As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

March 1907

10 articles

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

The article notes that wild pigeons, once numbering in the millions across northern Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota, had vanished for years but were reportedly sighted again at several points in 1906. It expresses hope that their return, even in modest numbers, might be permanent and that the species would not go fully extinct.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Connecticut Western News · 7 March 1907 · page 7

Wild pigeons, millions of which used to throng the woods of northern Michi gan, Wisconsin arid Minnesota in by gone years, but which for many years

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn. · 21 March 1907

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

Burlington hunters petitioned against a proposed Iowa law banning quail and prairie chicken hunting for five years, arguing few quail are killed by guns compared to winter cold and trappers. The article counters that passenger pigeons and prairie chickens were once thought too abundant to vanish, yet pigeons are now extinct and prairie chickens scarce, urging support for the protective law.

Evening Times-Republican · 7 March 1907 · page 10

PUT FORWARD WEAK ARGUMENT

The Burlington protest is but one of many that have goi)e up every time an loiilva. legislature has attempted to cor rect hunting evils' and protect the state's game. Years ago it was said the wild pigeons and prairie chicken were too numerous to be wiped out. Where are they now? The pigeon has

See the clipping

The Independent · Lincoln, Neb.

An editorial about ducks and geese being hunted wantonly on a Texas gulf island warns that these birds face the same fate as the passenger pigeons, which are described as already doomed to extinction. The reference treats the passenger pigeon's disappearance as an established historical fact and cautionary example.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Shepherdstown Register, 7 February 1907, Shepherdstown Register, 7 February 1907.

The Independent · 7 March 1907 · page 11

Hon. J. W. Deweese writes from Cor pus Christl, Texas, of the bloom and beauty of a spring that lasts nearly all winter; of fresh, green things to eat, along with strawberry shortcake, .and baked duck, and . other things that we delight to think about but cannot af ford at this time of year. But he tells of an island twenty miles out in the gulf where millions of ducks and geese pass the winter months, and hunters are going there by hundreds to wantonly kill these glorious birds ror the mere fun of the thing.

See moreSee less

This sort of thing means that in a few years at the longest there will be-jw more wild ducks and geese on this continent. They are doomed to suffer the fate of the passenger pigeons,

See the clipping

The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md.

A 1907 letter to Forest and Stream recounts a conversation with longtime pigeon trapper Thomas Hand, describing massive shipments of passenger pigeons decades earlier. Hand attributes their extermination to a four-day fog over Lake Erie that disoriented and drowned the birds, which washed ashore in windrows.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Republican Journal, 14 February 1907, The Baltimore County Union, 16 February 1907.

The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · 8 March 1907 · page 1

THE PASSENGER PIGEONS

that. But they couldn’t understand how it felt to see her grow thinner and paler every day that long winter, with the doctor telling me the only chance was to send her south where she’d have the flowers, and the fruit and the sunshine. God knows I’d have worked my fingers off to do it, but times were hard for everyone that year, and there didn’t seem any way. She died for want of the flow ers and the fruit and the sunshine!” she ended brokenly. “And she’s been having them all and more than all these thirty years.” “I know, Ezra, 1 know, and I wouldn’t call her back if I could; she’s better there.

See moreSee less

It’s only the longing for her that comes to me and that makes me talk that way. I suppose every mother’ who has lost a little child—an only child—knows that pain; but it’s the feeling that I couldn’t give her what she needed that’s hardest to bear.” “Well, let us see what we are to do with our money,” he said cheerily. “I suppose 3’ou will have to work a little, if you want to. But, we can buy new furniture. You said only this morning how shabby everything is. Then there will be realchina on the table, and silver spoons and forks— and the things you always planned to get. Don’t you remember?” The woman looked around the bare little room, at the two or three wooden chairs that bore the imprint of lont’ service, at the carpet revealing, de spite its many patches, glimpses of the floor beneath. How untiringly she had worked and saved for it in the early married 3 ears, and bow proud and happy she had been when it first lay in the little parlor, and when the neighbors bad praised the bright red and green tints now merged into a dull brown. She wondered if it could not be darned yet more carefully. Then she looked at the table which was laid for the evening meal, and her eyes rested on the delf set which Lad been a wedding gift. It. was sad y battered, with an edge out of both cups, and the handle of the teapot held in place by tightly wound wire. She remembered that the child had broken it long ago, and that the father had mended it. “I don’t think I could give up the old set,” she said unsteadily. “We could keep it, and look at it some times, even if we had a real chi la one, couldn’t we, dear?” The man did not answer. He was looking at the old mended teapot ami the woman wondered if a child’s hall , frightened cry had come echoing to ’ him as it bad to her asrrss l lit* 3 cars. “Ezra,” she said hesitatingly,“ when * you used to read to me of so ns conh -1 try away off you alwa3's said: “When Iwo are sick, we’ll see that for our isro ii the PASSESGELt PIGEONS. Mr. A. Clinton Wilmerding, of New York city, writing under date of Jan uary 4, 1907, to the “Forest and Stream,” says: The following remarks on wild pigeons aie from notes made by the writer during a conversation with Mr. Thomas Hand, of, Netherwood, N. J.,on Dec. 30, last. Mr. Hand was engaged in trapping passenger pig eons for a long time prior to their sudden disappearance. He is not one who exaggerates, but all his state ments are made in a quiet, unassum ing manner that is convincing : Sometimes he and others in his dis trict shipped 110 barrels of pigeons a day for sixty to seventy days running to New York. These came from Ohio Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota. The hens laid but one egg at each nesting. Mr. Hand saw some flocks of wild pigeons fifteen to twenty years ago in Minnesota. The flight always occu pied two or three days, and the birds all came at one time, none straggling a'ong after—that is, no particular quantities. The birds in their flight flew very high up, so that they looked like very small batches individually clear out of gunshot. The accepted season for their ex termination in that part of the country was a tremendous fog that lasted lour days, and the birds in taking their regular course across Lake Erie became bewildered and were finally lost and drowned in the lake. The natives on the C madian side said they were washed up on the shore in “wind rows,” so that they had to go from the villages and bury them. When Mr. Hand was asked how many were lost in this catastrophe, be stated that there could be no fair estimate, but bis opinion was that their were “millions of tons” of these birds destroyed. When the trappers set their nests for these biids—which was nearly al ways near their nesting or roosting place—in the mornings they caught what was called the “Tom” flight, indicating the male birds. In the afternoon the hens would come off the nests, and all the birds caught at that time of day were hens. At one time in a certain locality the pigeons had eaten up all the spring wheat, and the trappers found that they were feeding after that on small caterpillars or inch worms, finding their crops fall of them. In consequence of this, as the worms eaten decompos ed quickly, and for the reason that people would not purchase them after finding what they had fed on, thetrep pers had to pull the crops out of each bird before shipping. The old birds would leave the young one in its aest when resuming the flight, at a cer tain period, with the result that the helpless young were preyed upon to a tremendous extent by the hawks, owls, and crows. Shelby, Mich , was generally the center of the biggest flight. The highest price Mr. Hand ever got for these birds was $4 a dozen when their was a good demand for them, and from that down to fifteen cents a dozen. He shipped nearly all of the birds that he sent to New York to Mr. N. Durham, New York city. Two enterprising fellows from Bos ton got an idea that they could buy all the live birds that came to Shelby, put them in inclosures, feed them and ship them to the different markets, as “corn fed” birds and thereby get a very much enlarged figure for them. So, with this in view, they built a series of inclosures in the center of the town in some open lots, Shelby being then but a village, and they took all the livebirds that were brought to them paying twelve cents a dozen for them. Sjod, however, as many of the birds died and could not be reached without considerable des truction to the live birds that hardly had moving room in these inclosures, the stench became very great, with the result that some doctor intimated that one or two local eases of sickness resulted therefrom, the final outcome being that the natives went there one night and destroyed all the inclosures liberating an estimated number of of 600,000 birds. Mr. Hand thinks that the great dis aster to the birds in the fog occurred in the late seventies, as he was trapp ing them in 1876, and subsequent to that time, after which they all disap peared. The pigeons at that time were near Bellefontaine, and crossed the lake near Ashtabula, Ohio. isro ii the PASSESGELt PIGEONS. Mr. A. Clinton Wilmerding, of New York city, writing under date of Jan uary 4, 1907, to the “Forest and Stream,” says: The following remarks on wild pigeons aie from notes made by the writer during a conversation with Mr. Thomas Hand, of, Netherwood, N. J.,on Dec. 30, last. Mr. Hand was engaged in trapping passenger pig eons for a long time prior to their sudden disappearance. He is not one who exaggerates, but all his state ments are made in a quiet, unassum ing manner that is convincing : Sometimes he and others in his dis trict shipped 110 barrels of pigeons a day for sixty to seventy days running to New York. These came from Ohio Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota. The hens laid but one egg at each nesting. Mr. Hand saw some flocks of wild pigeons fifteen to twenty years ago in Minnesota. The flight always occu pied two or three days, and the birds all came at one time, none straggling a'ong after—that is, no particular quantities. The birds in their flight flew very high up, so that they looked like very small batches individually clear out of gunshot. The accepted season for their ex termination in that part of the country was a tremendous fog that lasted lour days, and the birds in taking their regular course across Lake Erie became bewildered and were finally lost and drowned in the lake. The natives on the C madian side said they were washed up on the shore in “wind rows,” so that they had to go from the villages and bury them. When Mr. Hand was asked how many were lost in this catastrophe, be stated that there could be no fair estimate, but bis opinion was that their were “millions of tons” of these birds destroyed. When the trappers set their nests for these biids—which was nearly al ways near their nesting or roosting place—in the mornings they caught what was called the “Tom” flight, indicating the male birds. In the afternoon the hens would come off the nests, and all the birds caught at that time of day were hens. At one time in a certain locality the pigeons had eaten up all the spring wheat, and the trappers found that they were feeding after that on small caterpillars or inch worms, finding their crops fall of them. In consequence of this, as the worms eaten decompos ed quickly, and for the reason that people would not purchase them after finding what they had fed on, thetrep pers had to pull the crops out of each bird before shipping. The old birds would leave the young one in its aest when resuming the flight, at a cer tain period, with the result that the helpless young were preyed upon to a tremendous extent by the hawks, owls, and crows. Shelby, Mich , was generally the center of the biggest flight. The highest price Mr. Hand ever got for these birds was $4 a dozen when their was a good demand for them, and from that down to fifteen cents a dozen. He shipped nearly all of the birds that he sent to New York to Mr. N. Durham, New York city. Two enterprising fellows from Bos ton got an idea that they could buy all the live birds that came to Shelby, put them in inclosures, feed them and ship them to the different markets, as “corn fed” birds and thereby get a very much enlarged figure for them. So, with this in view, they built a series of inclosures in the center of the town in some open lots, Shelby being then but a village, and they took all the livebirds that were brought to them paying twelve cents a dozen for them. Sjod, however, as many of the birds died and could not be reached without considerable des truction to the live birds that hardly had moving room in these inclosures, the stench became very great, with the result that some doctor intimated that one or two local eases of sickness resulted therefrom, the final outcome being that the natives went there one night and destroyed all the inclosures liberating an estimated number of of 600,000 birds. Mr. Hand thinks that the great dis aster to the birds in the fog occurred in the late seventies, as he was trapp ing them in 1876, and subsequent to that time, after which they all disap peared. The pigeons at that time were near Bellefontaine, and crossed the lake near Ashtabula, Ohio.

See the clipping

Virginia Citizen · Irvington, Va.

The article reports that after a 25-year disappearance, wild passenger pigeons are supposedly returning in large flocks to forests near Lake Superior and Wisconsin. It recounts the old days when the birds were so abundant they could be killed by the hundreds and were trapped commercially for market sale.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 34 days later.

Wrong

Virginia Citizen · 8 March 1907 · page 1

FOR THE YOUNG PEOPLE

[BMTBD BY 1IIS NI11S. SI.1NCKIST. [ Beporta froui the Lake Bvperior region indicate, that after M fthl of many }ears, wild pigeons?also called passeuger pigeons beean the conapicuoua habit of pat^it.^ from one part of the world |n another in IwwiM ilocks, aometiire* douding the snn in ilight?are cotniDg back to the foresta of "the north country." Juat where theae l>ntty birda of paaeage have kept themselves fora quarter of a century is not known, but the general auppo aitiou ia that they have btoftbretd-I iug in the woodtd and uneettled regioa8 of South America.

See moreSee less

The Boaton Advertiser saya woodsmen report hundreda of ilocks along the t'loquet river, and colonies havi . ??ippeared in the Wiaconsin wooda, north of Lake ISupeiior. JManv unddle-aged aud ehlerly tin u remember the old daya on their farni8 in the (ireat Lakea region, when theae birda were so numerous that a boy cculd kill hundreda in a day with no better weapon than u elub. In those daja trapping the birds for the niarket was a regnlar busiue68 with a large number of men. Nets were spred onc in the stubble lield after the harvest. A few deeoy pigeons were placed hen ind there, juat as 6portamen now decoy wild ducksin llu-ir ilight. Then, lureit by their kind, aud a laviah aprinkling of grain, the pigeons would desceud iu thousands in the net covered grounda. A dexterous awi-ep of the net by experienced hai.da would entrap the quurry. The birda were served at hotels and reatauranta in the cities aud were regardtd as a great delcaey. In fitct, auch great favor did thia bird win that aquab raiamg hae beeu a proOtable busineaa since the de parture of the wild apecies years ago. The Boaton paper aays storiea about old aettlera aeeing milliona of paasenger pigeons instead of thous ands might seenvsomewhat exagger ated, but early travelera iu the region of the Great Lakea have remarked in their writings the enormoas numbera of theae birda. Their food conaisted mainly of the amalleat acorn aud the thiu-shelled nuts, especially beech uuta, and a variety of berriea aud aaiall fruita. Where auch material waa plentiful they gathered in vaat congregatioue, which thronged upon the treea until the branchea would break with their weight." l*igeon ahooting waa a favonte amuaenu-nt among sportamen when birda were plentiful. Aa many as 20,000 birda were uaed at a aingle toumament before public sentiment and law checked the slaughter. The inceasant alaughter and persecution, togetber with the clearing away of large areaa of forest, rapidly drove the pigeons out. The di8appearance of the birda from the lakea region waa hastened by the cold winters and late. stormy springs betweeu 1860 aud 1880. Since theu the wild pigeons have been knpwn only in scattered cum bershereaud there, but their natural enemies are now diminished and for some reason they are coming back to their old haunta. Juat twenty-five years ago thia month Hi8 Nibs wa8 in camp in McKean county, l'ennaylvania, near Bradford?or about midway betweeu Alton and Sinethport?to be more weeurate, on Kit-zua creek, where a a great iion bridge 301 feet high atretchea from one uiountain top to another. We had hunted btar, trapped beara and had a bear-aud bull tight; had cha8ed the papa and mamma dter and little onea, aud found the battle ground and locked horna of two naagniliceut bucka, aa told you laat week. Rut one day a mountain lad told ua of a "pigeon rooat" uot far from Smethport, and wereaolved to find out what that meant. You needn't believe.it jf you don't want to; but it i8 a fact, and the hia toryof that section will bear it out? Febroary, 1882: towarda aundown the sky became darkened over the dense ttainM

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The piece discusses giant extinct birds like the Epiornis and Moa before pivoting to marvels of bird flight, including the passenger pigeon's reputed speed. It repeats Audubon's claim that wild pigeons found near New York with undigested Southern rice in their crops must have flown roughly a mile a minute.

Los Angeles Herald · 10 March 1907 · page 41

most distinguishing quality. - ... . The fleetest quadruped known^does not ap proach the speed , of certain birds, while it soon succumbs to the fatigue they hardly seem to experience at all. Three or four hundred miles in one flight is nothing extra ordinary for. the . artificially-bred carrier or passage pigeon. "_ : , ..■,:- Audubon tells us that wild pigeons have been killed in the neighborhood of New York with their crops still full of undigested rice, which they could not have ' obtained nearer than the fields of Georgia : and I Carolina — six .

See moreSee less

hundred to seven hundred miles distant. As . they . can digest . such grain entirely in twelve hours, that great naturalist "calculated that they must have flown through the named space at the rate of a mile a minute. j j The "homing" instinct of the carrier pigeon is very beautiful, and equally mysterious. The probability of any bird which can fly . to a great height, and so survey the country all around, finding its way home for any moderate distance, will be understood, but this does not explain the unerring instinct of a pigeon tak • en in a closed basket hundreds of miles from its cote. And yet it returns thither more cer tainly than does the skilled . mariner to an oft-visited port. •■ . ■<■ . - ■ „ ■ Pigeons : were i employed in early Egyptian days, navigators taking them on their galleys

See the clipping

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

During a New Mexico legislative council session on March 14, 1907, among many bills discussed was Council Bill Number 114, introduced by Mr. Murray, an act for the protection of wild pigeons. The bill was ordered translated, printed, and referred to the Committee on Territorial Affairs, amid a flurry of other legislative business including road taxes and medical practice regulations.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 14 March 1907 · page 8

Council Bill Number .114 by Mr. Murray, by request, an act for ' the protection of wild , pigeons. Ordered translated, printed and referred to the Committee on Territorial Affairs,

See the clipping

Las Vegas Daily Optic · Las Vegas, N.M.

The New Mexico territorial council's session on March 14, 1907 saw introduction of numerous bills, including Council Bill No. 114 by Mr. Murray for the protection of wild pigeons, referred to the committee on territorial affairs. The report details dozens of other unrelated legislative measures passed or referred that day, including road taxes, artesian wells, and saloon licensing.

Las Vegas Daily Optic · 14 March 1907 · page 1

SIXTY MEASURES UP

Council bill No. 114. by Mr. Mur ray, by request, an act for the pro tection of wild pigeons, and wea re ferred to the committee on territor ial affairs. Council bill No. 116. by Mr. Cam eron, an act providing for the estab lishment of commerce commission, and was referred to the committee on nllroads. The following bills were passed In the council: House substitute for bouse bill No. 63. House substitute for bouse bill No. 177. an act providing for establlshmeut of a road In Otero countty, a new scenic route from Alamogorri to the ton ot the Bacramento mountain, similar to the one between Santa Fe and La. Vegas. Thi. bill

See the clipping

Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn.

An old Callaway County, Missouri history recounts a tale from hunter Calvin Tate, who claimed wild pigeons once so weighed down a tree that it bent to the ground. He supposedly killed 800 with one shot, then the tree snapped upward again, hoisting his tethered horse until he returned with an axe.

Willmar Tribune · 20 March 1907 · page 4

rigaa) and tTttmlum Catalogfca (akawiag «aa yrcatiama) *at tra* A44raaa TMVMeCALL CO.. Maw Vara. A Missouri Munchausen. There are some pretty fair Nimrods in Missouri now, but a story which is printed in an old history of Callaway county shows that some of, those of former days could make contemporary sportsmen look cheap either as shots or as raconteurs. "Mr. Calvin Tate," ac cording to this history, "says that the wild pigeons were so plentiful one summer that frequently when they would alight on a tree it would bend down to the ground with their weight He went hunting one day, and, seeing a fine lot of pigeons in a tree, he bitched his horse to one of the limbs and fired and killed 800 at one shot The rest flew away, and as soon as the tree was relieved of their weight it straightened "up, carrying his horse .with' it and the poor brute had to bang there until Tate could go home

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A books/magazines column from 1907 summarizes contents of various periodicals, including a piece by Herbert K. Job titled 'Photographing Wild Pigeons' described as a narrative about the new sport of camera hunting. The article is listed among unrelated pieces on history, fashion, and travel.

The Salt Lake Herald · 31 March 1907 · page 20

Tew T w Sprague is one of the series of the theOuting theOuting theOuting Outing Magazines Timely History IIlsto arr ar arUeles artiCles for the redskin was the greatest Indian Indianorganizer Indianoranlzor Indianl l organizer who who ever lived Th The Soldiers Soldiersof f of the Sea1 SeaIJY Sea by Clay Emery is a picture pictureof of modern daring along our coasts Pho Photographing Photographlng Photographing ¬ tographing Wild Pigeons by Herbert K KJab 1 1Job Ktm tm I5 Job is a beguiling narrative of the new newsport ncwspOrt sport o of camera hunting The Vale of ofPlenty ofPiEmt ofpry pry Plenty PiEmt by h Clifton Johnson is the study studyof studyor studyt t of the evolution of a great game country couDtr countryk 0 avast vast wheat producing areaDRESSThe area areaDRESS areaDRESSThe DRESS DRESSThe The April number of Dress pre pres pret8 presegts s segts nts t8 in full detail and illustration thet the thegowns theSQwns that are advocated b by 3 f fashion to torepresentative take the lend In the new models designed for forspring forsPring forsiring spring sPringIh siringTh41nformation The Th41nformation Ih Information contained in the th fash fashI to idH articles is absolutely authentic emi eminating emiI I I nlUn nating from the most reliable sources

See the clipping