As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

August 1926

16 articles

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The Associated Press reports that members of 35 Indian tribes have filed claims against the U.S. government totaling over $1.25 billion for inadequate payment for lands taken in the past. Among these, the Sioux tribes' claim for nearly $800 million references the 1876 agreement, made after the Sioux war and the Custer massacre, in which the Sioux ceded the Black Hills.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 2 August 1926 · page 2

INDIAN TRIBES FILE

f DRAMATIC STORY OF HARDSHIPS t REVEALED IN COUNTESS’ SUICIDE jr Drama and Pathos Mark Course of Former Royalty From Wake of Russian Revolution Through Poverty, Ending in Leap fi - From Miami Hotel; Husband Courts Death *> MIAMI, FLA., AUK. 1.—(API—A coni eluding chapter to a dramatic story j that carried its principals from the broken legs and does not die. I told her to watt until morning and we would go out to Cocoanut Grove, get in

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The Department of Justice faces a claim that the 1876 agreement, made after the Sioux War and Custer massacre, ceded Black Hills lands in North and South Dakota under duress and for inadequate payment. A similar claim is noted from the Creek Indians over an 1814 land seizure.

Evening Star · 2 August 1926 · page 17

BERLIN, August 2 (^).—All truck and delivery horses owned by the city are having a three weeks’ vacation this Summer on a 300-acre municipal horse “sanitarium" in charge of a corps of veterinarians. Officials in charge of the place, formerly a nobleman's estate, say it pays the city to give horses a rest by the same token that it pays to give human beings a vacation. The animals get all the aats and hay they can eat and prance round the meadows or 101 l in the shade under the trees.

See moreSee less

Many private business concerns, are adopting the idea, sending their horses to the same farm while drivers are on vacationjdSgßs£jjbi, f i Wm IBM -.■ . szSigsgRSAL #sni I . Hf in 1 Wfl \ and duress byrihe Government in the procurement of the agreement of 1876, following the Sioux War and Custer massacre, under which the Sioux ceded to the United States the areas comprising the Black Hills of North Dakota and South Dakota. The Indians contend that the consideration was Inadequate. Another of the claims which the Department of Justice must defend is for $195,000,000, principal and Interest, brought by the Creek Indians. The tribes contend that by an unauthor ized treaty negotiated by Gen. Andrew Jackson following the Creek War in 1813. the Government took from the Indians more than 23,000,000 acres lying in western Georgia and eastern Alabama without any consideration.

See the clipping

White County Citizen · Searcy, Ark.

The U.S. Department of Justice reports that 35 Indian tribes have filed suits seeking over $1.25 billion, including a Sioux claim of nearly $801 million tied to the 1876 agreement following the Sioux war and Custer's defeat. The Sioux allege the government used fraud and duress to force them to cede the Black Hills for inadequate compensation.

White County Citizen · 4 August 1926 · page 6

INDIANS SUING U. S. FOR OVER A BILLION

principal and interest. separate causes of action one being based on the alleged fraud and duress by the government in the procurement of the agreement of 1876, following the Sioux war and Custer under which the Sioux ced massacre. id to the United States the areas com prising the black hills of North Da kota and South Dakota. contend that the consideration was in adequate. Another of the claims More than 45 are named J I The Indians I which the

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A promotional article for the film 'The Flaming Frontier' describes how the movie dramatizes the Little Bighorn battle, noting the fifty-year-old controversy over responsibility for Custer's death that once divided military and civilian opinion. It recaps the story of allied Sioux, Crow, Cheyenne and other tribes uniting under Sitting Bull against Custer's undermanned 7th Cavalry.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 8 August 1926 · page 34

FIFTY-YEAR-OLD CONTROVERSY REVIVED

Brought to Light in Thrilling Picture "• “The Flaming Frontier,” the specta cular Edward . Sedgwick-Universal Production that will be the attraction at the Empire theater Thursday, Fri day and Saturday Is expected to re vive an old-time controversy that for several years rocked the military arm of the government and found hot headed partisans among the civilian population. It Is 60 years now since Gen. George A. Custer and the 7th Cavalry were wiped out by allied 'In dian tribes on the Ulttle Big Horn, and the memory of that tragic event lives only in history and with the families of the surviving relatives of those who went to .their death.

See moreSee less

"The Flaming Frontier" deals with events In the Indian country, and in Washington with a dash of West Point worked In. These all lead up to the spectacular climax of this great picture. The Indians are shown on the move—Sioux and Crow. Cree and Brule and the other great tribes of the west who, forgetting their own differences had answered the call of ] Chief Sitting Bull and united to make one last desperate stand against the white man. Thousands of red men and their squaws are shown gathering to strike the last big blow. Scouts and settlers have warned General Custer' or tHe gathering of the tribes and he In turn apprises Washington of the growing menace. But the vision of Washington, It ap pears Is clouded by the operations of a band of profiteers who are seeking to bring discredit on Cuseer. At the head of the 7th Cavalry, at that time a skeleton organization numbering not more than 212 men. Custer moves out to meet the redskins Full of he hears Custer's rifles.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The article claims a vision of Custer's heroism is being clouded by profiteers seeking to discredit him, amid renewed 50th-anniversary controversy. It notes the 7th Cavalry was a 'skeleton organization' of about 212 men when Custer moved out to meet the Sioux and Cheyenne.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 8 August 1926 · page 34

CONTROVERSY REVIVED

thelmesa as the star. Anothgr, military expert who acted in an expert advisory capftctty In this picture was Colonel Cornelius C. Smith. They both helped to get the desired local color and, accuracy Into "Han son's Folly,” the famous Richard Hard ing Davis story, which Is laid at an army post in Montana during Indian i fighting days. Colonel Bryam, who is regarded as an expert in military matters, was graduated from West Point in 1815, served at Fort Custer, and was In

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

This passage describes a silent film depicting General Custer's final battle at Little Bighorn, including the division of forces, the failed messenger to Reno, and Custer's death. The review also recaps the historic controversy over whether Custer erred in attacking and whether Reno erred in not advancing, noting Reno's court-martial.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 8 August 1926 · page 34

Brought to Light in Thrilling Picture "• pathos Is this picture presented on the ' screen of the departure of the 7th | made doubly so because the audience 1 knows that its members are going on ; their last journey. As General Custer nears 'the Little Big Horn he divides his force, sending Major Iteno .with part .of his command on a flanking movement with orders to come in when he hears Custer's rifles. The battle begins and in this big scene Sedgwick who directed the pic ture, has given screen fans their greatest thrill.

See moreSee less

Daring horsemanship, and heroism feature this wonderful battle scene. One by one and in groups j the troopers are cut down. Then Custer is seen sending his messenger to Reno with orders to close In. There Is a spectacular bit with the messen- \ ger fighting his ’ way through the Indians, reaching Reno and the latter's ! refusal to advance. Then the Indians make their final charge. General Cus- ; ter and his remaining handful of men j are decimated, the general being the i last to fall. The pathos and futility of it all is vividly Illustrated in a . great scene showing the, .flgld the i morning after the fight. Abd here is j where the historic controversy began— : did Custer err In attacking with his j small force? Did Reno err in not ; answering his signal: Reno was courti martlaled but proved that he tried to i

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The War Department is studying the Bearpaw Battleground south of Chinook, site of Chief Joseph's 1877 surrender to General Miles, for designation as a national monument. The article recounts the Nez Perce War's path through Montana and notes the battle prevented Joseph's band from joining Sitting Bull's Sioux in Canada after the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn.

The Kevin Review · 12 August 1926 · page 3

STUDY BEARPAW BATTLE GROUND WHERE MILES DEFEATED NEZ PERCES MAY BE MADE A NATIONAL MONUMENT

The war department recently announced that it was about to embark upon a comprehensive study of the Bearpaw Battle ground south of Chinook, with a view to undertaking to have It set aside as a national monument. At the battle of the Bearpaws la October, 1877, United States troops under General Nelson A. Miles, de cisively defeated the Nes Perce In dians under Chief Joseph and com pelled their surrender, thus prevent ing them from joining in Canada the Sioux under Sitting Bull, who had fled across the border after the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · 13 August 1926

Pinedale Roundup · Pinedale, Wyo.

Thirty-five Indian tribes filed suits against the federal government seeking over $1.25 billion for land taken decades earlier. The largest claim, by the Sioux, cites fraud in the 1876 agreement ceding the Black Hills following the Custer massacre.

Pinedale Roundup · 12 August 1926 · page 2

in 1876. following the Sioux war und Custer massacre, under which the Sioux ceded to the United States the 1 areas comprising the Mm k H IIgs North and South Dakota The Indi ans contend that the consideration

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

Writing for the Custer massacre's 50th anniversary, the author disputes another paper's claim that Sitting Bull became a 'good Indian' and died peacefully on the reservation. Instead, the piece recounts that he was shot by Indian police in 1890 during the Ghost Dance unrest and buried without military honors.

Yorkville Enquirer · 13 August 1926 · page 3

DIED WITH BOOTS ON Sitting Bull Bad Until Killed By In dian Policeman. In regard to the fiftieth anniversary of the Custer massacre and the con nection therewith of Sitting Bull, the remark in an esteemed contemporary, “Sitting Bull beemae a ‘good Indian’ and died on the reservation" is to say the least, misleading. Inasmuch as it may convey to those uninform ed that the redmaq died in peace. Instead he wa3 shot to death by the Indian police and buried without ceremony by a quartermaster’s detail in a corner of the military cemetery at Fort Yates, N.

See moreSee less

D., while the hon ors ofwar were accorded a half doz en Indian police who lost their lives In the turbulence started by the me dicine man writes “F. C. B.” in the

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

A 1926 newspaper entertainment listing advertises upcoming films at local theaters, including a western melodrama titled 'With General Custer At Little Big Horn' featuring a fictional romance subplot. The ad describes it as based on the massacre of government troops by Indians under Sitting Bull and Chief Gall.

The Indianapolis Times · 14 August 1926 · page 6

For the last half of the week, starting Thursday, the feature at traction will be {‘With General Custer At Little Big Horn,” another “Epic Os Frontier Days,” released by Sunset Productions. The story, which embodies a romance between Lem Hawks, one of Custer's scouts and Betty Rossman, daughter of an army officer, is based on the massacre of government troops by the Indians under Sitting Bull and Chief Gall in the waste lands of Montana. In the cast are Roy Stewart. John Beck, Edmund Cobb, Arthur Morri son and others, together with a host of "extras" and real Indian chief tans. Short film subjects will com plete the program.

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

The article recounts how Comanche, Captain Keogh's horse, survived the Battle of Little Bighorn severely wounded and was nursed back to health at Fort Lincoln. It notes a military order forbidding the horse from ever being ridden or worked again, and says Comanche lived until 1899 at Fort Riley.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Watchman and Southron · 14 August 1926 · page 6

Little Big Horn, June 25, 1S76, the semircantennial of which was ob served June 25th at Custer Bat tlefield.. , Wjhilev the disaster that befell the five .companies of the Seventh cavalry was in no sense a massa cre—every trooper fighting to the last ditch—it was an annihilation from which not one man escaped jto tell the story of the battle. Yet there was a *‘soe survivor.” It was "Commanche,” the clay bank gelding mount of Capt. Myles W. Keogh. When he was five years old, the govemojment purchased Com manche and assigned him to Com pany I of the Seventh cavalry, then stationed at Ellis, Kansas.

See moreSee less

Capt. Keogh, acting inspector general on Gen. SpU.v's staff when an expedi tion was organized against south ern. Indians at Fort Dodge in 18G8, chose the animal. During one of the engagements with Com manclle Indians, the horse was wounded while Keogh was riding him. From that time hence the animal was known as Commanche. It was Commanche on which Keogh was mounted that fateful June 25 when Custer made his last charge into the great Indian village on the Little Big Horn. Two days later, while General Terrys ’men were performing the last rites for their dead comrades, a field quartermaster found Com mnache, riddled with bullets, wan dering weakly about the battlefield. The humane thing appeared to be to put the animal out of its misery, vet the soldiers leaped atva chance to save one life—man or boast — from among the still forms that •lotted the plains. Commanehe’s wounds were dressed with the same care that would have been shown one of the gallant troopers. The half-dead animal was conveyed to the steam er “Fast West,” at the junction of tlie Little and Big Horn rivers where a comfortable'stall was built to make his trip as painless as pos sible into Bismark, X. D. From there he was taken to Fort Lin coln. the post from which Custer and his command had started on their last expedition. Here, under the tender ministrations of sur geons, Commanche recovered, and his treatment and comfort there after was the solicitude of the Post. While many stories have boon fold of how the horse was* a fa vorite saddler unions the ladies of the post after liis wounds had healed, a general order, issued by Colonel Sturgis, would nidioate that Commatiehe never was ridden af ter the Custer battle. That section said: “The commanding officer of Company l. will see that a special and comfortable stall is fitted up for him and he will not again he ridden by any person whatsoever, under any circumstances, nor will he ever he put to any kind of work. When the Seventh was ordered to Fort Riley, ha11le-searred Com maindie was taken along. Fntil IS!*?, when at the age of twent.v e!*'ght years Commanehe died, lie was given tender and loving care. fmlifTercnt Woman. < Norfolk Ledger-Dispn teh) According to a Kansas City dis patch. a woman there has test her dghth husband. How careless. Dug an oil well 7.01*0 feet deep in Mexico. If they go any deeper they'll strike French francs.

See the clipping

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

Shoshone and Arapahoe braves joined a posse hunting train robbers in Wyoming, framed by the paper as avenging Custer's 1876 defeat as their ancestors had offered to do. The piece recalls Chief Washakie's historic alliance with whites after the Little Bighorn battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

New Britain Herald · 16 August 1926 · page 1

"'Follow me and find out," he quoted her. His story, published time and again in the newspapers, was neither dramatic nor touching. He told it as if repetition had dulled the edge of tragedy. Chewing gum and staring at Senator Simpson and Attorney Pfeiffer as they bickered and shouted epithets at each other. . Charlotte Mills, his daughter, chatted with newspaper investiga tors who published "exclusive stories" of her testimony, and listened, hsr . face twisted Into a wry expression, to the words of her father. Lawyers in Squabble The morning session ended with the special prosecutor and the de fense attorneys wrangling over whether Mills should be permitted to tell about an alleged visit of (Continued on Page 12).

See moreSee less

. the trail once more, and like their white brothers with whom they fought half a century ago, to avenge ithe massacre of Custer's cbmmand, have received orders to "shoot to kill." Head for J. ckson's Hole It is now be.'eved that the band its' ultimate goal is the Jackson Hole country, a wild, sparsely populated section where a decade ago Wyo ming outlaws and cattle rustlers made their last stand against the law In the rugged Teton mountain ranges. The newly organized posses ac companied by ten pack horses, with enough provisions for a week, was placed under the leadership of Col onel Tim McCoy, former adjutant general of Wyoming. At the Indian reservation Colonel McCoy is regarded bythe native In habiiints as a "Great White Father" and lias beer, given the title of "White Eagle." The posse expects to reach Sweet water, on the fringes of the Red desert this morning. The aboringe.i were engaged in filming a western movie thriller when the call for the posse came and they abandoned KIcig lights and grease paint for war paint, serviceable moccasins and weapons. Alliance Not New For the Shoshones and Arapahoes to ally themselves with white men is nothing rtew. Under Chief Wash akie, who ruled the Shoshones, the tribe extended the pipe of peace to the earliest white settlers and after the Custer, massacre, Washakie of fered the services of his braves to track down and punish the Sioux and Crow who slew the command. When the next word from the In dian-Caucasian posse might reach the outside world Is problematical. since, after leaving Sweetwater on the edge of the desert, communica tion will become Impossible except by couriers. Air mail pilots also have been asked to scan the country along their routes In the hope they may sight the bandits. Postal authorl- (Continued on Page 18)' BRITAIN T HERALD

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

A newspaper entertainment page reviews vaudeville acts at the Palace theater and lists other films playing around town. Among the listings is "With General Custer at Little Big Horn" showing at the Isis theater.

The Indianapolis Times · 20 August 1926 · page 6

er Know Women.” at the Ohio; “Eve’s Leaves.” at'the Colonial; “With General Custer at Little Big Horn,” at the Isis, and “Ranson’e Folly,” at the Uptown. Due at Palace HI Y -\ |^HfflpPs

See the clipping

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont.

Horses Ghost, described as the only survivor of the Custer massacre living on the Fort Peck reservation, died of heart failure at age 23... fifty years after the battle. The obituary recounts his community leadership, his trip to New York, and his role in ceremonial adoptions of military and government figures.

The Poplar Standard · 20 August 1926 · page 1

Verv sincorelv voun, R. M. MORFORD. omit ion, died at his home in the Chel sea district Tuesday morning, of heart failure. One of the oldest Indians on the ri wstlon, and the only survivor of the Custer massacre on this reserva tion, Horses Ghost hasbeen a power for good among the Indians, and a staunch believer in pro.gress. He was president of the Fast Bear Chapter of the Ft. Peck Farming and Livestock Association. lie was a young man of twenty-three at the time of the Custer

See the clipping

The Producers News · Plentywood, Mont.

Chief Horses Ghost, the last survivor on the Fort Peck reservation of the Custer massacre, died of heart disease at age 73 in the Chelsea district. He was recalled as a respected community leader who later became a friend to white settlers and an advocate for progress among his tribe.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Montgomery Advertiser, 8 August 1926, New Britain Herald, 16 August 1926.

The Producers News · 27 August 1926 · page 2

Fort Peck reservation, died at vT home in the Chelsea district T^esdïv meaning of heart disease. 1 One of the oldest Indians and the only survivor of the Custor massacre on this reservation. Horses Ghost had been a power for good among the tribe and a staunch believer in pro£ ress. He was president of the East Bear chapter of the Fort Peck Farm ing and Livestock association. He was 23 at the time of the Custer massacre. At the time of the opening of Glac ier park, Major Lohmiller, who was then superintendent of this reserva tion, took a party of Indians to New York to a land showwhich was spon sored by the Great Northern rail way.

See moreSee less

Horses Ghost, Spotted Eagle Clyde Lone Dog, Sam Savior and Alex Brown were the Indians who made the trip. Horses Ghost officiated at the cere monies of adoption on the occasion when former County Agent Dan S Noble and Col. Charles Sheridan were made members of the tribe here When General Dumont, military at tache of the French legation at Wash gton, who was adopted into the in tribe by the Indian boys of companv B during the encampment at Helena in 1924, sent a beautiful silk flag of France to the boys of the company. Horses Ghost was made the formai custodian of it. His funeral was held from the Catholic church at Box El der, Wednesday.

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This is a book review discussing a new volume about the history of U.S.-Native American relations, timed to the fiftieth anniversary of the Little Bighorn battle. It covers Custer's campaign, debunks the apocryphal 'revenge of Rain-in-the-Face' story, and discusses the killing of Crazy Horse.

The Bismarck Tribune · 31 August 1926 · page 5

HERE TROM - FLASHES Mrs. R. 0. Osburn ef flasher was skillful retreat of Chief .of ,' , fiftieth anniversary of the Custer the Ne* Perce*. * disaster on the Little Big Horn. Custer’s campaign is carefully de (irons agricultural wealth of Can-* scribed. and there are interesting and enlightening chapters on the ada at the end of 1025 was $7,832,- wholly apocryphal story of "the re 042.000. an increase of $324,888,M0 V.' venge of Rain-in-the-Fare,” on the over that of 1924, according to a bul ■» killing of that great warrior, Crazy letin of the Canadian Government * Horse, and of the almost incredibly Bureou of Statistic*. -,i4 >*?

See the clipping