As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1906

11 articles

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A newspaper item claims that after a thirty-year absence, wild passenger pigeons are reappearing in flocks in Minnesota and Wisconsin forests. It speculates they may have been breeding in South America and notes sightings near the Cloquet River and north of Spooner.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

Mineral Point Tribune · 1 November 1906 · page 4

Made tram Crapes NO ALUM Wild Pigeons Return. Reports would indicate that after ab sence of thirty years wild pigeons—also called passenger pigeons because of their conspicuous habit of passing from one part of the country to the other in immense flocks, sometimes clouding the sun in flight—are coming back to the forests of the north country. Just where these birds have kept themselves is not known, but the gen eral supposition is that they have been breeding in South America. Woodsmen report hundreds of them along tho Clo quet river in Minnesota, and colonies have also appeared in the Wisconsin woods north of Spooner to the vicinity of Lake Superior.

See moreSee less

Good Templars In Session. The regular annual session of Fifth District Lsdge, I. O. G, TANARUS., was held with Emery Lodge, No. 311, at Mineral Point, Oct. 26th and 27. Grand Chief Templar, H. A. Larson, was present, and assisted District Chief Templar, Mrs. Williams, in conducting the session. He lectured at a public meeting in the P. M. church on the evening of Oct. 2(5, and throughout the session his presence lent encourage ment and enthusiasm to all. Following lodges were represented : Emery, 311. Mineral Point. Dodgeville, 468, Dodgeville. Allen, 207, Mineral Point. Mt. Hope, 360, Mt. Hope. Fennimore, 340, Fennimore. Platteville, 134, Platteville. Edmund, 1(54, Edmund. Edmund Juvenile Temple. These lodges reported quite favorably and considered the outlook for Good Templary bright and hopeful. Visiting delegates and officers found Emery lodge a delightful hostess, and her hospitality came to a climax Satur day noon when dinner was served in the of Dodgeville, is making a lot of

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The article reflects on the passenger pigeon's extinction as one of ornithology's great unsolved mysteries, citing old estimates of flocks numbering over two billion birds that once darkened the sky. It notes no considerable flocks had been seen south of the Great Lakes in over thirty-three years, despite a large unclaimed reward for a surviving pair.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 69 days earlier.

Shepherdstown Register · 15 November 1906 · page 1

Hcgii NOVEMBER 15. 190' ic Passenger Pigeon?A Bird Tragedy The greatest of all tragedies in th< athered kingdom was the sadder :tinction, the magical disappearance the once countless hosts of passenir pigeons. The qaestion as to whal ?came of them and why they went is become one of the moet puzzling obleme of ornithology. Those old longh to remember these beautifu rds have never ceased to regret theii laccountable extermination. 0n< ly as numerous as the sands of th? ashore and dying in myriads thai irkened the sky for hours at a time ;xt day they have disappeared at impletely as if never in existence, completely that a large reward of on red for a pair still remains unclaim i.

See moreSee less

A celebrated American ornithol gist estimated that a flock he saw ?f trly in the last century numbered rgely over two thousand two hun red and thirty million?, and the} ould consume seventeen million foui tndred and twenty-four thousanc ishels of mast every day I Thes< e big figures but many of our olde1 aders, remembering flocks seen ii leir boyhood, will readily believ< lem to be true. As late as the six es it was no uncommon thing thinf i see in Kentucky, Indiana am Michigan, flocks that darkened th< y in every direction as far as th< 'e could reach, and they would b< issing for hours at a time. It has been over thirty-three year nee any considerable number of thes< rds were seen eoutb of the grea kes, though an extensive nesting iace was reported from the regioi ' Petoskey as late as 1881. Thougl rndreds of men were engaged 11 etting them and captured fully 10, X),000, it was estimated that not om rd in a thousand was taken. Ai re-witness declares that this nestinj ivered an area twenty-eight mile >ng and fully four miles wide, whil rery tree of any size over this eiten ve space had more or less nests am iany were full of them. This, how rer, seems to have been the last o le passenger pigeon in numbers oon thereafter he disappeared a iddenly as the Virginia sora after i oat an i as completely as the grea uk of the southern seas. What be ime of them still remains and doubt j88 always will remain one of th nsolved mysteries of science. It wa t first thought that they attemptei ) cross the ocean, but unequal to th ing flight fell and were swallowei y the waves. A more probable con lusion is that in the destruction o le forests, which deprived them o leir natural food, aided by the re intless persecution of man in ever 1*. ? 1 1.1 1 1 icailiy, we may una me reai expiau tiou of this deplorable tragedy intb ingdom of the birde. The domestic pigeon, so familia round all farm homes, is a descend at of the swift and forceful flye hose untimely end we have been la tenting. The whole pigeon family hich includes the doves, have somi smarkable peculiarities which dis nguish them from all other birds o oultry. They mate for life and th< tale and female each assists in th* icubating, dividing the time a irefully as a railroad schedule, th< rat taking the day shift from I clock in the morning until 2 o'cloct i the afternoon, while the mothe ts out the remaining hours. Th< tost notable characteristic of the* irds, however, is their methods o b leding the young. This is done en rely by regurgitation, the young in >rting its beak into that of the pa int and extracting therefrom a curd ke secretion, which is the tbickene< nd "peeled up" lining of the parent' rop. Both parents thus contribute >r nine days, after which the curd i lixed largely with the food of th arent, until at length the young, hav lg grown stronger, are compelled b at their bread without cheeee. Ii lany sections pigeon-breeding is ai nportant adjunct of the poultry bus ieee and when well managed is foam .11 uite profitable. Though sometime I ? ?L . I

See the clipping

The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss.

A newspaper reprints a hopeful but unverified report that wild pigeons have reappeared in flocks out West, prefacing it with 'if the reports be true.' It pairs this claim with nostalgic recollections of the species' former abundance in New England and its mysterious disappearance decades earlier.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

The Sea Coast Echo · 17 November 1906 · page 2

WILD PIGEONS RETURN: GREAT FLOCKS SEEN IN WEST RECALLS MIGRATIONS OF OLD DAYS

rnmense flocks which were a won or to the beholder disappeared all of a sudden, and no man could tell the cause Of their disappearance nor the place to which they had flown. They w r ere seen as late as the middle seventies in New York Slate, but be fore that time they had ceased to visit New England. Sixty years ago they were numerous in some parts of Maine, especially where the India wheat was grown in large quantities, and where the blueberry pastures of fered their tempting fruit.

See moreSee less

In those days the Boston markets supplied them sometimes at fifty cents a dozen and the memories Of pigeon stew with dumplings or the juicy pot pie are fragrant to many a man who has reached the Psalmist's limit of age. A remarkable characteristic of these birds was their associating to gether, both in their migsatians and during the time of incubation, in such prodigious numbers as almost to be beyond belief; no one of the other, feathered tribes is at all like the wild pigeon in this respect. The migrations of the biri do not. seem to have been caused simply by the cold of the climate, f*--r as late December they used to found in the northern regions around Hudson s Bay. It was rather in q iest of the food that they made their nights. As the beechnut was the <■. if food of the wild pigeon, in those* s a sens and places where it was mi.:- 1 abundant corresponding multitude.-. cf pigeons: might be expected. When they had consumed all the beech nuts iiT one district they would discover another, perhapa hundred miles off, to which they would go, returning at night to their general roosting place, which was a ways in u large forest. When the\ irequented one of these places for anlength of time great havoc was ma '•*. All the tender grass and other herbage be neath their rhost was u terly de stroyed, large limits of i; ees were broken down by the w :• i.t of the birds, and the trees the mselves, for hundreds of acres, as completely kill ed as if girdled by an axe. The breeding place warn of greater extent than the place where they roosted. There was one in Kentucky which was said to stieich through the woods. In a north an 1 south di rection, nearly forty mi; - in length and several miles in breadth. In this tract almost every tree was furnished with nests wherever trm branches could hold them. At this place the pigeons made their first appearance about April 11 and left it altogether with their young before May 25. Space is wanting to describe the Bad havoc made among the birds by the people in whose section they nested. The natives came from all the surrounding districts and en camped for days among the immense nurseries. Ther cut down the trees which were most crowded with nests, and the falling of one tree sometimes produced two hundred squabs little inferior in size to the old ones and almost one mass of fat. From the account given of the flight of vast flocks of the wild pig eons one is reminded of the locust swarms of the East. Wilson, in his “American Ornithology,” describes a flight which he once saw on his way to Frankfort, Ky. It travelled in a compact body at a height beyond gunshot, with great rapidity and steadfastness. Curious to know how long the pas-age would continue he look out his watch and waited more than an hour. But the procession seemed only to increase in numbers and so he continued on his journey. "When he reached Frankfort, four hours after he first saw the flock iho living torrent over the head was as extensive as ever. Mr. Wilson afterward made a cur ious calculation of this flock. If we suppose the column to have been only one mile in breadth (and ho believed it to be much more) and thai it moved at the rate of a mile a minute, four hours, tbe time it continued passing, would make the whole length two hun dred and forty miles. Again, suppos ing that each squab yard of this mov ing body enclosed three pigeons, the equate yards in the whole space multi plied by three would give two billion two hundred and thirty million, two hundred and seventy-two thousand. It could not be possible Liat simply ♦he daughter by man was the cause of the total disappearance of such huge flocks. Perhaps the cc ntinuance of : \\e civil war was the reason of the*.’ migrating to some more con genial district of our immense coun try whore man has not discovered them. Anyhow, if they are really coming back the old song ol seventy years ago will be revived and we can “bid farewell to pork and beans and live on pigeon pie.”

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A student's talk at a school Audubon society meeting recounted that passenger pigeons were once so numerous ninety nests were seen in one tree, but overhunting had made them thought extinct. The report claims they were beginning to reappear and hoped to return to former numbers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Minneapolis Journal · 18 November 1906 · page 38

11 fVev.1 KENWOOD. Attoward Riley, Beporter. At 2:45 p.m. on Oct. 29, the Audubon society of the Kenwood school held the regular monthly meeting in room. The topic was the "Life of Audubon," and several excellent papers were read on this subject. Ted Brown of the Kenwood Bird club gave an interesting talk on the passenger pigeon. He said that in the time of Audubon the passenger pigeon was very numerous, as many as ninety nests having been counted in one tree, and the birds flew in such large flocks that they darkened the sky.

See moreSee less

But the people killed so many of them that they were thought for a time to be extinct, but they are beginning to reappear and it is hoped that they will soon be as nu merous as in former years. At the close of the meeting a letter was read from Audubon's granddaughter, who lies in Salem, N. T. She said that she was a little girl when her grandfather died, but that her remembrances of him would always stay with her. She said he was very fond of children and was always ready to teach them a new game or to amuse them with his stories and pictures. She also told a little story which showed his dislike for anyone who was cruel to his feathered friends. One day a young man came to the house where Audubon was staying and the next morning he made the well-known trap, with a sieve, a stick, a string and some oats, to tempt the snowbirds. He had already caught several birds when Audubon entered the room. He was very angry when he saw what the man was doing. He shook the man rather roughly and then opened the window and let out the imprisoned birds. The meeting adjourned at 3:30 and the topic of the next meeting was decided to be "Our Winter Birds."

See the clipping

The Manning Times · Manning, S.C.

This piece reflects on the passenger pigeon's mysterious and sudden disappearance, recalling eyewitness accounts of flocks darkening the sky for hours in the 1860s-1880s. It laments that despite rewards offered, no pair of the birds could be found, calling their extinction one of ornithology's great unsolved puzzles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Manning Times · 21 November 1906 · page 8

A BIRD TRAGEDY. The Passenger Pigeon, Once So Plen tiful, Now Extinct. The greatest of all tragedies in the feathered kingdom was tue sudden extiuction, the magical disappearance, of the once countles 1 hosts of passen ger pigeons. The question as to what became of them and why they went has become one of the most puzzling problems of ornithology. Those old enough to remember these beautiful birds have never ceased to regret their unaccountable extermination. One day as numerous as the sands of the seashore and flying in myriads that darkened the sky for hours at a time, next day they have disappeared as completely as if never in existence so completely that a large reward cffbr ed for a pair still remains unclaimed.

See moreSee less

A celebrated American ornithologist estimated that a flck he saw early in the last century numbered largely over two thousand two hundred and thirty millions, and they would consume sev enteen million four hundred and twen ty.-four thousand bushels of mast every day I These are tremendous flgu:es but many of our older resiers, r mem bering flocks seen in their boyhood, will readily believe them to be true. As late as the sixties It was no un common thing to see in Kentucky, In diana and Michigan, flocks that dark ened the sky in every direction as far as the eye could reach and they would be psssing for hours at a time. It nas been over thirty-three years since any considerable number of these birds were seen south of the great lakes though an extensive nest ug was reported from the regin of Petoskov as late as 1881. Though hundreds of men were engaged in net ting them and captured fully 10,000, 000, It was estimated that not one brd in a thousand was taken. An eye witness declares that this nesting cov ered an area twenty-eight miles long and fully four miles wide while every tree of any size over this extensive space had more or less nests and many were full of them. This, however, seems to have been the last of the passenger pigeon in numbers. Soon thereafter he disap peared as suddenly as the Virginia sora after a frost as completely as the great auk of the southern seas. What became of them still remains and doubtless always will remain one of the unsolved mysteries of science, it was at frst thought that they at tempted to cross the ocean, but un equal to the long flight fell and were swallowed by the waves. A more prob able conclusion Is that in the destruc tion of the forests, which deprived them of their natural food, aided by the relentless persecution of main In every locality, we may find the real explanation of this delorable tragedy in the kingdom of the birds. Bomo in Sc. Peters. At Rome, Italy on last Sunday morning a bomb was exploded In St. Peters, which is the largest church building in the world. The edifice was crowded and an indescribable scene of confusion followed. There were no fatalities. As soon as the choes of the tremendous roar had ssased, a canon sought by reassuring words, to quilet the people, but in vain. They fled in all directions and a number of wcmen fainted. Women* nd childiren screamed and men tried ro protect their families in the crush. The church Is so large, however, that tere was ample room for the crowd o scatter and no one was Injured. N trace of the perpetrator of the leed has been found. . No Chage Wanted A dispatch from Richmond, Va., says by resolation the V.rginia Bap Ast Contnlion Wednesday broke off i relations with the American So

See the clipping

The Marlboro Democrat · Bennettsville, S.C.

This 1906 article reflects on the sudden, unexplained extinction of the once-countless passenger pigeon, noting that flocks once darkened the sky for hours and numbered in the billions. It recounts the last major nestings, estimated around the 1870s-1880s, including one near Petoskey in 1881, and laments that the species' disappearance remains an unsolved ornithological puzzle.

The Marlboro Democrat · 23 November 1906 · page 4

A BIRD TRAGEDY. Tho PASsongor Flgoon, Onoo Bo Plon tlful. Now Kxtii?ot, Tho greatest of all tragodloa in the feathorod kingdom was tne sudden extinction, the magical disappearance, of tho once counties} hosts of passen gor pigeons. The question as to what

See the clipping

The Marlboro Democrat · Bennettsville, S.C.

The article recalls the once-vast flocks that darkened Midwestern skies in the 1860s and describes the massive 1878 Petoskey nesting as apparently the last great gathering of the species. It speculates on causes of the pigeon's sudden disappearance, dismissing an ocean-crossing theory in favor of deforestation and relentless hunting.

The Marlboro Democrat · 23 November 1906 · page 4

A BIRD TRAGEDY.

This, however, seems to have been thc last of the passenger pigeon lu numbers. Soon thereafter lie disap peared as suddenly as the Virginia sora after a frost as oomplotoly as tho

See the clipping

The Marlboro Democrat · Bennettsville, S.C.

This retrospective article mourns the sudden, unexplained disappearance of the once-countless passenger pigeon, noting flocks that darkened the sky for hours now gone entirely. It cites an ornithologist's estimate of billions of birds and notes it has been over three decades since any large flocks were seen south of the Great Lakes, with a reward for a surviving pair still unclaimed.

The Marlboro Democrat · 23 November 1906 · page 5

A BIRD TRAGEDY. Tho PaasoiiKor Pigeon, Onco So Pion ttl ul, Now Hxttnot, Tho greatest of all tragedies Iv the feathorod kingdom was tne sudden oxtiuotion, the magioal disappearance, of tho onoe countless hosts of passen gor pigeons. Tho question as to what

See the clipping

The Marlboro Democrat · Bennettsville, S.C.

The article recalls flocks so vast they darkened the sky in the 1860s, and notes the last great nesting near Petoskey in 1878 (here given as 1881), after which the species vanished with startling suddenness. It weighs theories for the disappearance, dismissing an ocean-crossing die-off in favor of deforestation and relentless hunting as the likely causes.

The Marlboro Democrat · 23 November 1906 · page 5

A BIRD TRAGEDY.

This, however, seems to have been thc last of the passenger pigeon in numbers. Soon thereafter he disap peared as suddenly as the Virg'nia sora after a frost as oomplotely aa tho great auk of tho southern soas. What became of thom still remains and doubtless always will remain one of tho unsolved mysteries of scionoe. lt was at first thought that they at tempted to cross tho ocean, but un equal to tho long Hight foll and vero swallowed by the waves. Amore prob able conclusion ls that In the destruc tion of the forests, willoh deprived them of their natural food, aided by tho relentless persecution of malu lu every locality, wo may lind the real explanation of this deletable tragedy in tho kingdom of the birds.

See the clipping

Charlevoix County Herald · East Jordan, Mich.

A brief item in a Michigan news roundup claims that after many years' absence, wild pigeons are being seen again in Upper Peninsula locations. This appears amid a column of short, unrelated local news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

Charlevoix County Herald · 24 November 1906 · page 2

MICHIGAN IN BRIEF.

After an absence of many years wild pigeons are reported to be returning to OppOr peninsula points. Stewart I'M ward White, novella' ;ll write a story with scene in CJrand Map

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

An elderly settler recounts pioneer life in Deerfield Township, Fulton County, including hunting deer, wild turkeys, and passing mention of plentiful wild pigeons alongside prairie chickens and quails. He also recalls early schools, churches, settlers, and his civic service as justice of the peace and township supervisor.

Canton Weekly Register · 29 November 1906 · page 2

Ktlisville and 1 la by Ion, on horseback. “Prairie chickens.quails and wild pigeons were plentiful when L was a boy, and 1 used to trap them and hunt them with dog and gun. “We children used to attend school

See the clipping