As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

May 1895

5 articles

The Weekly Call · Topeka, Kan.

The passage first discusses cattle breeding, noting the difficulty of combining beef and milk qualities in one animal, citing British versus Jersey/Guernsey breeds. It then shifts to describe claims about pigeon flight speeds, including passenger pigeons allegedly flying 50-90 mph and a famous 1833 Ghent pigeon race where birds seemed to travel nearly 100 mph.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Call · 11 May 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE CARRIER PIGEON.

bove is repro- Review from . It shows a with a mes- case appears egs. a bird larger mon pigeon, nes in length

See moreSee less

lieve it possible for these birds to fly from 50 to 90 miles per hour in rare instances. It takes about 12 hours for a carrier pigeon to digest a crop full of grain. Passenger pigeons have been shot in New York with their crops full of rice, which they could not have obtained nearer than the Carolina rice fields. They must have traveled 300 or 400 miles in six hours, or over 50 miles per hour. In England pigeons have been repeatedly used in wagers, bets being made on the full speed of the birds. In such cases a greater speed than 36 miles per hour has rarely been made. In 1833 a great trial of pigeons was made at Ghent. On June 24, of that year, 24 birds that had been entered for the prize were thrown up at Rouen, about 150 miles from Ghent. The first pigeon arrived in Ghent in one and one-half hours; 16 came in within two and one-half hours, and three in the course of the day; four were lost. The first pigeon must have traveled at a rate of nearly 100 miles per hour, which seems incredible. Yet it is possible, seeing that sixteen others also obtained a speed of over 60 miles per hour. It is hard to believe that carrier pigeons are not governed by instinct, yet men that handle them say that it is merely a matter of education. If the bird cannot recognize some landmark he gets lost. Also birds thrown up during a fog or haze, seldom reach their destination. There are, however, some rare instances extant that seem to prove that the birds can succeed irrespective of the educational principle. Governor Hoard, of Wisconsin, who has made a special study of this subject of breeding for milk or for beef, says: "I believe that the English ideal of the form of a dairy cow has been on the whole, a hindrance to the development of dairy cattle. It is essentially based on the outline of the shorthorn, and hence is more or less a beef form. To my mind, the true science of breeding for dairy qualities is based on the same law of distinctiveness that governs in breeding horses for speed. I do not think that the English ideas of dairy breeding, based largely as they are on the 'general purpose' notion of beef and milk both, are conducive to the best development of dairy quality and potency."

We consider that Governor Hoard's views are quite right, and that though moderate capacity for beef and milk can be combined, yet superiority in both cannot be attained in the same animal. Therefore, we hold that British breeders who have striven for the perfection of beef cattle, and Channel island and Ayrshire breeders who have aimed at superiority of butter and milk, have been acting in strict conformity with physiological laws, which will prevent combined excellence in milk and beef, though, as we have said, moderate achievements are within the reach of everybody. The vindication of what our breeders have accomplished is consequently to be found in their observance of laws of nature, which cannot be set at nought, and if the attempt should ever be made it will be found to be incompatible with principles that are fixed and unalterable. Cheap Rations.—With butter selling at 18 cents on the Elgin board of trade, feeding for profit is not so easy as it used to be. The writer finds nothing cheaper this winter than a grain ration of bran equal in quantity to the milk the cow gives and a forage ration of cornstalks. Cornstalks cost nothing but saving them—we have to grow them to get corn—and exchanging a pail of milk for a pail of bran is a good trade, especially if it is Jersey milk. With this ration it requires about four and one-half pounds of bran to make a pound of butter. We have made it with less bran, but the increased feed makes a paying increase in butter yield per cow with good cows. A cow giving thirty pounds of milk per day has about seven and one-half pounds of bran, and a smaller yielder is matched with a correspondingly Pheasants of domesticated extensively if they are in China—domesticat-

pounds of bran, and a smaller yielder is matched with a correspondingly smaller mess of bran. Bran for milk in equal bulk—measure for measure—is so safe a rule that the veriest novice need make no mistake. The exper[t]

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A man named Mr. Healey has captured an unidentified bird resembling a pigeon, with dull mouse-colored plumage and a lost tail, after a massive flight of similar birds passed over New Orleans. Observers wonder if the strange nighttime migration was an extraordinary bird event, but the species remains unidentified.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 May 1895 · page 3

I dull, a mouse-colored covered with a like a pigeon, and is covered with a dull, mouse-colored plumage. He lost his tail in the struggle for his j capture, so that at least one Impor tant aid to his identification has van-:>;

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

The article discusses carrier pigeon flight speeds, citing a famous 1833 Ghent race and claims that passenger pigeons shot in New York with rice-filled crops must have flown 300-400 miles in six hours from Carolina. It presents these as evidence of pigeons capable of 50-100 mph flight speeds.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Wrong

The Frontier · 16 May 1895 · page 7

THE CARRIER PIGEON. llevo It possible for these birds to fly from 60 to 90 miles per hour in rare instances. It takes about 12 hours for a carrier pige< n to digest a crop full of grain. Passenger pigeons have been shot in New York with their crops full of rice, which they could not have ob tained nearer than the Carolina rice fields. They must have traveled 300 or 400 miles in six hours, or over 50 miles per hour. In England pigeons have been re peatedly used in wagers, bets being made on the full speed of the birds.

See moreSee less

In such cases a greater speed than 36 miles per hour has rarely been made. In 1833 a great trial of pigeons was made at Ghent. On June 24, of that year, 24 birds that had been entered for the prize were thrown up at Rouen, about 150 miles from Ghent. The first pigeon arrived in Ghent in one and nno-hnlf hnnr*a< 1R noma * u t _ t and one-half hours, and three In the course of the day; four were lost. The first pigeon must have traveled at a rate of nearly 100 miles per hour, which seems incredible. Yet it is possible, seeing that sixteen others also obtain ed a speed of over 60 miles per hour. It is hard to believe that carrier pigeons are not governed by instinct, yet men that handle them say that it is merely a matter of education. If the bird cannot recognize some landmark he gets lost. Also birds thrown up dur ing a fog or haze, seldom reach their destination. There are, however, 3ome rare instances extant that seem to prove that the birds can succeed Irrespective of the educational principle. abnormal milk or butter cow must have a carcase specially suited for ex cellence in one direction or the other. British cattle breeders are so captivat ed by symmetry of form that they have done comparatively little in de veloping special milk and butter breeds. There Is, indeed, only one—the Ayrshire—and in it the wedge shape, so suitable for milk, offends ideas of beauty. For the rest we have to go to Jersey and Guernsey for our special breeds, which have been developed as the result of at least a hundred years’ systematic breeding for this particular i quality. Our best milking shorthorns ; aioo leuu 10 me weuge snape. Governor Hoard, of Wisconsin, who has made a special study of this sub ject of breeding for milk or for beef, says: “I believe that the English ideal of the form of a dairy cow has been on WUU UL" the whole, a hindrance to the develop ment of dairy cattle. It is essentially based on the outline of the shorthorn, and hence is more or less a beef form. To my mind, the true science of breed ing for dairy qualities is based on the same law of distinctiveness that gov erns in breeding horses for speed. I do not think that the English ideas of dairy breeding, based largely as they are on the ‘general purpose’ notion of beef and milk both, are conducive to the best development of dairy quality and potency.” We consider that Governor Hoard’s views are quite right, and that though moderate capacity for beef and milk can be combined, yef superiority in both cannot be attained in the name animal. Therefore, we hold that Brit ish breeders who have striven for the perfection of beef cattle, and Channel island and Ayrshire breeders who have aimed at superiority of butter and milk, have been acting in strict con formity with physiological laws, which will prevent combined excellence in milk and beef, though, as we have said, moderate achievements are within the reach of everybody. The vindication of what our breed ers have accomplished Is consequently to be found in their observance of laws of nature, which cannot be set at naught, and it the attempt -s-n'j m bo made It will be touna to be lucou patible with prlnclploa that are fixed and unalterable. , Fat Hem. So much has been said about laying hens getting too fat, that more thun a few people have concluded that the beat way to keep hens in good condition tor laying Is to half starve them. This Is a mistake. If layers aro fed the proper kind of food, and given a chance to ex ercise properly, they will not get too fat to do their best as layers. Ap or dinary flock of farm fowls are not apl to get too fat, for they run at large and are constantly taking exercise enough to keep them In good condition. We know that when hens are kept In pens most of the time, they can easily be fattened beyond the point of profit, as far as laying 1b concerned, but our readers are nearly all farmers who al low their fowls perfect liberty r i to such we want to give the warning that they are Just aB liable to underfeed them. Those who have fed their fowls liberally during the past severe winter will be rewarded with plenty of eggs as soon ns the weather moderates this spring, while those who have been fear ful of overfeeding will probably be com pelled to wait till the price of eggs has fallen very low before their hens will be producing at their highest capacity. Too many are careless about properly feeding their hens during the season when they do not lay many eggs, for getting that it Is necessary to keep them at the highest point of health and vigor if best results are to be expected.— Farm News. S»lt In the Dnlry. 1. Salt, like acidity and charity, cov ers a multitude of sins. Co., New York or Cblca/o 2. To the majority ot consumers a small amount of salt will Increase fine flavors (n butter, while a large amount of salt may partially hide poor flavor. 3. Salt is thus partly a flavoring and partly a preservative. 4. No amount of salt will preserve poor butter, but good salt will help to preserve good butter. 5. Salt should be applied with a rea sonable addition of brains. 6. If working only once, use an eas ily dissolved salt, or else partially dis solve it before using. The latter is not a good plan, as it is difficult to dis tribute such a pasty mess. 7. The amount of moisture left In the butter when the salt is added should he regulated according to tho dissolu bility of the salt. 8. When salt is applied to drained butter and left to dissolve at the proper temperature (about 60 degrees) it will absorb moisture from the but ter globules in dissolving, and this is quite an important matter. 9. Heavy brine, when applied only once in brine salting, will be diluted in proportion to the water left from wash ing, and hence be apt to leave the but ter too light salted for the average con sumer. 10. It is more difficult to salt evenly with brine than with dry salt. 11. First and last and all things get a good dairy salt which has not been ex posed to bad odors. 12. Do not believe that you can fol low any fixed rules, but consider the dissolubility of your salt, the amount of moisture and the temperature in your butter, and use Judgment in salt ing as in all other work.—National Dairyman. Cheap Rations.—With butter selling at 18 cents on the Elgin board of trade, feeding for profit is not so easy as it used to be. The writer finds nothing cheaper this winter than a grain ration of bran equal in quantity to the milk the cow gives and a forage ration of cornstalks. Cornstalks cost nothing but saving them—we have to grow them to get corn—and exchang ing a pail of milk for a pail of bran is a good trade, especially if it is Jersey milk. With this ration it requires qjiout four and one-half pounds of bran to make a pound of butter. We have made it with less bran, but the in creased feed makes a paying increase veston News. in butter yield per cow with good cows A cow giving thirty pounds of milk per day has about seven and one-half pounds of bran, and a smaller yielder is matched with a correspondingly smaller mess of bran. Bran for milk in equal bulk—measure for measure— is so safe a rule that the veriest novice need make no mistake. The expert with good cows can profitably feed richer and more concentrated food._ Advantages of a Separator.—The whom God has spoken. gain of butter by the use of a separator over that of the best deep setting meth ods is slight, if any. Tests have varied considerably in this respect. The principal advantage of the separator is the economy in time and space in the dairy, no setting pan or pail being required. The cream is separated soon after the milking, and the cream only has to be taken care of. The skimmed milk too is sweet, and therefore better for feeding, as the souring' is at the expense of the nutriment in the milk, some of the sugar of it being changed into acid. The quantity of milk for a pound of butter depends on the pro '9 portion of fat in it. If there is 4 per cent, there will be a pound of butter for each 25 pounds, or about 12 quarts. And there should be this proportion in the kind of cows mentioned, if they are well fed*—-Country Gentleman. Keep Down Expenses—We hear from men on every side that farming does not pay as well as it did twenty years ago, and that the country is goi ig to the dogs. Their fathers or grandfath ers made money on the farm; why can’t they? The trouble is Just here: They live beyond their income. They spend more than they earn. Getting “on tick” has ruined many farmers, not only In Kansas, but all over the country. Farmers twenty and forty jours ago bought and sold for cash. Their wants were not so numerous as the wants of the average farmer today. They bought what they needed, and could pay for. There was none of this modern splash and empty style about things that we see now.—Ex. Whey Butter.—The agricultural de partment at Cornell claims to have found that butter fat can be extracted from whey by running it through a 1 separator. The department now has in press a bulletin explaining the process. It is estimated that general adoption of the process would save the agriculturist interest of New York i state nearly $1,000,000 a year, or, to I put it in another way, that the entire : expense of making cheese would be I paid by the saving of what has hereto- * tore torn e weatm Modact j

See the clipping

The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind.

The item describes claims that passenger pigeons traveled 300-400 miles in six hours, over 50 miles per hour, based on birds shot with crops full of rice from distant Carolina fields. It compares this to European carrier pigeon racing records, including a famous 1833 Ghent race where birds covered about 180 miles in under two hours.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

The Jasper Weekly Courier · 24 May 1895 · page 7

THE CARRIER FIGEON. KcRdrrxit Ytnt.l liy t KewarkatiU I,oo for I In air. The illustration given below I roacross Its bill and continues down on either side of the lower mandible. The great development of this muscle is what gives the. bird the power of tioned below: long continued flight - - -i .... so vaiuaoie as meici'cfa i v..v: nr Imme, which seems abnormally developed. The art of training them is carried to perfection in Turkey, where the procedure U about as fol lows: A number of very young birds are taken to a distance of one-half mile from their home and freed.

See moreSee less

The most intelligent, win quicm v.-v... -j to their homes. Those that get lost are regarded as stupid and are re jected. The ones that return home are then taken to greater distances, first only two or three miles from the domiCAmtlER riOEOS ON THE WI.N0. much dispute. The more conservative 1 Mwd is about 3C fcKl V lll4l W I mhos ner hour. Some, however, be . I Urb-lVVr 01. liv. it nossiblc for these uiras to uj btancH.s. IttaKcs noout. 1n carrier pigeon to digest a crop full ol grain. Passenger pigeons have been shot in 2few York with their crops full of rice, which they coulü not nave outained nearer than tne uaronna n fields. They must have traveled 300 ox 400 miles lu'six hours, or over 50 miles per hour. In England pigeons have been re peatedly used In wagers, bets being made on the full speed of tho birds. In auch cases a greater speed than 3fl miles per hour has rarely been made. .... . ... ? i.s.ri wn In 1833 a great, iriiu i y.v,.. made at Uhent. On June S4, of that year, 24 birds that had been entered for the prixe were thrown up at Rouen, about ISO miles from Ghent. The first pigeon arrived in Ghent in ona and one-half hours; 16 came in within two and one-half hours, and three in the course of the day; four were iosu aho ibl. Yet it s possioie, D.V.... ' ... ,

See the clipping

Fort Worth Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.

The account describes early settlers near Columbiana, Ohio, who supplemented their hard frontier life by hunting passenger pigeons at a 180-acre tamarack swamp known as a famous roost, using torches at night to blind and club down vast numbers of birds. It blends this with broader recollections of pioneer hardship, land-clearing, and family history passed down through generations.

Fort Worth Gazette · 30 May 1895 · page 8

built In this ltinlty and Included In Har mons scvtlon was what Is still called tho pine swamp which li not pine but tamarack Drainage has minced Its nroa but lu early times it com rod IB0 acres and was a funous pigeon roost In those early dijs tho swamp had n depth of guano ln many places of eight Inches and the anhal of tho birds In tho etiling and departure In tho morning was llko that of long continued rolling thunder From graudslro and granelnmo tho writer has listened to tales of pigeon bunting with lurches nt night tho pro coeds being n conBldornblo Item In tho sub sistence account The tamaricks and aiders would liter ally bo loaded down with mjrhuls of wild pigeons which blinded nnd confused by tho glare of tho torches madoof hickory bark conld bo clubbed down with llht jwlos and by bagfuls carried out Hut the lives of these peoplo wero made up of bard labor nud close economy To make a Journey over tho mountains was iv matter of coustdembla peril nnd Involv ing nt least a month of time nnd as a rule the wife guva n farewell when sho went wet to all her old homo klndreel for all time to como Some of tho men mado a few business return trips nnd then all their future hyin tho homes they wero hew lug out of tho groat western wilder

See the clipping