As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1907

11 articles

The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md.

A brief item reports that wild pigeons, once so abundant in the region, are said to be returning to this part of Maryland after an absence of more than thirty years, having mysteriously disappeared with no explanation. It notes they used to arrive in early autumn in countless flocks.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Baltimore County Union · 2 February 1907 · page 3

leghany avennes. It will be a brick structnre, I ornamented with Roman stone. It will have a seating capacity of about 150. —►The little “yellow birds” continue to find their way back to The Union office. The subscription list of this paper is something that the pnblisher of any country newspaper might well feel prond of. We doubt if there is another anywhere like it in Maryland, and the beauty of it is it’s growing better all the time. Contractor Charles Russell. ofGlen-Arm, has been awarded the contract to build for Mrs.

See moreSee less

Henry Fry, of Baltimore, a fine bouse on the property she purchased from the estate of ibelate John Beale Watkins, in Long Green Valley. Mr. Russell has also the contract for the erection of three houses on the York road. —lt is said that wild pigeons, once so abun dant in this section of the country, are return ing after an absence of more than thirty years. The birds mysteriously disappeared and no one was able to tell what became of them. They came to this part of Maryland in the early autumn and were generally in countless flocks. —Tbe annual horse show at the Kennels, Charles street avenue, will be held this year from the 23d to the 25th of May, inclusive. The board of directors is composed of Messrs. Alex. Brown, E. A. Jackson, Bberlock Swann, Thomas Deford, Spalding L. Jenkins, W.

See the clipping

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

The article claims passenger pigeons, absent for over a decade, are being spotted again in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan, with woodsmen reporting hundreds along the Cloquet River and a flock seen at Presque Isle Park. It speculates the birds had been breeding in South America during their absence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 5 February 1907 · page 2

FLOCKS ARE AGAIN APPEAR. .ING IN OLD HAUNTS Formerly Flew In Thousands About Lake Superior and Were Trappsd For Hotel Fare—Are Thought to Have Been in South America. Many old oitizens will reiwetnbA that forty or fifty years ago, the woods and forests of the northern states and In the regions of the great lakes swarmed with flocks of the wild or passenger from pigeons. For more than, a decade now. these pretty birds .have been miss ing from their former haunts. And-now from the country surrounding Lake Su perior come-reports that the flocks are coming back to the north country.

See moreSee less

Just where these birds of passage have kept themselves for more than a third of a century is not known, but the general supposition Is that .they have been breeding In the wooded and un settled regions of South America. Woodsmen report hundreds of them along the Cloquet river, In St. Louis county, Minnesota, and colonies have also appeared, It is said, in the Wiscon sin woods, north of Superior. Last spring a flock was seen In Presque Isle Park, at Marquette, Mich., by the care taker, who when a young man had kill ed many of the birds, and he recognis ed the species at once. Old Men Think of Former Days, Many middle age and elderly men re member the old days on their farms in Minnesota or Michigan .in the great lakes region, when these birds were so humerous that a boy could kill hun dreds In a day with no better weapon than a club. In those days traping the birds for the market was a regular business with a large number of men. Nets were spread out in the stubblefleld after the harvest. A few decoy pigeons were placed here and there, just as sports men now decoy wild ducks in their flleht. Then, lured by their kind, and a lavish sprinkling of grain, the pigeons would descend In thousands on the net covered grounds. A dexterous sweep of the net by experienced hands would en trap the quarry. The birds were serv ed at hotels and restaurants In the cit ies and were regarded as a great deli cacy. In fact, such great .favor did this food win the squab raising has been a profitable business since the departure of the wild species years ago. Belong to Dove FamilyWild pigeons are of the dove family. The male has a narrow, gracefully pointed tail, and is about seventeen Inches long. The female Is much small er. The upper parts are generally a variable blue, the neck richly glossed with metallic, golden violet, and the lower purplish or brownish red, fading behind into a violet tint, nearly white beneath the tail. The bird resembles the homing pigeons and has wings eight and one-half Inches long. Its flight is remarkably swift and powerful. The birds were once resident throughout the year in the South of Canada and the moit northern states, which they were compelled to leave In midwinter when the ground was covered with snow. Stories about old settlers seeing millions, of passenger pigeons Instead of thousands might seem somewhat exaggerated,- but ear ly travelers in the region of the great lakes have remarked in their writings the enormous numbers of these birds which required for their food great quantities of grain. However, grain never formed an extensive part of the feed, since the birds did not settle up on and attack the growing or ripening fields, but only gleaned among' the stubble. Feed Mainly on Some Nuts. Their food consisted mainly of the smallest acorn and the thin-shelled nuts, especially beech nuts, and a va riety of berries and small fruits. Where such material was plentiful they gath ered in vast congregations, which thronged upon the trees until the branches would break with their weight. They covered the ground so thickly, turning over the( leaves in search of something to eat, that the moment one rose upon wing another was ready to take its place. The pigeons would remain in one place as long as the food supplies held out, and In May or early June would make their nests in company, some times so loading the trees that they would break down. The nests were crude platforpns of twigs, holding two roseate white eggs, or sometimes only one. Pigeons multiply rapidly. Such con gregations years ago were more often seen In the great lakes region than elsewhere. Settlers would bank to gether and kill and catch the birds in great quantities, while wild animals from far and near would assemble for the feast. At flrst the killing was done for home needs, each family, perhaps, salting a few barrels of bodies but later, when transportation facilities Improved, large numbers were prepared for market. The birds, captured alive, especially the young pigeons, were transferred to enclosures and kept and fattened for the market. Men made such a business of this that they went from place to place wherever pigeons abounded. Pigeon shooting was a favorite amusement among sportsmen when birds were plentiful. As many as 20, 000 birds were used at a single tour nament before public sentiment and law checked the slaughter and perse cution/ together with the clearing away of large areas of forest, rapidly drove

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

An elderly Canton-area couple, Mr. and Mrs. Thomas J. Shepley, recount their pioneer lives, farming, local history, and early settlement of the county. Amid details of crops, railroads, and local businesses, the husband briefly recalls seeing wild pigeons along with prairie chickens, quail, and other game in the area's early days.

Canton Weekly Register · 7 February 1907 · page 6

MRS. THOMAS J. SHEPLEY

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Saint Mary's Beacon · Leonard Town, Md.

The Towson Union reports that wild pigeons, once abundant throughout the state but absent for nearly forty years, are said to be returning. The birds had previously vanished suddenly from their usual haunts in the county.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Saint Mary's Beacon · 7 February 1907 · page 3

The Towaon Union reports that wild pigeons once so abundant throughout the Stale are returning after an absence of nearly forty years. They used to frequent the county in great (locks, but sudden ly left their usual haunts and were seen no mure. , r ■ Judge Jqsepb H. Key, of Leonard town, has on his farm at this place between 60 am} 75 young lambs. Mr. Key has everything well fixed for the care and comfort of the little creatures and is deservedly one of the most successful sheep raisers in

See the clipping

Mexico Missouri Message · Mexico, Mo.

A county newspaper column reflects that wild pigeons, once seen in the millions, have been killed off by hunters, and asks why Missouri lacks a rigidly enforced game law. The remark appears amid miscellaneous local items about an editor's vacation, railroad lobbying, and prison reform.

Mexico Missouri Message · 7 February 1907 · page 4

THURSDAY. FBI. 7 1!M7 Trv the "smile cur." The per formance if il'Hrill as follow: Lift Ihe turner r tin mouth slightly by means of fuciul museles and expand the lips and fhw the N-oili. Practice thin before the m. king-glass night and morning utilii the smile has worn in. Wei come smiles. I hey are helpful aud healthful. How many years since you have seen a wild pigeon? Millions of

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

Newspaper reports describe sightings of large flocks of wild pigeons (passenger pigeons) returning to the Lake Superior region after a 30-year absence, with witnesses in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan claiming to recognize the species. The piece speculates the birds had been breeding in South America and recalls the old days of mass trapping with nets for market.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

Shepherdstown Register · 7 February 1907 · page 1

Regis FEBRUARY 7. 1907. Wild Pigeons Return Reports from various localities in be Lake Superior region indicate bat, after an absence of 30 years, rild pigeons, aleo called passenger ligeons because of tbe conspicuous labit of passing from one part of tbe fc ountry to another in immenee flocks, om-times c ouding tbe sun in flight ?are coming back to tbe forests of 'tfce north country." Just where heee pretty birds of passage hate

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The article reminisces about the former vast abundance of passenger pigeons in the Great Lakes region, describing netting and trapping methods, their food habits, and sport shooting tournaments. It attributes their decline to slaughter, deforestation, and harsh winters, while claiming the birds are now returning to their old haunts in diminished numbers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

Shepherdstown Register · 7 February 1907 · page 1

bat squab raising has been a profit,ble business since the departure of he wild species years ago. Stories about old settlers seeing Qillions of passenger pigeons instead it thousands might seem somewhat Xrtggerated, but early travelers in he region of the Great Lakes have

See the clipping

Audubon County Journal · Exira, Iowa

This filler item claims the passenger pigeon could travel one thousand miles in a single day, comparing it to the frigate bird's transatlantic flight and the black swift's extreme speed. It appears amid a miscellany column of unrelated anecdotes and curiosities.

Audubon County Journal · 14 February 1907 · page 1

The passenger pigeon has been known to travel one thousand miles in a day and it is said that the fri gate bird can cross the Atlantic

See the clipping

The Republican Journal · Belfast, Me.

This piece discusses the historical decline of oyster beds in Maine and Nova Scotia, comparing the mysterious loss of oyster populations to the disappearance of the wild pigeon. It notes that both phenomena remain unexplained and are left to conjecture.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Republican Journal · 14 February 1907 · page 4

Maine waters and the Times suggests that perhaps they may again be made to grow here. Some years ago Chas. H. Burd, then of Boston and since deceased, brought some oysters here and planted them in Belfast bay, but the experiment was not successful. So far as we know there are no oysters in Xova Scotia waters, unless it may be in Cape Breton, but Prince Edward Island produces a small, coppery oyster, which does not appeal to the tastes of those accustomed to the luscious bi valves of Chesapeake bay.

See moreSee less

tVe have heard of one attempt to colonize the Virginia oysters in Bedford Basin, a landlocked portion of Halifax harbor, which ended as did the experiment at Belfast. The cause of the decadence of the Maine oyster, which took place before our day, must be left to conjec ture. The disappearance of the wild pigeon is within the memory of many, and so far as we know is also unac counted for.

See the clipping

The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md. · and 1 other paper

A New York writer relays a conversation with Thomas Hand, a former pigeon trapper, describing massive shipments of passenger pigeons from the Midwest and a dramatic fog event over Lake Erie during which birds became disoriented and drowned, washing ashore in windrows. The account offers this fog catastrophe as the accepted local explanation for the species' sudden disappearance.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

The Baltimore County Union · 16 February 1907 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ESTABLISHED 1850.

THE PASSENGER PIGEONS.

See moreSee less

Mr. A. Clinton Wilmerding, of New York city, writing under date of January 4, 1907, to the Forest and Stream, says:

The following remarks on wild pigeons are from notes made by the writer during a conversation with Mr. Thomas Hand, of Netherwood, N. J., on Dec. 30, last. Mr. Hand was engaged in trapping passenger pigeons for a long time prior to their sudden disappearance. He is not one who exaggerates, but all his statements are made in a quiet, unassuming manner that is very convincing:

Sometimes he and others in his district shipped 110 barrels of pigeons a day for sixty to seventy days running, to New York. These came from Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota.

The hens laid but one egg at each nesting.

Mr. Hand saw some flocks of wild pigeons fifteen to twenty years ago in Minnesota. The flight always occupied two or three days, and the birds all came at one time, none straggling along after—that is, no particular quantities. The birds in their flight flew very high up, so that they looked like very small batches individually—clear out of gunshot.

The accepted season for their extermination in that part of the country was a tremendous fog that lasted about four days, and the birds in taking their regular course across Lake Erie became bewildered and were finally lost and drowned in the lake. The natives on the Canadian side said they were washed up on the shore in "wind-rows," so that they had to go from the villages and bury them. When Mr. Hand was asked how many were lost in this catastrophe, he stated that there could be no fair estimate, but his opinion was that their were millions of tons of these birds destroyed.

When the trappers set their nets for these birds—which was nearly always near their nesting or roosting place—in the mornings they caught what was called the "Tom" flight, indicating the male birds. In the afternoon the hens would come off the nests, and all the birds caught at that time of day were hens.

At one time in a certain locality the pigeons had eaten up all the spring wheat, and the trappers found that they were feeding after that on small caterpillars or inch worms, finding their crops full of them. In consequence of this, as the worms eaten decomposed quickly, and for the reason that people would not purchase them after finding what they had fed on, the trappers had to pull the crops out of each bird before shipping. The old birds would leave the young one in its nest when resuming the flight, at a certain period, with the result that the helpless young were preyed upon to a tremendous extent by the hawks, owls, and crows.

Shelby, Mich., was generally the center of the biggest flight.

The highest price Mr. Hand ever got for these birds was $4 a dozen when their was a good demand for for them, and from that down to fifteen cents a dozen. He shipped nearly all of the birds that he sent to New York to Mr. N. Durham, New York city.

Two enterprising fellows from Boston got an idea that they could buy all the live birds that came to Shelby, put them in inclosures, feed them and ship them to the different markets, as "corn fed" birds and thereby get a very much enlarged figure for them. So, with this in view, they built a series of inclosures in the center of the town in some open lots, Shelby being then but a village, and they took all the live birds that were brought to them, paying twelve cents a dozen for them. Soon, however, as many of the birds died and could not be reached without considerable destruction to the live birds that hardly had moving room in these inclosures, the stench became very great, with the result that some doctor intimated that one or two local cases of sickness resulted therefrom, the final outcome being that the natives went there one night and destroyed all the inclosures, liberating an estimated number of 600,000 birds.

Mr. Hand thinks that the great disaster to the birds in the fog occurred in the late seventies, as he was trapping them in 1876, and subsequent to that time, after which they all disappeared. The pigeons at that time were near Bellefontaine, and crossed the lake near Ashtabula, Ohio.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md. · 8 March 1907

The Weekly Examiner · Moorefield, W. Va.

A passenger pigeon reportedly came to the home of C. C. Fisher and was caught by his sons. The bird wore a silver leg band marked '225 A. G. H. C.'

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Weekly Examiner · 28 February 1907 · page 3

A passenger pigeon came to the home of C. C. Fisher recently and was caught by Mr. Fisher’s boys. . The pigeon has a silver band on its leg on which the followinu; “225 A. G. H. C.”

See the clipping