As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

September 1923

15 articles

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

A 1923 newspaper feature on the history of the Canadian Mounted Police recounts how Sitting Bull fled to Canada after the Little Bighorn battle and attempted to incite Canadian tribes to war. It credits the Mounted Police's diplomacy for avoiding bloodshed and peacefully escorting Sitting Bull back across the border.

Yorkville Enquirer · 4 September 1923 · page 2

non-explosive gas helium. one of the most remarkable in the his tory of the Canadian frontier. The first mounted police fort was completed at McLeod in 1874. In the same year a detachment pressed on to the coun try of the Wood Cree and Assinihoine Indians, and established a post at Fort lSdiponton, 400 miles to the north. In 1875 Inspector Brisbois built a fort where the city of Calgary now stands. Regina, Saskatchewan, first known as Pile of Bones by reason of the great stakes of buffalo skeletons standing; there in the early days, was made the headquarters.

See moreSee less

Regina retained the sit uation as headquarters until after the wdr, when the headquarters was mov ed to Ottawa, . Shortly following the massacre of General Custer in 1876, at the battle of the Little Big Horn, by the Sioux chief, Sitting Bull, the chief entered Canada with several hundred braves

See the clipping

The Cody Enterprise · Cody, Wyo.

The Interior Department approved a pension for Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curly, a Crow Indian who served in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns including the Custer Massacre. War Department records state he survived by mingling with the attacking Indians before rejoining government forces.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

Wrong

The Cody Enterprise · 5 September 1923 · page 2

The Department of the Interior has approved the issuance of a pension certificate to Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curly, a Crow Indian, for his services in the lidian campaigns of 1876 and 1877, which included participation in the Custer Massacre. Curly now lives on the Crow Reservation in Montana. According to War Department re cords he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and later rejoining the government forces.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An Oklahoma report announces the death of John Stout, aged 96, described as an Indian scout for General Custer at Little Bighorn who survived by hiding inside a dead buffalo's carcass. It notes he was also a Civil War veteran.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Star · 6 September 1923 · page 7

War Veteran. NOWATA. Okla.. September 6. j John Stout, ninety-six years old. an Indian scout for Ocn. Custer at the | time of the latter’s famous last stand, t died late Thursday night at his home in Delaware, near here. Stout es caped from the Indian massacre In 1 which hia comrades were slain by hiding in the carcass of a dead buf falo. He also was a veteran of the

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

John Stout, said to be 96, died near Nowata, Oklahoma, reportedly having served as an Indian scout for Custer at the Little Bighorn. The report claims he escaped the massacre by hiding inside the carcass of a dead buffalo while his comrades were killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Washington Times · 6 September 1923 · page 3

DEAD AT NINETY-SIX NOWATA, Okla., Sept. 6.—John Stout, ninety-six years old, an In dian scout for General Custer at the time of the latter’s famous last stand, died at his home in Delaware, near here. Stout escaped from the* Indian massacre in which his comrades were slain by hiding in the carcass of a dead buffalo. He alao was a veteran of the civil war,

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper Q&A column responds to a reader asking whether any man or animal survived the Custer massacre. It states no soldier survived, but one horse did, and the horse was later stuffed and mounted at Fort Riley, Kansas.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Cody Enterprise, 5 September 1923, Evening Star, 6 September 1923, The Washington Times, 6 September 1923.

Evening Star · 7 September 1923 · page 6

Q. Did either man or beast escape in the Glister massacre?—J. J. A. Os the men who rode )f»to halt . * under Custer no man lived td tell tt . tale of the massacre, but one hor* escaped and after Its death it was stuffed and mounted. It is now at Foi

See the clipping

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A 1923 newspaper profile describes veteran Trax, who claims to have been General Custer's orderly in the 2nd West Virginia cavalry. The article recounts Custer's fame as an Indian fighter and states he died at Little Big Horn, which it places in Wyoming.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Milwaukee Leader · 8 September 1923 · page 2

—By Leader Staff Photographer. were sternly marshalled to bed like school girls. Friday will be spent in rehearsal. From 9 to 12:30 al m. from 2:30 to 5 ;30 p. m., and from 7 :30 to 11:30 p. m., models and theatrical performers will go over and over their program. Because of the huge size of the runway, long and careful preparation is necessary. It is figured it will take each model four minutes to prome nade the length of the runway and back. Edith Church, noted lyric soprano, who will be featured at the show, ar rived in Milwaukee on Thursday.

See moreSee less

Miss Church has just completed a concert tour and comes direct from a successful appearance in Cleveland. She is a pupil of Joseph E. Erhart. of it are three keys of the Ford theater, where Abraham Lincoln was assassinated; the spurs of nine rebel officers and 24 union officers, and sev eral bugles. Trax, who enlisted when 15 in the 2nd West Virginia cavalry, proudly boasts that he was the orderly of Gen. George Custer, who attained his greatest fame as an Indian fighter, losing his life at Little Big Horn, in Wyoming. * * < Clarendon E. Adams, 77, Los An geles attorney, who is a native of Wisconsin, probably has the longest and most diversified military record of any man who attended the G. A. R. encampment. He served in the Civil war, enlisting at Monroe, Wis., when 15, in the sth Wisconsin regi ment, in the Spanish-American war, in the Indian fighting, and in the late war. During the Indian warfare he was Chief-of-staff and one of his lieuten ants was John J. Pershing, who was commander-in-chief of the American forces in the late war. Adams served three years during the late war, being in charge of the shipments of materials from the 11th zone, which extended from the west ern boundary of Illinois to the Pa cific coast. He also acted as legal adviser in settlements made in con nection with war contracts. When 12 years old, Adams heard the famous debate at Freeport, 111., between Abraham Lincoln and Ste phen Douglas. Nine hours before President Hard ing died, Adams and E. L. Hawk, Sacramento, also a delegate to the encampment, presented a flag to the late chief executive in the Palace hotel, San Francisco. Adams is in charge of arranging the program for the dedication on Armistice day of a $10,000,000 coli seum in Los Angeles, and he plans to have Secretary of War Week and Secretary of the Navy Denby among the speakers. • * * Benjamin Franklin has a name sake at the G. A. R. encampment in the Auditorium. This Benjamin Franklin is 81 and served in the Civil war three years as a member of the 37th Massachusetts regiment. He is a native of Phoenix, N. Y., but for many years has been a resident of Springfield, Mass. * * * J. P. Plattenburger, 76, Savanna, 111., has the distinction of being the biggest Civil war veteran attending the G. A. R. encampment in the Au ditorium, Plattenburger tips the scales at 275 pounds and his height is 6 feet 1 inch. He enlisted in the Union army when he was 15 and served with the 153rd Pennsylvania infantry and the 2nd heavy artillery. For 21 years Plattenburger filled the position of city engineer and street commissioner of Savanna.

See the clipping

The Calhoun Chronicle · Grantsville, W. Va.

The report states that John Stout, a 96-year-old man from Delaware, Oklahoma, died claiming to have been an Indian scout for Custer at the Little Bighorn. It recounts that he survived the battle by hiding inside the carcass of a dead buffalo while his companions were killed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Calhoun Chronicle · 13 September 1923 · page 1

Altoona Speedway Altoona, Pa.—Howard Wilcox, vet oran Indianapolis automobile racer, was fatally Injured in the inaugural 200-mile race on the new Altoona Speedway, when his car skidded and overturned in the one hundred and seventeenth lap. On the first curve of that lap Wil cox got so low on the wooden plank ing that he was temporarily off in the dirt. He swerved to get back on, and his w heels struck the castor oil-soaked boards at the track edge. His car whirled about completely, and turned over and over, wheels flying high up the bowl, and rolling some distance.

See moreSee less

Wilcox was rushed to the Field Hospital, but there it was found that he was dead, and it is believed death was instantaneous. His neck, arms and legs were broken, and his chest crushed in. His clothing had been torn to ribbons. \V ilcox was one of the racing game’s veterans. He had been fol lowing the sport for 17 or 18 years, and won first place at Indianapolis in the Memorial Day race a few years ago. He leaves a wife and two small children, residing at Indianapolis. He was one of the most popular drivers' in the game, his never varying good humor making friends on all sides, i Fred Duesenberg of the Duesenberg factory, one of whose drivers Wilcox was, has taken personal charge of the body, and will ship it to the late home ! at Indianapolis. Wilcox was in third place when the accident occurred. Diplomats Present Credentials. Washington, D. C.—Manuel C. Tel lez. Mexican charge d’affaires, pre sented his credentials to Acting Sec retary Phillips, finally restoring full international relations between the two governments. At the same time! George T. S\immerlin, charge of the American embassy in Mexico City, presented his credentials to the Mex- ■ ican foreign office. Custer Indian Scout Dies. Nowata. Okla.—John Stour, aged 96. an Indian scout for Con. Custer at the time of the latter’s famous last stand, died at his home In Delaware : near here. Stout escaped from the Indian massacre in which his com rades were slain by hiding Ittho car cass of a dead buffalo. He also was a veteran of the Civil War. Bethel Church Will Celebrate. Pittsburgh. Pa.—The congregation of Bethel Presbytorian Church, Bethel township, established in 1777, cole brated its one hundred and forty-fifth anniversary. On Saturday afternoon a reunion was held bringing together i many members of the church who at tended the centennial celebration held ! 45 years ago. Auto Kills Motorcyclist. Johnstown. Pa.—Charles Bellstein, 48 years old. of 622 Pine street, this place, was killed when an automobile crashed into tho sidecar of a motor-' cycle in which he was riding. Harold Boyd, driver of the motorcycle, es-' raped without injury. The automobile ! was driven by Miss Mary C. Whit aker of Johnstown, who was ordered to appear before Mayor Cauffiel. New $20 Counterfeit. Pittsburgh, Pa.—A new counterfeit $20 Federal Reserve note on the Fed eral Reserve Bank of San Francisco.

See the clipping

Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo. · and 1 other paper

The piece contrasts the famous 'Custer Massacre' with the little-known death of Thornburgh at Milk Creek, arguing the latter deserves equal remembrance for saving his command. It notes a monument exists for Custer but nothing marks where Thornburgh fell.

Rawlins Republican · 13 September 1923 · page 5

Everybody know« who General Custer was and how he died. There are few who know about the death of Thornburg. The one was a de bonair officer who sacrificed his command. The other was a brave man who saved it. A monument stands on the hill of the "Custer \Massacre.” There is nothing to mark the spot where Thornburg 1 fell and Milk Creek whimpers in its I bed unnoticed now as then. But [there are those who think that the children of this city, when they walk its most beautiful street, should know that it bears the name of a brave man the story of whose death the west will not willingly let die.

See moreSee less

W. T. Penland was a city visitor on Monday of this week from Baggs. Miss Alice Walker spent last week in Rawlins from her ranch homo on Pass Creek and was the house guest of Mr. and .Mrs. H. A. France and Mr. and Mi's. G. F.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 22 August 1923

White Pine News · East Ely, Nev.

A newspaper miscellany piece mentions Major Reno, namesake of Reno, Nevada, noting he was 'near' the Custer massacre but not present, and was later court-martialed—allegedly for insulting a brother officer's wife rather than drunkenness as commonly reported. The item includes a reprinted 1880 Washington dispatch about Reno's sentence and request for delay before presentation to the president.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

White Pine News · 16 September 1923 · page 6

Major Reno, for whom the Nevada divorce metropolis was named, was a regular army officer who came near to being in the Custer massa ere. but was not quite there. It has been printed that he was tried by court martial for a barroom es cape r.r drunkenness, but according1 lo the Ward paper it was in reality for the things that are bringing peo ple of the city of Reno intb 're prop.ch today Here is a copy of :i dispatch telling obout it:

See the clipping

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

An editorial about Moro resistance to Filipino self-government compares the situation to Custer's defeat, noting that Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse's warriors "massacred his command to the very last man." The piece argues this 1876 defeat didn't prove Native Americans' incapacity for self-rule, so similar logic shouldn't be used against Filipinos.

The Washington Daily News · 19 September 1923 · page 4

Not longer ago than the seventies the naked and painted tribe’s of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse surrounded our own intrepid Custer a.id massacred his command to the very last man. That bloody opposition to white domination came precious close to the hundredth anniver sary of our independence. Did it “prove” our incapacity for self-government ? No one is fool enough even to pretend it did. Then why use such a fool argument against the Filipinos ? • * Neither Klan Nor King

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

An editorial defending Filipino self-government compares Moro unrest to the Indian wars, noting that Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse's warriors wiped out Custer's command in the 1870s. It argues this long-ago defeat didn't prove Americans incapable of self-rule, so similar logic shouldn't be used against Filipinos.

The Indianapolis Times · 21 September 1923 · page 4

TRUTH ISN’T IN A DOLLAR m ROUBLE is brewing in the Philippines among the Moros, according to the cables. The cause, we are told, is that the Moros object to being gov erned by the Filipinos. Americans who have large financial interests in the Philip pines are using % the occasion as proof that the islanders are not yet ready for self-government. Nonsense! There are 10,350,750 people in the Philippine Islands. Only 886,999 of these are non-Christians and of this small minority less than 360,000 are Moros. The Moros are to the Filipinos what the American Indians used to be to us.

See moreSee less

Not longer ago than the seventies, the naked and paintel tribes of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse surrounded our own in trepid Custer and massacred his command to the very last man. That bloody opposition to white domination came precious close to the hundredth anniversary of our independence. Did it “prove” our incapacity for self-government.

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

A 1923 opinion piece argues against using Moro unrest as proof Filipinos can't self-govern, comparing it to how Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse's warriors massacred Custer's command in the 1870s without that being seen as disproving American self-government. The piece uses the Little Bighorn battle as a historical analogy rather than reporting it as news.

The Seattle Star · 24 September 1923 · page 8

%flfi “a” out of the country’s name. %;elfi'l. Coolidge didn't win the knigimg championship, but she can spin B yarn yorth two of that, i - An Argument That Doesn’t Stand ~ Trouble is brewing in the Philippines among the Moros, ‘according to the cables. ~ The cause, we are told, is that the Moros object to being governed by the Filipinos. . - Americans who have large financial interests in the ~ Philippines are using the occasion as proof that the island ~ers are not yet ready for self government.

See moreSee less

- Nonsense! ~ There are 10,350,750 people in the Philippine islands. Only 886,999 of these are non-Christians and of this ~ small minority less than 360,000 are Moros. - The Moros are to the Filipinos what the American Indians used to be to us. ~ Not longer ago than the seventies, the naked and ~ painted tribes of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse surrounded pur own intrepid Custer and massacred his command to ~the very last man.

See the clipping

The Indian Leader · Lawrence, Kan.

This item reports the death of Major James H. McLaughlin, a veteran Indian Service inspector who was agent at Standing Rock at the time of the Custer massacre and later gathered an authentic account of the battle from participating Indians. It also notes his later career suppressing the sun dance and ghost dance and preventing a Sioux uprising under Sitting Bull.

The Indian Leader · 28 September 1923 · page 1

Mr. McLaughlin entered the Indian Service July 1, 1871. He was an Indian agent at Standing Rock, N. Dak., at the time of the Custer massacre and obtained from Indians who participared an authentic history of the battle. While at Devils Lake he abolished the Indian sun dance on that reservation and later suppressed the ghost dance move ment at Standing Rock. At this time he also prevented an uprising of the Sioux under Sitting Bull. He was taken ill soon after returning from a visit among the Santee Sioux, where he had been detailed to secure a roll in connection with a judgment in the courts.

See moreSee less

He was 81 years of age at the time of his passing.. Major McLaughlin was credited with having more In dian friends than any other white man. He was the author of the book “My Friend, the Indian.” A Model Schoolhouse The Bureau of Indian Affairs has adopted the plans of Colonel Ralph E. Twitchell for the new schoolhouse and teacherage at Tesuque pueblo and a commanding site for the structure in the ancient apricot orchard, just east of the pueblo, has been selected for the building, which is Santa Fe mission style, and in addition to cheerful living quarters for the day teacher, provides for the schoolroom and The schoolhouse is to be a type that will auditorium. serve as a model in the other pueblos.—Albuquerque

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

A Montana newspaper article profiles the Royal Northwest Mounted Police, retelling how Sioux warriors who fought at Custer's defeat fled into Canada and were later escorted back to the U.S. border. It recounts an anecdote of a lone corporal and three constables handling thousands of refugee Sioux, framing it as the police's first brush with fame among Montanans.

The Ronan Pioneer · 28 September 1923 · page 3

MONTANANS on the border coun ties are familiar with the work of the Royal Northwest Mount ed Police, who patrol the boundary and keep order of a superior kind in western Canada. Ralph Connor has made the organizatton famous with his fiction, while scenario writers and motion picture producers have been quick to take advantage of the ro mantic character of the work of the “Red Riders of the Plains.” Prob ably the most noteworthy instance of their prowess which claimed the at tention of the people of Montana, oc curred shortly after the Custer mas sacre. Thousands of renegade Sioux who had participated in the annihila tion of Custer's command, fearing re prisals by the United States govern

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

This retrospective article traces the history of the Canadian Mounted Police from 1872 onward, noting that Sioux and other Indians fled to Canada after 'the massacre of General Custer and an entire squadron of the 7th U.S. cavalry' for fear of American reprisals. The piece is primarily about Mountie history and the Riel Rebellion, with Custer's defeat mentioned only as background context.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Ronan Pioneer · 28 September 1923 · page 3

followed shortly by the massacre of General Custer and an entire squad ron of the 7th U. S. cavalry. The Indians, fearing punishment for this atrocity went across the internation al boundary with the result as nar rated above.

See the clipping