As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1897

15 articles

Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah

A writer recalls wild pigeons once so abundant they darkened the sky and broke tree limbs, and wonders what became of them. He then recounts finding references to immense pigeon flocks in Chihuahua, Mexico, suggesting this may explain their disappearance from the US.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

Deseret Evening News · 1 November 1897 · page 6

0 1 Wild Pigeons Great Forests Sandy Deserts dlendant In I crlmill eOosol0014 innke too 8104201 requited 4 In the low 10 JS32 1 HEANDERINGS IN MEXICO 1 I and the Apache Kid I 10 a lung lmo I huyeeoodebd

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Smithsonian Institution reports it could not obtain a single live specimen of the wild passenger pigeon despite offering a reward and extensive correspondence. The piece recalls the species' former overwhelming abundance, citing Audubon's famous estimate of over 500 million birds in a single flight.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 51 days earlier.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 November 1897 · page 9

FRUITLESS SEARCH FOR A LIVB SPECIMEN OF THE WILD PIGEON. Time Was, and Not Long Ago, When the Autumn Atr Was Filled by Countless Millions of These Bird*. The announcement is made by the Smith sonian Institution that it has been impos sible to obtain a single live specimen of the wild, or Passenger pigeon. Notwith standing a liberal reward was offere-d by the institution and much correspondence carried on, no live wild pigeon has been brought forward. That this native American bird is ex tinct will no doubt astonish many persons, for it has been but a few years ago that they were so plentiful as to actually seem to outnumber the leaves on the trees through, which they drove their amazingly rapid flight.

See moreSee less

Persons yet in middle life can remember the vast flights of pigeons which could be seen any day in the fall after the middle of October and all through Novem ber. Sometimes these flights stretched across the sky from horizon to horizon, and so dense that the sun was hid for hours at a time from the eyes of the beholder. Audo bon, the great ornithologist, observed a flight of pigeons in Kentucky that extended as far as the eye could see and was more than five hours in passing. He attempted to compute the number of individual birds in the flight, and found that beyond ques tion there was more than five hundred mil lion. Further than this, he estimated thera could not have been less than this number in the smaller and detached flights wTiieh were passing to the north in great num bers early in the day, flying very swiftly and unusually high. These first flights, ap peared to be the vanguard of an immensa army patrolling the blue field of heaven, unheralded by banner or bugle, yet posses sing the dignity and confidence of over whelming numbers. He observed with the utmost wonder that the number of flights visible early in the day increased and multi plied until the earth was canopied with the feathered hosts, and that when the main body of the rank and file had passed there were yet detached regiments to cov er the rear of the fleeing army. The strag glers continued to pass until darkness ren dered them invisible. This wonderful flight is well authenticated, not alone by Audo bon, which would have been sufficient, but by many persons who were living in the territory the birds flew over. This portion of Indiana never witnessed such a flight as that, but every year tha birds flew in numbers utterly beyond count ing. During the latter part of October and during November the birds passed from their summer homes in the Northern for ests to the mild climate of the South, and selected that portion of the country for their home where their natural food wa most plentiful. The feeding ground of the birds was not restricted to a few square miles, but so numerous were they and so great the quantity of food they consumed that hundreds of square miles were re quired for their roosts and several States drawn upon to furnish their food.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes the enormous scale of passenger pigeon flocks, citing Audubon and local witnesses to their historic migrations. It details the deafening chaos of pigeon roosts, where birds broke branches, fell to earth, and were preyed upon by swine, while also describing mating devotion and the social hierarchy among the birds.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 November 1897 · page 9

A SCENE OF CONFUSION. A pigeon roost was a place where confu sion worse confounded reigned supreme. Towards evening, when the foraging party returned to Its nightly resting place, th*

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes passenger pigeon social behavior at roosts, including long foraging flights by males and aggression toward idle birds. It then details a commercial night-hunting operation from decades earlier near Connersville, Indiana, where men used torches and clubs to kill and capture roosting birds for shipment in barrels.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 November 1897 · page 9

Always about a pigeon roost were many birds, usually males, who evidently believed that “they also serve who only stand and wait.” Those birds were to the pigeon roost what the drones are to the hives, and reaped only some other pigeon’s sowing. These birds were evidently despised by tha workers, for when the demands for food became too aggressive they were set upon by a mob of pigeons and remorselessly lynched. The usefulness of these idlers ha* never been discovered, and as the family relations of pigepn life were known to ex ist, it is surmised that they were the dude* of pigeon civilization.

See moreSee less

In the neighborhood of Connersville, in tha southeastern part of this State, there was, some thirty years ago, an immense wooda which every fall, as the pigeons went south,

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The report states that Smithsonian Institution authorities have declared the passenger pigeon extinct, recalling how the birds once flew in flocks so vast they blocked out sunlight. It reflects on the mystery of their disappearance and draws a lesson for protecting native bird species.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 November 1897 · page 4

EXTINCTION OF BIRD SPECIES

breeding purposes otherwise they will I soon be a thing of the past I But the annihilation of the passenger I I pigeons how shall that be accounted for It seems impossible that they I should all have been destroyed by manI

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This 1897 editorial laments that the passenger pigeon has become extinct, questioning how such abundance could be wiped out and attributing it to human destruction. It calls for stronger protection of native bird species before they suffer the same fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 November 1897 · page 4

EXTINCTION OF BIRD SPECIES

j result in all our native birds being I are May it never be said of any other held In the same regard as the gulls American bird as it is said of the pas I senger pigeon = it has become extinct

See the clipping

The Emmett Index · Emmett, Idaho

A short filler item states that a large flock of wild pigeons has taken possession of a grove in Shasta County, California. No further detail or context is given.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Indianapolis Journal, 7 November 1897, The Salt Lake Herald, 10 November 1897, The Salt Lake Herald, 10 November 1897.

The Emmett Index · 12 November 1897 · page 3

cell botes, the 900 or 1,000 epileptic <'" tie " t " wl, ° wer *. • oatt * rH " bont in almshouses, in asylums for the insane ... , j . j. . , . or feeble-minded, and indigent private homes. In none of these places were . they securing proper or «'orative treat ment —I. Morris, in N. V. Sun. A 16-Inch gun casting was ma«le at the Bethlehem Iron Works on August It is intemie«! for the tube of a 16j 12. inch gun now being built for the govi eminent, anil is 19 feet 6 inches long, >*« a lf'>" al >'> 74 inches In diameter.

See moreSee less

M«»re than 100 tons of metal r wefe ufe ,| j„ ,|, e cai ,,j DKj [he first and » the largest of its kind ever ma«le in litis country. A large flock of wild pigeons has taken lessees ion of a grave in Shasta j county, California.

See the clipping

The Banner-Democrat · Lake Providence, La.

A report describes doves nesting in icehouses along the Penobscot River near Bangor, Maine, noting their rapid multiplication and comparing their nesting habits to those of the now 'practically extinct' wild passenger pigeon. The piece includes folklore about doves and a century-old rhyme predicting miraculous events when doves nest in trees.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Banner-Democrat · 13 November 1897 · page 4

ten of peodle, antdso forttt, Irom the re' t bak tunrs of this tax it ilearned tha everal there are 9,0,0U0 dogs in Frenee t wia i brisg inb a zIea lual brme reindeer. It requires about eight a cows to support a family, four being ,t milked in the summer and two in the winter. The cattle are very small in Lt size, and are fed on hay in the winter. Occasionally they are allowed to go k out when there is the slightest break in the weather, but their teats are aldevis ways carefully covered up.

See moreSee less

Milk is be ri the principal food. This is supplepoint 1mented with hares, which are quite man abundant, but not very relishable. streti ly The houses are constructed of wood, - covered with clay, and as a rule con a sist of only one room, in which the ie people and animals live together. The ie o upper and wealthier classes are better s provided with lodging and food. As a arace they are exceedingly courteous and very hospitable, and they are ex cessively punctilious concerning points of honor, such as the place at the is s table and the proper place as festivals. s Doves Growing Vise. es The doves which make their homes he in the icehouses on the Penobscot ad river, below Bangor, have multiplied by t to so rapidly this summer that they have sists n. been obliged to swarm and go outside ring gg to build their nests. Most of them this ).. went to barns and farm sheds, though very ,he as well. ea good number are building among the as v ar forked limbs of the red oaks, which grow near the shore. The nests are crude affairs, made of sticks and mud, en and are generally put up in groups of ier four and five. In general appearance eg they bear a close resemblance to the nests of the wild pigeons, which were s, very plentiful fifty years ago. The domestic dove is far ahead of the wild pigeon in matters of thrift ee as and fecundity. The pigeons reared to from three to four broods of two each s the in a season and always moved to new ors nesting grounds as soon as the young be

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report relays a circulating claim that the Smithsonian Institution offered a reward for a wild passenger pigeon but could not obtain a single specimen, despite extensive correspondence. The writer questions whether the bird is truly extinct, recalling its former vast flocks and reckless slaughter.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 15 November 1897 · page 4

AIM rUISY AT I. HOVE? The surprising statement is going the rounds that the announcement is made by the Smithsonian Institute that it has been impossible to obtain a single specimen of the wild or passenger pigeon. Notwithstanding a liberal re ward was offered by the Institution and much correspondence carried on, no live wild pigeon has been brought forward. Can this be true? Is it possible that this beautiful native American bird is extinct or so near it that one cannot be readily obtained for a liberal re ward? People who are not yet old can remember when there were such large flocks of them in tho air as to obscure the light of the sun.

See moreSee less

Hunters yet alive and hunting tell of catching them by hundreds in nets, shooting them until tired and knocking them off their roost ing places in heaps. Are they gone the way of the dodo and the great auk? It doesn't seem possible, and we hope it isn't. They were ruthlessly slaugh tered when they were numerous, and the remnants of their vast tribes haven't had any protection, as the In dians and the buffaloes have. But it will be astonishing if they are all gone? Can anybody in Connecticut produce a wild pigeon, dead or alive?

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report notes that Maine residents who recall vast flocks of wild pigeons darkening the sky will be surprised by the Smithsonian Institution's announcement that the bird is extinct. It adds that a reward offered last year for a single specimen went unclaimed, and warns that other wild birds may face similar fates without public action.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 November 1897 · page 6

Three strong articles in the North American Review for November arc j "The Life of Tennyson." Edmund Gosse; "Thirty Years of American Trade,” M. G. Mulaall. ai l A Review of the Cuban Question?" by Hon. Hau nts Taylor. Other valuable l apers are j "The Commercial Value of the Ship yard,” "Effect of the New Gold Upon Prices.” "The United States and the Spanish-American Colonies," "Leprosy and Hawaiian Annexation," and "Woman’s Political Evolution." The department of “Notes and Comments" contains several excellent short ar ticles. The Engineering Review. "The Effects of Trade Unionism Upon Skilled Mechanics,” "Futuie Supremacy in the Iron Markets of the World," "Modern Wharf Improve ments and Harbor Facilities."

See moreSee less

"Cost Keeping Methods in Machine Shop and Foundry,” "The American Tail Build ing From a European Point of View." "The Enormous Possibilities of Rapid Electric Travel,” “The Growing Im portance of Cement in Constructive Work,” “Iron-Ore Loading on the American Great Lakes,” and "English Goods Staitions and Railway Yards" are the subjects treated at length in the November number of the Engineer ing Magaklne. These articles in con nection with the many carefully edited departments make up an important number. Tht Humanitarian. In the opening article of the Novem ber Humanitarian Camille Flammarion considers that much discussed ques tion "Is Mars Inhabited?” and arrives at some interesting conclusions. Among the subjects treated at some length in this number ore “The Har vests of the Sands,” "The Practical TTse of Folk Lore,” “Tennyson as a Humanitarian,” "The Greek Satirist on Women.” “A Question in Heredity," "The Philosophy of Drink,” "The De pendent Sex,” and “An Optimist's View of the Seven Ages of Man.” Residents of Maine who can remember when the wild pigeons sometimes came in flocks dense enough to almost obscure the sun. will hear with surprise the announce ment of the Smithsonian institution that this bird' is extinct. Although a liberal reward was offered by the institution last year, for a single specimen of the bird, not one was brought forward. And there are those who predict that other wild birds will follow the pigeon into oblivion unless public sentiment is aroused to the danger before many more years. Even in the most severe cases of sprain or bruise, cut or burn. Thomas' EcleetrCc Oil gives almost instant relief. It is the ideal family liniment, man.wed fri&wky .When you are suffering from Catarrh or Cold In the head you Want relief right away. Only 10 cents is required to test'It. Ask your druggist for the trial size.of Ely’s Cream"Balm, or buy the 60c. size. We mail it. ELY BROS., 66 Warren St., N. Y. City. I was afflicted with catarrh last au tumn. During the month of October I could neither taste nor smell ai’.d could hear but little. Ely’s Cream Balm cured It.—Marcus Geo. Shautz, Rahway, JJ. J. For the cure of Alcoholic, Morphine and other drug addictions attend the Maine Keeley Institute at 151 Congress St., Portland, Maine.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The article reports a claim of 75-100 wild pigeons seen in Nebraska, noting old trappers' hope that the birds merely shifted routes rather than vanished. The author, Ed W. Sandys, argues this hope is mistaken, sharing memories of dwindling flocks in the 1880s-90s as evidence the species was being destroyed, not hiding.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Providence News · 20 November 1897 · page 12

Wild Pigeons In Nebraska

% e —— e Presideant Poweras of the Bastern League of Baseball Clubs has returned | the Steinert cup to its owner, | roomy but rather hard bunks, an early call and a cup of black coffee brought us on deck with the first gray of the morning. Then our_attention was at. tracted to a shore sloop towing the car cass ol a 4 dead horge down past the light ship. This was carefully anchored about b 0 yvards from us, and the little gloop filled away and got out of range, and we were drawn up behind bulwarks watching for an opportunity to get in the first shot, After waiting for some time we were called to attention by a remark, ‘There's one!” from the major, and we saw the kuifelike fin cutting through the water in the vicinity of our decoy and knew from the size of it that there was an unusually large shark un derneath it, It sailed carefally around the bait and was foon joined by another and yet another, and in the coursge of 15 minutes the outlines of at least a dozen of the tigers of the deep could he geen circling round us as though afraid to make an attack.

See moreSee less

We were all anxious for a shot, but were restrained by the major, unti! finally one fish, bolder than the rest, gave a quick turn over on his back, made a rush at the hofse and was soon tugging at the side of the dead an imal. "Every (ime you see a flash of white it's the belly of & shark, Shoot at it! gald the major, and we did, until the bow of the old lightship almost disap peared in smoke, “The major was shooting an old fash foned martini rifie, with a long bottle cartridge, one of the Kind that will kick yon over and kick at you after vou are down. Wherever a bullet would strike a shark a thin red streak would indi. cate the spot, and 1t was a very short time before the monsters became so en raged with the sgight of their own blood that they began tearing at each other like a pack of wolves, and the water immediately around our bait was liter ally boiling with struggling fish. This was kept up for over an hour, when we hecame tired of shooting at the seething mass as well ag short of ammunition, It was doubtfa! whether any gingle ghot killed a sharl, Dut our fusillade caused a terrific battfe, and many were slain.” Wild Pigeons In Nebraska. A recent report from Nebraska stated that a flock of from 75 to 100 wild, or passcenger, pigeons had been seen in that state, This will bhe interesting news to those who remember the birds when they fleWw in countless thousands like dark rivers across the sky during the spring migrations. Some grizzled old trappers, who regularly followed the flight of pigeons and netted them by thousands per week, have for vears zone on hoping against hope that the flights of pigeods had merely been di verted from the old routes and that the birds would some day reappear in all their former n@embers. This idea of course is erroneous. The pigeons are not haunting inaccessible sections of the country. The¥ have been destroyed, During the ecarly aatumn of 1887 I shot a lone pigeon, a male of that year, near the city of Eau Cladre, Wis,, and a few days later 1 saw a flock of perhaps 25 birds lving low near where 1 had shot the single one. In March, 1804, while traveling by train fear London, Ont., I saw four pigeons iYlag east, The day was very mild, with & warm rain fall ing, and the pigeons passed in plain view from the car winow. It was just the sort of day we used to deem the best for pigeons in the long ago when one gun could bag more birds than a man could carry.—Ed W. Sandys in Outing.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

A Nebraska state official reports that no wild (passenger) pigeons have been seen in the state in years, recalling when they flew in countless thousands during spring migrations. The article corrects old trappers' hopeful belief that the birds had merely been diverted from their usual routes, stating this idea is erroneous.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Weekly Union · 24 November 1897 · page 11

place of coffee. The more Grain-O ygu give the children the more health you distribute tarough their systems. Grain-O 13 made of pure grains, and when properly preparecd tastes like the choice grades of coffee, but costs about 4 as much, All gtiocers wsell it. 26c. and %¢, . o - : marked to have even suggested it. i s © WILD PIGEONS IN NEBRASKA.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

A writer recounts shooting a lone male passenger pigeon near Eau Claire, Wisconsin in autumn 1887 and spotting a small flock shortly after. He also describes seeing four pigeons flying near London, Ontario in March 1894, noting the weather conditions mirrored ideal pigeon-hunting days of the past.

Weekly Union · 24 November 1897 · page 11

“.. *_‘,,...," S - A o . i v - n money to keep them comfortably for years. country—they have been destroyed. During the early autumn of ’B7 I shot a lone pigeon, a male of that year, near the city of Eau Claire, Wis., and a few days later I saw a flock of perhaps twenty-five birds flying low near where I had shot the singie one. In March, 1894, while traveling by train near Lon don, Ont., I saw four pigeons flying east. The day was very mild, with a warm rain falling, and the pigeons passed in piain view from the car win dow.

See moreSee less

It was just the sort of dayv we used to deem the best for pigeons in the long ago, when one gun could bag more birds than a man could carry.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The item reports that the Smithsonian Institute is offering $100 for a live wild pigeon, noting that the birds have mysteriously vanished with none seen for several years. It recalls that within living memory the timbered regions of eastern and middle states were once full of them.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 25 November 1897 · page 2

—Th« Smithsonian Institute offers •lOOfor a live wild pigeon. For some maaoeeantable reason the wild pigeons have left this ooontry, end eo far as known there have been none of them

See the clipping

The Coeur D'alene Press · Coeur D'alene, Idaho

A newspaper item states that the wild pigeon (passenger pigeon) of the country is asserted to have become extinct, noting the Smithsonian's failed efforts to secure a living specimen. It recalls that middle-aged men remember when the birds existed in vast flocks, making their apparent extermination seem almost unbelievable.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Coeur D'alene Press · 27 November 1897 · page 2

—the worst type of an army officer.— Spokesman Review. It i* asserted that the wild p geon of hi. country has breome extinct. The 8 nithaonian Institution has been en leaioring for a long time to secure a living .pecimeu of the .pecies but have iieen unsuccessful. Middle aged men remember when wild pigeons were found in many of the eastern atttes in

See the clipping