As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

June 1901

5 articles

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The Macon Telegraph reprints a Richmond Dispatch piece recalling the once-vast flocks of wild pigeons and quoting old accounts of their overwhelming numbers. It then cites the Charleston News and Courier's claim that their disappearance is easily explained by a mysterious affliction that also swept away other bird species, dismissing deeper investigation as unnecessary.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 2 June 1901 · page 3

A Shot Gun Solution

:■';:'- -v^Y" •-.-.:- - ; - .• ;: :: -;--?"<, ■<- r ??!Ziirz&> 'i.-:"i ":■->'■ ■ VA; Sliot ' Gun. Solution. t <* i-^yV (Macon Telegraph.) • ' " Tha Richmond Dispatch recalls .wlthftaV-^ . sigh -"tha wild pigeons . which " one© .filled

See the clipping

Ottumwa Semi-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

This piece argues for a shift in hunting culture from trophy-taking to conservation, crediting sportsmen's leagues and Audubon Societies with pushing protective legislation despite early congressional mockery. It cites the passenger pigeon as already extinct, alongside dwindling prairie chicken and waterfowl populations, as evidence of the urgent need for bird and game protection.

Ottumwa Semi-Weekly Courier · 4 June 1901 · page 7

The legislatures of the various states are now awake to the necessity game from extinction. The wild pigeon find that bones of the reindeer, cave Our ancestors were all killers. In

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The newspaper responds to critics who blamed pot-hunters and sportsmen for the disappearance of wild pigeons, rejecting this explanation as the sole cause. It argues by analogy that other heavily-hunted birds like sora and partridge have not seen similar population declines, suggesting some other mysterious natural cause is at work.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Richmond Dispatch, 26 May 1901, Richmond Dispatch, 2 June 1901.

Richmond Dispatch · 4 June 1901 · page 4

WILD PIGEOXS, AGAIX. In a recent article on '"Birds. and Their Habits" we incidentally alluded to the ■ wild pigeons which formerly flocked by thousands to Virginia, and ventured the assertion that their disappearance in late years is "one of the dozens of mysteries which ornithology presents." . ~ Several of our contemporaries say that there is no mystery at all about the non appearance of .the wild" pigeons, and un hesitatingly attribute the abse'nee of these birds to pot-hunters and sportsmen, who formerly slaughtered them in great num bers. ■ , For.; our Part, we are more.

See moreSee less

than willing for the shotgun; to receive; its share or odium— the -more the better, we say, in fact— but we are not prepared to stand corrected in this matter. The same fallacious reasoning which attempts. to explain the absence* of the pigeons overlooks the annual visitations of millions of sora which , flock to our marshes at certain seasons. These strange little birds' are killed by the. ton 1 with guns, sticks, and what not: yet there ia no apparent diminutionin their numbers. Tear by year and decade by decade they mysteriously appear in certain months, and despite the /pitiless war /waged againstthem, tarry with us until the voice of Nature, speaking through, their instinct, "summons them to other climes. Their movements and the reasons which prompt: their migrations leave man en tirely but of the question. . " -So, too, our mottied little friend, the' partridge, lingers constantly with us, de spite the; cruel treatment" accorded hinl at times by sportsmen. In the summer, when nesting, "he is almost confidential., and conies quite near our. rural habitations to whistle the story of his domestic. felicity.. When autumn sears the meadow lands and the; forests blush^-possibly at the rapacity, and/ selfishness of . man— he grows shy, andthe; instinct.of self-pre-; servation makes / him /'. 'cautious. But through all his vicissitudes he is with us the year'round. and -eveh'the hosts of his enemies cannot. quite exterminate him. Xow why, we ask, do trie partridges and the sora— two most toothsome birds— still survive when the -wild pigeon has practi .oally disappeared from our woodlands? The arguments which apply to one should apply to the others— indeed, the wonder is that poor little. "Bob" White" .can. "live!. to whistle a single note when he is so beset by his pursuers. j Our critical contemporaries should -bear I in mind, too/ -that: we quoted Rev. Gilbert | White, the eminent English ornithologist j I who wrote "of : British; birds about the j

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

A new Nebraska game law taking effect July 1 sets hunting seasons for various game, including wild pigeons, doves, and plover from April 15 to October 30. The law limits kill numbers, bans game on restaurant menus out of season, and prohibits shipping game out of state.

The Frontier · 20 June 1901 · page 5

New Game Law. Tbe new game law goes into effect j July 1 ami copies Imve been generally ] distributed throughout the state by the chief depute game warden, George B. Simpkins of Lincoln. Under tbe terms of the law the open season for prairie chickens ami grouse is from October 1 to November 30; for ducks and other fowl, from September 1 to April 15; for wild pigeons, doves and plover, from April 15 to Octotier 30. The amount of game which may tie Killed according to tbe law during the open season is limited to ten geese or braids and twenty-five birds of any other variety.

See moreSee less

The season for flsbiug under the act is from April 1 to October 31, except for trout, the open season for which begins June 1 and ends October 31. Restaurant and hotels are prohibited from placing on their tables any of the game potected by the act except iu the open season, and severe penalties are provided for violations of the provisions of the law. The placing of the names of the fish or game on the menu shall be taken as prima facie evidence of the un lawful possession of game by the pro prietor of the house. Railroads and other carriers are pro hibited from shipping game from tbe state under any circumstances.

See the clipping

Decorah Public Opinion · Decorah, Iowa

The item disputes recent newspaper reports of passenger pigeon flocks seen in the west, arguing observers likely confused golden plovers with the pigeons due to similar erratic flight patterns. It asserts that wild passenger pigeons are doubtfully present anywhere north or south of Kentucky at this point.

Decorah Public Opinion · 26 June 1901 · page 3

Mistaken the Birds. We note several references in the papers of the west to flocks of pas senger pigeons being seen at vari ous points. We think that the ob servers in these eases were mistaker in the identy of the birds and that what they thought were wild pig eons were the golden plover, a bird which has the same irregular line of flight us the pigeon. It is doubt ful if there is a single flock of wild pigeons left north of Kentucky, and almost equally doubtful if there art any south of that line.

See the clipping