell in irnots not unlike melting flakes of snow, nnd the continual buzz of wings had a ten dency to tun my senses to repose. Not a single bird alighted, for not a nut or acorn was that year to bo seen in the neighborhood. They

See the clipping

Okolona Messenger · Okolona, Miss.

This report, quoting Outing Magazine, describes the passenger pigeon as the most gregarious and beautiful of game birds, now unhappily practically extinct. It discusses the bird's remarkable sustained flight speed, estimated by some authorities at up to 120 miles per hour, citing undigested Carolina rice found in birds shot in Canada as evidence of its speed and endurance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Bismarck Daily Tribune, 30 January 1909, The Manitowoc Pilot, 11 February 1909.

Okolona Messenger · 17 February 1909 · page 5

Speed of Flight of Pigeons; ' Of our game birds the most gre garious and most beam if ul passenger , pigeon, now unhappily practically ex- . Unet, Is or was doubtless" the most rapid, of continuous flyers; yet toi a total length of 16 inches its wings' length is about seven and eight-tenth Inches, a 'proportion less favorable for speed than with certain other les ; rapid specits of its family, says a writer In v Outing Magazine. Their sustained speed certainly exceeded . a ' mile a minute, and some authorities have estimated it as high as 120 miles per hour.

See moreSee less

The fact, often quoted, that the wild rice of the Carolina was sometimes found in the stomachs of birds shot in Canada shows both mar velous speed and. endurance. - - ' : - . v (v TsVr" -'r Trl"i. ' ': ' ' )C ' ''; ' ' ' ' 'i j:V' i.' aK.

See the clipping

Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va. · and 2 other papers

This piece recalls the passenger pigeon's historic abundance, describing a flock in 1813 Kentucky estimated at over a billion birds spanning the sky for hours. It also details how hunters trapped, fattened, and marketed the birds, treating their former numbers as almost unbelievable by 1909.

Clarke Courier · 24 February 1909 · page 3

THE AMERICAN WILD PIGEON “What a whopper!” remarked a | hearer as the oldest resident told that a flock of wild pigeons was so thick | he couldn't drive through it with a | two horse team, ; But do you believe us when we tell | Yon a modern locomotive couldn't do the stunt? If the jack rabbit grasshoppers of the west can stall a train, 2.000,000,000 pigeons ought to do it, and some flocks were estinfitéd at that number. In 1813 in Kentucky, a naturalist counted 16° flocks in two hours, the flogks increasing in size and continu ing to pass for three days.

See moreSee less

“The zIr was filled with pigeons, The sun was eclipsed. The continual buzz of wings lulled the senses to | sleep, while their excrement fell like | snow." : But they went like the buffalo. They were caught in news. Their nests were robbed of squabs, and even droves of hogs were fattened on pi geons. They were properly a species of dove that live in the woods and roost on trees. | Our tame pigeons came from the old world. About the only time they alight on a tree is when they are shot at and missed by so called sportsmen who continue the cruel practice of nsing | live birds for targets.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa. · 17 February 1909
  • Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J. · 4 March 1909