As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

June 1880

11 articles

Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa. · and 1 other paper

This report describes the breeding behavior of passenger pigeons, detailing incubation, parental care, and the production of 'pigeon's milk' used to feed squabs. It also describes the young birds' development, abandonment by parents after twelve days, and their awkward first flights.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Butler Citizen · 2 June 1880 · page 1

FOB GRAIN OF ALL KINDS. trated catalogue free. Address Hpitf I apl4-3m W. 0. BUNNELL, Lewi*towu, Pa. the phrase "pigeon's milk," two ex pressive words frequently used with out an idea of their meaning. On the return to tbe nest the squab puts its head into the parent bird's mouth, and draws the milk direct from the crop. For twelve days are they fed on this substance. They are then as fat as butter and as listless as toads at noon day. On the thirteenth day they receive their last meal from the bills of the old birds.

See moreSee less

Their throats are packed with beech juts, and they are left to their own resources. The toins and hens arise from the tops of the trees like agreat cloud, and are quickly lost to sight. The squabs lie blinking in their nests for hours. On finding themselves deserted, they toddle to the rims of their baskets and balance themselves. After a preliminary flut ter of the wings they strike out for a limb, reach it, lose their equilibrium, and tumble to the ground. They then wander about like drunken men for three or four days ere they know enough to seek food or water. Fully a week elapses before they are in good flying condition. When they become lean they readily take wing, and skir mish for themselves. Their wing feathers grow much faster than the feathers in their tails, and when flying this gives them a ludicrous appearance. They resemble boys in monkey jackets A lack of tail feathers sends them rudderless through the air. They are forced to fly in a straight line, swerv ing gently between the trees. On alighting they frequently pitch heels over head, and appear dumfounded. At first they form small flocks, but as they grow stronger of wing these flocks come together, and the downy brigade pitches for a good feeding ground. Either inst : "?tor some kind hearted old bird points the way, for veteran pigeon hunters say that a flock of squabs invariably finds the best feed. The parent birds nest anew within a few miles of the old place. If the beech nuts hold out they nest three times before summer. After the third nesting the myriad disbands and is scattered over the country. In au tumn they are found in the woods from Maine to Texas and from Wash ington Territory to Georgia. A very few mate and nest in odd places in the summer. All however, reunite in a grand army about the beginning of the new year This flock nested in Forest county in 1878, 1871 and 1867. Last year they nested in the Indian Terri tory, where .there was a superabund ance of acorns. A great crop of beech nuts is usually followed by a large crop of acorns. The two crops seldom grow in the same year. These facts are derived from professional pigeon hunters, who also assert that three immense flocks of the birds are now nesting in the United States— one in Missouri, a second in Michigan, and a third in Forest county. The professional pigeon hunter is keen-eyed, bronze-faced, and hard handed. He usually chews tobacco, drinks whisky, and indulges in pro fanity. He wears a black sombrero, a cassimer suit, and thick-soled boots. He is slouchy and reserved, and not particularly communicative. Once get on the inside of him, however, and you will fine him genial and generous. Sixteen years ago he made from SSOO to $2,000 net in a nesting season. Now he finds his receipts cut down by local catchers—men who were at first hired to assist him in spreading nets, but who have learned the calling and have gone into business on their own account. Ten years ago there were from thirty to forty professional pigeon trappers in the United States. They did nothing else. The number has been reduced until it includes Messrs. Ackerman and Jones at Co lumbus, Ohio ; Haycock and Cadmus of Geneva, Ohio ; Paxon of some town near Buffalo; Custen of Roanoke, Ohio; Little of Cartersburg, Indiana, and T. L. Utley of Neenah, Wisconsin. Mr. Ackerman is the oldest pigeon catcher in the country. He has been at the business over forty years. "I have been in the business for nearly twenty years," says Mr. Utley. '•Sixteen years ago I was trapping birds at this very roost. We trap for the market, and make more money out of them when game and poultry are scarce than at other times. I have fol lowed this flight of birds for years. Professional trappers know all the roosts, and keep each other posted by telegraph. The birds are hardly set tled at a roost before the trappers are after them with a supply of nets. Their flight is swift. I have known them to leave Wisconsin in the morn ing and roost here the same night. The nesting in Michigan is fully as large as this one. That in Missouri is much smaller. In the former they live on beech nuts, and in the latter on acorns. From my experience I should say that there are only two large flocks in the country. It would be as difficult to estimate their number as it was to estimate the number of buffalo in a herd on the plains fifty years ago. There are at least 2,000,000,000 in this flock, and probably many more. Those trapped and killed are like a pinch of grain taken from an elevator. When one of the two great flocks comes from the northwest it hugs the shores of the lakes, and then drives in a straight line for the roost. I have seen solid sheets of birds, five miles wide and two hundred and seventy miles long, skirt ing the shores of Lake Huron and Michigan. They were three hours in passing a given point. They will not cross the lakes if they can avoid it, be cause they are apt to either lose their wav in a fog or get bewildered in a storm. At such times thousands upon thousands drop in the lake and are drowned. I have seen the beach for more than a mile below Traverse City covered three feet deep with birds. At times the flock hugs the southern shore of Lake Superior, crossing the straitß of Mcakinaw, and following the trend of Huron and Erie until they are able to strike out for the east. They stream over the straits sometimes for days." Mr. Utley says that the profession als did not follow the flight of the birds into Indian Territory last year. The pigeons nested forty miles from the the phrase "pigeon's milk," two ex pressive words frequently used with out an idea of their meaning. On the return to tbe nest the squab puts its head into the parent bird's mouth, and draws the milk direct from the crop. For twelve days are they fed on this substance. They are then as fat as butter and as listless as toads at noon day. On the thirteenth day they receive their last meal from the bills of the old birds. Their throats are packed with beech juts, and they are left to their own resources. The toins and hens arise from the tops of the trees like agreat cloud, and are quickly lost to sight. The squabs lie blinking in their nests for hours. On finding themselves deserted, they toddle to the rims of their baskets and balance themselves. After a preliminary flut ter of the wings they strike out for a limb, reach it, lose their equilibrium, and tumble to the ground. They then wander about like drunken men for three or four days ere they know enough to seek food or water. Fully a week elapses before they are in good flying condition. When they become lean they readily take wing, and skir mish for themselves. Their wing feathers grow much faster than the feathers in their tails, and when flying this gives them a ludicrous appearance. They resemble boys in monkey jackets A lack of tail feathers sends them rudderless through the air. They are forced to fly in a straight line, swerv ing gently between the trees. On alighting they frequently pitch heels over head, and appear dumfounded. At first they form small flocks, but as they grow stronger of wing these flocks come together, and the downy brigade pitches for a good feeding ground. Either inst : "?tor some kind hearted old bird points the way, for veteran pigeon hunters say that a flock of squabs invariably finds the best feed. The parent birds nest anew within a few miles of the old place. If the beech nuts hold out they nest three times before summer. After the third nesting the myriad disbands and is scattered over the country. In au tumn they are found in the woods from Maine to Texas and from Wash ington Territory to Georgia. A very few mate and nest in odd places in the summer. All however, reunite in a grand army about the beginning of the new year This flock nested in Forest county in 1878, 1871 and 1867. Last year they nested in the Indian Terri tory, where .there was a superabund ance of acorns. A great crop of beech nuts is usually followed by a large crop of acorns. The two crops seldom grow in the same year. These facts are derived from professional pigeon hunters, who also assert that three immense flocks of the birds are now nesting in the United States— one in Missouri, a second in Michigan, and a third in Forest county. The professional pigeon hunter is keen-eyed, bronze-faced, and hard handed. He usually chews tobacco, drinks whisky, and indulges in pro fanity. He wears a black sombrero, a cassimer suit, and thick-soled boots. He is slouchy and reserved, and not particularly communicative. Once get on the inside of him, however, and you will fine him genial and generous. Sixteen years ago he made from SSOO to $2,000 net in a nesting season. Now he finds his receipts cut down by local catchers—men who were at first hired to assist him in spreading nets, but who have learned the calling and have gone into business on their own account. Ten years ago there were from thirty to forty professional pigeon trappers in the United States. They did nothing else. The number has been reduced until it includes Messrs. Ackerman and Jones at Co lumbus, Ohio ; Haycock and Cadmus of Geneva, Ohio ; Paxon of some town near Buffalo; Custen of Roanoke, Ohio; Little of Cartersburg, Indiana, and T. L. Utley of Neenah, Wisconsin. Mr. Ackerman is the oldest pigeon catcher in the country. He has been at the business over forty years. "I have been in the business for nearly twenty years," says Mr. Utley. '•Sixteen years ago I was trapping birds at this very roost. We trap for the market, and make more money out of them when game and poultry are scarce than at other times. I have fol lowed this flight of birds for years. Professional trappers know all the roosts, and keep each other posted by telegraph. The birds are hardly set tled at a roost before the trappers are after them with a supply of nets. Their flight is swift. I have known them to leave Wisconsin in the morn ing and roost here the same night. The nesting in Michigan is fully as large as this one. That in Missouri is much smaller. In the former they live on beech nuts, and in the latter on acorns. From my experience I should say that there are only two large flocks in the country. It would be as difficult to estimate their number as it was to estimate the number of buffalo in a herd on the plains fifty years ago. There are at least 2,000,000,000 in this flock, and probably many more. Those trapped and killed are like a pinch of grain taken from an elevator. When one of the two great flocks comes from the northwest it hugs the shores of the lakes, and then drives in a straight line for the roost. I have seen solid sheets of birds, five miles wide and two hundred and seventy miles long, skirt ing the shores of Lake Huron and Michigan. They were three hours in passing a given point. They will not cross the lakes if they can avoid it, be cause they are apt to either lose their wav in a fog or get bewildered in a storm. At such times thousands upon thousands drop in the lake and are drowned. I have seen the beach for more than a mile below Traverse City covered three feet deep with birds. At times the flock hugs the southern shore of Lake Superior, crossing the straitß of Mcakinaw, and following the trend of Huron and Erie until they are able to strike out for the east. They stream over the straits sometimes for days." Mr. Utley says that the profession als did not follow the flight of the birds into Indian Territory last year. The pigeons nested forty miles from the NO. 28, railroad, and would have spoiled before they could have been got to market. Besides this the Indians objected to the presence of the trappers. Mr. Ut ley is now trapping 12,000 live bird* for the New York State Sportsman's As sociation. He says that this associa tion will probably use up 1,200 dozen at its anuual meeting. Live birds bring from $1 to $1.25 a dozen, deliver ed at the depot in Sheffield. Eleven hundred barrels, containing over half a million dead birds, and many crates of live ones were shipped from Sheffield in 1878. Over $50,000 worth of birds were sold during the season. This year the shipments are much larger. Cooped in large quantities live birds become diseased and die. When they are "stall fed," to use a professional term, they become to fat for trap-shooting and are killed and sent to market They are rarely kept more than a month before they are placed in the traps, and are compelled to fly a guant let of crack shots. The fowlers begin netting the pig eons when they are forming a roost. The nets resemble common fish nets, and are usually sixteen feet wide and thirty feet long. They are spread in an open place over which the birds fly while in search of food. The net is set near a covert made of thick hemlock boughs. It is strung on a rope tied at either end to green hickory saplings bent parallel to the ground. Man is not the only agent in destroy ing these immense flocks of pigeons. Crows break their eggs and beat out the brains of their young ; an army of hawks hang around the nesting like wolves, and snatch up the unwary birds; owls prowl among them at night and destroy untold numbers; twelve years ago a snap of cold weather froze

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md. · 5 June 1880

Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa.

The report details a passenger pigeon nesting ground covering twenty square miles in Forest County, Pennsylvania, describing the remote wilderness terrain and beech-nut food source that attracts the birds. It explains how scouting parties monitor nut conditions in fall, with the main flock arriving in late February this year.

Butler Citizen · 2 June 1880 · page 1

A CITY OF WILD PIGEONS

These nuts attract the pigeons. The condition of the crop is studied by small scouting parties in the fall, and in some manner is told to the main ar

See the clipping

Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa.

The report describes a massive passenger pigeon roost forming in Forest County, Pennsylvania, with birds arriving by the millions to feed on beechnuts and mate. It details their courtship battles, pair bonding, and the destructive hunting methods used by local farmers who clubbed birds from the trees at night.

Butler Citizen · 2 June 1880 · page 1

NESTING IN FOREST COUNTY, PA.

At times huge branches, broken by the weight of birds, crashed to the ground, throwing the vast camp into dire con fusion. The unfortunate pigeons flut tered to and fro in the darkness, utter ing plaintive cries, which were answer ed by their more fortunate companions in the trees. A heavy fall of snow or a gale after dark breaks many over weighted limbs and spreads dismay among the flock. The fallen birds skulk to cover and await the break of day, filling the darkness with their cries of terror. Farmers and others visited the roost after night-fall, and, by the light of a blazing fire, clubbed hundreds of birds from the lower branches of the trees with long poles.

See moreSee less

While sojourning at the roost the birds mate. The torn pigeon coos in cessantly, swelling his chest and ruf fling the feathers at his neck. The mating lasts three or four days. A thousand millions of birds or more are courting. The forest resounds with love-making. Frequently toms court the same hen, and a battle royal en sues. Eyes flash fire, beaks are crossed like rapiers, and the combatants use their wings as Irishmen use shillelahs at a country fair. The hens stand by, coy and modest, and give themselves to the victor without reserve. Once mated, the pair is a model of constancy. The torn is all attention and the hen all affection. He brings her the choic est delicacies and she rewards him with kisses. Woe betide the feathered roue who tries to loosen the domestic bond. Respectable married pigeons make common cause against him, and club

See the clipping

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.

A news brief reports that Sheffield, Warren County, has shipped 2,000 barrels of dead wild pigeons to market this season, with another 1,200 barrels sent from Kane. The item appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous state news items.

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 2 June 1880 · page 2

Sheffield, Warren oounty, has ship ped to market this season 2,000 barrels of dead wild pigeons: 1,200 barrels were 6cnt from Kane. Silver mines are worked near Indian

See the clipping

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes a massive passenger pigeon nesting site in Forest County, Pennsylvania, covering twenty square miles, detailing how birds arrive in scouting parties to assess beechnut crops before migrating in enormous flocks. It also describes farmers clubbing birds from branches and the mating behavior that occurs during the roost.

The Daily Gazette · 4 June 1880 · page 3

SOME INTERESTING FACTS REGARDING THE HABITS OF THE BIRDS

spring. The condition of the crop seems to be studied by small scouting parties of pigeons in the fall, and they lead on the others in the spring. The first to arrive at the Forest county nesting this year came in the latter part of February, and they were fol lowed quickly bv others. They beat the light snow from the ground with their wings and gathered into their ops the rich nuts. Myriads of birds poured into the roost for the next fortnight. They came in|flocks that stretched from horizon to hori At night over live square zon.

See moreSee less

miles of trees were filled with these birds. At times the branches were broken by their weight. Farmers and others visited the roost witli torches and clubbed hundred» from the lower brauches of the trees with lono poles. While sojourning at the roost the pigeons mate. The mating lasts several days, during which time the

See the clipping

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

The article describes passenger pigeon breeding behavior, migration patterns, and nesting sites across states like Michigan, Missouri, and Pennsylvania's Forest County. It also details the declining but still active commercial trapping industry, including net techniques, use of decoy 'stool' pigeons, and shipment figures of hundreds of thousands of birds sold for profit.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Daily Gazette · 4 June 1880 · page 3

for themselves. The tail featlieri g row very slow, and, without tails,they y rudderless through tiie air, present ing a very ludicrous appearauce. On alighting they frequently pitch heels over head. A.t first they form in small Hocks, hut finally unite and pitch for some good feeding ground. The cut birds nest anew within a few miles of th# old place, aud if the beeoh nuts hold out they nest three timos before After the third nostiug they summer. disappear and scatter over the counjry. In autumn they are found in the wood» from Maine to Texas and from Wash ington Territory to Georgia, All, however, unite in a grand army about the beginning of the new year.

See moreSee less

This Hock nested in Forrest county in 1807, 1871 and 1H7S. Last year they nested in tiie Indian Territory, where there was an abundance of acorns. A great crop of beecli tints is usually fol lowed by a large acorn crop. The two crops seldom*grow in the same year. Old hunters assert that three immeuse Hocks are now nesting in the United Stttes, one 1 In Missouri, a second in Michigan aud a third in Forest county. Tiie professional pigeon hunter is a bronzed, hardy individual. Bixteeu years ago he made trom $300 to *2,000, net, iu season, but tiie profits are not nesting good now; because local catchers near so Ten years ago there were interfere. from thirty to fourty professional hunt eas iu tiie United Stales, who (lid nothing They are nuw reduced to nine. «Iso. They know tiie roosts and keep each other posted by tel graph. Tiie birds hardly settled before the trappers are I after them with ueis. The Forest county

See the clipping

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

The report details the scale of pigeon trapping, citing 600,000 birds shipped from one depot in 1878 worth $50,000. It describes the netting technique using decoy 'stool' and 'flyer' pigeons to lure flocks into traps baited with buckwheat.

The Daily Gazette · 4 June 1880 · page 3

pigeon« are used In trapping before I be mating set «ou, viz., the «tool and the dyer. When the net is let the flyer 1« thrown into the «Ir and diet until at the end ot a airing attached to the leg and then dutten to the ground. It» strange action« are noticed by oi her bird« that circle around. Then the stool pigeon is worked and the flock becoming ini «ranted settle in a bunch near the trap. On dis covering the buckwheat they throw ofl ail fear and feed ravenously and are grouped so closely together that only their tail* are seen.

See moreSee less

The trap spring« in a twinkling. Twenty-dve dozen birds a day is considered a good catch, and a« many as 1,000 bird« have been caught in one net.

See the clipping

The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md.

The report describes an enormous passenger pigeon nesting site covering twenty square miles in Forest County, Pennsylvania, drawn by an abundant beech nut crop. It details the remote wilderness terrain, the birds' mating and nesting behavior, and mentions millions of pigeons washed ashore at Traverse City.

The Baltimore County Union · 5 June 1880 · page 1

A CITY OF WILD PIGEONS

Washed Ashore at Traverse City. The great pigeon nesting of Forest county, I’a., rovers twenty miles. It is in jenks and Howe townshijis, near the source of streams that empty into the

See the clipping

The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md.

The report describes a massive passenger pigeon roost forming near Tionesta creek tributaries, with birds arriving in uncountable numbers that darkened the sky and covered five square miles of trees nightly. It details their mating rituals, territorial battles among males, and the destruction caused by overloaded branches, as well as farmers clubbing birds from low branches at night.

The Baltimore County Union · 5 June 1880 · page 1

THE BIRDS ROOSTING. Myriads of birds |>ourcd into the roost daily forthenext fortnight. They came in sheets that stretched front horizon to horizon, anti at times obsetiretl the light of the sun. At night over five square miles of trees were loaded with roosting birds. The noise was tleafening. At times huge branches, broken by the weight of birds, crashed to the ground, throwing the vast camp into dire confu sion. 'Phe unfortunate pigeons fluttered to anil fro in the darkness, ut tvring plain tive cries, which w?rc answered by their more fortunate com|ianions in the trees.

See moreSee less

A heavy fall of snow or a gale after dark breaks many overweighted limits and s|treads dismay among the llock. The fallen hints skulk to cover and await the break of day, filling the darkness with their cricsof terror. Farmers and others visited the roust after night-fall, and, by the light of a blazing fire, clubbed hun dreds of birds from the lower branches of the trees with long poles. While sojourning at the roost the birds mate. The tom pigeon coos incessant ly, swelling his chest a la Conkling and ruffling the feathers at his neck. The mating lasts three or four days. A thous and millions of birds or more are court ing. The forest resounds with love making. Frequently toms court the same hen, and a battle royal ensues.— Eyes flash fire, beaks are crossed like ra|iters, and the combatants use their wings as Irishmen use shillclahs at a country fair. The hens stand by, coy and ( modcst, and give themselves to the victor without reserve. Once mated, the pair is a model of constancy. The tom is all attention and the ben all af fection. He brings her the choicest dclicXfcics and she rewards him with kuaes. Woe lietide the feathered roue who tries to loosen the domestic bond. Respectable married pigeons make com mon cause against him, and club him from the camp in disgrace. The pair, however, are not mated for life. A nest ing breaks the contract, and ever after ward they treat each other like strangers. No tom was ever known to fight twice I lor the same hen. If a hen loses her mate she remains a widow until the next year. THE WAV THEY NEXT.

See the clipping

Centre Democrat · Bellefonte, Pa.

A Forest and Stream correspondent recounts witnessing a pigeon netting operation at a baited mud bed in Michigan, where birds were lured by salted muck rather than decoys. He describes nearly 300 pigeons caught in a single net spring as flocks poured down from the trees at dawn.

Centre Democrat · 10 June 1880 · page 3

A Great Patch;ol Wild Pigeons. A correspondent of the Foreat and Stnam, describing a pigeon roost in Michignn. rays: T i.e morning and evening bonis are ho for catching, us then I lie flights arc on. I saw two hun dred and cighty-scv< n tnk<n nt one spring of a single net, over a bed of n.uek to arfilch the birds had been baited for some days by sprinkling salt over the mud. On these beds no decoys arc used, the baiting being sufficient. The pigeons would eat greedily of the salted muck.

See moreSee less

On the ocea-ioh I speak of we arrived at the bower just before day break. The birds were well baited, and I expected to see a fine eatch, as no net bad as yet been sprung over that bed. Willi the first streaks of light we couid hear the flutter as they lit in the trees alicut the bed. As the light increased Ihey came faster and thicker, until soon the trees were alive with them, and the woods were filled with their calls. Soon a single pigeon dropped on the bed, and ; had hardly folded its wings before ' others began to pour from the trees in a j stream. When they seemed to be stand- |

See the clipping

Centre Democrat · Bellefonte, Pa.

An eyewitness describes the technique of trapping passenger pigeons using nets, decoy 'stool' and 'flyer' birds, at a roost thirty miles long with hundreds of trappers working simultaneously. The account notes huge daily catches, including one hundred barrels of dead pigeons shipped from a single village in one day.

Centre Democrat · 10 June 1880 · page 3

tention ot a parsing flock, and a stool (a pigeon trained to actus if alighting) being industriously worked to induce the night to strike upon the bed when the net is sprung. The catch per day per man ranges from nothing to fifty or sixty dozen. No shooting is allowed within five miles of the roost proper. Good shoot ing ffor those who wish to shoot nest ing birds) can be bad outside these limits, as the birds fly several miles for food, passing some points continuously, at some hours of the da£.

See moreSee less

This roost was thirty miles long, varying in width from one to five miles. There were three hundred men engaged in ttie business at one time that season, and as a result of their work I saw one hundred barrels of dead pigeons alone shipped in one day from the little vil lage of Shelby.

See the clipping