As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

April 1926

16 articles

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont.

This 1926 article reports the death of Sergeant John F. Prutting, a Second Cavalry veteran who helped bury Custer's troopers after the Little Bighorn battle. It recounts how Terry and Gibbon's relief column, including Prutting, arrived two days after the battle to find Reno and Benteen's survivors and bury 265 dead soldiers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Kevin Review · 1 April 1926 · page 7

SGT JOHN F. PRUTTING, PIONEER, HELPED BURY CUSTER'S TROOPERS

HE burial of Sergeant John F. T Civil War veteran, Prutting, Indian fighter and ranchman, at Big Timber, March 9, recalls many of the most stirring events in the earl ier history of Montana. Prutting, who came west with the famous Se cond cavalry in the later sixties, and who was a survivor of both the Sioux and the Nez Perces wars, as well as almost half a century of the most ac tive and varied civil life, was sud denly stricken with pneumonia at the advanced age of 85. When the gallant and impetuous Custer, with his 600 cavalrymen, went up against 6,000 Sioux on the banks of the Little Big Horn, on the afternoon of Sunday, June 25, 1876,

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont.

This 1926 article recounts Sergeant Prutting's memories of an 1877 march in the Mammoth Hot Springs area, where he narrowly missed a battle with Nez Perce warriors that left settler Cowan wounded and his family captured. It also notes Prutting's earlier service one day's march from Custer's command, and his refusal to join the bitter controversy over the Little Bighorn campaign's conduct.

The Kevin Review · 1 April 1926 · page 7

to keep a wagon from over-turning. There was not a house along the way until we reached Snake River. It was a lonesome road, and a dangerous one, if we had been aware of it, for it was through these mountains the minated by the necessities of ad vancing age. It is noteworthy that Sergeant Prutting never seemed to share in the bitterness that for so long has Custer-Reno-Benteen marked the controversy. Like a true soldier, he was certain that under the trying and all but impossible obstacles then ex isting, officers and men alike were not only actuated by the loftiest and most determined motives, but that each were also doing all within their power to achieve the purpose of the expedition—the subjugation of the Sioux Confederation.

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont.

The report is an obituary for Sergeant Prutting, a veteran who served in the Gibbon-Terry column during the Sioux campaign, describing pioneer wagon travel and his recollections of the aftermath at Little Bighorn. It recounts his belief that soldiers acted honorably under difficult conditions and describes his funeral with military honors.

The Kevin Review · 1 April 1926 · page 7

expedition—the subjugation of the Sioux Confederation. Not many days before his death, when pressed by the writer for just a few more details of those by-gone ev ents, he related how the Indians had scattered like frightened antelope at the approach of Gibbon and Terry, and how, from points of vantage the summits of surrounding hills, just out of rifle range, the scattered tho defiant Indians, had witnessed sullen silence, the burial of the Custer dead. Then he quietly added: "Like all soldiers, we did the best we could. If those Indians had only stood for a fight, either they would have been wiped out, or we ourselves would have shared the fate of Custer and his men."

See moreSee less

Needless to say, Sergeant Prutting was followed to his grave by a proud, though sorrowing community. As be fits the burial of a soldier, the col ors were carried at the head of the cortege, with a sailor at one side, and a marine on the other, acting as col or guard. Then followed Sweetgrass county's last surviving veteran of the

See the clipping

The Bozeman Courier · Bozeman, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The state's division of publicity will issue 50,000 eight-page pamphlets covering both the Custer battle and Montana's development since that time, tied to the 50th anniversary celebration planned near Hardin on the Crow reservation next June. The Montana board of examiners approved about $450 for the printing after a request from J. A. Shoemaker of the Custer Memorial Association.

The Bozeman Courier · 2 April 1926 · page 10

Fiftv thousand eight-page pamphlets, containing material partly in reference to the Custer battle and the 50th anniversary which is to be of the Custer massacre celebrated on tbe Crow reservation near Ilarlin next June, and partly relating to the state's resources and the development the state since the time of Ouster, will of .JP issued by the division of publicity of !><• the state department of agriculture. A re nnest for authority to incur an expense of approximately $450 in the Issuance of these pamphlets was made upon the board of examiners and the request was granted after J. A. Shoemaker of Billings, secre tary of the Custer Memorial association, had appeared before the hoard and re

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · 2 April 1926

The Bozeman Courier · Bozeman, Mont. · and 2 other papers

A 1926 article profiles Montana pioneer John F. Yancey, recounting his life near Yellowstone and a secondhand account of the Little Bighorn battle given to him by a Crow scout. The scout's story led Yancey to agree that Reno's retreat was the best course of action to save his command.

The Bozeman Courier · 2 April 1926 · page 11

WAS A TYPICAL MONTANA PIONEER

Little Big Horn, an Indian who was one of the numerous scouts em ployed by Custer and Reno, when so many were wiped out on that mem orable battlefield. This Crow In dian, a foe of the hostile Sioux tribe, knew all about the battle and by word of mouth and sign language conveyed his impressions to Yancey, and the latter agreed always with the friendly Indian that Reno could have done no better than to pursue the course he did when he made a re treat and thus saved the greater part of his command from the fate which befell Custer's soldiers.

See moreSee less

Yancey, as is true of most of the pioneers, left but little property when he died and was buried at Gar diner, but, among the relics of the past was a sawed-off shotgun with a history. This gun, now the property of the writer, was formerly owned by X. Beldler. Beidler used it in the Vigilante days, at the time he was deputy Un ited States Marshall and thereafter sold it to one, Joe Keeney, a noted character, who moved from his na tive state, Oregon, about 1866, and Yancey purchased the weapon from Keeney, paying for it in gold dust, all the traffic would bear in those days. "Uncle John" Yancey knew all of

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · 2 April 1926
  • The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont. · 2 April 1926

The Harlem News · Harlem, Mont.

Western film star Bill Hart announced he will attend the semi-centennial observance of the Battle of Little Big Horn at the Custer battlefield in June 1926. He wrote to the National Custer Memorial Association saying his interest stems from his own boyhood spent on a South Dakota Indian reservation, not from filmmaking.

The Harlem News · 2 April 1926 · page 1

Hillings.—Kill Hurt, motion picture stnr featured in many a wrstcru drama of the wilvciad screen, will come to Montana next summer to attend obaerv sure of the ncmi-ccntranial anniversary of ihr battle of the Little Big Horn at Custer battlefield, miles southeast of hen*, on .lune 21. 25 and 2H. next. An noum cmmils of his decision aas mndr in u |M*r*onnl letter to James A. Khue Minkcr, secretary of the National Custer Mrmoriu! association, which is s|M»nsor ing the affair. Hurt says in his letter thnt he is not iiiti-ic-f«*<| in the memorial from a Mandpoint of motion pictures, "but jubt us Bill Hurt” he in "very much int-iestvd.

See moreSee less

*• He tefers to his ImyhiMMi days s|m nt on n houth Ilnkotn Indian reservation by nnyiiig "I was brought up with the SiuuN kids myself."

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1926 promotional article touts North Dakota's growth, farmland, and tourist attractions, including Fort Abraham Lincoln near Mandan where General Custer was stationed before his fateful mission ending in the Battle of the Little Bighorn. The piece is primarily boosterism for settlers and tourists, not a historical account of the battle itself.

The Bismarck Tribune · 2 April 1926 · page 12

. Mandan. “Where the West Begins,” , j»st across the broad Missouri, re cently -bridged, may be seen the site of Fort Abraham Lincoln where Gen eral Custer was stationed at the time he went on his fateful mission, end ing in the battle of the Little Big Horn, Many stop to tout the Bac Lands along the Little Missour River, with their petrified forests burning coal mines, beautifully crflor • cd buttes and canyons as well as the Marquis de Mores properties near Mo dore in Hie valley where Roosevel

See the clipping

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · and 2 other papers

Colonel Graham argues that the Battle of Little Bighorn was a fairly fought combat between two civilizations rather than a massacre, since Custer's men died fighting with weapons in hand. He also claims that, contrary to popular belief, there was little mutilation of the dead except among Reno's men who fell near the village.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

The Poplar Standard · 9 April 1926 · page 6

ARMY OFFICER SAYS IT WAS A HOTLY CONTESTED MILL TARY ENGAGEMENT Rattle of Little Rig Horn Was Great est Contest Ever Waged Between Receding and Advancing Races, Saya Colonel W. A. Graham For half a century the battle of the Little Big Horn has Im*cii known as the Custer massacre. It is time that another name be given it, in the opinion of Colonel W. A. Graham, juilgc advocate. United States army, and author of “The Story of The Little Big Horn, Custer’s Last Fight," who is play ing a prominent imrt In activities of the National Custer Memorial association in sponsoring obser vance of the semi-centennial anni versary of the liattle on June 24, 23 and 20, next.

See moreSee less

Colonel Graham's story of the bat tle of the Little Big Horn is conced ed by surviving officers of the Sev enth and those historians and writers who have made a study of this mem orable engagement, to be the best, balanced account of the fray in which Gen George A. Custer and his im mediate command of five companies were annihilated by some 6,000 Sioux and Cheyenne Indian warsiors on June 25. 1576. “It was no massacre,” says Col onel Graham. "On the contrary it was a bitterly contested combat to death between the armed representatives of two civilizations, each of which fought after the manner of his kind. The simple truth is that in this, the greatest battle ever waged between the red men and the white, between a receding and an advancing race, the red men had the victory, because they exhibited that day greater pro ficiency in the art of war than did the chosen representatives of the white men. Warfare, however it be savage, is not a massacre when the conquered go to their deaths with arms in their hands. “In all Indian warfare mutilation of the bodies of the enemy dead, as well as torture of living prisoners is expected. It is part and parcel of savage war. And therefore, the battle of the Little Big Horn is all the more remarkable for the fact that there was no torture of prison ers. for the Sioux took none; and, contray to general belief there was not the usual mutilation of the bodies slain, except those of Reno's com mand who fell close to the village and were subjected to indignities by the squaws and children."

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Bozeman Courier · Bozeman, Mont. · 9 April 1926
  • The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont. · 9 April 1926

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A gossip column notes the premiere of 'The Flaming Frontier,' a Hollywood film dramatizing the Battle of Little Bighorn, fifty years after the event. It also reports the death of a man claimed to be the massacre's only survivor, an elderly Indian scout named S. B. Jones.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 23 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 11 April 1926 · page 67

rule may as consistently be applied to the average picture show. Enjoy wh*t you may, and leave the theater when satisfied; this will make room j held. This isthe longest rest Tom j has had, it is said, since he joined j Paramount 11 years ago. Plausible I excuses are given for it. "Gold tickets,” national decorations, Chief Red Eagle and fellow Indian braves in the lobbies and the largest electric sign in the United States marked the premier of “The Flaming Frontier” at the Colony Theater in New York. This is the picture of the battle of Little Big Horn, where Gen.

See moreSee less

George Armstrong Custer and ills army were massacred in 1876 by the Indians. i S. B. Jones, the only survivor of the Custer massacre and an elderly In dian scout died recently, according to a notice in an Anadarke, Okla., news paper. Allegorical sequences in "The Sor rows of Satan” will Include “the gates of heaven, the expulsion of Lucifer, the landing of Lucifer cn earth, hell, the creation of man, paradise and the flight of a shooting star,” accord ing to Paramount’s publicity depart ment. Bertram Miihauser will be in charge of the negro picture which Cecil B. De Mille has announced. No other par ticulars are vouchsafed as yet. It is said that Charles Gilpin may play the part of Uncle Tom in a pro posed new version of “Uncle Tom’s Cabin.” This#may be the proposed De Mille picture. June Mathis’ first production under her contract with First National, it is reported, will be “Sinners in Para- | disc,” a screen version of "Nazareth.” As might be expected. Harry Carey now is making “Satan Town.” A. E. Dupont, the foreign director who has recently connected with Uni versal, will present Mary Philbin, Norman Kerry and Henry B. Walt hall in “The Affairs of Hannerl” us his first Universal picture. Ray Taylor is Boon to start oft a great Western serial for Universal called “The Great West That Was.” Monta Bell's new picture for MetroGoldwyn-Mayer, “The Boy Friend.” will have in its cast Gwen Lee. a dead ringer for Gloria Swanson, it is said. Fox has purchased "The Great K. 1 & A. Train Robbery,” by Paul Lelces [ ter Ford, for direction by Irving Cum mings, with Madge Bellamy in the cast. Pola Negri, with Tom Moore and others, has started filming “Good and i Naughty,” under the direction of Mai colm St. Clair. Mary Alden, Snitz Edwards and Baby Peggy are in tho cast with Alex i under Carr in "April Fool,” a Chad i wick production. Pauline Frederick has started on “Devil’s Island.” an original by Leah Baird and Frank O’Connor, for Em bassy Pictures. "Paradise.” Cosmos Hamilton’s , I story, will be the first to be superIvueU by ii%y J&x&rtfc om> vs tbs

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The report describes Chauncey Yellow Robe, a Sioux chief and nephew of Sitting Bull, speaking at the Izaak Walton League convention in Chicago about ancestral Indian hunting grounds in the Black Hills. It notes he witnessed the Little Bighorn battle as a boy and credits Sitting Bull with killing Custer and his soldiers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Bismarck Tribune · 14 April 1926 · page 1

J Nephew of Sitting Bull Chief Chaunecy Yellow Robe, full-blooded Sioux Indian chief and a nephew of Sitting Bull who killed Custer and his soldiers at the battle of the Little Big Horn was a delegate to. the Izaak Walton League con vention at Chicago and told the delegates of the ancient Indian hunting grounds in the Black Hills of South Dakota. As a boy he witnessed the massacre.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A 1926 article discusses Colonel William A. Gresham's reassessment of the Battle of Little Bighorn, arguing it was not a massacre but a rout caused by poor government preparation and being outmaneuvered by Sitting Bull. The piece reflects on fifty years of historical mythmaking around Custer's Last Stand.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 April 1926 · page 4

“Custer’s Last Stand” Is it possible that those old paintings of "Custer's Massacre” or "Custer's Last Stand” which used to hang on the walls of nearly every village'school house and which typ ified to young American the struggle to conquer the great West, misrepresented what really happened on the Little Big Horn fifty years ago? Vandal hands have been revising much of our history for us lately. There has devel oped an iconoclastic school of writers who have taken a sort of fiendish delight in shattering our traditions and removing the halos from the heads of our cherished leas - roes.

See moreSee less

To present the truth about historical characters is not to be deployed, if it be done for the sake of truth and not for the purpose of breeding irreverence and con tempt for great figures of the past. The questioner of the time-honored ac count of the wiping out of the Custes* expe dition by Sitting Bull and his red-skinned warriors, however, is not one of the pro fessional idol wreckers, but a soldier-his torian, who has delved into ap many official records as it is possible to find, dealing with the expedition. He is Colonel William A. Gresham, judge advocate general of the sixth army' corps area. Colonel Oresham denies that it was a mas sacre. “The Cattle we have alwpys called a massacre was in reality not a'massacre at all. but a rout in which the United State's forces were outgeneraled by the willy Sit ting Bull," he declares and presents volum inous records to prove his contention. The responsibility for the disaster, he di vides between the government foi* not prop erly equipping the expedition, and upon Cus ter himself, who, he says, discounted mili tary practice ilk launching his attack. "The Indian leaders simply showed more tactical ability than the whites," he concludes in hla summary of the battle. If Colonel Gresham's version of what oc curred is corrects the Indiana have been done an fnjnstlce these fifty years, by hav ing been represented as simply a horde of savages falling upon an inferior force of white troops, and massacring them. In cold blood, and it shows a true sportsmanship when a United States army officer acknowl edges that the United 8tates forces were fairly beaten in an open battle_Houston Post-Dispatch.

See the clipping

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont.

Western film star Bill Hart announced he will attend the semi-centennial observance of the Battle of the Little Big Horn in June, citing personal rather than movie interest due to his boyhood among Sioux children. Thousands of Sioux, Cheyenne, Blackfeet, Assiniboine, and Crow are expected to attend the ceremonies at Custer Battlefield.

The Poplar Standard · 16 April 1926 · page 3

BILL HART COMING TO CUSTER EVENT FAMOUS MOVIE STAR WILL PARTICIPATE IN THE CEREMONIES

occasion of a memorial to the dead Sioux left as the price of their anni hilation of Custer and hie immediate command and the casualties they in flicted on the commands of Reno and Benteen at Reno Point, four miles away. The acceptance of Bill Hart is the first Secretary Shoemaker haa re ceived from motion pitcure stars to whom he addressed special Invita tions recently to attend the semi-cen tennial ceremonies. These invita tions were directed especially to stars who have participated in western dramas of an historical nature. o An emblem of good luck, a stuffed crockodile. is seen over many doors and gateways in Cairo, Egypt. The custom of putting these animals to exalted positions corresponds to ou custom of nailing a horseshoe over the door.

See the clipping

The Cody Enterprise · Cody, Wyo.

Mr. Gail, publisher of 'The Golden Guide' tourist guidebook, visited Cody and spoke to the Cody Club, suggesting the town promote itself during the upcoming Semi Centennial celebration of the Custer Massacre in late June. The article also covers other local news including the Pikes' return from England and a meat market sale.

The Cody Enterprise · 21 April 1926 · page 1

luncheon and kept up his reputation 1 of the past for being one of the best, after dinner speakers who favor this community with their wit and enter-1 tainment. In his talk Mr. Gail made j an invaluable sugge.-.tion that Cody take steps to have some publicity at the Semi Centennial celebration of the Custer Massacre, to be held the last of June. This suggestion will be taken advantage of as there is oppor tunity for the best kind of publicity at that time and place and the best possible prospects for tourists to visit the Buffalo Bill country will be pres ent, as Mr.

See moreSee less

Gail brought out. Mr. Gail is one of the few we are always glad to see return and are al ways willing to listen to, for he has the knack of mixing enough enter tainment with his business to put it over big.

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont.

The National Custer Memorial Association plans a semi-centennial celebration of the Battle of Little Big Horn for June 24-26, expecting nearly 1,000 veterans and Indian survivors. A symbolic peace ceremony will unite former enemy tribes, the Crow and Sioux, with the Seventh Cavalry participating and White Man Runs Him representing the Crow scouts.

The Kevin Review · 22 April 1926 · page 3

EXPECT VETERANS AT CUSTER EVENT

Big Horn and for establishment of a great tourist park at Crow Agency to care for the thousands who are expected to attend the semi-centennial anniversary of the battle June 24, 25 and 26, next, have been completed by the gen eral committee of the National Custer Memorial association which is sponsoring the observance. Details of the hatchet burying cer emony for which the seventh United States cavalry, now stationed at Port Bliss, Texas, will be sent to Montana next June, were worked out by the committee, in co-operation with Rep resentatives of the Indians, 3,000 of whom will participate in this event.

See moreSee less

As a result of the meeting the Sioux and Crow tribes, enemies until recent years since time immemorial will smoke the pipe of peace on Custer's field where a half century ago, the Crows as allies of whites and the Sioux bent upon annihilation of a pitifully small force of United States troops sent to herd them to the reservations, came to grips in a memorable combat. This feature of the program suggested by the Indians themselves will find White Man Runs Him, only survivor of the Crow scouts, who aided Custer and the battalions of Benteen and Reno, rep resenting his tribe in the pledge of peace. The entire ceremonies incident to observance of the semi-centennial will be held on historic ground, the battlefield itself, a great national amphitheater capable of accommo dating 50,000 persons as sightseers,. It was on this great natural stage* that the committee marked the ap pointed place of each unit of whites which will in the pageantry.

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont.

Actor William S. Hart has accepted an invitation to attend the semi-centennial observance of the Battle of the Little Big Horn at Custer Battlefield on June 24-26. Thousands of Sioux, Cheyenne, Blackfeet, Assiniboine and Crow Indians are expected to attend the commemoration of the battle's casualties on both sides.

The Kevin Review · 22 April 1926 · page 7

,T. A the observance of the semi-centen ial anniversary of the Battle of the Little Big Horn at Custer Bat tlefield, on June 24, 25 and 26. Announcement of the decision was made in a personal letter to James A. Shoemaker, secretary of the National Custer Memorial as sod tion, which is sponsoring the af fair. Hart says In his letter that he is not interested In the memorial from a standpoint of motion pictures, "but just as Bill Hart" he is "very much Interested." He refers to his boyhood days on a South Dakota Indian reservation by I was brought up with the saying: Sioux kids myself."

See moreSee less

Several thousand Sioux, Chey ennes, Blackfeet, Assinnibolne and Crow Indians will be present at the semi-centennial and will make it the occasion of a memorial to the dead Sioux left as the price of their anni hilation of Custer and his immediate command and the casualties they in flicted on the commands of Reno and Benteen at Reno Point, four miles away. The acceptance of Bill Hart Is the first Secretary Shoemaker has re ceived from motion pitcure stars to whom he addressed special Invita tions recently to attend the semi-cen tennial ceremonies. These invita tions were directed especially to stars who have participated in western dramas of an historical nature.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1926 article describes Mrs. Payne Whitney's historical exhibit at the Colony Club, which includes Custer's last message dated June 25, 1876, addressed to Major Reno. The piece is part of a broader society feature on historical relics, nightcaps, and quilts on display.

Evening Star · 25 April 1926 · page 56

flces of the New York bar for Mr. Aaron Burr, who sought admission into that body. Another is Custer’s last message dated June 25, 1876. and addressed to Major Reno. Mrs. Payne has gathered a most amusing col lection of historic nightcaps, many of which adorned famous heads, and of both sexes. Her patchwork quilts

See the clipping