As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

April 1881

13 articles

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

While waiting for a verdict in a petty larceny case, lawyers in Justice Carey's courtroom traded exaggerated anecdotes, including one about a Minnesota farmer who netted millions of roosting passenger pigeons and threshed wheat from their crops to sell at market. The tales grew increasingly absurd, including stories of alligators trained to fetch children and dogs that herded lumber.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 3 April 1881 · page 2

ROBUST IMAGINATIONS. Canon CHy (JN'ev.) Appeal. Yesterday afternoon, when the la wers in Justice Carey’s Court were : waiting for the verdict in a petty larceny, case. Attorney Soderberg related' an incident of .his early cliildliood in Minnesota, illustrative of the peculiar customs in vogue ili that State: “I knew an old farmer there who dwned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each year to roostThey devastated the wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch the birds in nets and thrash them out onthe barn floor..

See moreSee less

Each bird had three ounces of wheat in his'crop, and it w as a bad year for ‘ Old. Thompson’ when he couldn’t ship LUOO bushels of wheat to mar ket at S2.CO a bushel, and it ranked A No. 1 when it readied the Chicago elevator. If there had beena few ; million ‘ more <of pigeons he. would have come .pretty near getting a comer on the Minnesota .wheat crop.” . “I know a planter-down in Alabama,” said Kittreil, “who was fully os sharp as that He trained an alligator to work up and down the river and, catch the little pica ninnies that played along the bank; The al ligator would take the little kids in his jaws and swim back to the plantation. It.was a dnll day that he couldn’t corral three or four. The planter raised ’em carefully, and when they got big sold ’em in New: Orleans at prices ranging from 53,000 to 310,000 apiece. He was rolling in wealth when Lin coln’s Emancipation Proclamation was. is sued, and after that the alligator never did any morework. ’ The man is now hardy England on a visit to the Duke and Duchess of Edinburg)'has been sent-on a European tour, ,wlt&*lJcrerDptory instructions to nadasuitaoie spouse in the course* of bis travels.—not an easy task considering’ the ugly scandal which not long ago made his mime so notorious. It is certain* at least* that there is not the alichtest tion forthe rumor that he will laconic the hus*. band of one of the Queen’s granddaughters.

See the clipping

The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.

In a courtroom while awaiting a verdict, a lawyer tells an exaggerated anecdote about a Minnesota farmer who caught migrating passenger pigeons by the millions, each carrying three ounces of wheat, and sold the grain for profit. The story is part of a series of comic tall tales shared by courtroom attorneys, including an absurd one about an alligator catching children.

The Somerset Herald · 6 April 1881 · page 5

Some Nevada Stories. ' Yesterday afternoon, when the lawyers of Justice Cary's court were waning mr mo vcrutci in a pewy lareeny case. Attorney Soderberg related an incident of his early child hood in Minnesota, illustrative of the . peculiar customs in vogue in that state: "I knew an old farmer there who owned 10 acres of timber hind, where millions of pigeons came each year to roost 1 hey devasted the wheat fields, and tho old coon used to catch the birds in neta and thrash them out on the barn floor.

See moreSee less

Each hire! had three ounces of wheat in hiacrop, and it was a bad vear for old Thompson when he couldn't ship a thousand bushels of wheat to market at GO a bushel, and it ranked A No. 1 when it reached the Chicago elevator. If there had been few millions more of pigeons he

See the clipping

Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · Chillicothe, Mo.

A humor column recounts exaggerated anecdotes swapped by lawyers in a Nevada courtroom while awaiting a verdict. One lawyer tells of a Minnesota farmer who netted millions of roosting pigeons, wheat-fattened, to nearly corner the wheat market.

Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · 7 April 1881 · page 1

ROBUST IMAGINATIONS.

Some Very Able Stories Alleged to Have Been Told in Nevada. Cannn CI j Apr!. Yesterday afternoon, when the law yers in Justice Cary's court were wait ing for the verdict in a petty larceny case, Attorney Sodenberg related an in cident of his early childhood in Min nesota, illustrative of tho peculiar cus toms in vogue in that state: "I knew an old fanner tliero who owned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each year to roost. They devastated tho wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch the birds in nets and thrash them out on tho barn floor.

See moreSee less

Kach bird had three ounces of whoat in his crop, and it was a bad year for 'Old Thompson' when lie couldn't ship a thousand bushels of wheat to market at $2.00 a bushel, and it ranked A No. 1 when it readied the Chicago elevator. If there had been a few millions more of pigeons lie would

See the clipping

Staunton Vindicator · Staunton, Va.

A courtroom anecdote describes a Minnesota farmer who netted millions of roosting passenger pigeons each year, thrashing wheat from their crops to ship to market. The story is one of several exaggerated tall tales traded by lawyers waiting on a verdict.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

Staunton Vindicator · 8 April 1881 · page 4

SOME VERY ABLE STORIES ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN TOLD IN NEVADA.

HAVE BEEN TOLD IN NEVADA. Yesterday afternoon, when the lawyers in Justice Cary’s court were waiting for the verdict in a petty larceny case, Attor ney Soderberg related an incident of his early childhood in Minnesota, illustrative of the peculiar customs in that State: “I knew an old farmer there who owned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came pach year to roost. They devastated wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch the birds in nets and thrash them out on the barn floor. Each bird had three ounces of wheat in his crop, and it was a bad year for ‘Old Thompson’ when he couldn’t ship a thousand bnshels of wheat to market at $2.60 a bushel, and it ranked A No.

See moreSee less

1 when it reached the Chicago elevator. If there had been a few millions more of pigeons he would

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

This report surveys various extinct and unusual bird species, including the dodo, solitaire, and nutmeg-eating fruit pigeons, before introducing the passenger pigeon as one of the most remarkable members of the pigeon family. It begins quoting Wilson's description of passenger pigeon nesting grounds and the human activity they attracted.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 April 1881 · page 14

FACTS ABOUT PIGEONS.

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

This 1881 piece describes passenger pigeons' vast nesting colonies, quoting ornithologist Alexander Wilson's famous account of the chaos, noise, and destruction at their nurseries, plus estimates of flock sizes and food consumption. It also repeats a folk claim that pigeons process nutmegs for germination in their stomachs.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.

Wrong

Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 April 1881 · page 14

FACTS ABOUT PIGEONS. The Giant Among Tliem—Ainoelc Con taining more than 2,000*000,000 lllrdi. Ntw York San. “That's the only bird that over created a boom,** n Park keeper said, referring to a One largo blue bird with an Immense crown of feathers waving on 1U bond. “How so?*' . " Because that's the only sound It makes. If you didn't too It you would think some ono had struck a bass drum a quarter of a billo away. Its a regular boom-boom, and when it makes tbo nolsoltbows Its head, so that its crown sweeps tho ground.

See moreSee less

It's tbo crowned pigeon from Now Zoland, and bctweou this cage and tbo stuffed birds. In tbo museum wo can show nearly every pigeon in tho world, and you'd bo astonished to sco how. many different kinds tboro nro. Wo bavo pouters, fan-tails, nuns, carriers, and all tho fancy breeds alive, besides wood doves and this crowned follow! and oc casionally wo* have a big Hook of wild pigeons hero, but tho sparrows drive thorn off. Vou wouldn't think u big bird like a pigeon would run from n sparrow, but they do. Tho little birds collect la tbo trees In crowds, and when a fleck of pigeons cotno swooping over they make n rush for thomln a body, and tako right hold, tooth and nail, and ns the pigeons swoop down to got outof tbo way they arc literally chased out of tho Park." In the plgcon-coso In tho museum nro some of the bones of that extinct and much-maligned bird, tbo dodo, the giant of pigeons, being the only specimen In tho country, two hundred and Ilf ty years ago they wore found In tho Mauritius Islands lu groat quantities. It was a curious bird, ns largo ns a swan. Tho bill In tho ease is not unplgoonllko, though UK) times tbo size of Its modern representative. They wore sluggish birds, uunblo .to fly, and laid a single egg, about tbo size of n turkey's. Brontlus, nn old Dutch writer of tbo period, gives tho following quaint account ,of tboro: '• The drontc, or doddors, Is, for big ness, of menu size, between. an ostrich and a turkov, from which It partly differs in shapoand partly agrees with them, especially with tho African ostriches, If you consider tho ntrap, quills, and feathers, so that It was liken pigmy among them, if you regard shortness of legs. It bath a great ill-favored head, with a kind of mombrano resembling a hood; great i' black eyes: a bunding, prominent, fat nook; nn I extraordinary, long, strong, bluo-wblto bill, only 1 tho ends of ouch mandible are a different color, —that of tho upper black, that of the nether yellowish,—both sharp-pointed and crooked: its gape huge, wide, ns being naturally vora cious. Its body Is fat and round, covered with soft gray feathers, after the manner of an ostrich's, on each side. Instead of bard wing feathers, or quills. It Is furnished with small soft-feathered wings ot a yellowish nsh color, and behind, tbo rump, instead of a tall, Is adorned with llvo small curled feathers of tno same color. Four toes onoach foot—solid, long, | as It were, really armed with strong, black claws." They nt ono time wore so plentiful that they wore killed for tbo stones that wore found In their stomachs, and on which the sailors sharpened their knives. Another queer pigeon that lived at that time, and which Is now extinct, Is tho solitaire. Itwns found on tho Island of Hodrlgncz. It was larger than n turkey, ana In general respects resembled the dodo. Another was tho Naznrouc, that was twice ns largo as tbo dodo. But tho post re markable was the dldueculus, a living relative, aud closely allied to tbo doao. Tbo bird was rather larger than our common partridge, and possessed tno curious naked .skin surrounding the eyes which characterized Its ancestor. Ono of tbo tlnostof tbo thirty or morodlfforont species of pigeons istboOcounlofruft-blrd of tho Felon Islands. There thhy nro found in thou sands, feeding ou nutmegs. They become very fat, and tbo fat, which has n strong Haver of nutmeg, Is considered a groat dainty by many. It is said that they grow so fat that when shot they full on tho ground, and nro shattered to pieces by the fall. Not only ore they valuable as a means of subsistence,. but they seem to bavo been appointed to help carve out ono of tho groat laws of Nature. It Is n well-known fact that tho nutmeg has to pass through sonto ohoralcal process before It will grow, and in tho stomach of those birds the nutmeg Is prepared for reproduction. Among this family of birds tho passenger pigeon Is one of tho most wonderful. Wilsons description of their camping-grounds Is: "As : soon as tbo young were fully grown, and before they loft their nests, numerous parties ot tho* Inhabitants from all parts of the country como with wagons, oxen, beds, cooking utensils, many of them accompanied by tbo greater part of their families, aud encamped for several days at this Immense nursery. Several of them Informed roe that tho noise in tbo woods was so groat as to terrify, their horses, and that It was allllcultforouo person, to .boar another speak without bawling in bis car. Thogrounawns strewn with branches, broken limbs, eggs, and young squab pigeons which had boon precipi tated from above, and on wbloh herds of hogs wore fattening. Hawks, buzzards, and eagles were sailing about In groat numbers, and seiz ing the squabs from their neats at pleasure, while from twenty feet upward to too top of tho trees tho view through the trees presented a perpetual tumult of crowding and fluttering multitudes of pigeons, their wings roaring like thunder, mingled with tho frequent crash of fall ing trees." It is utterly Impossible to estimate tbo numbers that congregate together. On some trees more than 300nests wore found, aud tbo branches were continually fulling owing to tho weight of tbo old birds. Tho amount consumed by a flock of those birds is wonderful. Wilson calculates that, taking tho breadth of a column of pigeons bo saw to bo only ono mile. Its length tobcJihJ miles, and to contain only three pigeons In each square yard, (taking no account of the : several strata of birds ono above tbo other,) and, that each bird consumes half a pint of food dally, all ot which Assumptions nro below tno ac tual amount, tbo quantity of faodconsumod In a day would bo 17,C100,000 bushels. Supposing this column to bo ono mile In breadth, and Hying at tbo rnto of ono mile n minute for four hours, and supposing that each square yard contains three pigeons, the square yards In the whole space, multiplied by throe, would give birds! In tbo Kentucky country, where they nro mostly found, they ap pear suddenly, darkening tbo sky so completely that all work and labor is givenup until they have passed. The air Is literally flllod with pig eons, and In some places mortars are used to bring down hundreds at ono discharge. Their rapidity ot Hlght Is wonderful. The wood-doves or rlng-plgoons aro bettor known In Franco than elsewhere. Our domestic pigeon Is only a modification of tho blue-rook pigeon, and this Is proved oy tho fact that If tbo domestic and blue nr wild rock Is allowed to breed tbo young will in many oases resemble tho wild rook, with its plain plumage and barred wlugs. The domestic plgoous ore divided Into two classes, tbo oolomnrlo and tho aviary pig eons. The former aro almost wild, and the lat ter nro those with wbloh wo aro so familiar. Tho question bow carrier-pigeons find their way homo Is probably ono never to bo deter mined. Some writers assort that tbo birds aro guided by landmarks, and give ns proof, that when tbo ground Is covered with snow tbo birds, aro confused, and others say that they aro In fluenced by some magnetic or clootno current, and on this point It Is noticed that birds either Hy cast or west, north or south, and whoa started rise at a groat bight, and for n minute hesitate, and then by unknown Instinct they dart off In tbo right direction. Tho oxuot dote of their utilization is not known, but ns fur ns we know, Noah bad tho honor pf having first pressed Into service our feathered friends. Pliny says that those birds wore used by Brutus and Hlrtius during tho siege ofa town by Mure Antony. In 1781, at tho siege of Loyoon, they worn used by the Prloeo of Orange, and by their means he succeed In freeing a town that was besieged. To show bis gratitude bo ordered-that the sagacious birds should bo fed on straw berries. and that when dead they should bo em balmed with all honor, in Pliny’s lime navi gators from Cyprus and Egypt carried tboso birds nn their galleys, and on their safe arrival liberated them to convoy tho good news to tbotr families. Of the different kins of carrier pigeons tho Belgian bird Is preferred. It has a short buck, largo round bead, and broad shoul ders. Tho fancy carrier, with largo wattles on the bonk, Is often used, but It la vastly Inferior to tho former.

See the clipping

The Kentucky Gazette · Lexington, Ky.

A newspaper trivia column lists various animal facts, including claims about lions, vultures, gorillas, and tigers. Among these is a note describing a flock of wild pigeons in southern Ohio estimated at over a billion birds, consuming eight million bushels of grain daily.

The Kentucky Gazette · 16 April 1881 · page 1

A flock of pigeons estimated to con tain over a billion waa once seen in Southern Ohij They would eat not less than right million nushela of grain

See the clipping

St. Tammany Farmer · Covington, La.

A newspaper humor item recounts courtroom banter in which lawyers traded exaggerated anecdotes, including one about a Minnesota farmer netting millions of roosting pigeons each carrying wheat in their crops to sell for profit. The piece is framed explicitly as comic tall-tale telling, not factual reporting.

St. Tammany Farmer · 16 April 1881 · page 3

ROBUST IMAGINATIONS. SOME VERY ABLE STORIES ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN TOLD IN NEVADA.

SoME VERY ABLE STORIBB ALBLEGED TO HAVE BEEN TOLD IN NEVIDA. Yesterday afternoon, when the lawyers in Justice Carey's count were waiting for the verdict in a petty laseeny case, Attorney Soder berg related an incident oa his early childhood in Minnesota, illustrative of the peculiar customs in vogue in that State, "I knew an old farmer there who owned' ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each

See the clipping

Alpena Weekly Argus · Alpena, Mich.

A humor column recounts an attorney's childhood memory of an old Minnesota farmer whose ten acres of timberland hosted millions of roosting pigeons each year. The birds devastated his wheat fields, and the farmer used to catch them.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 21 days earlier.

Alpena Weekly Argus · 20 April 1881 · page 1

that can be laughed to-day. Kingston j tate . Frecmnn: j "I knew an ohl farmer there who Of all free institutions thc free luiirti J owned ten acres of timber laud, where ' is dearest to thc communist. New Orj millions of pigeons came each year to leans Picayune. j roost. They devastated thc wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch i A man who "walked en his ear'' out

See the clipping

Alpena Weekly Argus · Alpena, Mich.

A humorous filler item describes netting pigeons and thrashing them for wheat in their crops, tying it to a joke about cornering the Minnesota wheat market. It continues with an unrelated tall tale about an Alabama planter training an alligator to catch children.

Alpena Weekly Argus · 20 April 1881 · page 1

When ihc lawyers in Justice Carey' uurg rciaieu nn incKient ot Ins early childhood in Minnnsritn illiif i-itii-r fields, and the old coon used to catch i the birds in nets and thrash them out on thc barn floor. Each bird had i when he couldn't ship 1,000 btu-luls of it ranked A .No. 1 when it reached the j fbw millions more of pigeons he would i TTTmn have conic pretty near getting a cor:;ei-,' Jo U JL JL O, on the .Minnesota wheat crop." j "I know a planter down in Alabama," ' ...

See moreSee less

; i i.v. ... i .. i n ii i saiu iviurei, -wno was juav as .-narp q fyp work up and down the river and catch the piccanninnics that played along the bank. The alligator would take the little kid:' in his jaws and swim back to ' thc plantation. It was a dull day that j he couldn't corral three or tour. Thei

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A newspaper humor column recounts exaggerated courtroom anecdotes, including one about a Minnesota farmer who caught millions of roosting pigeons and threshed wheat from their crops to sell at a profit. The tales grow increasingly absurd, ending with a dog trained to herd lumber.

Bismarck Tribune · 22 April 1881 · page 2

ROBUST IMAGINATIONS.-^ Some Able Stories Toid In a Western Court Room. Butte (Mont) Inter-Mountain: Yesterday afternoon, when the lawyers in Justice Carv's court were waiting for. the. verdict in a petty larceny case. Attorney Shodenberg related an incident of his early childhood in Minnesota, illustrative of the peculiar customs in vogue in that State: "I knew an old farmer there who owned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each year to roost They devastated the wheat fields and the old coon u&od to catch tho birds in nets and thresh them out on the barn floor.

See moreSee less

Each bird had three ounces of wheat in his crop, and it was a bad year for 'Old Thomp­ son' when he couldn't ship a thousand bushels of wheat to market at $2.60 per bushei, and it ranked A No. 1 when it reached the Chicago elevator. If there had been a' few millions more of pigeons he .would have come pretty near getting a corner on the Minnesota wheat

See the clipping

The New Bloomfield, Pa. Times · New Bloomfield, Pa.

Lawyers in a Carson City courtroom swap exaggerated tall tales while awaiting a verdict, including one about a Minnesota farmer who netted millions of roosting passenger pigeons and extracted wheat from their crops to sell for profit. Other absurd stories follow about an alligator trained to catch children and a lumber-herding dog.

The New Bloomfield, Pa. Times · 26 April 1881 · page 1

Some Very Able Stories. THE Carson City (New) Appeal in a recent issue says: Yesterday after noon, when the lawyers In Justice Cary's court were waiting for the verdict in a petty larceny case, Attorney Soder berg related au Incident of his early childhood in Minnesota, illustrative of the peculiar customs in vogue In that State. " I knew an old farmer there who owned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each year to roost. They devastated the wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch the birds in nets and thrash them out on the barn floor.

See moreSee less

Each bird had three ounces of wheat in bis crop and it was a bad year for 'Old Thompson' when he couldn't ship a thousand bushels of wheat to market at $2.00 a bushel, and it ranked A No. 1 when It reached the Chicago elevator, if there had been a few millions more of the pigeons he would have come pretty near getting a corner in the Minnesota wheat crop." "I know a planter down In Ala baina," said Kittrell, "who was fully as sharp as that. He trained an alligator to work up and down the river and catch the little piccaninnies that played along the bank. The alligator would take the little kids In his jaws and swim back to the plantation. It was a dull day that he couldn't corral three or four. The planter raised 'em carefully, ,00 slmi.! r-;

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A humorous 'liars' column recounts a tale of a Minnesota farmer who caught millions of roosting pigeons in nets, thrashed wheat from their crops, and nearly cornered the wheat market. The story is explicitly presented as a comic exaggeration among a series of outlandish anecdotes.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 19 days earlier.

Morning Journal and Courier · 27 April 1881 · page 1

AmU the Tales They Told In Modern Grocery. "I knew an old farmer in Minnesota," said the man with the red nose, "who owned ten acres of timber land where millions of pigeons came each year to roost. They de vastated the wheat fields, and the old coon used to catch the birds in nets and thrash them out on the barn floor. Each bird had three ounces of wheat in his crop, and it was a bad year for 'Old Thompson' when he couldn't ship a thousand bushels of wheat to market at $2 a bushel, and it ranked A No.

See moreSee less

1 when it reached the Chicago elevator. If there had been a few millions more of pigeons he would have come pretty near get ting a corner in the Minnesota wheat crop."

See the clipping