As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

August 1906

16 articles

The Times-Journal · Malvern, Ark. · and 2 other papers

The paper reports hopeful rumors that wild passenger pigeons have reappeared in parts of the Western country after years of mysterious absence. It recalls the vast flocks of the Civil War era that once darkened the skies, and jokes about pigeon pot pie if they return.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Times-Journal · 1 August 1906 · page 2

The Pigeons Are Coming. It is most welcome news, if the re ports be true, that the wild pigeon has been seen in some parts of the West ern country. It is many years since those immense flocks which were a wonder to the beholder disappeared all of a sudden, and no man could tell the cause of their disappearance nor the place to which they had flown. One year during the Civil war they were numerous in the South, the heavens often being darkened as they flew in armies of tens of thousand.

See moreSee less

Let them come again to Arkansas. There is. even now an odor of pot pie in the air. Hard +Ht. Lightning struck the electric light plant at Malvern and it was set on fire and destroyed. The plant was owned by B. W. Turner and cost about *5,000.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark. · 27 July 1906
  • Woodruff County News · McCrory, Ark. · 2 August 1906

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A nostalgic nature essay recounts an English governess's anecdote about a Shropshire boy and bird's nests, then draws a parallel to Thoreau's discovery of a passenger pigeon's loosely built nest in Minnesota during his final June. The piece blends folklore, apple-howling traditions, and wistful recollection of the once-common bird.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 August 1906 · page 4

Thndy called out 'Quice,' which is the Shropshire name of the wood pigeon. I lingered, looking up at the shining, round, pink ecgs. with the light glimmering through the twigs, and then I mounted up the hill.” A discovery like this of the loosely built nest of our passenger pigeon was made by Thoreau in one of his walks

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

Mrs. Jane E. Rappleye of Brooklyn writes a reminiscence describing a massive passenger pigeon flock that settled in Adams County, Wisconsin around 1871-72, detailing their nesting behavior and the 35-mile-long belt of nests. She recounts how the birds devastated local crops before reportedly moving on to feed in Minnesota wheat fields.

The Mirror and Farmer · 2 August 1906 · page 7

Five minutes later Cody had been roped securely to the stakes and Dr. Baird, knife in hand, coolly cut the abscess off the leg. The operation consumed forty minutes and after the bandages were in place the keepers dashed away over the fence while the buffalo was rising from the ground. * * * Mrs. Jane E. Rappleye of Brooklyn writes the following interesting letter about wild pigeons: In Adams county, Wisconsin, one morn ing in April, 1871 or 1872, a large flock of strange pigeons alighted in our yard and foraged on the acorns.

See moreSee less

The previous au tumn there had been the most beautiful crop of nuts we had ever known. Every day large flocks of the birds appeared, until within a week the air wa§ so full of them that their shadows were like those from heavy rain clouds. At that time, thirty-five years ago, that part of the country was thinly settled. One could ride miles without finding an inhabitant. We were pioneers. The end less forests of oak and pine were still untouched. Every few miles there was a beautiful stream. It was an ideal rest ing place for the pigeons. From daylight till dark they were busy building nests,

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

A pioneer recounts childhood memories of massive passenger pigeon nesting colonies stretching 35 miles through the forest, describing how settlers and Indians harvested the birds for food, oil, and feathers. The writer reflects on the pigeons' mysterious migration patterns and eventual disappearance from the region.

The Mirror and Farmer · 2 August 1906 · page 7

of game and feathers come to them. Every one that could muster a shot gun was out whenever a flock of pigeons de scended near a settler's home in the open, The hunters had only to wave their arms to scare up the birds, then fire, walk over the ground and pick them up in baskets or bags. * * * The birds were not very wild and were not quite as large as our tame pigeons, but fine eating. It was a great treat for

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

A reminiscence describes passenger pigeons nesting in Ulster County, New York, and parents feeding squabs before migrating onward without stragglers. It also repeats a famous exaggerated yarn about a farmer shooting into a flock and collecting a bushel basket of severed legs, which the writer frames as folklore rather than fact.

The Mirror and Farmer · 2 August 1906 · page 7

* * * There was a story told to give strang ers some idea of the millions of birds in that flock—of a farmer who blazed away as the birds rose for flight. He did not bring down a bird, but picked up a bushel basket full of legs. He had fired low. It did not require a very" remarkable imagination to invent even such a yarn after seeing fully 23,000 acres of dense forest filled with one army of countless millions of wild pigeons. * * * A beautiful Egyptian gazelle hound (Slughi) was among the wedding gifts of I the young queen of Spain.

See moreSee less

The dog, which ;is a lovely pale cream color, and named j Saddan, was the gift of the Hon. Florence ;Amherst, who is a sister of Lady William !Cecil, who has been in waiting on the queen of Spain in Madrid. * * * These desert hounds are among the latI est of society's pets, says the London 'Tribune, and bid fair to outrun in Dopu- [ larity even the aristocratic Borzoi, which is the nearest in character to the east ern greyhound, and is probably, derived from him. * * * The Slughis are perhaps the oldest breed ;in the world, not even excepting the his toric spaniel of the palace of Pekin. Their MIRROR AND FARMER. THURSDAY. AUGUST 2. 1906. r BRIGHT. form was sculptured on some of the ear liest of Egyptian mural tablets, and some '„ monuments preserve the names of favor Church —When judges disagree, who is ite hounds of various kings. to decide? Gotham—Why, Lawyer Albert T. Pat The pedigrees of noble hounds notable rick, it seems.—Yonkers Statesman. for their speed in the chase are current today, having been traditionally handed 1 Horticultural Gentleman —You say here down among sheiks of Bedouin tribes of I In this article of yours that you have cul the deserts of Egypt and Arabia as from ; tivated hothouse lilac bushes that have the days of Saladin, one of whose hounds ; | attained the height of over fifty feet. wks named Saadan, while Persian nobles Literary Man—Yes. Why? claim that strains they own are older; ago while trying to save the left। Horticultural Gentleman (musingly)— I than either, and that the breed first orig Nothing, only I wish I could lilac that.— nearly lost his own life a few days ;

See the clipping

Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa.

A report claiming wild pigeons had reappeared in the state is declared incorrect; the birds sighted were doves, not pigeons. The piece notes the mystery remains of how pigeons once so numerous they darkened the sky in flight could vanish entirely.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: The Twice=a=week Herald, 24 July 1906, Ellsworth American, 25 July 1906, Ellsworth American, 25 July 1906, Warren Sheaf, 26 July 1906, The Times-Journal, 1 August 1906.

Butler Citizen · 2 August 1906 · page 3

grounds -'4,' he Wuller neas property on S. Main St., 20 feet front, changed hands last week for |15,500. A. Rrut, ..orlst, is the purchaser. —The Street Fair advertised for But ler for this week failed to put in an ap pearance. for the season that it was "at tached" for wages at Oil City, last week, Tip ror.d r,innjng wej,t ttou} Kw taaton bridge, and which nearly paral lels the line between the counties, is be ing improved by the Cantr&ctQV Jfanna'ifl floing'the work, —The report that wild pigeons had again made their appearance in this state proves to be incorrect.

See moreSee less

The al leged wild pigeons are doves. The mys tery of the disappearance o* j»igoon» uno« w*re s3 numerous that flying flocks darkened the sky j» ks deep as 4ver.—Ex. —The Penn'a R. R. Co alter fts meeting of Ho in Philadelphia, Tuesday, announced that it would issue a S2O mileage book, good in the hands of any one or number of persons, to be followed later by a new tariff reducing the maximum one-way fares from 8} and 3 cents to 2) cents a mile to any point on its line east of Pittsburg and Erie. —The destruction of so many barns by lightning during late electrical storms will, probably, increase the in terest in what we call "lightning rods." A "lightning rod" is undoubtedly a goo 4 if it doe o the work—that is turns the fluid-fire from the barn to the ground. The Objections to them are that they are too small, are fixed too close to the buildings and coat too much. A string or two of old oil-well tubing, two or three feet above the combing of the roof, held in place by wooden up rights and connected to the ground, would, probably, do as good work, and won Id cost less. —Electrical storms are among the strangest phenomena of nature that a hnyu»n being becomes accustomed to. How the clouds originate ia known tc almost everybody, but how the tremen dons amounts of electricity in them is generated is known to nobody. Storms have always been credited with some strange attributes, among which is the soaring of milk, but they have anothei not generally known— breaking oi watch springs, - On Saturday last (aftei the electrical storm of the night before: one of our Jewelers put in eight new watch springs though he had had norn to put in for three months before, ant he says he has known to snap dur ing an electrical storm, loose ii his desk. —Why is Newton "The Piano Mau See adv.

See the clipping

Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis. · and 1 other paper

Naturalist John Burroughs traveled to Sullivan County, New York to investigate reports that wild passenger pigeons had been seen there, interviewing witnesses who claimed to recognize the birds from decades earlier. He concluded the witnesses were credible and suggested the pigeons may have relocated to South America rather than been exterminated.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

Watertown Weekly Leader · 3 August 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tember 4, 1906. J. J. M'GILLIVRAY. Black River Falls, Wis., July 28.

FLOCKS OF WILD PIGEONS.

See moreSee less

John Burroughs Investigates Report of Their Being Seen in Sullivan County.

John Burroughs, the author-naturalist, has returned to West Park from a trip to Sullivan county, N. Y., where he passed some time investigating reports that wild pigeons had been seen recently in that locality. When Mr. Burroughs was in Poughkeepsie, he said:

"I have seen the men who saw the birds and have every reason to believe that they are telling the truth. Some of them knew the passenger pigeon in the old days, and it is not likely that all have been mistaken in the identity of the birds seen lately."

Thirty or forty years ago immense flocks of wild pigeons frequented the Hudson river valley. They disappeared suddenly and it was supposed that they had been exterminated by ruthless slaughter. The sequence of events indicates, however, that they were driven away and sought new feeding and resting grounds in other parts of the globe, perhaps in the southern part of South America.

Recently flocks of considerable size have been reported in Sullivan county, and two flocks have been seen along the Hudson, one a week ago Saturday by Elting Van Akin of Tower Hill farm, near Port Ewen.—New York Sun.

A Slow Golfer.

At St. Andrews one of the most respected and popular members of the club had the misfortune to crush his leg early in life and walked with the aid of a wooden one.

Being portly as well as lame, it was impossible for him to walk as fast as most people, but, being a good sportsman, and hating to keep people back, he made it a rule when he did play golf to start late. One day, however, two strangers, happening to start late, were kept back. Instead of making the best of it, they began to press the lame man. Back came his caddie. "Capt. J.'s compliments, and he knows he walks d——d slow, but he can walk a d——d sight slower."—Tatler.

Advertise in Your Home Paper.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 3 August 1906

The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.

Naturalist John Burroughs traveled to Sullivan County, NY, to investigate reports that wild passenger pigeons had been seen, and he concluded the witnesses were credible. He suggested the birds, which vanished decades earlier, may not have been exterminated but instead migrated to South America.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Pensacola Journal · 7 August 1906 · page 4

RETURN OF: WILD PIGEONS. John Burroughs’ View of Flocks Re ported Seen In Sullivan County. John Burroughs, the authornatural ist, has returned to West Park from a trip to Sullivan county, N. Y., where he passed some ‘time investigating re ports that wild pigeons had been seen recently imithat.lecality, says a Pough keepsie dispatch to the New York Sun. Mr. Burroughs was In Poughkeepsie recently. He said: “I bave seen the men whe saw the birds and have every reason to believe that they are télling the truth. Seme of them knew tlre passenger pigeon im the eM days, and it is not likely that all bave been mistaken in the identity of the birds seen lately.” Thirty or forty years ago immense flocks of wild pigeons frequented the Hudson river valley.

See moreSee less

They disappeared suddenly, and it was supposed that they had been exterminated by ruth less slaughter. The sequence of events Indicates, however, that they were driven away and sought new feeding and resting grounds in other parts of the globe, perhaps in the southern part of Bouth America. Recently flocks of considerable size have been reported in Sullivan county, and two flocks have been sen along the Hudson, one a few days ago by Elting Van Akin of Tower Hill farm, near Port Ewen. The Flower of Tramphood. A New York woman was surprised recently when an apparently well man stopped her on the street and asked for money. “How is it that a great, strong fellow like you should walk the streets begging 7’ she asked. With a Chesterfieldian how, the beg gar replied, “Because, madam, it is the only calling that permits a man to ad dress a beautiful lady without the for mality of an introduction.”—~Woman’s Home Companion. - — ———— cs c— Misundevrstandine “Hannah,” said the mistress to her few girl, “you can take that brown serge dress of mine and put it In sodk.”™ “Yea'm,” sald Hannah. “Who's your fav'rite pawnbroker?” — London Ane ower Seto :

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

The report claims that passenger pigeons, absent from the region for over thirty years, have been sighted again in large colonies along the Cloquet River in Minnesota and in northern Michigan, Wisconsin, and near Lake Superior. Lumbermen are cited as the source of these sightings.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Princeton Union · 9 August 1906 · page 2

After an absence of over thirty years, during which time not a single specimen of the species has been seen wild in these parts, the wild pigeons

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

This 1906 report traces the historical range and decline of the prairic chicken (pinnated grouse), comparing its disappearance in parts of the eastern U.S. to the fates of the great auk, Labrador duck, and passenger pigeon. It cites naturalists' observations from the early-to-mid 1800s showing the bird's extinction in various eastern states by the mid-to-late 19th century.

The New Haven Union · 22 August 1906 · page 8

Their Way. Among the North American birds that a little while ago seemed to be following the road which the great auk, the Lab rador duck and the passenger pigeon have

See the clipping

The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D.

John Burroughs investigated claims of passenger pigeons spotted in Sullivan County after a 30-year absence and said witnesses seemed credible. The report speculates the birds were not exterminated but instead migrated to new grounds, possibly South America.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 21 days earlier.

The Bottineau Courant · 24 August 1906 · page 8

WILD PIGEONS COME BACK. Again Seen in the Cat skills .and Hud son Biver Valley, After Ab sence of 30 Years. Poughkeepsie, N. Y.—John Bur roughs, the author-naturalist, has re turned from a trip to Sullivan county, where he investigated reports that wild pigeons had been recently in that locality. He said: "I have seen the men who saw the birds, and lave every reason to be lieve that they are telling the truth. Some of them knew the passenger pi geon in the old days, and it is not likely that all have been mistaken in the identity of the birds seen lately."

See moreSee less

Thirty years ago immense flocks of wild pigeons frequented the Hudson river valley. They disappeared sud denly, and it was supposed that they had been exterminated by ruthless slaughter. The sequence of events in dicates. however, that they wera driven away and sought new feeding and resting grounds in" other parts of the globe, perhaps in the southern part of South America. Milwaukeean with Big Name. Milwaukee.—Milwaukee has come to the front with one of the longest names i nthe country. Seldom has such a combination pf vowels and con sonants been seen within the borders of the United States as the following, which is given in the city directory for this year: Jack Pappatheodorokom mountourgeotopoulos. jFack etc. lives at 425 Sycamore street. The holder of the record in Milwaukee before this was Pauline Nabuchodonozorowiczow na, 1702 Midland avenue, a widow. Another of Wealth's Hardships. "There is no place like home," said the man of gentle sentiments. "Ye6," answered Mr. Cumrox. "But when you've got two country houses, *a residence in the city and are paying board at three summer resorts, how are you going to know where it la?"

See the clipping

Ladysmith News · Ladysmith, Wis.

A Duluth dispatch claims millions of wild pigeons, which had recently returned to Minnesota's pineries after a thirty-year absence, were seen flying south again, driven out by forest fires and lack of water. Observers reportedly watched flock after flock pass over Duluth toward South America.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Ladysmith News · 25 August 1906 · page 3

Duluth, Minn., Aug. 23. —Presumably driven from the north woods by the numerous forest fires and the scarcity of water, millions of wild pigeons that recently returned to the Minnesota pineries, after an absence of thirty years, again are winging their way to the dense jungles of South America, where they are supposed to have their habitat of recent years. The flight of the birds was watched yester day by many people in Duluth. Flock after flock of the birds went sailing by, apparently following the nortli shore until Dulufh was reached, and then winging their wgy southwesterly across the bay until lost to sight.

See the clipping

Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis.

A newspaper item reports unconfirmed sightings of 'wild pigeons' in the Western U.S., recalling the vast historic migrations of passenger pigeons that once darkened the skies. It notes the birds vanished mysteriously decades earlier and recounts an ornithologist's memory of a flock a mile wide and 240 miles long.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wausau Pilot · 28 August 1906 · page 6

RECALLS MIGRATIONS OF OLD DAYS. Dnce Plentiful in the East—Ornith ologist Tells of One Flock a Mile Wide and Two Hundred and Forty Miles Long. It is most welcome news, if the re ports be true, says the Providence Tribune, that the wild pigeon has been seen in some parts of the Western country. It is many years since those immense flocks which were a won der to the beholder disappeared all of a sudden, ana no man could tell the cause of their disappearance nor the place to which they had flown.

See moreSee less

They were seen as late as the middle seventies in New York State, but be fore that time they had ceased to visit New England. Sixty years ago they were numerous in some parts of Maine, especially where the India wheat was grown in large quantities, and where the blueberry pastures of fered their tempting fruit. In those days the Boston markets supplied them sometimes at fifty cents a dozen rod the memories of pigeon stew with dumplings or the Juicy pot pie are fragrant to many a man who has reached the Psalmist’s limit of age. A remarkable characteristic of :hese birds was their associating to gether, both in their migrations and during the time of incubation, in such prodigious numbers as almost to be beyond belief; no one of the other feathered tribes is at all line the wild pigeon in this respect. The migrations of the bird do not seem bo have been caused simply by the cold of the climate, for a? late is December they used to be found in the northern regions around Hudson’s Bay. It was rather in quest of the :ood that they made their flights. As the beechnut was the chief food of the wild pigeon, in those seasons and places where it was most abundant corresponding multitudes of pigeons might he expected. When they had consumed all the beech nuts in one district they would

See the clipping

Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · and 1 other paper

The article recalls Wilson's famous account of a massive passenger pigeon flock he witnessed near Frankfort, Kentucky, calculating its staggering size using his migration-time observations. It then speculates that hunting alone could not explain the species' disappearance, suggesting instead that the pigeons may have migrated elsewhere during the Civil War and could still return.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 51 days later.

Wrong

Wausau Pilot · 28 August 1906 · page 6

one of these places for any length of time great havoc was made. All the tender grass and other herbage be neath their roost was utterly de stroyed, large limbs of trees were broken down by the weight of the birds, and the trees themselves, for hundreds of acres, as completely kill ed as if girdled by an axe. The breeding place was cf greater extent than the place where they roosted. There was one in Kentucky which was said to stretch through the woods, in a north and south di rection, nearly forty miles in length and several miles in breadth.

See moreSee less

In this tract almost every tree was furnished with nests wherever the branches could hold them. At this place the pigeons made their first appearance about April 11 and left it altogether with their young before May 25. Space is wanting to describe the sad havoc made among the birds by the people in whose section they nested. The natives came from all the surrounding districts and en camped for days among the immense nurseries. Ther cut down the trees which were most crowded with nests, and the falling of one tree sometimes produced two hundred squabs little inferior in size to the old ones and almost one mass of fat. From the account given of the flight of vast flocks of the wild pig eons one is reminded of the locust swarms of the East. Wilson, in his “American Ornithology,” describes a flight which he once saw on his way to Frankfort, Ky. It travelled in a compact body at a height beyond gunshot, with great rapidity and steadfastness. Curious to knew how long the passage would continue he took out his watch and waited more than an hour. But the procession seemed only to increase in numbers and so he continued on his journey. When he reached Frankfort, four hours after he first saw the flock the living torrent over the head was as extensive as ever. Mr. Wilson afterward made a cur ious calculation of this flock. If we suppose the column to have been only one mile in breadth (and he believed it to be much more) and that it moved at the rate of a mile a minute, four hours, the time it continued passing, would make the whole length two hun dred and forty miles. Again, suppos ing that each squab yard of this mov ing body enclosed three pigeons, the square yards in the whole space multi plied by three would give two billion two hundred and thirty million, two hundred and seventy-two thousand. It could not be possible that simply the daughter by man was the cause of the total disappearance of such huge flocks. Perhaps the continuance of the civil war was the reason of their migrating to some more con genial district of our immense coun try where man has not discovered them. Anyhow, if they are really coming back the old song of seventy years ago will be revived and we can “bid farewell to pork and beans and live on pigeon pie.” The Drummer in Africa. If all American exporters showed the same energy in selling their wares abroad that is shown by the agricul tural machinery men. the United States would become the leading na tion in foreign commerce. A South African journal says that ' the ener getic American drummer selling agri cultural machinery is not satisfied with keeping his stock in a central storeroom, or of being a regular ex hibitor at the shews, but in addition he endeavors to bring his machine or implement to the very gate of the farm. Wherever he can sufficiently engage the attention of the farmer, he gives an experimental demonstration of his machine’s qualities, the inevi table result of a tour of this charac ter being a large crop of orders, which more than repays for the heavy out lay incurred on transport, etc. In 1904, 54 per cent, of the agricultural machinery imported into South Africa came from the United States.” —Uri*- To Remove Splinters. Splinters of wood or glass which can not be removed with a fine needle can be very easily taken out by filling a wide-mouthed boftie with not water and holding it firmly against the flesh where the splinter has entered. The steam will draw the flesh down and a little additional pressure will take out the splinter. This is an easy and very satisfactory method, and comparative ly pcinles*

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss. · 17 November 1906

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

The article recounts the passenger pigeon's former abundance in Canada and the U.S., describing massive nesting colonies, roosting sites that destroyed forests, and the toll taken by locals who harvested squabs by felling nesting trees. It claims the birds disappeared suddenly and inexplicably, comparing their vast flights to swarms of locusts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 48 days later.

Wrong

Shenandoah Herald · 31 August 1906 · page 4

| .ce the pigeons made their first ap* vam iboul April 11 and left it altogether **.** uh their young before May 35. "pace is wanting to describe tbe

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

The piece quotes ornithologist Alexander Wilson's famous account of an enormous passenger pigeon flock he witnessed flying for hours near Frankfort, Kentucky, estimating its length at 240 miles and its population in the billions. It then speculates that human slaughter alone could not fully explain the species' total disappearance.

Shenandoah Herald · 31 August 1906 · page 4

Again,8uppo**ing thal each sq..sb \ard ol this moving body enclosed three pigeons, the square yards is tbe iv sole ppace multiplied by three \v .'?!<! gjb/e two billion two hundred ai.d sevcntv-two thou--ind. It could Bel I e possible that sim ply the slaughter by man was the cause of the total die ipp* arance . f such begs flocks. Perhaps Inc con

See the clipping