As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

May 1904

14 articles

The Chippeway Herald · White Earth, Minn.

A writer recounts decades-old personal memories among Winnebago and Pottawatomi peoples, including a story about finding a lost arrow shot at a wild pigeon and a band killing 214 dozen pigeons in four hours. The passage also recalls an 1863 incident involving a Pottawatomi man named Kau-kee and a murder report.

The Chippeway Herald · 1 May 1904 · page 3

(wild pigeons.) I there saw the first and only game moccassin I ever saw played. It was indeed interesting, but on the gambling order. Late in the autumn of 1863 Wes mota, a son-in-law of Chief Me-nom-i ----nee, as well as a brother-in-law of the late Chief Simon Pokagon, came to my house very much excited, saying the Pottawattomis of Michigan were all in tears and great trouble because as he said: “We hear bad white man kill ’um Joe Kau-kee way up north to Saddle Lake cause him mad; cause Kau-kee kill ’um many deer (suc-cee,)” og,” (whiskey eggs;) and then ask, , “would you like to take some of them?” She would then carefully put into each i extended hand some of these charm ing colored eggs.

See moreSee less

On receiving them, childlike, they : would feel of the little beauties with the tips of their fingers, when to their ! great surprise, the frail egg shells would crumble a way and from each egg come forth a little snake, squirm ing and wriggling in their hands. With a shriek of horror they would let the young reptiles drop and scat ter like leaves in a whirlwind. The cruel joke impressed their youthful minds with such a loathsome hale against “ish-kot-e-wawbo” that their very souls ever after would revolt at the sight, smell, taste, or even the thought, of that deceptive curse. This shrewd Indian woman would then make application of the strong object lesson, convincing the children that what they had witnessed was but a slight foretaste of the awful reality, and that they who drank the curse, after a while would be torment ed with mi-che-sin-e-bis (great big snakes) which they could not escape or let go of. Some 35 years ago I spent a few weeks among the Winnebagos of Wisconsin. While there I witnessed the shrewdness of one of that tribe in finding a lost arrow. On pasing along an old trail I noticed that he was shooting arrows into the top of a tall tree. I asked: “What are you shoot ing at?” He replied, “Me shoot ’um to find ’um my lost arrow.” I looked up into the tree, but could see no arrow, and so told him. He replied: “Me know dat — me shoot ’um at me-me (wild pigeon) in dat tree and lose ’um my arrow; him he fell mebby on ground somewhere.” I replied, “If the lost arrow fell on the ground how can you expect to find it by shooting into the tree?” He replied; “Me tell you me hab shot in now four arrows to find the one me lose; me watch ’um fall; me stand in same place; me shoot in de tree top in same place.” He then said; “Come, go wid me.” I did so; he pointed out to me the four arrows and said. “Arrow me lose here some where,” then quickly added, “Here im be,” and picked up the lost arrow. It was three-cornered at the head and made of hickory. I bought the arrow and still have it in my office, kept as a relic of native shrewdness. This band of Indians in less than 4 hours on that day killed with their bows and arrows 214 dozen me-me-og (wild pigeons.) I there saw the first and only game moccassin I ever saw played. It was indeed interesting, but on the gambling order. Late in the autumn of 1863 Wes mota, a son-in-law of Chief Me-nom-i ----nee, as well as a brother-in-law of the late Chief Simon Pokagon, came to my house very much excited, saying the Pottawattomis of Michigan were all in tears and great trouble because as he said: “We hear bad white man kill ’um Joe Kau-kee way up north to Saddle Lake cause him mad; cause Kau-kee kill ’um many deer (suc-cee,)”

See the clipping

Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me.

A 1904 Kansas City Journal item recounts an old Callaway County history's story of Calvin Tate, who allegedly killed 300 wild pigeons in one shot from a tree so laden with birds it bent to the ground. When the tree snapped back upright after the birds flew off, it supposedly carried his tethered horse into the air until he returned with an ax.

Oxford Democrat · 3 May 1904 · page 4

A MI.HMonrl Μ iim-liit uncii . Then* are some pretty lair Ni m rods in Missouri now. hut 11 story which is printed in ;in old history of Callaway county shows that some of those of former days ciuId make contemporary sportsmen !<:ok like ">U rents either as shots 4 r as raconteurs. "Mr. On! vin Tate." according to this history, "says that the wild pigeons were so plentiful one summer that frequently when they would alight on a tree it would bend down to the ground with their weight. lie went hunting one day, and seeing a tine lot of pigeons in a tree he hitched his horse to one of the limits and tired and killed .".(mi at one shot.

See moreSee less

The rest flew away, and as soon as the tree was relieved of their weight it straightened up. carrying his horse with it, and the poor brute had to hang there until Tate could go home and get an ax and cut the tree· down."

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article reflects on the extinction of the great auk and Pallas' cormorant as a warning, then turns to the passenger pigeon and Carolina paroquet, both nearing extinction by 1904. It quotes Audubon's famous eyewitness accounts of immense pigeon flocks darkening the sky for days and describes a massive roosting site in Kentucky spanning many miles.

Evening Star · 7 May 1904 · page 23

These birds ire the passenger pigeon and the Carolina paroquet. Ornltho'oglsts of the first half of the last century, notably Audubon and Wilson, tell of the almost inconceivable numbers of wild pigeons which they saw in the val ley of the Mississippi and its tributaries and farther east. The former describes a flight of pigeons which he saw while trav eling on horseback between Hardensburg and Louisville, Ky. The birds were In such numbers that the noonday sun was ob scured as by an eclipse. This flight con tinued uninterrupted and in undiminished numbers for three days in succession.

See moreSee less

The vast multitudes of birds in such a flight cannot even he estimated, but some sense of theli numbers might, perhaps, be reached by visiting a nesting site or roost ing place. Audubon describes a roosting place on the banks of the Green river in Kentucky in the following words:

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report quotes Audubon's historical description of a massive passenger pigeon roosting site along the Green River in Kentucky, detailing the enormous scale of birds, the destruction of trees, and hunters who slaughtered them in huge numbers. It then reflects on the causes of the species' extinction, citing overhunting, market demand, and raids on nesting sites, while urging protection for the mourning dove before a similar fate occurs.

Evening Star · 7 May 1904 · page 23

A Roosting Place. "It was, as is always the case, in a por tion of the forest where the trees were of great magnitude ?.nd where there was little underwi.cd. I rode through It upwards of forty miles, and, crossing it at different parts, lound its average breadth to be rath er more than three miles. My first view of ii was ribout a fortnight subsequent to the period when they had made choice of it. and I arrived there nearly two hours before sunset. Few pigeons vere then to be seen, but a great number of persons, with horses Tind wagons, guns and ammunition, had al ready established encampments on the bor ders.

See moreSee less

Two farmers from the vicinity of Russelville, distant more than a hundred miles, had driven upwards of 300 hogs to be fattened on the pigeons which were to be slaugllteied. Here ani there, the people etnploved in plucking and salting what had already been procured, were seen sitting in the midst of large piles of these birds. Many irees two f<et in diameter. I observed, v,ere. tiroken off at no great distance from the ground; ajul branches of many of the largest : nd tallest had given way, as if the forest had been swept by a tornado, livery thins proved to me that the number of birds lesorting to th'.j part of the forest must 1>? immense bejond conception. As the per'od of thoir arrival approached, their

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article reflects on the passenger pigeon's extinction, attributing it to firearms, market hunters, hog raisers, and mass squab harvesting from nesting sites. It urges protection of the mourning dove, citing state laws and growing public sentiment against bird destruction, hoping the pigeon's fate will not be forgotten.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 12 days earlier.

Evening Star · 7 May 1904 · page 23

in the main to the unrestrained use of Im proved firearms, the reckless and avaricious operations of market hunters and of hog raisers at roosting places, and especially to the systematic raids upon nesting sites for the purpose of sending squabs, in car or train lots, to the ready markets of the larger cities. From both ethical and material points of view the extinction of the pigeon is to be deplored. It is a great pity that the pub lic conscience against bird destruction was not aroused before it was too late to save this magnificent bird, but let it be suggest ed in passing that it is not yet too late to save the mourning dove, now the only com mon representative of the pigeon family in the United States.

See moreSee less

In many states this de sirable little bird is rapidly following the course of the pigeon, because of the efforts of some sportsmen to place it upon the game bird list. A number of states, how ever. restrict the shooting of the dove, while an increasing number are placing li in the wholly protected list. Since the publication of the studies of the food habits of the dove, public sentiment Is rapidly growing in favor of absolute pro tection. Farmers' Bulletin 100 of the United States Biological Survey enumerates the states which protect the dove at all sea sons as follows: Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut. New York. Delaware, West Virginia, Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin, Iowa, Arkansas and Wyoming, and the District of Columbia. Nineteen states and territories allow shooting during certain months only, while eight states and territories offer the dove no protection at any time. This plain ly dressed but most Interesting and bene ficial member of the pigeon family, which is still common, should be fully protected by all of the states at an early date. It is hoped that the extinction of the pas senger pigeon, deplorable as It is, will not be a lesson lost, but that the public con science, which Is being1 slowly but surely awakened, will insist upon preservation of the dove. The dove hunter, the robin eater and the devourer of meadow larks are of a class for which there should be small en couragement in the United States.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A local sportsman argues that game laws are ineffective due to public disregard, modern firearms, and relentless hunting pressure. He lists the buffalo, deer, wild turkey, wild pigeon, ruffed grouse, and prairie chicken as already nearly or entirely extinct due to market hunters and the pump gun.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 8 May 1904 · page 11

USELESS GAME LAWS. 'Sportsman Says No Attention is Paid to Them. "AS' it looks now, all attempts at lcgis tation to .-ecure the preservation of tho wild game of this country will come to j 'naught. The people generally do not re Bpect'gamc laws. This fact, coupled with the advent of modern firearms, the changed conditions under which wild things have to live and the almost insane desire to kill all -types of wild thing? on ight,4 nSvkcs the early extinction of near ly all kinds of game, both tfosh and fowl, absolutely certain. The buffalo, the deer, the, wild turkey, the wild pigeon, the ruffed grouse and the prairie chicken are practically all gone, while the wild fowl

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This editorial from 1904 reflects on the extermination of the passenger pigeon and buffalo as examples of wanton destruction of wildlife, arguing both could have been preserved through wise legislation. It uses this historical lesson to praise current efforts to protect elk in Yellowstone Park.

New-York Tribune · 9 May 1904 · page 6

PROTECTING ELK. In many regions of the great West elk, for countless centuries so plentiful, have been al most extirpated, although they are not so rare #s American bisons, which formerly were num bered by millions on the prairies. It is good news that the elk in Yellowstone | Park will be carefully preserved by the gov ernment officials, and that every effort will be made to add to their number. The wiping out of the armies of the buffalo and the extermi nation of the vast flocks of wild pigeons were | among the most wanton massacres of beast and bird ever known and a loss of a deplor | able kind to the people of the United States.

See moreSee less

Wise degislation by the federal government and | by the legislative bodies of States and Terri tories would have protected the buffalo and the wild pigeon to a reasonable extent, and the benefit to the country would have been of no small importance. — ———————————————

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This article describes the rapid destruction and shrinking range of the Carolina paroquet during the 19th century, drawing a direct parallel to the passenger pigeon's extinction. It notes the bird's powerful flight did not protect it from decline, citing observations by naturalists like Alexander Wilson and Audubon.

Evening Star · 14 May 1904 · page 28

APPROACHING EXTINCTION

Written for The Evening Star. . The rapid destruction of the Carolina paroquet (Conurus carolinus), and the re striction of its habitat in the United States during the past century, presents a case in many respects parallel to that of the pas senger pigeon. Ornithologists and travelers who were familiar with the section of coun try embraced within the longitude of K in sas City, Mo., and the Atlantic seaboard on the west and east, and the Great Lakes and the Gulf of Mexico on the north nii south, with scarcely an exception, speak of the abundance of this handsome repre sentative of the great parrot family of birds during the.

See moreSee less

first half of the century Just closed. The Carolina paroquet was not. abundant in the sense that the passenger pigeon was abundant, but the birds were numerous enough to cause comment upon the s ze of the flocks seen at different times and places within the district outlined. They w:-re birds of powerful flight, "not unlike the flight of the dove," says Mr. Ridgway, but rapid flight in the'r ease appears to have offered no exemption against exlinct on any more than in the c ifc of the p -ssonger pigeon, whien. in its search for food, un doubtedly crossed several states en route to feeding grounds at a speed of ninety miles or more per hour.

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

This is a biographical obituary-style article about Peter TenEyck and his wife, detailing their farm acquisitions, livestock, and family history in Fairview township. It mentions in passing that they once kept as many as 3,000 wild pigeons caught on roosts and fed in a crib for food.

Canton Weekly Register · 19 May 1904 · page 1

At tin1 time when Peter TenEyck passed from the scenes of his earthly joys and sorrow s he had accumulated, with tin* assistance of his devoted wife, a handsome fortune, and was the owner of over 800 acres of land. Hi* also had many thoroughbred shorthorn cattle and tine, fleet-footed trotters, in which he took great pride, lie was fond of the rod and gun and spent some time hunting and fishing. Mrs. TenKyck recalls the time when they had two pet deer, which her husband caught in the woods, and also w hen •hey had as many as 3,000 wild pigeons in the crib at one time. These

See the clipping

The Hartford Republican · Hartford, Ky.

The report praises government efforts to preserve Yellowstone elk from the fate suffered by the American bison and passenger pigeon. It characterizes the earlier destruction of buffalo herds and wild pigeon flocks as wanton, deplorable massacres and losses to the nation.

The Hartford Republican · 20 May 1904 · page 7

It is good news that the elk in Yel lowstone Park will be carefully pre served by the government officials and that every tffort will bmade to add to their number The wiping out of the armies of the Iniflalo and the extermination of the vast flocks fiOCk91of of wild pigeons were among the most I wanton massacres of beast and bird i I

See the clipping

The Hartford Republican · Hartford, Ky.

A brief editorial fragment reflects that wise legislation by federal and state governments could have protected the buffalo and the wild pigeon to a reasonable extent. It states the loss of these species was deplorable and of no small importance to the country.

The Hartford Republican · 20 May 1904 · page 7

ev r known and a loss of a deplorable Kind to the people of the United Sates Wise legislatLn b the fed Iotl government and l > v Ui < legis a live bodies of States ad1tardotis woull have protected the buffalo and the wild pigeon to n rssnnabe ex tent and the benefit to the country would have been ot no small impor

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

A Quebec paper reports that wild pigeons, once so abundant they darkened the sky and sold cheaply in markets, are apparently reappearing in former haunts after disappearing mysteriously in the late 1860s or early 1870s. The piece notes many theories for their disappearance but says none has been satisfactorily proven, while insisting their return is now beyond doubt.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Irish Standard · 21 May 1904 · page 2

THE WILD PIGEON. Again in Evidence After an Absence of Almost Forty Years. There seems to be 110 longer any doubt that the wild pigeons which were once so abundant as to be a nuisance and which disappeared so mysteriously all of a sudden from the inhabited parts of the United States and Canada, are reappearing in some of their old haunts, says the Quebec Saturday Budget. It it not likely that they will be ever witnessed again in the vast numbers of former years. Many of our citizens, who are still on the bright side of half a century, will readily recall when they were so plentiful in this district that they sold 11 the city markets as low as I2J4 cents a dozen, while others, whose mem ories carry them back still further, will remember when their flights were so great as to almost darken the sky and when the divine intercession was frequently implored to save the grow ing crops from their destructiveness.

See moreSee less

On all sides they were shot and trap ped without mercy and, being exceed ingly game as well as toothsome birds, pigeon-hunting was a favorite sport all over the country and contributed largely to the food supply of the peo ple. But their numbers did not seem to very greatly diminish until almost suddenly in the latter sixties or early seventies they disappeared altogether from the settled parts of the United States and Canada. What became of them: All sorts of more or less color able theories have been imagined to account for that disappearance, but it has never yet been satisfactorily ex plained. The fact, however, that they are now reappearing is much more im portant at present and will be hailed with much joy both by Canadian and American sportsmen. O11 the subject, there is apparently little room for doubt, as the news comes from dif ferent quarters and from good sources. Among others, for instance, the New York "Sun" says:— Reports from the forest dwellers of Catskills in the townships of Denning and Hardenburgh, in Ulster county, in this State, say that considerable numbers of wild blue wood pigeons are returning to that locality. The forest in those townships thir ty years ago sheltered millions of these birds, which lived 011 the beech nuts, of which there were large quan tities. Among about 1873 the pigeons suddenly abandoned this county, and since then until this spring there had been hardly a pigeon seen in the Cat skills. During the summers ofand 1873 iS".} there were such immense flights of pigeons in this locality as to ob scure the still as with a cloud at noon-1 flay. The next summer they were gone, and nobody could tell whither. It is believed that the severe winter just past has driven the pigeons from their nesting and roosting grounds in the far northern Canadian woods to a new breeding ground further south, and that some of the flocks have tak-

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

The item claims passenger pigeons have taken up residence in the dense wilderness woods of an unspecified Minnesota county, with sportsmen welcoming the news. It states the birds will now be protected as game, noting that earlier reckless netting and slaughter in the 1860s-70s had driven them away, though food was never scarce.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Irish Standard · 21 May 1904 · page 2

I N N E A O I S cn tip their home in the almost im penetrable woods of the wilderness of this county. This is cheering news to the sportsmen, as the pigeons will never be slaughtered here again by netting by pothunters as they were years ago. The remorseless manner *md the means of slaughter in the later six ties and early seventies no doubt helped to drive the pigeons away, as there has never been any lack of food. They will be protected now along with the other game.

See moreSee less

Praise for Irish Christian Brothers. It would be impossible to imagine a more flattering testimonial Jo the effi ciency oi the Christian Brothers' .schools in this country than the refer ences made to them at the Protestant Synod last week says the Dublin Irish Catholic. Speaker after speaker bore witness to the noble work of the schools, and admitted their vast sup eriority over the schools under the management of the Protestants. Thus the Bishop of Killaloc remarked "that the monastic orders of the Catholic Church had established schools every where. The Christian Brothers' schools in Cork last year earned con siderably more than one thousand pounds, and they were earning all this over all the country, because they had mm*

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The report describes President Theodore Roosevelt's extensive collection of birds sent to the Smithsonian Institution, including specimens of hawks, herons, and waterfowl gathered through correspondence with collectors worldwide. Among the most scientifically valued items is a carefully preserved passenger pigeon, described as belonging to a species now almost extinct.

The Washington Times · 22 May 1904 · page 31

Probably the bird most valued even to this day from a scientific standpoint, is the specimen of the now almost ex tinct carrier-pigeon. This pigeon is so beautifully mounted that has been so carefully kept all these twenty and more Years, that it is as fresh today as when young Theodore Roosevelt selected and prepared it for study.

See the clipping