As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

March 1898

8 articles

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

This brief item observes that wild animals are vanishing faster than people realize, citing the buffalo as nearly extinct and the once-abundant wild pigeon as now forgotten. It warns that soon the only wild animals left may be rats, mice, and bugs, with birds confined to poultry houses.

The Evening Times · 3 March 1898 · page 5

A QUEER WORLD

(From flie Pittsburg Times.) The ild animals jre going more rapidly than is generally upoeil. The buffalo ii nearly ex tinct. The wild pigeon, once mi abundant that the bird"? came in clouds that darKrtied the sky. is forgotten. The ong spjrtow, the thrush and mejdow lark jml a dozen other Fniall creatures are known to the children amply as bird, .ind not well known at that. Wlut a queer u;J it will lie -when tlie only iild aninialo anj Tats. mice and Img. and the birds are CQnSried tt the, poultry houses. Rat we are tending that way, ami do fast tlutt it is almo-t tlie reso now in some sections.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

A House committee favorably reports Congressman Lacey's bill to protect and propagate game and song birds, citing the near-total extermination of the wild pigeon as a cautionary example. The report argues federal involvement will help build public sentiment needed for effective bird protection laws.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 3 March 1898 · page 2

FAVORABLY REPORTED. The bill Introduced by Congressman Laoey some times ago, to protect and propagate game and song birds has been favorable reported by the commit tee in tie house. The report compli ments the bill very highly and says among other things: Birds introduced by the National is believed,would be pro tected by quite a different state of pubHe opinion from that which has prevail ed as to birds introduced by private in uivtduals or shooting elubs. The wild pigeon, once so abundant, has been

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

A congressional committee report on Congressman Lacey's bird protection bill notes that the wild pigeon, once abundant, has been practically if not totally exterminated. The report uses this as a cautionary example while recommending passage of the bill to protect other threatened species.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 3 March 1898 · page 3

FAVORABLY REPORTED. The bill lntrodaoed by Congressman Lsoey tome times ego, to protect and propagate game and song birds has been favorable reported by the oommlt tee In the honse. The report compli ments the bill very highly and says among other things: Birds introduced by the National Governmental is believed,would be pro tected by quite a different state of pub* lie opinion from that which has prevail ed as to birds lntrodaoed by private in dlvidaals or shooting dabs. The wild pigeon, onoe so abundant, has been practically If not totally exterminated,

See the clipping

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va. · and 1 other paper

The report recounts an eyewitness account of mass pigeon slaughter and scavenging by wolves, foxes, and other animals, then shifts to discussing theories about the species' disappearance. It cites a Mr. Waterloo who speculates the birds may have relocated to uninhabited regions of South America rather than being extinct.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

The Webster Echo · 4 March 1898 · page 6

LIKE THE BUFFALO IX HAS ALMOST DISAPPEARED FROM VIEW. Coantle** Number* In Various Parts o! tl»e Country—The Old "Pigeon Roo*iH ! IVai a Wonderful Exhibition—'Tlie Wai i of Extermination That Was Waged. | In Recreation, a sportsman’s maga zine, Mr. Stanley Waterloo propound; an interesting query and goes as fai toward answering it as lie can. H« wants to know wliat has become of th( passenger pigeon—commonly called , “wild pigeon” — which within thf memory of middle-aged men existed* in North America in billions, and has almost utterly disappeared. The fate of this bird, says H.

See moreSee less

H. Canfield in the Chicago Times-Herald, is strangely similar to the fate of the buffalo. Both were here in countless swarms and both were wiped out by the waves ol civilization because they were easily approached and slain. Nature, how ever, generally has its balances, Anybody could kill wild pigeons by the car load where they were plenti ful, but the bird was gifted with an instinct which warned it to forsake a country wherein it was ruthlessly slaughtered. This it has done repeat, edly since the settlement of America. It was formerly abundant in New York, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and other States of the Atlantic seaboard. There the work of extermination be gan. The bird crossed the Alle ghenies, never to return, and made its “roosts” in Michigan, Wisconsin and neighboring territories. Still insane ly pursued with destruction, it moved further west and south. It,would not cross the Rockies, and the last “roost” of the old gigantic size of which we have any record was made in Indian Territory. When this was broken up the bird disappeared from the United States. This was twenty years ago. The dead pigeons were shipped through the country in car load lots and sold in (he St. Iionis market at twenty-five cents a dozen. The old “pigeon roost” was a won derful thing. When the’birds came in at night the beating of their wings was like the roar of the league-long rollei thundering on the strand. Branches snapped under their weight. Potter ing about under the trees were foxes, wolves and other small animals of prey feeding upon the'squabs which weri jostled from the nests. Describing i “roost” in Kentucky, Audubon says! ; “When they passed above my head 1 felt a eurreut of air which astonished ! me. Thousands were already struct down by men armed with poles, but | they continued to arrive without inter j mission. mres were ligntea. Tht birds precipitated themselves in massei and ^pitched where they could, om upon the pther, in large heaps like bar' rels. Then the branches gave waj under their weight, cracked and fell bringing to the ground and crushing the closely packed flocks which cow ered every part of the trees. In vain I tried to speak, or even to call th« person nearest me. It.was with diffi culty 1 could hear the guns tired. The uproar continued all night. At sum rise all that could fly had disappeared Now it was the wolf's turn, the howls of which saluted our ears. Poxes, lynxes, cougars, bears, rats, opossums and martens, bounding, running, climbing, pressed to the quarry, while eagles and falcons of different species Hew down to take part of such rich booty. The pigeons were piled in heaps. Each took what he wished and the pigs were left to satiate themselves on the remainder.” Even after the great slaughter in Indian Territory millions of pigeons were left. They came no more to this country. In the course of an in quiry that has extended over many years, Mr. Waterloo has discovered that they have come back to the United States iu small bunches and then, revisiting their old haunts in the Middle States in a “pitiful seeking way, ’ as late as four or five years ago. Air. Edward B. Clarke, a Chicago naturalist, saw one in Lin coln Park i':kiir years ago. Two years ago somle hunters on the Illi nois River found at flock of a dozen and shot a eWk and hen. Other small groups h|yve been seen in Mis souri and India n Territory. A flock of fourteen now resists in Wisconsin. It escaped from ^confinement in Mil waukee last wintfer. The millions of surviving passenger pigeons have gone somewhere, but where? Mr. Waterloo inclines to the belief that Soutllf America is their present habitat, t He says: “With the instinct of knowing when a terri tory had become! uninhabitable, it decided to return uo more to the United States. What then became of tt?»*Is it not now annually flying southward and* making its great roosts iu the vast wild region forming tl)e central part of South America, 1 having for its food the nuts and rries of the vegetation lying between : Andes and the peopled area along Atlantic coast? This is a portion lie problem yet unsolved. It is a 1 extreme difficulty to reach or to find in any way intelli ei vers in any portion of tha er which, in theory, the pas geon may now be flying." the passenger pigeon? This of„ oh interest to the ,1 interest, iu fact, l in out

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The True Democrat · Bayou Sara, La. · 29 January 1898

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A Kansas City Journal item reports that wild pigeons, once filling southwest Missouri's woods from October to January, no longer appear with the mast season. It recalls huge flocks and mass slaughter at a roost near Hopewell church about 24 years earlier, the last significant roost in the area.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 10 March 1898 · page 2

DESERTED BY WILD PIGEONS

Dliappramncr or IMrda Wtiicb I wed to Klork In Mhaourl Wooda. ! The wild pigecn no longer visits southwest Mussouri with tile return of tbe mast season, as formerly, report* , tbe Kansas City Journal. Years a^o the woods of the Ozark region were full of these birds from October to Janu ary. A pigeon roost was the wonder and delight of tlhe pioneer hunter. Mil lions of the birds would gather in ecme ( thick forest at the approach of night. From all directions and for miles away dense flocks of pigeons could be teen fly ing toward the roost.

See moreSee less

The unerring instinct of the birds guided them to the place, and by sundown tbe flutter of countless wings founded like an np ' proaching storm in the vicinity of the roost. Hunters killed the birds by th< । thousands, for in a roost r.o skill was required to shoot pigeons. A shotgun fired into any tree or bush at random i never failed to bringdown game. The ■ ground waa often nearly covered with . dead and wounded birds after a volley had been fired into a tree loaded down with pigeons. Hogs fattened on the crippled birds left In the woods, and bawka. owU, f&cicu nnd other wild ani mala bad a continual feast. The lasi pigeon roust of any Importance near Springfield was not far from Hopewell church, south of the James river, about 24 ^ears ago. The birds occupied a thick oak fore*! covering several acres, and remained three or four weeks.

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · and 1 other paper

A general interest piece reflects on the rapid decline of wild animals in America, noting the passenger pigeon—once so abundant it darkened the sky—is now largely forgotten. The author warns that buffalo, songbirds, and other wildlife are vanishing at an alarming rate.

Watertown Republican · 16 March 1898 · page 2

Milwaukee, photo articles, etc., trade mark’ Racine Knitting Cos., Racine, hosiery. A Queer World. The wild animals are going more rapid ly than is generally supposed. The buf falo is nearly extinct. The wild pigeon, once so abundant that the birds came iu, clouds that darkened the sky, is lorgot-i ten. The song sparrow, the thrush and! meadow lark and a dozen other small creatures are known to the children simply as birds, and not well known at! that. What a queer world it will bei when the only wild animals are rats, mice and bugs, and the birds are confined to the poultry houses. But we are tend ing that way, and so fast that it is al most the case now in some sections.—

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Virginia Enterprise · Virginia, Minn. · 25 March 1898

The Banner-Democrat · Lake Providence, La. · and 2 other papers

After recalling a massive historic slaughter in Indian Territory, the report describes Mr. Waterloo's years-long inquiry into scattered pigeon sightings in the Middle States and Wisconsin during the 1890s. He theorizes the surviving millions of passenger pigeons relocated to a remote region of South America rather than having been exterminated.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 97 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 15 days earlier.

Wrong

The Banner-Democrat · 19 March 1898 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIKE THE BUFFALO IT HAS ALMOST DISAPPEARED FROM VIEW.

Countless Numbers In Various Parts of the Country--The Old "Pigeon Roost" Was a Wonderful Exhibition--The War of Extermination That Was Waged.

See moreSee less

In Recreation, a sportsman's magazine, Mr. Stanley Waterloo propounds an interesting query and goes as far toward answering it as he can. He wants to know what has become of the passenger pigeon--commonly called "wild pigeon"--which within the memory of middle-aged men existed in North America in billions, and has almost utterly disappeared. The fate of this bird, says H. S. Canfield in the Chicago Times-Herald, is strangely similar to the fate of the buffalo. Both were here in countless swarms and both were wiped out by the waves of civilization because they were easily approached and slain. Nature, however, generally has its balances. Anybody could kill wild pigeons by the car load where they were plentiful, but the bird was gifted with an instinct which warned it to forsake a country wherein it was ruthlessly slaughtered. This it has done repeatedly since the settlement of America.

It was formerly abundant in New York, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and other States of the Atlantic seaboard. There the work of extermination began. The bird crossed the Alleghenies, never to return, and made its "roosts" in Michigan, Wisconsin and neighboring territories. Still insanely pursued with destruction, it moved further west and south. It would not cross the Rockies, and the last "roost" of the old gigantic size of which we have any record was made in Indian Territory. When this was broken up the bird disappeared from the United States. This was twenty years ago. The dead pigeons were shipped through the country in car load lots and sold in the St. Louis market at twenty-five cents a dozen.

The old "pigeon roost" was a wonderful thing. When the birds came in at night the beating of their wings was like the roar of the league-long roller thundering on the strand. Branches snapped under their weight. Pottering about under the trees were foxes, wolves and other small animals of prey feeding upon the squabs which were jostled from the nests. Describing a "roost" in Kentucky, Audubon says: "When they passed above my head I felt a current of air which astonished me. Thousands were already struck down by men armed with poles, but they continued to arrive without intermission. Fires were lighted. The birds precipitated themselves in masses and pitched where they could, one upon the other, in large heaps like barrels. Then the branches gave way under their weight, cracked and fell, bringing to the ground and crushing the closely packed flocks which covered every part of the trees. In vain I tried to speak, or even to call the person nearest me. It was with difficulty I could hear the guns fired. The uproar continued all night. At sunrise all that could fly had disappeared. Now it was the wolf's turn, the howls of which saluted our ears. Foxes, lynxes, cougars, bears, rats, opossums and martens, bounding, running, climbing, pressed to the quarry, while eagles and falcons of different species flew down to take part of such rich booty. The pigeons were piled in heaps. Each took what he wished and the pigs were left to satiate themselves on the remainder."

Even after the great slaughter in Indian Territory millions of pigeons were left. They came no more to this country. In the course of an inquiry that has extended over many years, Mr. Waterloo has discovered that they have come back to the United States in small bunches now and then, revisiting their old haunts in the Middle States in a "pitiful seeking way," as late as four or five years ago. Mr. Edward B. Clarke, a Chicago naturalist, saw one in Lincoln Park four years ago. Two years ago some hunters on the Illinois River found a flock of a dozen and shot a cock and hen. Other

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The True Democrat · Bayou Sara, La. · 29 January 1898
  • The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va. · 4 March 1898

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

A syndicated commentary piece observes that American wildlife is disappearing rapidly, noting the buffalo is nearly extinct and the once-abundant wild pigeon, which formerly darkened the sky in great flocks, is now largely forgotten. It muses that soon only rats, mice, bugs, and penned poultry will remain as familiar creatures to children.

The Superior Times · 19 March 1898 · page 4

A QUEER WORLD

The wiM animals an* going more rapid * than is generally suppose,!. The bnf talo is marly * Mini t. The wild pigeon, on**** so abundant that th • birds * anm in ■■'■■■'ids itiiit darkened the sky, is f.irgot i - sM'tti row . the' ■ finish and 1 a dozen *-tii. r small •Teatun - anknown to the children I simply is bil ls, and not well known at that. What a ipii* r world it will be! w hi'ii the only wild animals are rats, mice ■mi bugs, and the bin's are confined to the poultry heus* s. But w*• are t.-ml ng that way. and s*. lost that it is al ■ ■ now in some ; (ious.— Pittsburg Times.

See the clipping