As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

June 1904

9 articles

Montgomery County Sentinel · Rockville, Md.

This humorous item recounts an old Callaway County, Missouri tale about hunter Calvin Tate, who allegedly killed 1,100 passenger pigeons with a single shot from a tree so laden with birds it bent to the ground. When the tree snapped back up after the shot, it supposedly carried his tethered horse into the air until he could fetch an axe to cut it down.

Montgomery County Sentinel · 3 June 1904 · page 1

A MISSOURI NIMROD

A llarcNln. "Did you hear what Whlmpton’s lit tle boy said when they showed hlin the twins?” “No. Wbit was It?” “He said: There! Mamma’s been gel tin’ bargains again!' ’* A SlHourl %l if tirhnaunt. There are some pretty fair Nlmrods In Mlsaourl now, but a story which Is printed In an old history of (Jaliuway county shows that some of those of former days could make contemporary sportsmen look like IVi cents either ss shots or us raconteurs. “Mr. Cal vln Tate,” according to this history, "says that the wild pigeons were so plentiful one summer that frequently when they would alight on n tree It would bend down to the ground with their weight.

See moreSee less

He went hunting one day, and seeing a line lot of pigeons In a tree he hitched his horse to one of the limbs and fired and killed 1100 at one shot. The rest flew nwny, and as soon as the tree was relieved of their weight It straightened up, rarfylng his horse with It, and the poor brute had to hang there until Tate could go home and get an ax and cut the tree down.” -Kansas City Journal.

See the clipping

The Coeur D'alene Press · Coeur D'alene, Idaho

A newspaper exchange item praises new government protections for elk in Yellowstone but laments that the bison and passenger pigeons, once uncountable on the western plains, were never similarly protected. It blames reckless hunters and government indifference for turning these species into practically extinct races through wasteful slaughter.

The Coeur D'alene Press · 4 June 1904 · page 6

AMONG OUR EXCHANGES.

Now, have the commissioners neglect , , ^ d '^ir duty, or .s the sheritf carry■ lng here without paying ing one saloon here without license? This school district needs all the money that belongs to it. and not half. — Bonuers Kerry Progress. hhe government is going to protect *he great elk in the leiiowstone Park ^ rum hunters and try to add to their number It is a vast pity that the bison and wild pigeons which once througed the western plains in couut

See the clipping

Wauwatosa News · Wauwatosa, Wis.

The National Committee of Audubon Societies is distributing numbered educational leaflets from its New York headquarters to recruit bird lovers and protectors. One of the eight leaflets issued so far covers the passenger pigeon, alongside others on nighthawk, meadowlark, mourning dove, tern, flicker, snowy heron, and marsh hawk, each including a picture, scientific classification, economic value, and study points for schools.

Wauwatosa News · 18 June 1904 · page 4

The national committee of the Audu bon societies of the I'uited Stales j* inn ing from its headquarters in New York a series of numbered educational leaflets that will surely make many >oinig re cruits to the ranks of tic loveis mid pro tectors of biids. Each of these leatlcts bason its first page 1 picture of the bird of which it treats, with ; as ;., name, order, suborder, family, g, nns and spe cies. The text consists of a ompact de scription of the birds, followed by 1 xpla nation as to their oeonomi, value, ami 1 “study points" for teachers and pupils.

See moreSee less

The birds discussed in the eight leatlcts thus far issued are the iiiglitiiawk. mead owlark. mourning dove, t in, nicker, passenger or wild pigeon, smovy heron, and marsh hawk. Those loathes could be made particularly serviceable by use as supplemental reading in the schools, in connection with nature study. The expenditures of the federal gov ernment during the mouth, of .May ex ceeded the receipts by the formidable amount of s,l-1.7550.4 Ifi: but this is mu so bad a showing as it looks for there

See the clipping

Times-Promoter · Hernando, Miss. · and 11 other papers

A humorous anecdote from an old Callaway County, Missouri history describes pigeons so plentiful they bent trees to the ground, and recounts a hunter who tied his horse to a pigeon-laden branch, shot 300 birds at once, and watched the tree spring up carrying his horse aloft. The story is framed explicitly as a 'Munchausen' tall tale about legendary pigeon abundance.

Times-Promoter · 24 June 1904 · page 3

A Missouri Munchausen. There are some pretty fair Nimrods in Missouri now, but a story which is printed in an old history of Callaway county shows that some of those of former days could make contemporary sportsmen look like 30 cents either as shots or as raconteurs, says the Kan sas City Journal. "Mr. Calvin Tate," according to this history, "says that the wild pigeons were so plentiful one summer that frequently when they would alight on a tree it would bend, down to the ground with their weight. He went hunting one day, and seeing a fine lot of pigeons in a tree he bitched his horse to one of the limbs and fired and killed 300 at one shot.

See moreSee less

The rest flew away, and as soon as the tree was relieved of their weight it straightened up, carrying his horse with it, and the poor brute had to hang there until he could go home and get an ax and cut the tree down.

See the clipping

Also printed in 11 papers
  • Oxford Eagle · Oxford, Miss. · 23 June 1904
  • The Tupelo Journal · Tupelo, Miss. · 24 June 1904
  • Lawrence Democrat · Lawrenceburg, Tenn. · 24 June 1904
  • The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn. · 24 June 1904
  • The Greenville Times · Greenville, Miss. · 25 June 1904
  • The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss. · 25 June 1904
  • The Leader · Brookhaven, Miss. · 25 June 1904
  • The Scranton Chronicle · Scranton, Miss. · 25 June 1904
  • The Commonwealth · Greenwood, Miss. · 9 July 1904
  • · · 14 July 1904
  • Water Valley Progress · Water Valley, Miss. · 30 July 1904

The Bellefontaine Republican · Bellefontaine, Ohio

A brief item claims that wild passenger pigeons, once abundant in the region, are being seen returning. This rumor appears among a long list of other local trivia and news briefs.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

The Bellefontaine Republican · 24 June 1904 · page 3

Mansfield on July 4. While opening an old gravel pit near Wapakoneta workmen unearthed a score of Indian skeletons. At a local option election held in Mechaniceburg Monday the "drys" won by a majority of seven. Burton Wellman, of this city, suc cessfully passed the examination for admission to the Ohio State bar. It is reported that the wild pigeons which were formerly found in such numbers in these parts are returning. Judge Dow has granted the trustees of the Christian church of Rushsyl vania the right to sell lands owned by t he church. Upon application. C. C. Ontland has been released by Probate Judge W. 8. Plum from acting longer as guardian

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

An article about the mysterious disappearance of Chesapeake Bay crabs speculates whether cold weather killed them or they migrated, comparing their vanishing to the extinction of wild pigeons and other birds and beasts. The passenger pigeon reference is a brief analogy within an otherwise unrelated crab market report.

The Washington Times · 25 June 1904 · page 4

CRABS ARE SCARCE AND PRICE IS HIGHER

About Twice as Much as Last Year. What has become of the crab? 1s the side-stepping tribe to disappear like the vast flock of wild pigeons and other birds and beasts that have become ex tainct? Did the long and coid weather of last winter kill them off, or have they moved? These are questions marketmen, bay and river men, and consumers generally are asking concerning the water spiders so popular among all who have ever lived near or heard of Chesapeake Bay. unobtainable.

See the clipping

The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss.

Hunters in the Osage reservation and elsewhere claim to have spotted wild pigeons, a species long believed vanished from the U.S. Sportsmen debate whether these are surviving native birds or stragglers from South America.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Sea Coast Echo · 25 June 1904 · page 2

The Wild Pigeon

QUAINT AND CURIOUS. An innkeeper of Wilhelmborg, who turns the scale nt 502 pounds, is the heaviest man In Germany. Bourn, in the Congo Free State has a road nearly 150 miles long, which is practicable for automobiles. There are now 29 women of title In England who were American girls, in cluding four duchesses and two count esises. At Edinburg. Scotland, n lady has been found insane who left S2OO to pro vide a fund for the rescue of sane per sons Improperly placed In lunatic asy lums. Picked up In a Manchester (Eng land) street a dynamite blasting cart ridge was found to have been run over, hut luckily at the end farthest from the cap.

See moreSee less

The religious feelings of the natives of the Punjab aro so strongly opposed to the killing of rats that It has been decided to let tho plague follow Its course there, absolutely unchecked. An antl-swcarlng league has been formed nt Hammersmith, London, which will appoint Inspectors whoso duty It will he to warn and afterward, it necessary, summon any person found swearing in the street. The chief desire of the municipality of Haro. In Chile, Is to have their town known as a second London, and within tho last decade much money has been spent to make It an exact replica of tho British capital. The streets have been laid down and named after those in l>ondon. The WMd Pigeon. Members from the hunting party of the Osage reservation say they saw wild pigeons a few days ago In flight in the hills north of the Arkansas river. The disappearance of the wild pig eon from the United States, where o.ice it abounded in vast numbers, was a remarkable event, and sportsmen have never been able to learn the cause. The persons who saw wild pigeons In the Osage country were fa miliar with their appearance years ago. and are positive that the birds wore pigeons. The pigeons were seen nt different places. One hunter saw a single pigeon In full flight south ward and two other hunters saws two pigeons, also flying south. It is al leged that a tew wild pigeons have I been seen this fall in the Illinois marsh lands east of St, Louis. Sportsmen are interested In know ing whether the pigeons in the Osag* country were natives that have re mained undisturbed in the remote hills since early days, or whether thc-v are stray - from South America, where tho pigeons are suppose;! to have gone. One of the largest pigeon roosts in the United States was in tl<- Cherokee tin tion, southeast of Tahlequah.—Bar ; Otsvllle Examiner. again, for often those brigands make mistakes and single out a man for whom their threats have no terrors. These men Immediately come to ui and tell us of the threats made. There after they ore not annoyed by any more threatening letter*. "What makes It hard for us is that even the boldest sometimes fear to turn over lo us the letters they receive. They have no fear of the threats, but they do fear to turn over tne letters. "These Italian societies never select on American for a victim. For the av erage American the dread Mafia has no terrors, hut the mysterious secrecy of those organizations is a terror In It self to the timid Italian. If I could only Induce them to turn over to tho police department all the Information they have I have no doubt that tho ‘Black Hand' would bo stamped out la abort order."—New York World.

See the clipping

Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah

A brief item in a newspaper miscellany column states that the once-abundant wild pigeons of early American history are reportedly returning in large numbers to New England. It calls for their return to be welcomed and for efforts to protect them.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

Deseret Evening News · 25 June 1904 · page 4

The wild pigeons so famous In early American history are said to bo return Ing In large numbero to New England Theirreturn should be hailed vltb Joy and every effort made to protect them

See the clipping

Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis.

The newspaper reprints an old Callaway County, Missouri history recounting a tall tale about hunter Calvin Tate, who allegedly killed 300 passenger pigeons with one shot from a tree so laden with birds it bent to the ground. The tree supposedly sprang upright afterward, hoisting his hitched horse into the air until he could fetch an axe to cut it down.

Vilas County News · 27 June 1904 · page 8

A MISSOURI MUNCHAUSEN. There are some pretty lair Nlmrods in Missouri now. but a story which is printed In an old history or Callaway county shows that seme of those of former days could make contempor ary sportsmen look like thirty cents either as shots or as raconteurs. “Mr. Calvin Tate,” according to this history, “says that the wild pigeons were so plentiful one summer that frequently when they would alight on a tree it would bend down to the ground with their weight. He went hunting one day, and seeing a fine lot of pigeons in a tree he hitched his horse to one of the limbs and fired and killed three hundred at one shot.

See moreSee less

The rest flew away, and as soon as the tree was relieved of their weight it straightened up, carrying his horse with it, and the poor brute had to hang there until Tate could go home and get an ax and cut the tree down.”

See the clipping