As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

October 1924

11 articles

The Carbon County Chronicle · Red Lodge, Mont.

D.F. Barry, a Duluth photographer and authority on Western pioneer history, challenges the claims of Frank Fleck, who has been lecturing in Minnesota as a survivor of the Battle of Little Bighorn. Barry calls Fleck's account full of twisted and warped facts, asserting Fleck was never actually in the battle despite his detailed claims about troop movements and Custer's final engagement.

The Carbon County Chronicle · 1 October 1924 · page 3

TAKES ISSUE WITH STATEMENT OF FRANK FLECK WHO SAYS HE IS A CUSTER SURVIVOR

assigned to the Seventh U. S. cavalry. In 1875 ho was one of the cavalry detail that captured the Indian chief, Kaln-ln-the-Face, and placed hint In a prison ut Fort Lincoln, Ne braska. The chief afterwards es caped and was one of Custer's bit terest enemies. " 'The Seventh cavalry was sta tioned In the northwest and waged continuous warfare upon the Sioux under Chief Sitting Bull,' stales this f the man Fleck. 'Before the buttle Little nig Horn, where Custer und his men met death, ut the hands of the Sioux.

See moreSee less

Custer divided hts forces Into two parts, one commanded by himself and the ohor by Colonel Reno. Lost Entire Command " 'He hud planned tu strike the Indians from two sides and demor alize them, but instead he suffered the loss of his entire command and Ueno and his men narrowly escaped annihilation. Just before the en gagement Custer detailed 90 men to guard the supplies, and with this de tail Fleck was stationed. " 'We were separated from the other men but a short time,' said Fleck, 'when we saw that they were being surrounded by Um Sioux. There was no commissioned officer In our detail, but we Immediately de termined to follow the trail of He llo's command. We lost the trail nnd came out 30 or 40 rods to the loft of the position occupied by Re no's men.

See the clipping

The Carbon County Chronicle · Red Lodge, Mont.

A writer disputes claims made by a man named Fleck who lectures as a Little Bighorn survivor, pointing out numerous factual errors including wrong troop numbers, false details about Rain-in-the-Face's capture, and nonexistent casualties. The piece argues Fleck's account is unreliable and contradicts established facts about the battle, including confirming Custer's body was not mutilated.

The Carbon County Chronicle · 1 October 1924 · page 3

I say where they captured Raln-ln-the | Face, although he claims to have ta i ken part In that. Hotly Not Mutilated, "Uono and Benteen loft the Reno ! Hill, on the Twenty-seventh, when I General Terry came up and proceed j ed to the field where General Custer j and his command fell. General Cus ter's body was not mutilated at all. "Fleck states he is 60 years old now. The Custer fight took place 48 years ago last June. From his state ment he must have been 12 or 13 years of age at thé time.

See moreSee less

No child ren took part In that fight with Gen eral Custer. Fleck tells about his friend Knapp, who lived In Milwau kee. There was no person killed in the Custer fight by the name of Knapp. Headed for Canada.

See the clipping

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont. · and 1 other paper

An article recounts a man named Fleck's claim to have survived Custer's Last Stand, describing his wounds and four days trapped under his dead horse before rescue. A critic, Mr. Barry, disputes details in Fleck's account, including factual errors about Sitting Bull and Rain-in-the-Face.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Kevin Review · 2 October 1924 · page 3

TAKES ISSUE WITH STATEMENT OF FRANK FLECK WHO SAYS HE IS CUSTER SURVIVOR Places Lecturer in the Light of an Imposter; Gives Pacts Concerning Memorable Indian Battle, and Shows Biscrepencies of Article. D. F. Barry, a Duluth, Minn., photographer, and a widely known authority on pioneering life of the early West, takes issue with one, Frank Fleck, age 60, a so-called survivor of the battle of the Lit tle Big Horn (The Custer Massa cre), who in an article appearing recently in Minnesota newspapers, in which state Fleck has been de livering lectures, gives an account of the memorable battle.

See moreSee less

In calling attention to the article of Fleck, and his claims made there in, Mr. Barry states, in part, as fol lows: "From his twisted and warped facts, Fleck was never in the bat tle. The article published by Fleck states that Fleck enlisted in the reg ular army in 1867 going from To ledo with 16 other recruits, and was assigned to the Seventh U. S. cavalry. In 1875 he was one of the cavalry detail that captured the Indian chief, Rain-In-the-Face, and placed him in a prison at Fort Lincoln, Ne braska. The chief afterwards es caped and was one of Custer's bit terest enemies. " 'The Seventh cavalry was sta tioned in the northwest and waged continuous warfare upon the Sioux under Chief Sitting Bull,' states this man Fleck. 'Before the battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer and his men met death, at the hands of the Sioux, Custer divided his forces into two parts, one commanded by himself and the ober by Colonel Reno. Lost Entire Command " 'He had planned ta strike the Indians from two sides and demor alize them, but instead he suffered the loss of his entire command and Reno and his men narrowly escaped annihilation. Just before the en gagement Custer detailed 9 0 men to gnard the supplies, and with this de tail Fleck was stationed. " 'We were separated from the other men hut a short time,' said Fleck, 'when we saw that they were being surrounded by the Siqux. There was no commissioned officer in our detail, but we immediately de termined to follow the trail of Re no's command. We lost the trail and came out 30 or 40 rods to the by no's men. Faced Deadly Fire. " 'We had just reached the top of the bluff when a hand of savages seemed to rise out of the ground an but fifty feet distant and poured a deadly fire into our detail. We were completely overwhelmed and in a short time every trooper except myself and a trooper named Frank Knapp of Milwaukee had been killed. " 'Knapp was shot through the hip and I had four bullet wounds and an arrow wound. One bullet passed through my left wrist and the same ball or another pierced my shoulder. Another bullet entered my right leg and a fourth my right side. Both of our horses were shot from under us, and in falling my mount rolled on my legs and pinned me to the ground. I lay for four days with that dead horse on my legs before some of Reno's men got me and carried me from the field.' " "Knapp was shot on the third day when he peered over the carcass of Fleck's dead horse and on the fourth day the Indians withdrew fearing re inforcements, Fleck further states. Reno's men then picked up Fleck and withdrew from the field. "In withdrawing from the field. Fleck states, he passed over the scene of Custer's last stand and saw the mangled and mutilated bodies of the brave general and his men, and that Cuser's body was so mutilated that it was scarcely recognizable," Mr. Barry continues. ren Article Is Amusing. "Fleck's article amuses me," Mr. Barry states in reply. "First, Sitting the Bull was not a chief, he was a Sioux medicine man. Second, Rain-in-the-| Face did not hate General Custer.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Wolf Point Herald · Wolf Point, Mont. · 2 October 1924

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · and 3 other papers

D.F. Barry, a Duluth photographer and authority on the Old West, publicly disputes claims made by Frank Fleck, a lecturer who claimed to be a survivor of the Little Bighorn battle. Barry says Fleck's account is full of twisted and warped facts and that Fleck was never actually in the battle.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Poplar Standard · 3 October 1924 · page 7

BARRY ATTACKS ARTICLE BY FLECK; FACTS TWISTED

TAKES ISSUE WITH STATEMENT OF FRANK FLECK WHO SAYS HE IS CUSTER SURVIVOR Places Lecturer in the Light of an Imposter; Gives Facts Concerning Memorable Indian Battle, and Shows Discrepencies of Article. D. F. Barry, a Duluth, Minn., photographer, and a widely known authority on pioneering life of the early West, takes issue with one, Frank Fleck, age 60, a so-called survivor of the battle of the Lit tle Big Horn (The Custer Massa cre), who in an article appearing recently in Minnesota newspapers, in which state Fleck has been de livering lectures, gives an account of the memorable battle.

See moreSee less

In calling attention to the article of Fleck, and his claims made there in, Mr. Barry states, in part, as fol lows: “From his twisted and warped facts, Fleck was never in the bat tle. The article published by Fleck states that Fleck enlisted in the reg ular army in 1867 going from To ledo with 16 other recruits, and was assigned to the Seventh U. S. cavalry. In 1875 he was one of the cavalry detail that captured the Indian chief. Rain-In-the-Face, and placed him in a prison at Fort Lincoln, Ne braska. The chief afterwards es caped and was one of Custer’s bit terest enemies. “ ‘The Seventh cavalry was sta tioned in the northwest and waged continuous warfare upon the Sioux under Chief Sitting Bull,’ states this man Fleck. ‘Before the battle ot tho Little Big Horn, where Custer and his men met death, at the hands of the Sioux, Custer divided his forces into two parts, one commanded by himself and the oher by Colonel Reno. Lost Entire Command “ ‘He had planned ta strike the Indians from two sides and demor alize them, but instead he suffered the loss of his entire command and Reno and his men narrowly escaped annihilation. Just before the en gagement Custer detailed 90 men to guard the supplies, and with this de tail Fleck was stationed. “ ‘We were separated from the other men but a short time,’ said Fleck, ‘when we saw that they were being surrounded by the Sioux. There was no commissioned officer in our detail, but we immediately de termined to follow the trail of Re no’s command. We lost the trail and came out 30 or 40 rods to the left of the position occupied by Re no’s men. Faced Deadly Fire. “ ‘We had just reached the top of the bluff when a band of savages seemed to rise out of the ground but fifty feet distant and poured a deadly fire into our detail. We were completely overwhelmed and in a short time every trooper except myself and a trooper named Frank Knapp of Milwaukee had been killed. “ ‘Knapp was shot through the hip and I had four bullet wounds and an arrow wound. One bullet passed through my left wrist and the same ball or another pierced my shoulder. Another bullet entered my right leg and a fourth my right side. Both of our horses were shot from under us, and in falling my mount rolled on my legs and pinned me to the ground. I lay for four days with that dead horse on my legs before some of Reno’s men got me and carried me from the field.’ ” “Knapp was shot on the third day when he peered over the carcass of Fleck's dead horse and on the fourth day the Indians withdrew fearing re inforcements, Fleck further states. Reno’s men then picked up Fleck and withdrew from the field. “In withdrawing from the field. Fleck states, he passed over the scene of Custer’s last stand and saw the mangled and mutilated bodies of the brave general and his men, and that ('user’s body was so mutilated that it was scarcely recognizable," Mr. Barry continues. Article is Amusing. “Fleck’s article amuses me,” Mr. Barry states in reply. “First, Sitting Bull was not a chief, he was a Sioux medicine man. Second, Rain-in-theFace did not hate General Custer. Geenral Custer and Mrs. Custer were kind to him, when he was a prisoner in the guard house at Fort A. Lin coln, North Dakota. Third, he don’t say where they captured Rain-in-theFace, although he claims to have ta ken part in that. Body Not Mutilated. “Reno and Benteen left the Reno Hill, on the Twenty-seventh, when General Terry came up and proceed ed to the field where General Custer ami his command fell. General Cus ter’s body was not mutilated at all. “Fleck states he is 60 years old now. The Custer fight took place 48 years ago last June. From his state ment he must have been 12 or 13 years of age nt the, time. No chlfi ren took part in that fight with Gfl - oral Custer. Fleck tells abo t ( s friend Knapp, who lived in M Iwa - kee. There was no person kil ed' n the Custer fight by the na te J f Knapp. jnp Htuided fcMra&ada. “On the tewefiTy-“eventh ( ;y ' f June the Indians broke cam a 1 headed forrtanada as soon a th X learned4#owtheir scout that G neal Terry and the infantry were c< nln . It seems strange that if Flee

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • · · 1 October 1924 · an extract
  • The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont. · 2 October 1924
  • The Wolf Point Herald · Wolf Point, Mont. · 2 October 1924

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Chief William Red Fox, visiting Montgomery on a Boy Scout speaking tour, claims his father Black Eagle helped direct the Sioux uprising alongside Red Cloud, Rain-in-the-Face and others leading to Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn in 1876. He also seeks to correct misconceptions about Indian face paint and portrays early U.S.-Indian relations as largely sympathetic after independence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 4 October 1924 · page 7

Will Visit With Montgomery Scoots With the bronze tint wrought by winds and plains still predominant In his acqulllne features, despite a six months' sojourn In the south. Chief William Red Fox, full blooded Sioux Indian, of Kose Bud, 8. D„ strolled Into the Whitley hotel Friday evening, and registered without attracting more than a casual glance or two from the guests who filled the lobby. But the chief was not arrayed In his elaborate and multl-colon^d head gear, Ills beautiful headed vest and broad bottomed trousers, nor did he I tip the bell hop with ''wampum."

See moreSee less

| These he had stored in two large travelling bags and aside from the name on the register he was to all appearances just the average United States citizen, that he is. Chief Red Fox Is the son of Chief Black Eagle of the Sioux tribe, and was only six years old when his fa ther with other famous chiefs, John Bull, Spotted Eagle, Red Cloud and Itain-ln-The-Face directed maneuvers of the great Sioux uprising which end ed with Custer's fight on the Little Big Horn river In Montana, June 25, 1876. It is this great movement that dies nearest to the heart of the chief, Who Is known to boy scouts throughout the United States. Another object of the tour is to correct the erroneous Idea school children have assimilated through reading cheap literature con cerning the Indian and his habitd. He came to Montgomery from Pen sacola, where he spoke before civic clubs and students In the schools. In addition to aiding in Boy Scout work. "Children are under the Impression that the Indians used paint to make them look wild,” but this Isn't true. It was used as we used symbols In beads to denote our tribe and follow ing. It was a part of our sign lan guage for we had no alphabet." "But speaking of paint. I have been here only two hours, and I wonder if the children didn’t get the Idea from some other source than historical sketches of Indian life. The chief then spoke reminiscently of the struggle of the frontier days: "There is another false Impression I would like to correct. When the pale faces first came to this country, they

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A newspaper Q&A trivia column answers a reader's question about when Custer was killed by Indians, stating the Battle of the Little Big Horn occurred in June 1876. The item is one of many unrelated trivia facts answered in the same column.

South Bend News-Times · 6 October 1924 · page 6

Q-—How did the word “tailor” originate ? A.—From the French word “tail ler” meaning cutter. Q.—How far does the gravitational attraction of the earth extend? A.—Theoretically, to infinity, in \ constantly decreasing amount. Q.—In what year did t>ie battle occur in which Gen. Custer was kill ed by the Indians? / A.—The battle of the Little Big Horn, Montana, occurred in June, 1876. Q.—About how many Indians is it supposed were in North America at the time Columbus discovered America? A.—It is estimated that there were about 1,115,000. Q.—Did Magellan actually circum navigate the globe?

See moreSee less

A.—‘He did not personally live to the end of the voyage in which his ship sailefi around the globe, yet he did circumnavigate the globe, for on his longest voyage eastward he had reached Banda Island at long. 130 degrees E. of Greenwich, and when he 'was killed by an attack of naj

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

William Red Fox, visiting as guest of the Boy Scouts, lectured students on Indian history and defended Native Americans against charges of barbarism. He claimed to be the son of Chief Black Eagle, who had fought at Custer's Last Stand, and performed traditional dances for the audience.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 12 October 1924 · page 26

was an event of the past month, was Miss Bmllr Black. Indian Chief Speahs On Thursday at ‘the third hour the school enjoyed a lecture by William Red Fox, the Indian chief who Is the guest of the Montgomery council of boy scouts this week. Red Fox, who spoke first to the girls and then to the joys, was Introduced by W. F. Sprouse boy scout executive. Mr. Sprouse said that the speaker was a chief of the Mohawk Indiana on the government reservation In South Dakota "was the son of Chief Black Eagle, who parti cipated In many famous Indian flghta Among which was Custer’s last stand, md was a graduate of Carlyle Univer sity In the class of Ills.

See moreSee less

He Is also a reteran of the Spanlsh-Aiperlcan war. In his talk the chief defended the [nflans from the accusation that they ire barbarlous and told of the part >layed by them In the early history of >ur country. He told something of the ablts of the Indians on the reservation ind the kindness of the government :o them. . He suggested that the stu lents redd Fenlmore Cooper’s "Lea iheretocklng Tales,” and Helen HulR Jackson's "Ramona,” In order to get a true picture of his race. Red Fox then delighted the audience with some dances Including the war dance of the Mohawks and accompanied them with the native chant. He was dressed In the custome of his tribe. Germany has a remedy for sleep ing sickness which she refuses to sell.

See the clipping

Vashon Island News-Record · Vashon, Wash.

A 1924 feature profiles Matt Dunham, 72, a hermit night watchman at Glacier National Park's lodge, who claims to have served as a U.S. government scout attached to Custer's army. He says he was on detached duty 80 miles away on the Tongue River searching for the main Sioux band during the Battle of the Little Big Horn.

Vashon Island News-Record · 17 October 1924 · page 3

WAS A SCOUT IN CUSTER’S ARMY Matt Dunham, ‘“the old man of the a log cabin in the forest near the hotel Mountains,”” 72 years old, Is the picturthe year round. In the summer months esque night watchman of the Glacier he breaks the monotony of his winter's National Park mammoth log hotel which loneliness by confabbing with the tour stands in the shadows of the Rocky .ists. He has bcen in the Rocky MounMountains. He was born in northeastern | tains since 1872, and has many stirring Indiana, and went West a young man, {tales of adventures with the Indians and serving 12 years as a U.

See moreSee less

S. government | wild anima! life of that region. His cab scout, He was attached to General Cusfin is a veritable curiosity shop, and it ter's army. During the battle of the :is the center of great interest to the tourLittle Big Horn, in which Custer was |ists. Dunham has had a kodak ever killed, Scout Dunham was on detached |since the “little picture taking hoxes' duty 80 miles away, scouting on the ‘arrived on the frontier, and he deveclops Tongue River in an endeavor to:locate his own prints. It is estimated he has the main band of Sioux. five thousand interesting Western snapDunham is a typical hermit, living ir. shots stowed away in piles in his cabin NEW INDUSTRIES BREAK RECORD Eighty-five new industries estab Washington as of 1919, show the fol

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Chief William Red Fox, who as a child hid in Wolf Mountain during the battle, recounts the story of Custer's last stand as passed down by his father Chief Black Eagle and other warriors. He contrasts these oral accounts with the brief versions found in white historians' written histories.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 15 days earlier.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 19 October 1924 · page 33

CUSTER GREATLY ADMIRED BY INDIANS, SAYS RED FOX

uviiuiu—vu«itr naiiiriiria, BT CHIEF WILLIAM RED FOX The story of Custer's last fight as told by historians and by son of the braves of Sitting Bull and by their fathers and mothers who fought that fight on the 26th day of Juns, 1*76 on the Big Horn never differs In many particulars. I was a boy six year and fourteen days old.at the time and with old men and women and ■ oMttrcm •• was hidden In the .recesses of old Wolf mountain. Until this day I remember vividly the details as told by my father, Chief Black Eagle, one of the leaders In the fight.

See moreSee less

Even now I can see Old Wolf mountain rearing Its majestte peaks towards the sky and the lights and shadows In the valley where we had pitched our wigwam. In the cool nights that followed I would lay gazing Into the glowing coals of the campflr?' with my head resting In my palms and as my fath er and other braves spoke of the hor rors of that fight I could hear the din of battle above the roar of the Big Horn river and catch the echo of the war whoops In the breeze. Today I read stories written by the whtle man of the fight and as I re call the way, It was told to me by those to whom truth and bravery were two of the paramount virtues, I say "how different. How different." Short Acre oat Gives When we read history we only find a short account of this battle. Some of the writers have said that Custer and his entire command were mas sacred hy the Sioux Indians with the exception or one man and one horse. This Is true. Only one man and a horse came out of that battle alive. But history does not go Into detail and show how this government warned men not to trespass and trade on In dian's land, nor give concrete Ideas of the cause of the battle. In the late part of tho winter of 1873 and the early part of the winter 1874, a misunderstanding arose be tween the missing company and the

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Chief William Red Fox recalls childhood memories of his father Black Eagle describing the Little Bighorn battle, and claims the conflict stemmed from an 1873-74 dispute over trespassing traders killed by Chief Rain-in-the-Face. He asserts only one man and one horse survived the battle, and that an 18-month manhunt followed before the killer was identified.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 41 days later.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 19 October 1924 · page 33

uviiuiu—vu«itr naiiiriiria, BT CHIEF WILLIAM RED FOX The story of Custer's last fight as told by historians and by son of the braves of Sitting Bull and by their fathers and mothers who fought that fight on the 26th day of Juns, 1*76 on the Big Horn never differs In many particulars. I was a boy six year and fourteen days old.at the time and with old men and women and ■ oMttrcm •• was hidden In the .recesses of old Wolf mountain. Until this day I remember vividly the details as told by my father, Chief Black Eagle, one of the leaders In the fight.

See moreSee less

Even now I can see Old Wolf mountain rearing Its majestte peaks towards the sky and the lights and shadows In the valley where we had pitched our wigwam. In the cool nights that followed I would lay gazing Into the glowing coals of the campflr?' with my head resting In my palms and as my fath er and other braves spoke of the hor rors of that fight I could hear the din of battle above the roar of the Big Horn river and catch the echo of the war whoops In the breeze. Today I read stories written by the whtle man of the fight and as I re call the way, It was told to me by those to whom truth and bravery were two of the paramount virtues, I say "how different. How different." Short Acre oat Gives When we read history we only find a short account of this battle. Some of the writers have said that Custer and his entire command were mas sacred hy the Sioux Indians with the exception or one man and one horse. This Is true. Only one man and a horse came out of that battle alive. But history does not go Into detail and show how this government warned men not to trespass and trade on In dian's land, nor give concrete Ideas of the cause of the battle. In the late part of tho winter of 1873 and the early part of the winter 1874, a misunderstanding arose be tween the missing company and the

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · and 2 other papers

A 1924 newspaper reprints a veteran's 1902 account of serving under General Miles in 1879, three years after Little Bighorn, describing a cavalry detachment's march past the Lame Deer agency. E. M. Locke claims he carried a message that let Miles prevent a massacre of Captain Clark's command similar to Custer's fate.

The Poplar Standard · 31 October 1924 · page 2

CAMPAIGNING Wi t h General Miles has been a portion of the experience of may a resident of Montana. Interesting indeed are some of the stories told by the old timers of the days when they served in the army with Miles. E. M. Locke, in 19 02, told an interesting story of how he prevented a massacre that might have ended similar to the one in which Custer and his command died. The message he bore to Gen eral Miles and the latter’s prompt response prevented a second catas trophy like that of the battle of the Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

His narrative fol lows : "In 1579 I was at Fort Custer in the quartermaster’s department. Miles, then a colonel of the Fifth in ' fantry, was in charge of the district of the Yellowstone which included the ■ country from the head of that river down about as far as the present site of the city of Glendive. ‘"Under command of Major D. S. Gordon of the Second cavalry, a de tachment left Fort Custer, June 25, 1579. three years almost to a day following the Custer massacre. We I were under orders from Miles to proceed overland to Fort Keogh. The detachment consisted of Troops i C. G, I and M of the Second cavalry, four companies of the Eleventh in fantry, and 31 Crow Indians. Henry Kiser, later a merchant in Billings, accompanied the party as interpreter. The infantrymen were mounted. A ' wagon train and a pack train from Fort Custer accompanied the party. "This side of Fort Keogh we went , through the Lame Deer agency on the Little Wolf. These Indians, the 1 Northern Cheyennes, were the same captured the year before by Cap tain W. P. Clark of the Second cav alry on the Powder river. Little Wolf, the chief, who had an intense state prior to January 1, 1910. The present limitation of residence is Jan. 1. 1900.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • · · 29 October 1924
  • The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont. · 31 October 1924